throbber
Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 1 of 34 PageID #: 85
`Case 1:20-cv-00662—UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 1 of 34 PageID #: 85
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT 2
`
`EXHIBIT 2
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 2 of 34 PageID #: 86
`case liZO'CV'OO‘A’F’Z'UNA D°°“"‘e“t 1'1|||1|illlleflFllllfiflllillll'flllfimlillll’I|111111111fillfillflllf6
`
`US010639521B2
`
`(12) United States Patent
`US 10,639,521 B2
`(45) Date of Patent:
`*May 5, 2020
`Foley et al.
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`
`(54)
`
`(71)
`
`(72)
`
`EXERCISE SYSTEM AND METHOD
`
`Applicant: PELOTON INTERACTIVE, INC.,
`New York, NY (US)
`
`Inventors: John Paul Foley, New York, NY (US);
`Hans Schlichting Woolley, West
`Hollywood, CA (US)
`
`(73)
`
`Assignee: Peloton Interactive, Inc., New York,
`NY (US)
`
`(*)
`
`Notice:
`
`Subject to any disclaimer, the term of this
`patent is extended or adjusted under 35
`U.S.C. 154(b) by 0 days.
`
`This patent is subject to a terminal dis-
`claimer.
`
`(21)
`
`Appl. No.: 16/666,332
`
`(22)
`
`Filed:
`
`Oct. 28, 2019
`
`Prior Publication Data
`
`US 2020/0061416 A1
`
`Feb. 27, 2020
`
`Related US. Application Data
`
`Continuation of application No. 16/412,327, filed on
`May 14, 2019, now Pat. No. 10,486,026, which is a
`(Continued)
`
`(65)
`
`(63)
`
`(51)
`
`Int. C l.
`A63B 24/00
`G1 6H 20/10
`
`US. Cl.
`
`(52)
`
`(2006.01)
`(2018.01)
`(Continued)
`
`CPC ........ A633 24/0075 (2013.01); A633 21/015
`(2013.01); A633 22/06 (2013.01);
`(Continued)
`
`240
`
`220
`
`RachelC
`
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`CPC . A63B 24/0075; A63B 24/0062; A63B 22/06;
`A63B 21/015; A63B 22/0605;
`(Continued)
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`4,844,451 A
`4,880,225 A
`
`7/1989 Bersonnet et al.
`11/1989 Lucas et al.
`
`(Continued)
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`EP
`W0
`W0
`
`0919259
`WO 1997/041925
`WO 2005/087323
`
`2/1999
`11/1997
`9/2005
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`US 8,092,344 B2, 01/2012, Tagliabue (withdrawn)
`(Continued)
`
`Primary Examiner 7 Sundhara M Ganesan
`(74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm 7 Haynes and Boone, LLP
`
`ABSTRACT
`(57)
`A method for displaying archived exercise classes compris-
`ing displaying information about archived exercise classes
`that can be accessed by a first user via a computer network
`on a display screen at a first location, wherein the first user
`can select among a plurality of archived classes, outputting
`digital video and audio content comprising the selected
`archived class, detecting a performance parameter for the
`first user at a particular point in the selected class, displaying
`the performance parameter on the display screen, and dis-
`playing performance parameters from a second user at a
`second location on the display screen such that at least one
`of the performance parameters from the first user and at least
`one of the performance parameters from the second user at
`the same point in the class are presented for comparison.
`
`20 Claims, 17 Drawing Sheets
`
`Manheimw
`
`, -_ _ 45 Min Pure Cyde
`
`w [i] 1312'? we @ 591
`
`,0
`
`Chan’le
`
`‘4‘"
`
`.1“:Avg
`
`
`
`“_ hum: not“
`
`
`‘ Cadence _ Output
`”2Resislance
`'
`, Calories
`Avg Max
`HGEIIRale K
`,
`Max
`N9
`92 112
`245 g
`SE? 72
`WATTS
`MPH ‘ RPM
`
`1245 155
`216 508
`| sumac
`172ERC8ENT
`am
`
`‘5“ _
`7Z
`b 77 Q
`228
`1232
`226
`
`,,
`
`224
`
`230
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 3 of 34 PageID #: 87
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1—2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 3 of 34 PageID #: 87
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 2
`
`Related U.S. Application Data
`.
