Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 1 of 34 PageID #: 85
`Case 1:20-cv-00662—UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 1 of 34 PageID #: 85
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT 2
`
`EXHIBIT 2
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 2 of 34 PageID #: 86
`case liZO'CV'OO‘A’F’Z'UNA D°°“"‘e“t 1'1|||1|illlleflFllllfiflllillll'flllfimlillll’I|111111111fillfillflllf6
`
`US010639521B2
`
`(12) United States Patent
`US 10,639,521 B2
`(45) Date of Patent:
`*May 5, 2020
`Foley et al.
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`
`(54)
`
`(71)
`
`(72)
`
`EXERCISE SYSTEM AND METHOD
`
`Applicant: PELOTON INTERACTIVE, INC.,
`New York, NY (US)
`
`Inventors: John Paul Foley, New York, NY (US);
`Hans Schlichting Woolley, West
`Hollywood, CA (US)
`
`(73)
`
`Assignee: Peloton Interactive, Inc., New York,
`NY (US)
`
`(*)
`
`Notice:
`
`Subject to any disclaimer, the term of this
`patent is extended or adjusted under 35
`U.S.C. 154(b) by 0 days.
`
`This patent is subject to a terminal dis-
`claimer.
`
`(21)
`
`Appl. No.: 16/666,332
`
`(22)
`
`Filed:
`
`Oct. 28, 2019
`
`Prior Publication Data
`
`US 2020/0061416 A1
`
`Feb. 27, 2020
`
`Related US. Application Data
`
`Continuation of application No. 16/412,327, filed on
`May 14, 2019, now Pat. No. 10,486,026, which is a
`(Continued)
`
`(65)
`
`(63)
`
`(51)
`
`Int. C l.
`A63B 24/00
`G1 6H 20/10
`
`US. Cl.
`
`(52)
`
`(2006.01)
`(2018.01)
`(Continued)
`
`CPC ........ A633 24/0075 (2013.01); A633 21/015
`(2013.01); A633 22/06 (2013.01);
`(Continued)
`
`240
`
`220
`
`RachelC
`
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`CPC . A63B 24/0075; A63B 24/0062; A63B 22/06;
`A63B 21/015; A63B 22/0605;
`(Continued)
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`4,844,451 A
`4,880,225 A
`
`7/1989 Bersonnet et al.
`11/1989 Lucas et al.
`
`(Continued)
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`EP
`W0
`W0
`
`0919259
`WO 1997/041925
`WO 2005/087323
`
`2/1999
`11/1997
`9/2005
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`US 8,092,344 B2, 01/2012, Tagliabue (withdrawn)
`(Continued)
`
`Primary Examiner 7 Sundhara M Ganesan
`(74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm 7 Haynes and Boone, LLP
`
`ABSTRACT
`(57)
`A method for displaying archived exercise classes compris-
`ing displaying information about archived exercise classes
`that can be accessed by a first user via a computer network
`on a display screen at a first location, wherein the first user
`can select among a plurality of archived classes, outputting
`digital video and audio content comprising the selected
`archived class, detecting a performance parameter for the
`first user at a particular point in the selected class, displaying
`the performance parameter on the display screen, and dis-
`playing performance parameters from a second user at a
`second location on the display screen such that at least one
`of the performance parameters from the first user and at least
`one of the performance parameters from the second user at
`the same point in the class are presented for comparison.
`
`20 Claims, 17 Drawing Sheets
`
`Manheimw
`
`, -_ _ 45 Min Pure Cyde
`
`w [i] 1312'? we @ 591
`
`,0
`
`Chan’le
`
`‘4‘"
`
`.1“:Avg
`
`
`
`“_ hum: not“
`
`
`‘ Cadence _ Output
`”2Resislance
`'
`, Calories
`Avg Max
`HGEIIRale K
`,
`Max
`N9
`92 112
`245 g
`SE? 72
`WATTS
`MPH ‘ RPM
`
`1245 155
`216 508
`| sumac
`172ERC8ENT
`am
`
`‘5“ _
`7Z
`b 77 Q
`228
`1232
`226
`
`,,
`
`224
`
`230
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 3 of 34 PageID #: 87
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1—2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 3 of 34 PageID #: 87
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 2
`
`Related U.S. Application Data
`.
`.
`.
`.
`cont1nuat1on of appl1cat1on No. 16/036,894, filed on
`Jul. 16, 2018, now Pat. No. 10,322,315, which is a
`continuation of application No. 15/865,206, filed on
`'
`'
`Jan..8, 2018, now Pat. .No. 10,022,590, Wthh 1s a
`cont1nuat1on of appl1cat1on No. 14/992,032, filed on
`Jan. 11, 2016, now Pat. No. 9,861,855, which is a
`continuation of application No. 14/930,398, filed on
`-
`-
`NOV: 2’ 2015,fnow1.Pat, N11 93135525766682}??? a
`0011911113190“ 0 311313 10am“
`0-
`,
`,
`e on
`Jul. 31, 2013, HOW Pat. No. 9,174,085.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`Prov1s1onal appl1cat1on No. 61/677,985, filed on Jul.
`31, 2012, provisional application No. 61/798,342,
`filed on Mar‘ 15’ 2013‘
`
`(60)
`
`(51)
`
`(2018.01)
`(2006.01)
`(2006.01)
`(200601)
`(201891)
`(2006.01)
`(2006.01)
`
`Int- 0-
`G16H 15/00
`A63B 22/06
`A63B 21/015
`A63B 71/06
`G16H 20/30
`A633 21/005
`A63B 21/22
`(52) US Cl
`.
`'
`'
`'
`CPC ...... A633 22/0605 (2013.01), A633 24/0062
`(2013.01); A633 71/0622 (2013.01); G16H
`15/00 (2018.01); G16H 20/10 (2018.01);
`G16H 20/30 (2018.01);A63B 21/0051
`.
`.
`(2013.01), A63B 21/225 (2013.01), A63B
`2022/0658 (2013.01); A63B 2024/0065
`(2013.01); A63B 2024/0068 (2013.01); A63B
`2024/0081 (2013.01); A63B 2071/0658
`.
`.
`22909313038133?22313512722209513‘0381343?
`(
`~
`),
`(
`~
`),
`A63B 2220/806 (2013.01); A63B 2225/107
`(2013.01); A63B 2225/20 (2013.01); A63B
`.
`2225/50 (2013.01); A63B 2230/06 (2013.01);
`A63B 2230/40 (2013.01), A63B 2230/75
`(201391)
`
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`.
`.
`CPC ........ A63B 71/0622; A63B 2024/0081; A63B
`2220/34, A63B 2.024/0065, A63B
`2225/50, A63B 21/0051, A63B 2225/20,
`A63B 2022/0658; A63B 2071/0658;
`A63B 2225/107; A63B 2230/06; A63B
`2230/40. A63B 21/225. A63B 2220/58
`’
`.
`’
`.
`’
`A63B 2230/75’ A63B 2220/17’ A63B
`2220/806; A63B 2024/0068; G16H 15/00;
`G16H 20/10; G16H 20/30
`See application file for complete search history.
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`4932550 A
`133%? 2
`4,981,294 A
`5,000,444 A
`5,014,980 A
`5,089,960 A
`5,149,312 A
`5,203,826 A
`5,213,555 A
`5,247,853 A
`5,259,611 A
`
`“990 Bmgham et 31'
`341338 32128811185211.
`1/1991 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1991 Dalebout et a1.
`5/1991 Bersonnet Ct 211.
`2/1992 Sweeney, Jr.
`9/1992 Croft et 31.
`4/1993 Da1ebout
`5/1993 Hood et al.
`9/1993 Dalebout
`11/1993 Dalebout et a1.
`
`5,458,548 A
`5,462,503 A
`5,466,200 A
`5,512,025 A
`2,2335%”; 2
`a
`a
`5,547,439 A
`5,591,106 A
`5,595,556 A
`3,223,322 2
`,
`,
`5,669,857 A
`5,672,140 A
`5,674,156 A
`5,674,453 A
`5,676,624 A
`2,2335%; 2
`,
`,
`5,702,325 A
`5,704,879 A
`5,718,657 A
`5,722,922 A
`5,743,833 A
`5,772,560 A
`5,827,155 A
`5,860,893 A
`5,860,894 A
`5,888,172 A
`5,890,995 A
`5,899,834 A
`5,947,868 A
`RE36,574 E
`6,033,347 A
`6050924 A
`2923;; 2
`a
`a
`6,171,217 B1
`6,171,218 B1
`6,280,362 B1
`2,353,322 31
`,
`,
`6,350,218 B1
`6,458,060 B1
`6,471,622 131
`6,569,063 B2
`,
`,
`223:3; E:
`6,648,798 B2
`6,695,752 B2
`6,702,719 B1
`,
`,
`2,323,222 3%
`6,749,537 B1
`6,761,667 B1
`6,808,472 B1
`6,902,513 B1
`6,918,858 B2
`6,921,351 B1
`6,974,404 B1
`6,997,852 B2
`7,004,888 B1
`7,060,006 B1
`7,060,008 B2
`
`7,077,789 B1
`D532,063 S
`7,166,062 B1
`7,166,064 B2
`7,192,388 B2
`7,285,075 B2
`7,455,622 B2
`Z’Q‘fi’if); E:
`,
`,
`7,537,546 B2
`7,537,549 B2
`7,540,828 B2
`7,549,947 B2
`7,556,590 B2
`7,575,536 B1
`7,603,255 B2
`
`10/1995 Crossing et a1.
`10/1995 Benjamin et a1.
`11/1995 Ulrich et 81.
`4/1996 Dalebout et al.
`28332 FD_a11ebout et 31'
`1n ayson
`8/1996 Rawls et a1.
`1/1997 Dalebout et 31.
`1/1997 Dalebout et a1.
`3133; Siewer 6t 31~
`1
`atterson et a .
`9/1997 Watterson et a1.
`9/1997 Watterson et a1.
`10/1997 Watterson et a1.
`10/1997 Watterson et al.
`10/1997 Watterson et a1.
`13133; 3130:5011 ft 31~
`r10
`et a .
`12/1997 Watterson et a1.
`1/1998 Watterson et al.
`2/1998 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1998 Watterson et al.
`4/1998 Watterson et al.
`6/1998 Watterson et al.
`10/1998 Jensen et al.
`1/1999 Watterson et al.
`1/1999 Dalebout et a1.
`3/1999 Andrus et a1.
`4/1999 Bobick et al.
`5/1999 Dalebout et al.
`9/1999 Dugan
`2/2000 Hochstein et 31.
`3/2000 Dalebout et a1.
`4/2000 Shea
`13/3888 Elckman
`t
`1
`evasseur e a .
`“2001 Cutler
`1/2001 Shea
`8/2001 Dalebout et a1.
`1?;5881 grunfeld et all
`atterson et a .
`72002 Dalebout er 9
`10/2002 Watterson et a1.
`10/2002 Hammer et a1.
`5/2003 Chen
`a erson e a .
`3388;
`{3411811 et 31,
`1
`“/2003 Yoo
`2/2004 Lee
`3/2004 Brown et al.
`us
`en e 3.
`3388::
`212111;: al. 1
`1
`6/2004 Hic
`7/2004 Cutler et 31.
`10/2004 Hickman
`6/2005 McClure
`7/2005 Watterson et al.
`7/2005 Hickman et a1.
`12/2005 Watterson et al.
`2/2006 Watterson et al.
`2/2006 Weng
`6/2006 Watterson et 31.
`6/2006 Watterson et al.
`
`7/2006 Chen
`11/2006 Kim et al.
`1/2007 Watterson et al.
`1/2007 Watterson et al.
`3/2007 Dalebout et al.
`10/2007 Cutler et al.
`11/2008 Watterson et a1.
`lggggg gown, Jr
`10km“
`5/2009 Watterson Ct 211.
`5/2009 Nelson et al.
`6/2009 Watterson et al.
`6/2009 Hickman et a1.
`7/2009 Watterson et al.
`8/2009 Hickman
`10/2009 Case, Jr. et a1.
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 4 of 34 PageID #: 88
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1—2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 4 of 34 PageID #: 88
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 3
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`7,225,133? 3%
`7:628:730 B1
`7,637,847 B1
`7,645,212 B2
`7,645,213 B2
`7,658,698 B2
`776747205 B2
`7’713’171 B1
`7,713,172 B2
`7,717,828 B2
`7,736,272 B2
`7,740,563 B2
`7,766,797 132
`7,775,940 B2
`7,785,236 B1
`7,789,800 B1
`7,857,731 B2
`7,862,478 B2
`7,862,483 B2
`7’874’957 B2
`7’901’323 B2
`7,901,334 B2
`7,909,740 B2
`7,934,983 B1
`7,980,996 B2
`7,981,000 B2
`8,021,270 B2
`8,029,415 B2
`8,052,581 B1
`8,068,858 B2
`8,298,123 B2
`8,585,561 B2
`8’784’270 B2
`8,858,400 B2
`8 892 219 B2
`’
`’
`8,950,276 B2
`9,044,635 B2
`9,364,712 B2
`2001/0053735 A1
`2003/0064863 A1
`2003/0166437 A1
`2003/0171190 A1
`2005/0020410 A1
`2007/0011027 A1
`388;;8:?;3§§ :1
`2007/0219059 A1
`2007/0232452 A1
`2007/0254778 A1
`2008/0015089 A1
`2008/0051256 A1
`2008/0096725 A1
`2008/0096726 A1
`2008/0125288 A1
`2008/0161733 A1
`2008/0300110 A1
`2009/0098980 A1
`2009/0227429 A1
`2009/0233769 A1
`2009/0258758 A1
`2009/0291805 A1
`2010/0062818 A1
`2010/0197461 A1
`2010/0234185 A1
`2010/0279823 A1
`2011/0071003 A1
`2011/0172059 A1
`2011/0224999 A1
`2011/0098156 A1
`
`152883 3:11:32: et a1.
`12/2009 Watterson et a1.
`12/2009 Hickman
`1/2010 Ashby et a1.
`“2010 Watterson et 3L
`2/2010 Pacheco et 31'
`3/2010 Dalebout et 31'
`5/2010 H1ckman
`5/2010 Watterson et a1.
`5/2010 S1monson et a1.
`6/2010 Martens
`6/2010 Dalebout et a1.
`8/2010 Dalebout et 31.
`8/2010 Dalebout et 31.
`8/2010 Lo
`9/2010 Watterson et a1.
`12/2010 Hickman et al.
`“2011 Watterson et 3L
`“2011 Hendrlckson et 31'
`“2011 Hurw1tz et a1.
`3/2011 Olason et a1.
`3/2011 Chen et a1.
`3/2011 Dalebout et a1.
`5/2011 Eisner
`7/2011 Hickman
`7/2011 Watterson et 31.
`9/2011 D’Eredita
`10/2011 Ashby et a1.
`11/2011 Lohr et a1.
`“/2011 Werner et 3L
`10/2012 Hickman
`11/2013 Watt et al.
`7/2014 Ashby et a1.
`10/2014 Johnson
`“/2014 P or
`ry
`2/2015 Wu
`6/2015 Lull
`6/2016 Wu
`12/2001 Cohen et a1.
`4/2003 Chen
`9/2003 Ho
`9/2003 Rice
`1/2005 Chang
`“2007 Melendez
`$588; Eel/2:31:21: 31'
`9/2007 Schwartz et a1.
`10/2007 Hanoun
`11/2007 Ashby
`1/2008 Hurwitz et a1.
`2/2008 Ashby et a1.
`4/2008 Keiser
`4/2008 Riley et 31.
`5/2008 Case
`7/2008 Einav et 31.
`12/2008 Smith et 31.
`4/2009 Waters
`9/2009 Baudhuin
`9/2009 Pryor
`10/2009 Hickman et a1.
`11/2009 Blum et a1.
`3/2010 Haughay, Jr. et a1.
`8/2010 Czarnecki
`9/2010 Watt 6t 31.
`11/2010 Waters
`3/2011 Watterson et a1.
`7/2011 Watterson et a1.
`9/2011 Baccarella-garcia
`12/2011 Ng et a1.
`
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED),“Response in Opposition re 89 Motion to Dismiss Plain-
`tiff’s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)” filed by
`Peloton Interactive, Inc., (Smith, Melissa), Docket 105, filed on
`Aug. 21, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Reply to Response to Motion re 89 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”, filed by
`Fl
`h IS It
`I
`G' b
`J ff
`D k t106 fil d A
`3"” ee
`P0 5’ n°"( ”‘5 erg’ e reY)’
`0° e
`’
`e 0“ “’3'
`23, 2019
`_
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Sur-Reply to Reply to Response to Motion re 89 Motion
`to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to
`State a Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”,
`filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc.,(Smith, Melissa), Docket 107, filed
`on Aug. 30, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Report and Recommendations re 89 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Second Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim
`Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6)”, filed by
`Fl
`heelS It
`I
`.
`db M . tr t
`J d R S P
`3"”
`P0 5’ 1”" S‘gne
`y
`agls ‘1 e “ ge 0y '
`ayne 0“
`Sep. 5, 2019, Docket 108, entered on Sep. 6, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Objection to 108 Report and Recommendations by
`Flywheel Sports, Inc.”, (Ginsberg, Jeffrey), Docket 112, entered on
`Sep. 20, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cV-00390
`(TXED), “Response to 112 Objection to Report and Recommen-
`dations filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc.”, (Smith, Melissa), Docket
`119, entered on Oct. 4, 2019
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-
`“
`,
`.
`.
`2019-00564, Patent Owner s Response to Pet1t10n for Inter PaItes
`Review [Public Redacted] and Exhibits” Docket 33 Sep. 3 2019.
`’
`’
`’
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-
`2019-00295, “Flywheel Infringement Contentions”, Docket 2048,
`Sep. 3, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-19-cV-00317
`(TXED), “Complaint against Flywheel Sports, Inc. with attach-
`ments”, filed by Peloton Interactive, Inc., (Smith, Melissa), Docket
`1, entered on Sep. 20, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-2019-
`00294, “Peloton’s Opposition to Motion to Stay”, Docket 1030,
`entered on OCt'
`.3’ 2019'
`.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Echelon. Fitness, LhC., 1-19-cV-01903
`(DED),- Comp1a1nt for Patent Infr1ngement w1th-attachments 7
`filed w1th Jury, Mag1strate Consent Not1ce to P1a1nt1ff, Docket 1,
`entered on Oct 8a 2019
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. V. Peloton Interactive, Inc., PTAB-IPR-2019-
`00294, “Peloton Bike Claim Charts”, Docket 2053, filed Sep. 3,
`2019.
`“NetAthlon 2XF Software, WebRacing Component of NetAthlon
`2XF Software and/or WebRacer Bike incorporating NetAthlon
`Software”, Software on sale at http://www.webracingstore.com/
`indexphp/netathlonhtml, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.org/web/20110418014442/http://www.instyleaerobiking.co.
`uk:80/catalog/index.php?main7page:index&cPath:66>, 1 page.
`“NetAthlon Version 2XF”, Cycling 2XF User Guide, Publication
`date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the
`internet: <URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20110313210842/http://
`www.webracing.org/trailidownloads/NA%202XF%20for%
`20Cycling%202.2.pdf>, 40 pages.
`Instylefitness, “Instyle Fitness WebRacer Bike”, Published on Mar.
`15, 2011, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://youtu.be/bWFIXEuZUZY>, 2 pages.
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 5 of 34 PageID #: 89
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 5 of 34 PageID #: 89
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`Page 4
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`“Virtual Reality Fitness Experience”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110424065356/http://www.webracing.
`0rg/index.htm>, 1 page.
`“Commercial Products”, Fitness is Evolving, A revolution is taking
`place in our gym culture, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive .0rg/web/20 1 10424050520/http://www.webracing.0rg/
`commercia1.htm>, 1 page.
`“Turn your fitness equipment into a fitness experience”, RA Sports,
`Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved
`from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113140506/
`http://www.riderunr0w.com/index.htm>, 1 page.
`“Fitness Machines Compatibility”, NetAth10n® Compatible Fitness
`Equipments,WebRacing, Inc., Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110123111916/http://www.riderunr0w.com/fitness7
`machines.htm>, 1 page.
`“NetAthlon® 2XF Virtual Interactive Fitness Software for Cycling”,
`NetAthlon® Products, WebRacing, Inc ., Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113140511/http://www.riderunr0w.
`com/productsina2.htm>, 3 pages.
`“Turn Any Bike Trainer, ExerciseBike, Treadmill, 0r Rowing Machine
`into a Virtual Reality Experiencefor home and club use”, PEAK
`Virtual Indoor Training System, WebRacing, Inc., Publication date
`is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110113142318/http://www.
`riderunrow.com/pr0ductsisensors.htm>, 2 pages.
`“WebRacing®”, WebRacing, Inc., Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110503225914/http://riderunr0w.com/
`productsiwebracing.htm>, 2 pages.
`“Peak Sensor Kit Installation and User’s Guide”, Model ITS-2,
`WebRacingTM Ltd., Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20120816050742/http://www.riderunr0w.com/pdf/
`CYCLEFXSensorGuide.pdf>, 18 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Bike and Expresso Live service”, On sale by various
`dealers, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20101101203035/http://www.ifholdings.com/buyinow/dealers.
`htm>, 2 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Novo”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110713004606/http://www.ifl101dings.com/index.
`htm>, 1 page.
`“Ride on Expresso Biles”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110111201822/http://www.express0.net/UserP01tal/
`welcomed 0>, 1 page.
`“Rider Experience”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20111001031535/http://ifl101dings.com/experience/index.
`htm1>, 1 page.
`“Expresso Rider Experience”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/2011100103135 8/httpz/ifholdings.com/experience/
`rideriinteractiveiexperience.htm1>, 3 pages.
`“The Expresso Interactive Cardio System”, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120123205226/http://www.
`ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/s3inovoibrochure72011.
`pdf>, 4 pages.
`“Expresso S3 N0v0 Products Specification”, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120402221412/http://www.
`ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/s37n0v07e17spec .pdf>, 5 pages.
`
`“Expresso Live! ”, Harnessing the Internet and social media for you,
`Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved
`from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20111005111028/
`http://ifholdings.com/pdf/productiservices/expressoiliveibro.
`pdf>, 2 pages.
`“Expresso S3 Upright Bike”, User Guide, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: https://s3 .amazonaws.com/docs.ifl101dings.com/IFH7S37UG.
`pdf>, 8 pages.
`“Expresso Bikes, The Experience”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`http://www.ucfitness.pitt.edu/img/equip/cardio/exp7s3ur7br071008087
`web.pdf>, 2 pages.
`Expressorussia, Expresso Interactive Exercise Bike, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.
`youtube.com/watch?v:41tNF1AWuBU>, Nov. 14, 2012, 2 pages.
`“Wayback Machine”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110614001441/http://singu1arityhub.com/2010/
`12/06/vide0-game-exercisebikes-ride-0nt0-the-social-netw0r1d>, 4
`pages.
`Wattbike, on sale at http://wattbike.com/us/sh0p, Publication date is
`unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet:
`<URL: http://wattbike.com/us/sh0p>, 3 pages.
`Wattbike, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110702220339/http://wattbike.com/uldwattbike/>, 5 pages.
`Wattbike, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110604140446/http://wattbike.com/us/>, 3 pages.
`Wattbike, Train Less, Ride Faster, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110708052957/http://wattbike.com/
`assets/docs/wattbikeibrochure.pdf>, 6 page.
`Wattbike, User Manual, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20140712065824/http://wattbike.com/assets/docs/
`wattbikeiuseri manua1.pdf>, 32 pages.
`Shaman Clown, “Wattbike Indoor Trainer”, [retrieved on Apr. 1,
`2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.y0utube.
`com/watch?v:t0ijde0RA>, Mar. 30, 2010, 2 pages.
`STTu, “Wattbike computer racing”, [retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019],
`Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.y0utube.com/watch?
`v:YMHthg-Qeg>, Sep. 26, 2011, 2 pages.
`“An introduction to the Wattbike”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110604140626/http://wattbike.com/
`us/wattbike>, 4 pages.
`“Race Power Cycling”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110926050934/http://wattbike.com/u1dwattbike/
`powericyclingisoftware/raceipowericyc1ing>, 1 page.
`“Fitness, Group Cycling and PT”, Publication date is unknown,
`[retrieved on Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL:
`https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110604140508/http://wattbike.com/
`us/gymsiandischools/gymsz 3 pages.
`“Group Power Cycling”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on
`Apr. 1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20110926051143/http://wattbike.com/u1dwattbike/
`powericyclingisoftware/groupipowericyc1ing>, 1 page.
`“Expert Software”, Publication date is unknown, [retrieved on Apr.
`1, 2019], Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20110901133907/http://wattbike.com/uldwattbike/experti
`s0ftware>,
`1 page.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc.’s cycling classes oifered in New York, Florida,
`and Illinois, Publication date is unknown, class Schedules retrieved
`on Apr. 1, 2019, Retrieved from the internet: <URL: https://www.
`flywheelsports.com/classes/stadium-cycling>, 4 pages.
`Flywheel Stadium Cycling New York, Performance Metrics, 2012,
`pp. 1-2.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint for
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 6 of 34 PageID #: 90
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 6 of 34 PageID #: 90
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`
`Page 5
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Failure to State a Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure
`12 (b)(6) filed by Flywheel Sport, Inc.”, Docket 23, Filed on Dec.
`3, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Response in Opposition re 23 Motion to Dismiss Plain-
`tiff’ s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim Pursuant to
`Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by Peloton Interac-
`tive. Inc.”, Docket 29, Filed on Dec. 24, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Reply to Reponses to Motion re 23 Motion to Dismiss
`Plaintiff s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a Claim Pursuant
`to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by Flywheel Sport,
`Inc.”, Docket 31, Filed on Jan. 9, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. V. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED), “Sur-Reply to Reply to Response to Motion re 23 Motion
`to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint for Failure to State a
`Claim Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 (b)(6) filed by
`Peloton Interactive. Inc.”, Docket 38, Filed on Jan. 23, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276,
`Docket 10, filed on Mar. 6, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response,”
`US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 14, filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB),“Patent Owner’s Sur-Reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition from Inter Partes review”, US.
`Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 15, filed on Mar. 27, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085,
`Docket 10, filed on Mar. 6, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response,”
`US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 14, filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Sur-Reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition from Inter Partes review”, US.
`Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 15, filed on Mar. 27, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276,
`Docket 21, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 23, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response to Petition
`for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855,
`Docket 11, filed on May 8, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Reply to Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 14, filed on May 22, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Sur-reply t0 Petitioner’s Reply to
`Preliminary Response to Petition for Inter Partes Review”, US. Pat.
`No. 9,861,855, Docket 15, filed on May 28, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855,
`Docket 20, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 22, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Trial Instituted Document”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085,
`Docket 20, filed on Jun. 5, 2019.
`
`Flywheel Sport, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Patent Owner’s Objections to Petitioner’ s Pre-Trial
`Evidence”, US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 22, filed on Jun. 19,
`2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00295 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,233,276, Docket 2, filed on Nov. 15, 2018.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00564 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,861,855, Docket 1, filed on Jan. 17, 2019.
`Flywheel Sports, Inc. et al v. Peloton Interactive, Inc., IPR2019-
`00294 (PTAB), “Petition for Inter Partes Review and Exhibits”,
`US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, Docket 2, filed on Nov. 15, 2018.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390
`(TXED),“Notice by Flywheel Sports, Inc. of Compliance of service
`of PR. 3-3 and 3-4 Invalidity Contention Disclosures (Ginsberg
`Jeffrey)”, Docket 56, Filed on Mar. 21, 2019.
`Peloton Interactive, Inc. v. Flywheel Sports, Inc., 2-18-cv-00390-
`RWS-RSP, “Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement” filed by
`Peloton Interactive, Inc., US. Pat. No. 9,174,085, filed on Nov. 19,
`2018.
`Alshammari et al., “An Investigation on the Identification of VOIP
`Traffic: Case study on Gtalk and Skype,” Retrieved at <https://www.
`cs.dal.ca/sites/default/files/technicalfreports/CS-2010-05.
`pdf>(cited at reference 1 in paper by same name in 2010 Interna-
`tional Conference on Network and Service Management, Niagara
`Falls, ON, 2010, pp. 310-313, Retrieved at <http://ieeexp10re.ieee.
`0rg/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp:&arnumber:569121 0&isnumber:
`5691186>).
`Bonfiglio et a1., “Detailed Analysis of Skype Traific,” in IEEE
`Transactions on Multimedia, v01. 11, N0. 1, pp. 117-127, Jan. 2009,
`Retrieved at <http://ieeexp10re.ieee.0rg/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp:
`&arnumber:471721 0&i snumber:47494 80>.
`Xu et a1., “Video Telephony for End-consumers: Measurement
`Study of G00g1e+,
`iChat, and Skype,” Proceedings of the 2012
`Internet Measurement Conference (IMC ’12). Boston, Massachu-
`setts, Nov. 14-16, 2012, pp. 371-384. DOI: https://d0i.0rg/10.1145/
`2398776.2398816 , Retrieved at <https://dl.acm.0rg/citati0n.cfm?
`doid:2398776.2398816>.
`Lu et a1., “Measurement Study of Multi-party Video Conferencing,”
`Networking 2010, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 6091,
`Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp. 96-108, Retrieved at https://d0i.
`org/10.1007/978-3-642-12963-678 , Retrieved at <https://1ink.
`springer.corn/chapter/10.1007/978-3 -642-12963-678>.
`Leena Rao, “Skype Teams Up With Citrix to Bring GOTOMeeting
`Web Conferencing to Business Offerings,” TechCrunch, Mar. 1,
`2011, Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/20110305033430/
`http://techcrunch.co m:80/2011/03/01/skype-teams-up-with-citrix-
`t0-bring-g0t0meeting-web-conferencing-to -business-oiferings/> (pp.
`4-8 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Afiidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Elizabeth Woyke, “Facebook, Google Battle to Be Video-Calling
`Home Base,” www.f0rbes.com, Jul. 6, 2011 Retrieved at <https://
`web.archive.0rg/web/20141019021702/http://www.f0rbes.com/sites/
`e1izabethw0yke/2011/07/06/facebook-google-battle-to -be-vide0 -
`calling-h0me-base/> (pp. 9-11 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex.
`A to Aflidavit)).
`Megan Geuss, “Group Video Chat Showdown: Google Hangouts
`and AnyMeeting Come Out on Top,” PCWorld, Nov. 7, 2011,
`Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120928000621/http://
`www.pcw0rld.co m: 80/article/24323 8/gr0up7videoichatishowdowni
`googleihangoutsiandianymeetingic0me70ut70n7t0phtm1> and
`<https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120930044906/http://www.pcw0r1d.
`com:80/article/243238/gr0up7vide0 chatishowdownigooglei
`hangoutsiandianymeetingicomeioutionitop.html?page:2> (Pages
`12-25 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Catherine Saint Louis, in New York, a Rivalry Shifts into High Gear,
`The New York Times (Oct. 8, 2010), Retrieved at <https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20101014044600/http://www.nytimescom/2010/
`10/10/fashi0n/10Spin.htm1> and <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`2010101407393 5/http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/fashi0n/
`10Spin.html?pagewanted:2> (pp. 26-30 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit
`and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 7 of 34 PageID #: 91
`Case 1:20-cv-00662-UNA Document 1-2 Filed 05/15/20 Page 7 of 34 PageID #: 91
`
`US 10,639,521 B2
`Page 6
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`“Soul Cycle vs. Flywheel: A comparison shop and spin,”
`WellandGoodNYC.com (Feb. 22, 2010), Retrieved at https://web.
`archive.0rg/web/20161115223126/http://www.welland g00d.com: 80/
`g0od-sweat/soul-cycle-vs-flywheel-a-comparison-shop-and-spin/ (pp.
`31-36 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Aifidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Lauren Glassberg, “Flatiron studio takes spin class up a notch,”
`abclocal.g0.com (Mar. 11, 2010), Retrieved at <https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/20100409054516/http://abclocal.g0.com: 80/wabc/st0ry?
`section:news/loca1&id:7325608> (Pages 37-42 Ex. 1036 (Butler
`Affidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Nick Sortal, “Flywheel brings high-tech cycling to South Florida,”
`Sun Sentinelcom (Apr. 16, 2011), Retrieved at <https://web.archive.
`0rg/web/2011042307245 8/http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/2011-04-
`16/health/fl-hk-flywheel-cycling-041711-20110415717stati0nary-
`cycling-flywheel-specific-bike> and <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20110423043400/http://articles.sun-sentinel.comz80/2011-04-16/
`health/fl-hk-flywheel-cycling-04 17 1 1-201 10415717smti0nary-cycling-
`flywheel-specific-bike/2> (pp. 43-44 of Ex. 1036 (Butler Affidavit
`and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Flywheel Website, Retrieved at <https://web.archive.0rg/web/
`20120529111518/http://www.flywheelsp orts.com/locati0ns> (p. 45
`of Ex. 1036 (Butler Affidavit and Ex. A to Aflidavit)).
`Katherine Rosman, “The Latest Spin in Studio Cycling: Anti-Swe