Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 1 of 10 PageID #: 1503
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`Filed 10/25/24
`Page 1of 10 PagelD #: 1503
`
`Exhibit A
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 2 of 10 PageID #: 1504
`Filed 10/25/24
`Page 2 of 10 PagelD #: 1504
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`
`Comparison: 772 Patent Claims Compared to Asserted ’920 Patent Claims!
`
`7920 Patent Claim 1
`°772 Patent Claim 11
`
`
`
`
`A method=ofmethod of presenting 1. A presenting
`
`
`
`1.
`l.a
`representations of payment accepting
`representations of payment accepting
`unit events, comprising:
`unit events, comprising:
`
`at a mobile device with one or more
`
`processors, Memory, one or more
`output devices including a display, and
`one or moreradio transceivers:
`
`at a mobile device with one or more
`
`processors, memory, one or more
`output devices including a display, and
`one or more radio transceivers:
`
`1.b
`
`l.c
`
`l.d
`
`
`
`the one or more payment
`
`or more
`one
`identifying
`or more
`one
`identifying
`units—in
`payment
`accepting
`units
`im
`payment
`accepting
`
`proximit;tethemebile-deviee
`that
`proximity to the mobile device that
`are available to accept payment
`are available to accept payment
`from a mobile payment application
`from a mobile payment application
`executing on the mobile device, the
`executing on the mobile device, the
`identifying based at least in part on
`identifying basedat least in part on
`an identifier corresponding to the
`an_identifier___or__location
`one or more payment accepting
`corresponding to the one or more
`payment accepting units, wherein
`units, wherein the one or more
`payment
`accepting
`units
`are
`the one or more payment accepting
`payment operated machines that
`units
`are
`payment
`operated
`accept payment for dispensing of
`machines that accept payment for
`products and/orservices;
`dispensing of products
`and/or
`services;
`
`displaying a user interface ofthe
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device, the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visualindication ofthe one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input ¢e-4}+ecene
`
`displaying a user interface of the
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device,
`the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visualindication ofthe one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input to (i) receive
`selection by a user of the mobile
`device of an available payment
`accepting unit of the one or more
`payment accepting units and (11)
`trigger payment by the mobile
`payment
`pplication
`for
`a
`transaction initiated by the user of
`themebie-deeesth-theselecting
`the mobile device with the available
`payment accepting unit ofthe one or
`an available paymentaccepting unit
`more payment accepting units;
`of
`
`lp
`
`to-5
`
`
`ent; Blue Bold and
`Underlined Text reflect text added to claims of the ?920 Patent
`
`1
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 3 of 10 PageID #: 1505
`
`1.e
`
`1.f
`
`1.g
`
`11.a
`
`11.b
`
`11.c
`
`accepting units;
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`after establishing the wireless
`communication path, enabling user
`interaction with the user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`complete a transaction with the
`available payment accepting unit,
`wherein
`the user
`interface
`includes a visual representation of
`the available payment accepting
`unit, an indication of a balance,
`and an affordance
`that,
`in
`response to a user input, indicates
`completion of the transaction;
`exchanging
`information with
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`the
`after
`exchanging
`the
`information, displaying, on
`display, an updated user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`Claim 1 of the ’920 Patent is an
`independent claim
`
`Limitation 1.e of the ’920 Patent recites
`“a visual representation of the available
`payment accepting unit;”
`Limitation 1.e of the ’920 Patent recites
`“an indication of a prepared balance;”
`
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`after establishing the wireless
`communication path, enabling user
`interaction with the user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`complete the transaction;
`
`
`
`information with
`exchanging
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`the
`after
`exchanging
`the
`information, displaying, on
`display, an updated user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`The method of claim 1, wherein the user
`interface of
`the mobile payment
`application, after establishing
`the
`wireless communication path, includes:
`a visual representation of the
`available payment accepting unit;
`
`an indication of a prepared
`balance; and
`
`2
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 4 of 10 PageID #: 1506
`Page 4 of 10 PagelD #: 1506
`Filed 10/25/24
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`
`
`
`an affordance that whenslid,
`indicates
`the
`initiation of
`the
`transaction:
`
`wherein the affordanceis slid in
`response to receiving a user input of
`swipe on the affordance-displayed
`on the display of the mobile device.
`
`Limitation 1.e of the "920 Patentrecites
`“an affordance that—vhen—skd,
`in
`responseto a user input, indicates the
`initiaten-completion of the transaction
`herein
`4
`ford
`@
`slid
`—j
`:
`.
`.
`swipe e# the affordance displayed-on
`he
`dice!
`-
`ile
`devies”
`
`
`
`
`Limitation|*772 Patent Claim 9 (Disclaimed by 7920 Patent Claim 9
`
`
`PayRange on Nov.22, 2023. See id.
`
`comprising:
`
`The method of claim 1, further
`comprising:
`
`in addition to exchanging the
`in addition to exchanging the
`information, receiving, via the one
`information, receiving, via the one
`or moreradio transceivers, a coupon
`or more radio transceivers, a coupon
`that is targeted to the user of the
`that is targeted to the user of the
`
`
`mobile on_the on_thedevice based mobile device based
`
`
`
`
`
`transaction.
`transaction.
`
`ll.d
`
`Limitation
`
`3
`
`4
`9
`
`7772 Patent Claim 4 (Disclaimed by
`PayRangeon Nov.22, 2023. See D.I.
`1, Ex. 5.
`The method of claim 1, wherein the
`information indicates completion of the
`transaction between the user of the
`mobile
`device
`and
`the
`available
`payment accepting unit.
`
`The method of claim 3, wherein the
`mobile device includes a long-range
`transceiver and the informationat least
`includes an amount of the completed
`transaction, and the method further
`comprises:
`
`sending at least the amount of
`the completed transaction to a
`server
`via
`the
`long-range
`transceiver.
`
`920 Patent Claim 4
`
`The method of claim 1, wherein the
`information indicates completion of the
`transaction between the user of the
`mobile
`device
`and
`the
`available
`payment accepting unit.
`
`The method of claim 3, wherein the
`mobile device includes a long-range
`transceiver and the informationatleast
`includes an amount of the completed
`transaction, and the method further
`comprises:
`
`sending at least the amount of
`the completed transaction to a
`server
`via
`the
`long-range
`transceiver.
`
`
` The method of claim 1, further
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 5 of 10 PageID #: 1507
`Page 5 of 10 PagelD #: 1507
`Filed 10/25/24
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`
`Limitation|’772 Patent Claim 10 (Disclaimed by 7920 Patent Claim 10
`
`
`PayRange on Nov. 22, 2023. See id.
`The method of claim 1, wherein the
`user interface of the mobile payment
`application, after establishing the
`wireless communication path, indicates
`that the wireless communication path
`has been established with the available
`payment accepting unit.
`
`10
`
`Limitation
`
`12
`
`°772 Patent Claim 12 (Disclaimed by
`PayRange on Nov. 22, 2023. See id.
`The method of claim 1, wherein the
`payment operated machines include a
`payment activated washer, a payment
`activated dryer, a vending machine, a
`parking meter, a toll booth, an arcade
`game, a kiosk, a photo booth,or a ticket
`
`The methodofclaim 1, wherein the user
`interface of
`the mobile payment
`application,
`after
`establishing
`the
`wireless communication path, indicates
`that the wireless communication path
`has been established with the available
`payment accepting unit.
`
`7920 Patent Claim 12
`
`The method of claim 1, wherein the
`payment operated machines include a
`payment activated washer, a payment
`activated dryer, a vending machine, a
`parking meter, a toll booth, an arcade
`game,a kiosk, a photo booth,or a ticket
`dispensing machine.
`
`
`
`
` dispensing machine.
`
`
`Limitation|’772 Patent Claim 13 (Disclaimed by 7920 Patent Claim 13
`
`
`PayRange on Nov. 22, 2023. See id.
`A mobile device, comprising:
`
`13.a
`
`13.b
`
`A mobile device, comprising:
`
`one or moreradio transceivers;
`one or more output devices
`including a display;
`one or more processors; and
`memory storing one or more
`programs to be executed by the one
`or more processors, the one or more
`programs comprising instructions
`for:
`
`one or moreradio transceivers;
`one or more output devices
`including a display;
`one or more processors; and
`memory storing
`one or more
`programs to be executed by the one
`or more processors, the one or more
`programs comprising instructions
`for:
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 6 of 10 PageID #: 1508
`
`13.c
`
`13.d
`
`or more
`one
`identifying
`units
`in
`payment
`accepting
`proximity to the mobile device that
`are available to accept payment
`from a mobile payment application
`executing on the mobile device, the
`identifying based at least in part on
`an identifier corresponding to the
`one or more payment accepting
`units, wherein the one or more
`payment
`accepting
`units
`are
`payment operated machines that
`accept payment for dispensing of
`products and/or services;
`
`
`displaying a user interface of the
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device, the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visual indication of the one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input to (i) receive
`selection by a user of the mobile
`device of an available payment
`accepting unit of the one or more
`payment accepting units and (ii)
`trigger payment by
`the mobile
`payment
`application
`for
`a
`transaction initiated by the user of
`the mobile device with the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`
`or more
`one
`identifying
`units
`in
`payment
`accepting
`proximity to the mobile device that
`are available to accept payment
`from a mobile payment application
`executing on the mobile device, the
`identifying based at least in part on
`or
`location
`an
`identifier
`corresponding to the one or more
`payment accepting units, wherein
`the one or more payment accepting
`units
`are
`payment
`operated
`machines that accept payment for
`dispensing of products and/or
`services;
`
`
`displaying a user interface of the
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device, the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visual indication of the one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input to (i) receive
`selection by a user of the mobile
`deviceselecting
`an
`available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units and
`(ii) trigger payment by the mobile
`payment
`application
`for
`a
`transaction initiated by the user of
`the mobile device with the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`
`5
`
`

`

`Page 7 of 10 PagelD #: 1509
`
`after establishing the wireless
`after establishing the wireless
`communication path, enabling user
`communication path, enabling user
`interaction with the user interface of
`interaction with the user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the mobile payment application to
`
`complete the transaction; completeHee—Hteectionat
`transaction with the_available
`payment accepting unit, wherein
`the _user_interface_ includes
`a
`visual
`representation
`of
`the
`available paymentaccepting unit,
`
`an indication of a balance, and an
`affordance that, in response to a
`user input, indicates completion
`
`of the transaction:
`
`13.e
`
`13.f
`
`Limitation
`
`14
`
`exchanging information with
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`
`the
`exchanging
`after
`information, displaying, on the
`display, an updated userinterface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`
`°772 Patent Claim 14 (Disclaimed by
`PayRange on Nov. 22, 2023. See id.
`The mobile device of claim 13, wherein
`identifying the one or more payment
`accepting units includes identifying a
`payment activated washer, a payment
`activated dryer, a vending machine, a
`parking meter, a toll booth, an arcade
`game, a kiosk, a photo booth, or a ticket
`dispensing machine.
`
`exchanging information with
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`
`the
`exchanging
`after
`information, displaying, on the
`display, an updated user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`
`7920 Patent Claim 14
`
`The mobile device of claim 13, wherein
`identifying the one or more payment
`accepting units includes identifying a
`payment activated washer, a payment
`activated dryer, a vending machine, a
`parking meter, a toll booth, an arcade
`game,a kiosk, a photo booth,or a ticket
`dispensing machine.
`
`
`
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 7 of 10 PageID #: 1509
`Filed 10/25/24
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`
`
`
`13.e
`
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a_ wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`paymentaccepting unit ofthe one or
`more paymentaccepting units;
`
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a_ wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`paymentaccepting unit ofthe one or
`more paymentaccepting units;
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 8 of 10 PageID #: 1510
`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1
`Filed 10/25/24
`Page 8 of 10 PagelD #: 1510
`
`Limitation|’772 Patent Claim 15 (Disclaimed by 7920 Patent Claim 15
`
`
`PayRange on Nov. 22, 2023. See id.
`A non-transitory computer readable|A non-transitory computer readable
`
`
`15.a
`storage medium storing one or more|storage medium storing one or more
`programs, the one or more programs|programs, the one or more programs
`comprising instructions, which, when|comprising instructions, which, when
`executed by a mobile device with one or|executed by a mobile device with one or
`more processors, one or more output|more processors, one or more output
`devices including a display, and one or|devices including a display, and one or
`more radio transceivers, cause the|more radio transceivers, cause the
`
`mobile device to perform operations|mobile device to perform operations
`comprising:
`comprising:
`
`displaying a userinterface of the
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device,
`the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visualindication ofthe one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input to (i) receive
`selection by a user of the mobile
`device of an available payment
`accepting unit of the one or more
`payment accepting units and (ii)
`trigger payment by the mobile
`payment
`application
`for
`a
`transaction initiated by the user of
`Hetbedeteetteselecting
`the mobile device with the available
`payment accepting unit ofthe one or
`an available payment accepting unit
`more payment accepting units;
`of
`the one or more payment
`accepting units;
`
`
`
`
`
`15.b
`
`15.c
`
`or more
`one
`identifynmg
`units
`in
`payment
`accepting
`proximity to the mobile device that
`are available to accept payment
`from a mobile payment application
`executing on the mobile device, the
`identifying basedatleast in part on
`an identifier corresponding to the
`one or more payment accepting
`units, wherein the one or more
`payment
`accepting
`units
`are
`payment operated machines that
`accept payment for dispensing of
`products and/orservices;
`
`or more
`one
`identifying
`units—im
`payment
`accepting
`proximiftethemeobiedevice
`that
`are available to accept payment
`from a mobile payment application
`executing on the mobile device, the
`identifying based at least in part on
`an
`identifier
`or
`location
`corresponding to the one or more
`payment accepting units, wherein
`the one or more payment accepting
`units
`are
`payment
`operated
`machines that accept payment for
`dispensing of products
`and/or
`services;
`
`displaying a userinterface ofthe
`mobile payment application on the
`display of the mobile device, the
`user interface being configured to
`display a visualindication ofthe one
`or more payment accepting units
`and accept user input ¢e-++-eeeHe
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 9 of 10 PageID #: 1511
`
`15.d
`
`15.e
`
`15.f
`
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`after establishing the wireless
`communication path, enabling user
`interaction with the user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`complete the transaction;
`
`
`information with
`exchanging
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`the
`after
`exchanging
`the
`information, displaying, on
`display, an updated user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`
`establishing via the one or more
`radio
`transceivers
`a wireless
`communication path including the
`mobile device and the available
`payment accepting unit of the one or
`more payment accepting units;
`after establishing the wireless
`communication path, enabling user
`interaction with the user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`transactiona
`complete
`the
`transaction with the available
`payment accepting unit, wherein
`the user
`interface
`includes a
`visual
`representation of
`the
`available payment accepting unit,
`an indication of a balance, and an
`affordance that, in response to a
`user input, indicates completion
`of the transaction;
`
`
`information with
`exchanging
`the available payment accepting
`unit via the one or more radio
`transceivers, in conjunction with the
`transaction; and
`the
`after
`exchanging
`the
`information, displaying, on
`display, an updated user interface of
`the mobile payment application to
`the user of the mobile device.
`
`8
`
`

`

`Case 1:24-cv-00733-MN Document 23-1 Filed 10/25/24 Page 10 of 10 PageID #:
`1512
`
`