`.
`.
`.
`cont1nuat1on of appl1cat1on No. 16/036,894, filed on
`Jul. 16, 2018, now Pat. No. 10,322,315, which is a
`continuation of application No. 15/865,206, filed on
`'
`'
`Jan..8, 2018, now Pat. .No. 10,022,590, Wthh 1s a
`cont1nuat1on of appl1cat1on No. 14/992,032, filed on
`Jan. 11, 2016, now Pat. No. 9,861,855, which is a
`continuation of application No. 14/930,398, filed on
`-
`-
`NOV: 2’ 2015,fnow1.Pat, N11 93135525766682}??? a
`0011911113190“ 0 311313 10am“
`0-
`,
`,
`e on
`Jul. 31, 2013, HOW Pat. No. 9,174,085.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`Prov1s1onal appl1cat1on No. 61/677,985, filed on Jul.
`31, 2012, provisional application No. 61/798,342,
`filed on Mar‘ 15’ 2013‘
`
`(60)
`
`(51)
`
`(2018.01)
`(2006.01)
`(2006.01)
`(200601)
`(201891)
`(2006.01)
`(2006.01)
`
`Int- 0-
`G16H 15/00
`A63B 22/06
`A63B 21/015
`A63B 71/06
`G16H 20/30
`A633 21/005
`A63B 21/22
`(52) US Cl
`.
`'
`'
`'
`CPC ...... A633 22/0605 (2013.01), A633 24/0062
`(2013.01); A633 71/0622 (2013.01); G16H
`15/00 (2018.01); G16H 20/10 (2018.01);
`G16H 20/30 (2018.01);A63B 21/0051
`.
`.
`(2013.01), A63B 21/225 (2013.01), A63B
`2022/0658 (2013.01); A63B 2024/0065
`(2013.01); A63B 2024/0068 (2013.01); A63B
`2024/0081 (2013.01); A63B 2071/0658
`.
`.
`22909313038133?22313512722209513‘0381343?
`(
`~
`),
`(
`~
`),
`A63B 2220/806 (2013.01); A63B 2225/107
`(2013.01); A63B 2225/20 (2013.01); A63B
`.
`2225/50 (2013.01); A63B 2230/06 (2013.01);
`A63B 2230/40 (2013.01), A63B 2230/75
`(201391)
`
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`.
`.
`CPC ........ A63B 71/0622; A63B 2024/0081; A63B
`2220/34, A63B 2.024/0065, A63B
`2225/50, A63B 21/0051, A63B 2225/20,
`A63B 2022/0658; A63B 2071/0658;
`A63B 2225/107; A63B 2230/06; A63B
`2230/40. A63B 21/225. A63B 2220/58
`’
`.
`’
`.
`’
`A63B 2230/75’ A63B 2220/17’ A63B
`2220/806; A63B 2024/0068; G16H 15/00;
`G16H 20/10; G16H 20/30
`See application file for complete search history.
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`4932550 A
`133%? 2
`4,981,294 A
`5,000,444 A
`5,014,980 A
`5,089,960 A
`5,149,312 A
`5,203,826 A
`5,213,555 A
`5,247,853 A
`5,259,611 A
`
`“990 Bmgham et 31'
`341338 32128811185211.
`1/1991 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1991 Dalebout et a1.
`5/1991 Bersonnet Ct 211.
`2/1992 Sweeney, Jr.
`9/1992 Croft et 31.
`4/1993 Da1ebout
`5/1993 Hood et al.
`9/1993 Dalebout
`11/1993 Dalebout et a1.
`
`5,458,548 A
`5,462,503 A
`5,466,200 A
`5,512,025 A
`2,2335%”; 2
`a
`a
`5,547,439 A
`5,591,106 A
`5,595,556 A
`3,223,322 2
`,
`,
`5,669,857 A
`5,672,140 A
`5,674,156 A
`5,674,453 A
`5,676,624 A
`2,2335%; 2
`,
`,
`5,702,325 A
`5,704,879 A
`5,718,657 A
`5,722,922 A
`5,743,833 A
`5,772,560 A
`5,827,155 A
`5,860,893 A
`5,860,894 A
`5,888,172 A
`5,890,995 A
`5,899,834 A
`5,947,868 A
`RE36,574 E
`6,033,347 A
`6050924 A
`2923;; 2
`a
`a
`6,171,217 B1
`6,171,218 B1
`6,280,362 B1
`2,353,322 31
`,
`,
`6,350,218 B1
`6,458,060 B1
`6,471,622 131
`6,569,063 B2
`,
`,
`223:3; E:
`6,648,798 B2
`6,695,752 B2
`6,702,719 B1
`,
`,
`2,323,222 3%
`6,749,537 B1
`6,761,667 B1
`6,808,472 B1
`6,902,513 B1
`6,918,858 B2
`6,921,351 B1
`6,974,404 B1
`6,997,852 B2
`7,004,888 B1
`7,060,006 B1
`7,060,008 B2
`
`7,077,789 B1
`D532,063 S
`7,166,062 B1
`7,166,064 B2
`7,192,388 B2
`7,285,075 B2
`7,455,622 B2
`Z’Q‘fi’if); E:
`,
`,
`7,537,546 B2
`7,537,549 B2
`7,540,828 B2
`7,549,947 B2
`7,556,590 B2
`7,575,536 B1
`7,603,255 B2
`
`10/1995 Crossing et a1.
`10/1995 Benjamin et a1.
`11/1995 Ulrich et 81.
`4/1996 Dalebout et al.
`28332 FD_a11ebout et 31'
`1n ayson
`8/1996 Rawls et a1.
`1/1997 Dalebout et 31.
`1/1997 Dalebout et a1.
`3133; Siewer 6t 31~
`1
`atterson et a .
`9/1997 Watterson et a1.
`9/1997 Watterson et a1.
`10/1997 Watterson et a1.
`10/1997 Watterson et al.
`10/1997 Watterson et a1.
`13133; 3130:5011 ft 31~
`r10
`et a .
`12/1997 Watterson et a1.
`1/1998 Watterson et al.
`2/1998 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1998 Watterson et al.
`4/1998 Watterson et al.
`6/1998 Watterson et al.
`10/1998 Jensen et al.
`1/1999 Watterson et al.
`1/1999 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1999 Andrus et a1.
`4/1999 Bobick et al.
`5/1999 Dalebout et al.
`9/1999 Dugan
`2/2000 Hochstein et 31.
`3/2000 Dalebout et a1.
`4/2000 Shea
`13/3888 Elckman
`t
`1
`evasseur e a .
`“2001 Cutler
`1/2001 Shea
`8/2001 Dalebout et a1.
`1?;5881 grunfeld et all
`atterson et a .
`72002 Dalebout er 9
`10/2002 Watterson et a1.
`10/2002 Hammer et a1.
`5/2003 Chen
`a erson e a .
`3388;
`{3411811 et 31,
`1
`“/2003 Yoo
`2/2004 Lee
`3/2004 Brown et al.
`us
`en e 3.
`3388::
`212111;: al. 1
`1
`6/2004 Hic
`7/2004 Cutler et 31.
`10/2004 Hickman
`6/2005 McClure
`7/2005 Watterson et al.
`7/2005 Hickman et a1.
`12/2005 Watterson et al.
`2/2006 Watterson et al.
`2/2006 Weng
`6/2006 Watterson et 31.
`6/2006 Watterson et al.
`
`7/2006 Chen
`11/2006 Kim et al.
`1/2007 Watterson et al.
`1/2007 Watterson et al.
`3/2007 Dalebout et al.
`10/2007 Cutler et al.
`11/2008 Watterson et a1.
`lggggg gown, Jr
`10km“
`5/2009 Watterson Ct 211.
`5/2009 Nelson et al.
`6/2009 Watterson et al.
`6/2009 Hickman et a1.
`7/2009 Watterson et al.
`8/2009 Hickman
`10/2009 Case, Jr. et a1.
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 4 of 34 PageID #: 88
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1—2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 4 of 34 PageID #: 88
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 3
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`7,225,133? 3%
`7:628:730 B1
`7,637,847 B1
`7,645,212 B2
`7,645,213 B2
`7,658,698 B2
`776747205 B2
`7’713’171 B1
`7,713,172 B2
`7,717,828 B2
`7,736,272 B2
`7,740,563 B2
`7,766,797 132
`7,775,940 B2
`7,785,236 B1
`7,789,800 B1
`7,857,731 B2
`7,862,478 B2
`7,862,483 B2
`7’874’957 B2
`7’901’323 B2
`7,901,334 B2
`7,909,740 B2
`7,934,983 B1
`7,980,996 B2
`7,981,000 B2
`8,021,270 B2
`8,029,415 B2
`8,052,581 B1
`8,068,858 B2
`8,298,123 B2
`8,585,561 B2
`8’784’270 B2
`8,858,400 B2
`8 892 219 B2
`’
`’
`8,950,276 B2
`9,044,635 B2
`9,364,712 B2
`2001/0053735 A1
`2003/0064863 A1
`2003/0166437 A1
`2003/0171190 A1
`2005/0020410 A1
`2007/0011027 A1
`388;;8:?;3§§ :1
`2007/0219059 A1
`2007/0232452 A1
`2007/0254778 A1
`2008/0015089 A1
`2008/0051256 A1
`2008/0096725 A1
`2008/0096726 A1
`2008/0125288 A1
`2008/0161733 A1
`2008/0300110 A1
`2009/0098980 A1
`2009/0227429 A1
`2009/0233769 A1
`2009/0258758 A1
`2009/0291805 A1
`2010/0062818 A1
`2010/0197461 A1
`2010/0234185 A1
`2010/0279823 A1
`2011/0071003 A1
`2011/0172059 A1
`2011/0224999 A1
`2011/0098156 A1
`
`152883 3:11:32: et a1.
`12/2009 Watterson et a1.
`12/2009 Hickman
`1/2010 Ashby et a1.
`“2010 Watterson et 3L
`2/2010 Pacheco et 31'
`3/2010 Dalebout et 31'
`5/2010 H1ckman
`5/2010 Watterson et a1.
`5/2010 S1monson et a1.
`6/2010 Martens
`6/2010 Dalebout et a1.
`8/2010 Dalebout et 31.
`8/2010 Dalebout et 31.
`8/2010 Lo
`9/2010 Watterson et a1.
`12/2010 Hickman et al.
`“2011 Watterson et 3L
`“2011 Hendrlckson et 31'
`“2011 Hurw1tz et a1.
`3/2011 Olason et a1.
`3/2011 Chen et a1.
`3/2011 Dalebout et a1.
`5/2011 Eisner
`7/2011 Hickman
`7/2011 Watterson et 31.
`9/2011 D’Eredita
`10/2011 Ashby et a1.
`11/2011 Lohr et a1.
`“/2011 Werner et 3L
`10/2012 Hickman
`11/2013 Watt et al.
`7/2014 Ashby et a1.
`10/2014 Johnson
`“/2014 P or
`ry
`2/2015 Wu
`6/2015 Lull
`6/2016 Wu
`12/2001 Cohen et a1.
`4/2003 Chen
`9/2003 Ho
`9/2003 Rice
`1/2005 Chang
`“2007 Melendez
`$588; Eel/2:31:21: 31'
`9/2007 Schwartz et a1.
`10/2007 Hanoun
`11/2007 Ashby
`1/2008 Hurwitz et a1.
`2/2008 Ashby et a1.
`4/2008 Keiser
`4/2008 Riley et 31.
`5/2008 Case
`7/2008 Einav et 31.
`12/2008 Smith et 31.
`4/2009 Waters
`9/2009 Baudhuin
`9/2009 Pryor
`10/2009 Hickman et a1.
`11/2009 Blum et a1.
`3/2010 Haughay, Jr. et a1.
`8/2010 Czarnecki
`9/2010 Watt 6t 31.
`11/2010 Waters
`3/2011 Watterson et a1.
`7/2011 Watterson et a1.
`9/2011 Baccarella-garcia
`12/2011 Ng et a1.
`
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED),“Response in Opposition re 89 Motion to Dismiss Plain-
`tiff’s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)” filed by
`Peloton Interactive, Inc., (Smith, Melissa), Docket 105, filed on
`Aug. 21, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Reply to Response to Motion re 89 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”, filed by
`Fl
`h IS It
`I
`G' b
`J ff
`D k t106 fil d A
`3"” ee
`P0 5’ n°"( ”‘5 erg’ e reY)’
`0° e
`’
`e 0“ “’3'
`23, 2019
`_
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Sur-Reply to Reply to Response to Motion re 89 Motion
`to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to
`State a Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”,
`filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc.,(Smith, Melissa), Docket 107, filed
`on Aug. 30, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Report and Recommendations re 89 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”, filed by
`Fl
`heelS It
`I
`.
`db M . tr t
`J d R S P
`3"”
`P0 5’ 1”" S‘gne
`y
`agls ‘1 e “ ge 0y '
`ayne 0“
`Sep. 5, 2019, Docket 108, entered on Sep. 6, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Objection to 108 Report and Recommendations by
`Flywheel Sports, Inc.”, (Ginsberg, Jeffrey), Docket 112, entered on
`Sep. 20, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Response to 112 Objection to Report and Recommen-
`dations filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc.”, (Smith, Melissa), Docket
`119, entered on Oct. 4, 2019
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-
`“
`,
`.
`.
`2019-00564, Patent Owner s Response to Pet1t10n for Inter PaItes
`Review [Public Redacted] and Exhibits” Docket 33 Sep. 3 2019.
`’
`’
`’
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-
`2019-00295, “Flywheel Infringement Contentions”, Docket 2048,
`Sep. 3, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-19-cV-00317
`(TXED), “Complaint against Flywheel Sports, Inc. with attach-
`ments”, filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc., (Smith, Melissa), Docket
`1, entered on Sep. 20, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-2019-
`00294, “Peloton’s Opposition to Motion to Stay”, Docket 1030,
`entered on OCt'
`.3’ 2019'
`.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Echelon. Fitness, LhC., 1-19-cV-01903
`(DED),- Comp1a1nt for Patent Infr1ngement w1th-attachments 7
`filed w1th Jury, Mag1strate Consent Not1ce to P1a1nt1ff, Docket 1,
`entered on Oct 8a 2019
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-2019-
`00294, “Peloton Bike Claim Charts”, Docket 2053, filed Sep. 3,
`2019.
`“NetAthlon 2XF Software, WebRacing Component of NetAthlon
`2XF Software and/or WebRacer Bike incorporating NetAthlon
`Software”, Software on sale at http://www.webracingstore.com/
`indexphp/netathlonhtml, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.org/web/20110418014442/http://www.instyleaerobiking.co.
`uk:80/catalog/index.php?main7page:index&cPath:66>, 1 page.
`“NetAthlon Version 2XF”, Cycling 2XF User Guide, Publication
`date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the
`internet: <URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20110313210842/http://
`www.webracing.org/trailidownloads/NA%202XF%20for%
`20Cycling%202.2.pdf>, 40 pages.
`Instylefitness, “Instyle Fitness WebRacer Bike”, Published on Mar.
`15, 2011, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://youtu.be/bWFIXEuZUZY>, 2 pages.
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 5 of 34 PageID #: 89
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 5 of 34 PageID #: 89
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`Page 4
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`“Virtual Reality Fitness Experience”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110424065356/http://www.webracing.
`0rg/index.htm>, 1 page.
`“Commercial Products”, Fitness is Evolving, A revolution is taking
`place in our gym culture, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive .0rg/web/20 1 10424050520/http://www.webracing.0rg/
`commercia1.htm>, 1 page.
`“Turn your fitness equipment into a fitness experience”, RA Sports,
`Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved
`from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113140506/
`http://www.riderunr0w.com/index.htm>, 1 page.
`“Fitness Machines Compatibility”, NetAth10n® Compatible Fitness
`Equipments,WebRacing, Inc., Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110123111916/http://www.riderunr0w.com/fitness7
`machines.htm>, 1 page.
`“NetAthlon® 2XF Virtual Interactive Fitness Software for Cycling”,
`NetAthlon® Products, WebRacing, Inc ., Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113140511/http://www.riderunr0w.
`com/productsina2.htm>, 3 pages.
`“Turn Any Bike Trainer, ExerciseBike, Treadmill, 0r Rowing Machine
`into a Virtual Reality Experiencefor home and club use”, PEAK
`Virtual Indoor Training System, WebRacing, Inc., Publication date
`is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113142318/http://www.
`riderunrow.com/pr0ductsisensors.htm>, 2 pages.
`“WebRacing®”, WebRacing, Inc., Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110503225914/http://riderunr0w.com/
`productsiwebracing.htm>, 2 pages.
`“Peak Sensor Kit Installation and User’s Guide”, Model ITS-2,
`WebRacingTM Ltd., Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20120816050742/http://www.riderunr0w.com/pdf/
`CYCLEFXSensorGuide.pdf>, 18 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Bike and Expresso Live service”, On sale by various
`dealers, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20101101203035/http://www.ifholdings.com/buyinow/dealers.
`htm>, 2 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Novo”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110713004606/http://www.ifl101dings.com/index.
`htm>, 1 page.
`“Ride on Expresso Biles”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110111201822/http://www.express0.net/UserP01tal/
`welcomed 0>, 1 page.
`“Rider Experience”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20111001031535/http://ifl101dings.com/experience/index.
`htm1>, 1 page.
`“Expresso Rider Experience”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/2011100103135 8/httpz/ifholdings.com/experience/
`rideriinteractiveiexperience.htm1>, 3 pages.
`“The Expresso Interactive Cardio System”, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120123205226/http://www.
`ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/s3inovoibrochure72011.
`pdf>, 4 pages.
`“Expresso S3 N0v0 Products Specification”, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120402221412/http://www.
`ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/s37n0v07e17spec .pdf>, 5 pages.
`
`“Expresso Live! ”, Harnessing the Internet and social media for you,
`Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved
`from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20111005111028/
`http://ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/expressoiliveibro.
`pdf>, 2 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Upright Bike”, User Guide, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://s3 .amazonaws.com/docs.ifl101dings.com/IFH7S37UG.
`pdf>, 8 pages.
`“Expresso Bikes, The Experience”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`http://www.ucfitness.pitt.edu/img/equip/cardio/exp7s3ur7br071008087
`web.pdf>, 2 pages.
`Expressorussia, Expresso Interactive Exercise Bike, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.
`youtube.com/watch?v:41tNF1AWuBU>, Nov. 14, 2012, 2 pages.
`“Wayback Machine”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110614001441/http://singu1arityhub.com/2010/
`12/06/vide0-game-exercisebikes-ride-0nt0-the-social-netw0r1d>, 4
`pages.
`Wattbike, on sale at http://wattbike.com/us/sh0p, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: http://wattbike.com/us/sh0p>, 3 pages.
`Wattbike, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110702220339/http://wattbike.com/uldwattbike/>, 5 pages.
`Wattbike, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110604140446/http://wattbike.com/us/>, 3 pages.
`Wattbike, Train Less, Ride Faster, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110708052957/http://wattbike.com/
`assets/docs/wattbikeibrochure.pdf>, 6 page.
`Wattbike, User Manual, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20140712065824/http://wattbike.com/assets/docs/
`wattbikeiuseri manua1.pdf>, 32 pages.
`Shaman Clown, “Wattbike Indoor Trainer”, [retrieved on Apr. 1,
`2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.y0utube.
`com/watch?v:t0ijde0RA>, Mar. 30, 2010, 2 pages.
`STTu, “Wattbike computer racing”, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.y0utube.com/watch?
`v:YMHthg-Qeg>, Sep. 26, 2011, 2 pages.
`“An introduction to the Wattbike”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110604140626/http://wattbike.com/
`us/wattbike>, 4 pages.
`“Race Power Cycling”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110926050934/http://wattbike.com/u1dwattbike/
`powericyclingisoftware/raceipowericyc1ing>, 1 page.
`“Fitness, Group Cycling and PT”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110604140508/http://wattbike.com/
`us/gymsiandischools/gymsz 3 pages.
`“Group Power Cycling”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110926051143/http://wattbike.com/u1dwattbike/
`powericyclingisoftware/groupipowericyc1ing>, 1 page.
`“Expert Software”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20110901133907/http://wattbike.com/uldwattbike/experti
`s0ftware>,
`1 page.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc.’s cycling classes oifered in New York, Florida,
`and Illinois, Publication date is unknown, class Schedules retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019, Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.
`flywheelsports.com/classes/stadium-cycling>, 4 pages.
`Flywheel Stadium Cycling New York, Performance Metrics, 2012,
`pp. 1-2.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint for
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 6 of 34 PageID #: 90
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 6 of 34 PageID #: 90
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 5
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Failure to State a Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure
`12 (b)(6) filed by Flywheel Sport, Inc.”, Docket 23, Filed on Dec.
`3, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Response in Opposition re 23 Motion to Dismiss Plain-
`tiff’ s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim Pursuant to
`Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by Peloton Interac-
`tive. Inc.”, Docket 29, Filed on Dec. 24, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Reply to Reponses to Motion re 23 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim Pursuant
`to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by Flywheel Sport,
`Inc.”, Docket 31, Filed on Jan. 9, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Sur-Reply to Reply to Response to Motion re 23 Motion
`to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a
`Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by
`Peloton Interactive. Inc.”, Docket 38, Filed on Jan. 23, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276,
`Docket 10, filed on Mar. 6, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response,”
`US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 14, filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB),“Patent Owner’s Sur-Reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition from Inter Partes review”, US.
`Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 15, filed on Mar. 27, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085,
`Docket 10, filed on Mar. 6, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response,”
`US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 14, filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Sur-Reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition from Inter Partes review”, US.
`Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 15, filed on Mar. 27, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276,
`Docket 21, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 23, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855,
`Docket 11, filed on May 8, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 14, filed on May 22, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Sur-reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition for Inter Partes Review”, US. Pat.
`No. 9,861,855, Docket 15, filed on May 28, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855,
`Docket 20, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 22, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085,
`Docket 20, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`
`Flywheel Sport, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’ s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 22, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 2, filed on Nov. 15, 2018.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 1, filed on Jan. 17, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 2, filed on Nov. 15, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED),“Notice by Flywheel Sports, Inc. of Compliance of service
`of PR. 3-3 and 3-4 Invalidity Contention Disclosures (Ginsberg
`Jeffrey)”, Docket 56, Filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390-
`RWS-RSP, “Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement” filed by
`Peloton Interactive, Inc., US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, filed on Nov. 19,
`2018.
`Alshammari et al., “An Investigation on the Identification of VOIP
`Traffic: Case study on Gtalk and Skype,” Retrieved at <https://www.
`cs.dal.ca/sites/default/files/technicalfreports/CS-2010-05.
`pdf>(cited at reference 1 in paper by same name in 2010 Interna-
`tional Conference on Network and Service Management, Niagara
`Falls, ON, 2010, pp. 310-313, Retrieved at <http://ieeexp10re.ieee.
`0rg/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp:&arnumber:569121 0&isnumber:
`5691186>).
`Bonfiglio et a1., “Detailed Analysis of Skype Traific,” in IEEE
`Transactions on Multimedia, v01. 11, N0. 1, pp. 117-127, Jan. 2009,
`Retrieved at <http://ieeexp10re.ieee.0rg/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp:
`&arnumber:471721 0&i snumber:47494 80>.
`Xu et a1., “Video Telephony for End-consumers: Measurement
`Study of G00g1e+,
`iChat, and Skype,” Proceedings of the 2012
`Internet Measurement Conference (IMC ’12). Boston, Massachu-
`setts, Nov. 14-16, 2012, pp. 371-384. DOI: https://d0i.0rg/10.1145/
`2398776.2398816 , Retrieved at <https://dl.acm.0rg/citati0n.cfm?
`doid:2398776.2398816>.
`Lu et a1., “Measurement Study of Multi-party Video Conferencing,”
`Networking 2010, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 6091,
`Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp. 96-108, Retrieved at https://d0i.
`org/10.1007/978-3-642-12963-678 , Retrieved at <https://1ink.
`springer.corn/chapter/10.1007/978-3 -642-12963-678>.
`Leena Rao, “Skype Teams Up With Citrix to Bring GOTOMeeting
`Web Conferencing to Business Offerings,” TechCrunch, Mar. 1,
`2011, Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110305033430/
`http://techcrunch.co m:80/2011/03/01/skype-teams-up-with-citrix-
`t0-bring-g0t0meeting-web-conferencing-to -business-oiferings/> (pp.
`4-8 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Afiidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Elizabeth Woyke, “Facebook, Google Battle to Be Video-Calling
`Home Base,” www.f0rbes.com, Jul. 6, 2011 Retrieved at <https://
`web.archive.0rg/web/20141019021702/http://www.f0rbes.com/sites/
`e1izabethw0yke/2011/07/06/facebook-google-battle-to -be-vide0 -
`calling-h0me-base/> (pp. 9-11 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex.
`A to Aflidavit)).
`Megan Geuss, “Group Video Chat Showdown: Google Hangouts
`and AnyMeeting Come Out on Top,” PCWorld, Nov. 7, 2011,
`Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120928000621/http://
`www.pcw0rld.co m: 80/article/24323 8/gr0up7videoichatishowdowni
`googleihangoutsiandianymeetingic0me70ut70n7t0phtm1> and
`<https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120930044906/http://www.pcw0r1d.
`com:80/article/243238/gr0up7vide0 chatishowdownigooglei
`hangoutsiandianymeetingicomeioutionitop.html?page:2> (Pages
`12-25 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Catherine Saint Louis, in New York, a Rivalry Shifts into High Gear,
`The New York Times (Oct. 8, 2010), Retrieved at <https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20101014044600/http://www.nytimescom/2010/
`10/10/fashi0n/10Spin.htm1> and <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`2010101407393 5/http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/fashi0n/
`10Spin.html?pagewanted:2> (pp. 26-30 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit
`and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 7 of 34 PageID #: 91
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 7 of 34 PageID #: 91
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`Page 6
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`“Soul Cycle vs. Flywheel: A comparison shop and spin,”
`WellandGoodNYC.com (Feb. 22, 2010), Retrieved at https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20161115223126/http://www.welland g00d.com: 80/
`g0od-sweat/soul-cycle-vs-flywheel-a-comparison-shop-and-spin/ (pp.
`31-36 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Lauren Glassberg, “Flatiron studio takes spin class up a notch,”
`abclocal.g0.com (Mar. 11, 2010), Retrieved at <https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20100409054516/http://abclocal.g0.com: 80/wabc/st0ry?
`section:news/loca1&id:7325608> (Pages 37-42 Ex. 1036 (Butler
`Affidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Nick Sortal, “Flywheel brings high-tech cycling to South Florida,”
`Sun Sentinelcom (Apr. 16, 2011), Retrieved at <https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/2011042307245 8/http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/2011-04-
`16/health/fl-hk-flywheel-cycling-041711-20110415717stati0nary-
`cycling-flywheel-specific-bike> and <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110423043400/http://articles.sun-sentinel.comz80/2011-04-16/
`health/fl-hk-flywheel-cycling-04 17 1 1-201 10415717smti0nary-cycling-
`flywheel-specific-bike/2> (pp. 43-44 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Affidavit
`and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Flywheel Website, Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20120529111518/http://www.flywheelsp orts.com/locati0ns> (p. 45
`of Ex. 1036 (Butler Affidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Katherine Rosman, “The Latest Spin in Studio Cycling: Anti-Swe

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket