throbber
Filing # 180954471 E-Filed 08/31/2023 10:12:09 PM
`
`
`
`
`
`VERONICA BOURLAKOVA, in her individual
`capacity,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`vs.
`
`NIKOLAI KAZAKOV, VERA KAZAKOVA,
`HEMAREN STIFTUNG, a Panamanian
`Foundation, and EDELWEISS INVESTMENTS,
`INC., a Panamanian corporation,
`
`IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 11TH
`JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR MIAMI-
`DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
`
`DIVISION: CIVIL
`
`CASE NO. 2023-001158 CA (43)
`
`
`
`
`
`Defendants.
`
`/
`
`NOTICE OF FILING DECLARATION OF NIKOLAI KAZAKOV IN
`OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COUNTERCLAIMS
`FOR FORUM NON CONVENIENS [D.E. 64]
`
`PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Defendants and Counter-Plaintiffs Nikolai and Vera
`
`Kazakova hereby file the attached Declaration of Nikolai Kazakov in opposition to the Motion of
`
`Plaintiff and Counter-Defendant Veronica Bourlakova to Dismiss Amended Counterclaims for
`
`Forum Non Conveniens [D.E. 64].
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
` /s/Peter H. Levitt
`Peter H. Levitt, Esq.
`Florida Bar No. 0650978
`Aliette D. Rodz, Esq.
`Florida Bar No. 173592
`John W. Bustard, Esq.
`Florida Bar No. 0641871
`SHUTTS & BOWEN LLP
`Attorneys for Kazakovs
`200 S. Biscayne Blvd., Suite 4100
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Miami, Florida 33131
`(305) 358-6300 Telephone
`(305) 381-9982 Facsimile
`Primary Email: plevitt@shutts.com
`Primary Email: arodz@shutts.com
`Primary Email: jbustard@shutts.com
`Secondary Email: sboisvert@shutts.com
`
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served on this
`
`31st day of August 2023 by transmission of Notices of Service of Court Document generated by
`
`the E-Portal to all parties registered to receive email in this case.
`
`
`
`
`
`/s/ Peter H. Levitt
`Peter H. Levitt
`
`
`
`
`
`2
`
`

`

`DECLARATION OF NIKOLAI KAZAKOV
`
`Nikolai Kazakov affirms under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States
`
`of America as follows:
`
`1.
`
`I am a Counterclaim-Plaintiff in this action, along with my wife, Vera
`
`Kazakova,
`
`I makethis declaration out of personal knowledge, except as otherwise indicated,
`
`in opposition to the motion of Counterclaim-Defendants, Loudmila Bourlakova (“Loudmila”),
`
`Veronica Bourlakova (‘Veronica’), Elena Bourlakova (“Elena”), and Gregory Gliner
`
`(“Gliner”) (“Counterclaim Defendants”), to dismiss the counterclaims Vera and I have served
`
`on the ground offorum non conveniensinfavoroflitigating those claims in the High Court of
`
`Justice of England and Wales in London, England.
`
`De
`
`On December19, 2022, I filed comprehensive counterclaimsin this matter. On
`
`June 7, 2023,
`
`I
`
`filed amended counterclaims (the “Counterclaims”). A copy of those
`
`counterclaimsis attached as Exhibit A.
`
`| filed virtually identical amended counterclaimsin the
`
`separate action captioned Veronica Bourlakova v. Hemaren, et al., on or about June 9, 2023.
`
`BACKGROUND
`
`3.
`
`This case, and the separate case filed by Veronica, are components of a far-
`
`reaching dispute between myself and Vera on the one hand and the Counterclaim-Defendants
`
`on the other hand regarding rights to a considerable fortune that myself and my long-time
`business partner, Oleg Bourlakov, built and peoeunaeied over the course of thirty years of
`
`doing business together. Oleg was mybrother-in-law. Wefirst met in the 1970s and,in 1988,
`in St. Petersburg, Russia, agreedto enter an oral partnership pursuant to which we would work
`
`together on various businesses and split on a 50/50 basis, the assets and liabilities that we
`
`accumulated through these businesses.
`
`WK,
`
`

`

`4.
`
`Our efforts were very successful. We developed several lucrative businesses
`
`based in Russia and sold our interests in those businesses for substantial sums of money.I
`
`would estimate that the assets that we jointly accumulated are worth over $3 billion today.
`
`5.
`
`In 2018, I cameto understand that Oleg’s marriage to Loudmila had come under
`
`stress. At that time, a substantial portion of my assets, which had been generated through my
`
`partnership with Oleg, were being held by Loudmila as a nominee. Loudmila had agreed,to
`
`hold these assets for the benefit of Oleg and myself as part of an effort to remove the proceeds
`
`of our sale of a Russian oil company knownas Burneftegaz out of Russia.
`
`6.
`
`Given the uncertainty surrounding Oleg’s marriage, at a meeting held in April
`
`2018 in London upon request of the Bourlakovas, I requested that my share of these assets be
`
`returned to me. On this Elena asked meto provide their lawyers with documents andsaid that
`
`"they take a look". In other words, Loudmila, supported by her daughters, Elena and Veronica
`
`as well as Gliner and her other son-in-law, refused.
`
`I later learnt that, Loudmila, aided by the
`
`other Counterclaim Defendants, had taken a series of steps to move these assets to other
`
`jurisdictions and into instruments that made their recovery difficult. It is possible that these
`
`efforts began even before our meeting. Counterclaim-Defendants’ efforts knew few bounds,
`
`having gone even so far as raiding Oleg’s family office in Monaco, Sarl Hermitage Family
`
`Office, imaging the computer, cancelling files and taking away important documents so the
`
`assets would be moredifficult to access or trace.
`

`
`I
`
`In June 2021, Oleg died, leaving a holographic will made in 2019, enforceable
`
`in Monacothat bequeathssubstantially all of his assets to myself and Vera. A Russian court
`
`has determined that will to be valid, applying Monaco law and that determination has been
`
`upheld by two appeal courts. A copy of an English translation of the decision upholding the
`
`lower court’s determination is attached as Exhibit B.
`
`Wk.
`
`

`

`8.
`
`Since the inception of the dispute in 2018,litigation has beenfiled in several
`
`jurisdictions regarding the same,including Monaco, Switzerland,the United Kingdom,the Isle
`
`of Man, Montenegro, Cyprus, Russia, Latvia, Ukraine, Panama, and the United States, mainly
`
`at the initiative of the Bourlakovas. Thelitigation in manyofthese jurisdictions is ongoing.
`
`9.
`
`The Counterclaim-Defendants have brought a total of three separate actions
`
`naming myself, Vera and others in Florida. Thereis this case, in which Veronica and Elena,
`
`purportedly in their capacities as “guardians” of their children, seek to recover a property
`
`located at 7471 Fisher Island Drive fromatrust created by Oleg naming myself and Vera as
`
`beneficiaries, as well as certain cash that Oleg sent to Florida to make additional investments.
`
`In fact, Oleg informed me that given the failure of Counterclaim-Defendants to return my
`
`portion of the partnership assets to me, he decided to alter his plans for holding the Fisher
`
`Island Property.
`
`10.
`
`There is also the second action, referenced earlier, in which Veronica, in her
`
`individual capacity, seeks a declaration from this Court that she is the owner of Edelweiss,Inc.
`
`a Panamanian companythat in fact is owned by a Panamanian foundation of which I am a
`
`beneficiary.
`
`11.
`
`The third case was brought against myself, Vera and others in a Florida federal
`
`court in Miami, asserting claims under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations
`
`Act relating to the Fisher Island property as well as a plane owned by a company that Oleg
`
`controlled. That case was dismissed voluntarily by the plaintiffs in February ofthis year, before
`
`service was made.
`
`.
`
`MY NON-EXISTENT CONTACTS WITH THE UNITED KINGDOM
`
`i2.
`
`Onor about July 2020, | was namedas defendant in an action in the High Court
`
`of Justice of England and Walesentitled Loudmila Bourlakova,et al., Claimants against Oleg
`
`Bourlakov, et al., Defendants, bearing case number BL-2020-001050. Vera and I, along with
`
`AWE.
`
`

`

`certain other defendants, asserted that the London Court lacked personaljurisdiction over us
`
`for purposesof the claimsfiled by Loudmila. The London Court disagreed with our position.
`
`Wewere refused permission to appeal.
`
`13.
`
`Neither I nor Vera owns, or have ever owned,any real property anywhere in the
`
`United Kingdom.
`
`14.
`
`Neither I nor Vera ownsor has ever owned anyotherassets located in the United
`
`Kingdom. Neither of us maintain any bank or investment accounts of any kind in United
`
`Kingdom. Weneverhave doneso.
`
`1Ss
`
`I do not, nor have I ever, maintained any businesses in the United Kingdom.
`
`While I have made a few trips to the United Kingdom overthe years, these have been sporadic.
`
`16.
`
`I have never resided in United Kingdom and neither has Vera. Neither of us
`
`speak English, and we have never engaged in any business ventures with any persons or
`
`enterprises located in the United Kingdom.
`
`17.
`
`I was born in what wasthen called the Estonian Soviet Socialist Republic, and
`
`I have lived in Estonia, Russia and Monaco and nowhereelse. Vera was born in Ukraine, and
`
`she has lived in Ukraine, Russia, Estonia and Monaco and nowhereelse.
`
`18.
`
`The only significant event in connection with this dispute that relates in any way
`
`to the United Kingdom was a meeting held in London on April 6, 2018, the location having
`
`been unilaterally decided by the Bourlakovas, at which time I had requested that Loudmila
`
`return to methe assets of mine that she was holding in trust as a nominee. She refused to do
`
`so. We met in London because Oleg’s and Loudmila’s younger daughter Veronica (whois
`
`Vera’s niece) and her American husband GregGlinerreside there, and we were invited to meet
`
`at their home. We reached no agreements of any kind during that meeting.
`
`19.
`
`Loudmila is a permanentresident of Monaco where Vera and I also reside. Oleg
`
`and Loudmila resided in Monacofor several years before Oleg’s death.
`
`WK
`
`

`

`20:
`
`To my knowledge, the only witnesses in this case who reside in the United
`
`Kingdom are Veronica and her husband Greg (whoI also understand claim to be equally a
`
`Monacoresidentsince 2007, so they can take advantage offavorable tax treatment in Monaco).
`
`Outside of those two individuals, I am not aware ofany individual likely to be a witness in this
`
`case whoresides in the United Kingdom.
`
`21.
`
`Additionally, Oleg and Loudmila neverresided in the United Kingdom,and, to
`
`my knowledge, Oleg neverdid business there or purchased anyrealestate there. By contrast,
`
`he did purchase real estate in South Florida. Oleg and I never conducted any partnership
`
`business in the United Kingdom.
`
`Affirmed under penalty of perjury underthe laws of the United States of America.
`
`eS
`
`
`
`Nikolai Kazakov
`
`Zl.0Ff28
`
`

`

`CONVENIENCE TRANSLATION
`
`3AABJIEHHE HUKOJIAA KASAKOBA
`
`Hukonai Ka3akop jesaer
`
`cllefytoulee
`
`3aaBJIeHHe MOQ CTpaxOM Haka3aHHA 3a
`
`mpeocTaBsleHHe
`
`3aBeOMO JIOXKHbIX
`
`CBeJeCHHH B
`
`COOTBETCTBHH C
`
`3aKOHOJaTeJIbCTBOM
`
`CoeyMHeHHbix LItarop AMepHKH:
`
`ly
`
`B pamkax HacTosilero jlesla A ABIAIOCch McTuOM NO BCTpe4YHOMy HCKy BMeCcTe CO
`
`cBpoei »xeHOK, Bepo Ka3akosoi; 9 esa HaCTOALee 3adBJIEHHe Ha OCHOBaHHM CBeeHHH,
`
`W3BeCTHbIX MHe
`
`JIMYHO, KpOMe
`
`cCJlyyaeB, Pye yKa3aHO HHOe, B KayeCTBe BO3Pa7xKeHHA Ha
`
`xojatTalicTBo OTBeTUHKOB NO BCTpeyHoMy UcKy — JItogmMusibt byplakoBoi (aasee — «JItoaMua»),
`
`Bepouuku bypsakosoli (manee — «Bepouuka»), Enenbi bypsakosoli (danee — «Esena») uw Pperopu
`
`Tnuuepa (ganee — «InuHep») (qasiee HMeHyroTca «OTBETYHKH TO BCTPpe4YHOMY HCKy»>) — OTKa3aTb
`
`B YMOBJICTBOPeHHH BCTPe4HbIX TpeOoBaHHii, KoTOpble Bepa u A MpeAbABHJIM Ha OCHOBaHHH
`
`HeyOOHOrO MeCTa pacCMOTPeHHA JeNa B NOAepxKKy yKa3aHHbIX TpeOoBaHHni B BeicoKoM cyze
`
`Aurauu 4 Youbca B JIongqoHe, AHTIHA.
`
`Zs
`
`19 nexa6ps 2022 r. 1 nowan UCuepNbIBarollMe BCTDeUHbIe TpeOoBaHHA MO JaHHOMY
`
`neny.
`
`7 wutoHs 2023 r. 1 nOsal W3MeHEHHbIe BCTpeyHble TpeOoBanna (Jaslee — «BcTpeuHple
`
`TpeOoBaHua»). Kona yKa3aHHbIxX BCTpe4HbIX TpeOoBanui MpuiaraeTca B KayecTBe IIputoxKeHHA
`
`A. A 3aaBHsl MpakTH4ecKH MJeHTHUHbIe H3MeHeHHbIe BCTpedHble TpeOoBaHHA B paMKax
`
`OTebHOrO UCKa NO Ha3BaHvem «Veronica Bourlakova v. Hemaren, et al.» 1pwOnu3nTesbHO 9
`
`urona 2023 r.
`
`BBOJIHAH HH®OPMAIMSA
`
`3:
`
`Hacrosllee Je0, a TaK2xKe OTMEMbHOe We0, BO3OYKAEHHOe NO HCKy BepoHuKnH,
`
`ABNAIOTCA COCTABJAIOLIMMM OOLIMpHOrO cnopa MexaAy MHOM wu Bepow c OfHOM CTOPOHbI u
`
`OrTBeTYHKaMH MO BCTPe4HOMY HCKy C pyro CTOPOHb! OTHOCHTeIBHO MpaB Ha 3HaYHTeJIbHOe
`
`VE
`
`

`

`MMYLIeECTBO, KOTOpOe A H MOM DaBHH NapTHep no Ou3Hecy Osler bypsiakosB co3asiM W HaKOMMIN
`
`B TeyeHHe 30 eT COBMeCTHOrO On3HeCca. Osler Ob] MOM LypHHOM. BriepBble MbI BCTpeTHJIMCb
`
`B 1970-e rogbl, a B 1988 rogy B Cankt-IletepOypre (Poccua) MbI YCTHO JOPOBOPHJINCb 3aKIOUNTb
`
`MapTHEpCTBO, B COOTBETCTBHH C KOTOPbIM MbI OyeM padoTaTb BMeCTe HaJl pa3sBUTHeM pa3sIM4HbIX
`
`KOMMaHHii
`
`UW OYJIeM JeJIUTb AKTHBbI HW OOA3ATeJIbCTBA, HAKOMJICHHbIe B XOJle JeATeIbBHOCTU THX
`
`KOMMaHHi, B paBHbIX JOJIAX.
`
`4.
`
`Hawu ycviuaA OKa3aiIMcb O4eHb ycrewiHbIMH.
`
`Mbl
`
`co3jasin HeCKOJIbKO
`
`NpHObLIbHbIX KOMNaHHH B PoccuH HW NpOAaiM CBOM JOJIN B ITHX KOMMAHHAX 3a CYLUECTBEHHbIe
`
`JeHexKHbIe CyMMbI. Ilo Moeii OLIEHKe, COBMECTHO CO3JaHHble HAMM AKTHBbI CeroOHA CTOAT Oosee
`
`3 MJIPA AOsWIapos.
`
`>.
`
`B 2018 r. MHe cTajo u3BeCTHO, YTO Opak Osera c JIKOAMMNON CTOJIKHYJICA C
`
`TpyaHoctamMu.
`
`B To BpeMA CYLIeCTBeHHad YaCTb MOMX AKTHBOB, KOTOPble OBIH CO3aHbl
`
`Oarojyapa MOeMy NapTHepcTBy c Oslerom, xpaHHiacb y JItOJMHJIbI B KaYeCTBe HOMHHAJIbHOrO
`
`Bllafebua.
`
`JlOUMusIa Cormacnlach BJlajleTb J@HHbIMH aKTHBaMH B MOJb3y Oslera H MeHsA B
`
`pamkax jlelicTBHi NO BbIBOAY NOcTyMJIeHHH OT MpojaxKH HaMU poccHiicKkol He*@TAHOM KOMMAaHHH
`
`«ByprHedtera3» 43 Poccuu.
`
`6.
`YuuTpipad HecTaOuJIbHoe cocTosHHe Opaka Oslera, Ha BCTpeye, MpoBeeHHOH B
`anpene 2018 r. B JIoHqoHe NO NpocbGe 2KeHbI coupe bypJlakoBbIx, 4 NMOTpeOoBaJ BePHYTb MHEe
`
`MOtO JOJO YKa3aHHbIX akTHBOB. Ha 9To Enena nompocusia MeHA MpeOCTaBUTb HX afBOKaTaM
`JOKYMCHTbI UM CKa3asia, YTO “OHH MOCMOTpAT», T.e. JlKoaMUsa, KOTOpyto ioihepaaa ee Wouepu
`
`Eneua 4 Bepounka, a TakxKe IMHep 4 Apyrol ee 31Tb, MHe OTKa3asIv.
`
`[lo3qHee # y3HaJ, YTO
`
`JIiogMUla C NOMOLIbIO OCTAJIbHbIX OTBETUHKOB MO BCTpe4HOMY HCKy MpeANpHHAIAa pA Mep m0
`
`BbIBOAY Ja@HHbIX AKTHBOB B JIpyrve tOpHCAHKUHH U UX BJIOKCHHE UHCTPYMCHTbI, KOTOPbIe
`
`Ve
`
`es
`
`

`

`YCNOKHWIM HX B3bICKAaHHe. BO3MO%*KHO, YTO STH JEHCTBHA Haya MpeANPHHUMATECA ele DO
`
`Halle BcTpeun. JlevictBua OTBeTUHKOB NO BCTpeYHOMY HUCKy He 3HAJIM HUKAaKMX rpaHuil, H OHH
`
`HOWJIM axe 0 TOrO, TO YCTPOHJIU OObICK B CeMeHHOM Oduce Osera B Mouako, Sarl Hermitage
`
`Family Office, co3qamu oOpa3 KommbtoTepa, yoann daiinpi wv 3a0pasin BarkKHbIe AOKYMeHTHI,
`
`YTOObI AKTHBbI ObIJIO COMHKHO HATH WIM OTCICAMTb.
`
`ds
`
`B utone 2021 r. Oner ckonyasica, OcTaBuB COOCTBeHHOpyy¥Hoe 3aBeLlaHHe,
`
`coctTaBsieHHoe B 2019 r. uv HcnosHUMOe B Monako, M0 KOTOPOMy MOUTH BCe ErO HMYLIECTBO OBIIO
`
`3aBellaHo MHe
`
`HU Bepe.
`
` Poccniickui cya onpefenui,
`
`4YTO
`
`9TO 3aBellaHHe ABJIACTCA
`
`JICMCTBUTEIBHbIM TIpH MpvHMeHeHun mpapa Monako,
`
`uv ero pellieHve ObIIO OCTaBeHO Oe3
`
`M3MeHeHHii ABYMA CY1aMH BbICIUeH MHCTAaHUMH. Konva nepepojla NOCTaHOBJIeHHA 00 OCTaBJIEHHH
`
`pelleHua HWKecTOAMero cya Oe3 H3MeHeHHK Ha AaHPIMMCKHH ASbIK MpHJlaraeTcA B KayecTBe
`
`IIpunoxenna B.
`
`8.
`
`C momenta Hayasia cnopa B 2018 r. B STO CBA3H ObIIM NOAaHbI CyeOHbIe UCKH B
`
`HECKOJIBKUX FOPHCAMKUMAX, BKIHOUaA Mouako, LIBeiaputo, BenuKoOpuranuto, Octpos Mou,
`
`Yepuoroputo, Kunp, Poccnio,JlarBuro, Ykpanny, Ilanamy 4 CLUA, B ocHOBHOM, No HHMLMaTHBe
`
`*KEHbI
`
`HW ouepeti byplakoppix.
`
`CyeOuble pa30vpaTebcTBa
`
`BO MHOrHX yKa3aHHbIxX
`
`FOPHCAMKUMAX MpOAOMKAIOTCA MO Cet JeHb.
`D
`OrTBeTUHKH M0 BCTpe4dHOMy HCKy nojasu BCerO TPH OTCJIBHbIX HCKa KO MHe, Bepe
`
`Vi JIpyruM siMuaM Bo Onopuze. Mmeetca Jeno, no KoTopomy Bepounkau Entena, JehicTByA AKOOBI
`B Ka4ecTBe “OMeKYHOB» CBOMX JeTel, TpeOylOT B3bICKaHHA OObEKTA HejBHOKUMOrOUMytecTBa,
`
`pacniooxKeHHoro Mo afpecy: Pumep AtonA JIpaiis, 4. 7471, y Tpacta, co3qaHHoro Ouierom, B
`
`KoTOpomM # HW Bepa yka3aHbl B KayecTBe OeHeMUMapOB, a TaKKE OMPeJCJICHHbIX HCHOKHBIX
`
`cpegcTB, KoTopbie Osler nepeyncnna Bo MNnopufly IA AONOAHMTEAPHBIX MHBECTHLMH.
`
`B
`
`Vik
`
`

`

`HelicTBUTebHOCTH Oster CooOUIHsI MHe, YTO BBU AY TOrO, YTO OTBETYHKH MO BCTpeyYHOMyHCKy He
`
`BepHYJIM MHe MOFO JOJIKO HMYLUeCCTBa MapTHepCTBa, OH PeLIHJI H3MCHHTb CBOM MJIaHbI M0
`
`BulaeHHIO HEABMKUMOCTHIO Ha Ouwep AMISH.
`
`10.
`
`Takxke uMeeTcs BTOPOe e10, O KOTOPOM POBOPHJI0Cb BbILUe, B PaMKAaX KOTOPOrO
`
`Bepouuka,
`
`felicTBya B JIMYHOM KayecTBe,
`
`JOOMBaeTCA OT JaHHOrO Cyfla Npw3HaHHA ee
`
`Bilafqesbuem Edelweiss, Inc., naHamcKol KOMNaHHH, KOTOpas B JCMCTBUTeIBHOCTH NpHHadexKHT
`
`maHaMckomy (OHAY, OCHEPULMAaPOM KOTOPOLO ABJIAIOCh A.
`
`rhe
`
`Tperuii uck Obi Moan KO MHe, K Bepe UM HHbIM JIMLaM B (esepaibHbI cyl
`
`@Maopuabi B Maiiamu, B KOTOPOM 3aABJIAIOTCA TpeOOBaHHA 0 3aKOHY O KOPpyMMMpOBAaHHbIX H
`
`HaXOJALIAXCA MOJ, BIIMAHHEM PIKETHPOB OpraHh3allHAX B OTHOLUCHHH HEABH2KHMOCTH Ha Dulep
`
`Aion, a TakwokKe CaMOJieTa, MpHHasexKaulero KOMMAaHHH, KOTOpylO KOHTposMpoBan Ouer.
`
`VUctust 4O0OpoBosbHO OTKAa3aIMCb OT 9TOFO HCKa B eBpale sTOrO rofa elle WO BpyyeHua
`
`MpoueccyasIbHbIX JOKYMCHTOB
`
`MOH HECYUIECTBYFOUIME KOHTAKTHI C BEJIMNKOBPHTAHHEN
`
`12:
`
`[puOnu3uTesbHO B ulosie 2020 r. 4 Obl MpHBIeUeH B Ka4eCTBE OTBETUNKA M0 HCKY
`
`B Bpicokom cyge Anraunv vu Youbca No, HaMMeHOBaHHeM «JlioqMusia bypsakosa u Ap., Mcrupt,
`
`npotus Onera bypsakosa u ap., OTrBeTunKH», C HOMepoM jesa BL-2020-001050. Bepa, 4 u
`
`HeEKOTOpble HHbI€
`
`OTBETYMKH 3aABHJIM, YTO Ha Hac He pacnpocTpaHseTca MepcoHasbHaad
`
`NOACYAHOCTb JOHAOHCKOLO cya Wiad WeseH TpeOoBanni, 3adBeHHbIX JItoaMusOK.
`JIOHAOHCKHK
`cy], He corjacuiica c Halle no3uuvei. Ham Oblio OTKa3aHO B pa3pellieHHH Ha upiivenies
`
`13.
`
`Hu a, Hu Bepa He BulaqeeM MW HUKOra He B/aesIM HeABH2KHMbIM HMYLIECTBOM B
`
`BesukoOputaHun.
`
`MK
`
`

`

`14.
`
`Hu a, Hu Bepa He BilajeeM MW HUKOra He B/1aflesIM HAKAKHM HHbIM HMYLICCTBOM B
`
`BeaukoOputanuu. Hukto u3 Hac He HMeeT OaHKOBCKHX WJIM HHBECTHLMOHHBIX CYeTOB J1000ro
`
`poga B BenukoOputannn. Mobi HuKorga HX He OTKPbIBaJIN.
`
`15.
`
`A we 3aHMMarocb WM HMKOra He 3aHMMaJIcA On3HeCOM B BeankoOputanun. Xora
`
`3a mocueqHve TOAbI
`
`A HeCKOJbKO pa3 mMocemjan BenukoOputaHuio,
`
`9TH Moe3qKH Obi
`
`9T1M30 (MY HbIMH.
`
`16.
`
`Hu a, Hu Bepa HukKorga He mpoxknBasiv B BenukoOputanuv. HuKTo 43 Hac He
`
`rOBOpHT MO-aHraWiicKM,
`
`WM Mbl HMKOrga He
`
`y4aCTBOBaJIM B KaKHX-JIMOO KOMMep4eCKHX
`
`nmpeAMpwaTHAxX
`
`C
`
`KaKHMH-sIHOO
`
`JIMUaMH WIM MpeANpMATHAMH,
`
`paCHOsOXKeHHbIMH— B
`
`BeaukoOputannn.
`
`1.
`
`A poguica B OpiBuieit IcroHcKoi CopetcKoii Couvanuctuyeckor PecnyOluKe 4
`
`npoxknBa B IcroHuu, Poccun u Monako u Oosbuie Hurge. Bepa poauiacb Ha YKpanue u
`
`npoxknpasa Ha Ykpanue, B Poccuu, Icrouun 4 Mouakou OosIbuue Hurye.
`
`18.
`
`EMHCTBeHHbIM 3H@4MMbIM COObITHEM B CBA3H C HaCTOALIHM CNOPOM, KOTOpoe
`
`oTHocutca K BennkoOputanun, ABsAsacb BcTpeya B JloHzoHe 6 anpena 2018 r. B MecTe, B
`
`OJHOCTOPOHHEM MOpsAAKe ONpeseeHHbIM 2KeHOM MH JOYepbMH bypsaKOBbIMH, Ha KOTOpOH 4
`
`noTpeOosan oT JIOQMMJIbl BeEpHYTb MHE MOe MMYLIeCTBO, KOTOPbIM OHA Bylatela Ha MpaBe
`JOBEPUTeIbHOM COOCTBEHHOCTH B Ka4ecTBe HOMMHaMbHOTO Bilagqesmbua. Ona OTKa3aslacb 9TO
`
`coenaTb. Mbi scrperuiucb B JIOHJOHe, NOCKOJIbKy TaM NpO2XKMBAaIOT Maat NOUb Onera u
`Jiogmusbt Beponuka (KoTopas npuxogutca Bepe MuIeMAHHULe) HW ee aMepukancKnit Myx Iper
`
`ymuep, 4 MbI nonyHWIN Mpursauienne BCTpeTHTbCA y HHX Joma. B xoue 3TOH BCTpe4uH MbI He
`
`HOCTHIIM HHKaKHX Oro BOpeHHOcTeH :
`
`MR,
`
`

`

`19.
`
`JltoouMusia wMeeT MOCTOAHHOe MecTO 2KUTebcTBa
`
`B Monako,
`
`rae TakwoxKe
`
`npoxkuBaem H MbI cc Bepoii. Oner u JItoaMusa HeCKOJIbKO seT KH B Monako 10 cmMepTH Onera.
`
`20.
`
`HackosbKO MHE H3BECTHO, CJHHCTBCHHbIMM CBHeTeAMH MO JaHHOMy Jelly,
`
`KoTOpble MpoxuBaroT B BenuKoOputanun, aBistoTcA BepoHuka u ee Myx [per (koTopble,
`
`HACKOJIbKO MHE H3BECTHO, TaK2Ke 3AABJIAIOT, UTO OHV B PaBHOH CTEMECHH ABJAIOTCA pe3sHJeHTaMu
`
`Monako, Tak 4TO OHH MOFyT BOCMOJb30BaTbCA JIBFOTHBIM PeC%KHMOM HaJOPOOONOXKeHHA B
`
`Monako). Mue He u3BeCTHO 0 KaKOM-J1M60 JIMLe HOMMMO 9THX ABYX JIL, KOTOPOe MOrJ10 ObI ObITb
`
`NpoxKUBAaIOLHM B BesMKOOpHTaHun CBMJeTeeM MO JaHHOMY Jled1.
`
`21.
`
`Kpome toro, Oster u JiltoqMuja HuKorya He NpoxKBaH B BenukoOpuranun, a
`
`Oner, HaCKOJIbKO MHE H3BECTHO, HUKOra He 3AHMMaJICA TaM OH3HECOM HM He MpHoOperas Tam
`
`HeJBUxKHMOCTb. HaoGopor, OH AeHCTBUTeEbHO MpHoOpes HEABH2KHMOCTH B FOokHOK Dopuze.
`
`Hu Oner, Hu « HHKOra He 3aHMMaJINCb HalliMM MapTHepcKuM Ou3HecoM B BesMKoOpuTanun.
`
`3aaBsICHO MOA CTpaxXOM Haka3aHHA 3a MpeOCTABJICHHE 3aBEOMO JIOKHBIX CBeCHHH B
`
`COOTBETCTBHH C 3AKOHOaTCJIbCTBOM CoeJMHeHHbIX LUtTaros AMepHKH.
`
`Del2MGM ae
`
`Huxkosiai Ka3axos
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket