UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
`
`WASHINGTON, D.C.
`
`BEFORE THE HONORABLE THEODORE R. ESSEX
`ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
`
`C
`In the Matter 0f=
`CERTAIN SEMICONDUCTOR CHIPS
`WITH MINIMIZED CHIP PACKAGE
`SIZE AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING
`SAME
`
`Investigation No. 337-TA—649
`
`RESPONDENTS SILICONWARE PRECISION INDUSTRIES
`CO., LTD. AND SILICONWARE U.S.A., INC.’S
`
`OPPOSITION TO
`
`COMPLAINANT TESSERA’S MOTION TO SHORTEN
`
`TIME TO RESPOND TO MOTION TO COMPEL
`DEPOSITIONS AND COSTS
`
`Siliconware Precision Industries Co., Ltd. and Siliconware USA Inc., (collectively,
`
`“Siliconware”) hereby oppose Tessera, Inc.’s (“Tessera”) motion to shorten time to respond to
`
`Tessera’s “Emergency” Motion To Compel Depositions and for Costs.
`
`While Tessera’s Motion seeks to shorten the time for Siliconware to respond, Tessera
`
`does not provide any basis for this request. Indeed, Tessera does not even indicate the relief it
`
`seeks. Since Tessera failed to meet and confer on this, Siliconvvare does not understand why
`
`Tessera believes that a shortened response time is necessary or even what Tessera is seeking.
`
`Siliconware would be prejudiced were the Court to shorten its time to respond to the
`
`Motion to compel. In its l2 page motion and 31 accompanying exhibits, Tessera makes
`
`significant and unfounded allegations and demands over $30,000 in alleged costs. Siliconware
`
`requires time to review and rebut these spurious claims. At the same time, Siliconware is
`
`responding to Tessera’s Motion to Amend the Complaint and Notice of Investigation (which
`
`Tessera has also designated as an “emergency” and sought to shorten the response time).
`
`

`
`In contrast, Tessera will not suffer any prejudice were Siliconware permitted ten days to
`
`respond as allowed for in Ground Rule 3.6. Fact discovery does not close until December 9,
`
`2008 and Siliconware has already proposed dates the week of November 10, 2008 for the
`
`depositions that Tessera seeks to compel.
`
`Thus, Tessera’s Motion to Shorten Time should be denied. Since Tessera did not file or
`
`serve the declaration in support of its Motion to Compel until October 8, 2008, Siliconvx/are’s
`
`opposition should be due Monday, October 20, 2008 as set forth in the Court’s Ground Rules.
`
`See Exh. A.
`
`Dated: October 9, 2008
`
`OHS West:260528928.l
`
`; 2 E -
`
`0À¨n À-¨n
` UTCLIFFE, LLP
`
`ORRICK, HERRINGTON
`1000 Marsh Road
`
`Menlo Park, CA 94025
`Tel. (650) 6l4—7400
`Fax (650) 6l4—7401
`
`Jeff Dunn
`
`Jeffrey L. Eichen
`Rebecca G. Lombard
`Lisa M. Kattan
`VENABLE LLP
`
`575 7th Street, NW
`Washington, DC 20004
`Telephone: (202) 344-4000
`
`Counsel for Respondents
`Siliconware Precision Industries Co., Ltd. and
`Siliconware USA Inc.,
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`
`\ ggwf
`n7n
`§:
`Q
`5.
`
`(_)<:r<>bcr 8, 2008
`
`VIA EJWAIL
`
`_]on:1timn W. ].,.cm
`(}<)od\\7i11 Prc.>ct<.>r L} ,1’
`(,:<:)unscl0r>’; at Lsaxv
`
`iirzcrlmnge. Place
`:33 Start: Str<:c:t
`B<):»‘t011, M./-\ {‘}21(')9
`
`
`
`Gas (19 Blank
`(650) 6147343
`bdeblank@orri¢:k.c:om
`
`Re:
`
`(I<:17‘mir1 .Sc~mi<:<,>;3du<:tor Chig.9 with ;\~1i11i111jz<;(_LC}xip Paclgggrg Size :md,_I’n‘>duc€5
`
`§,;g>_g_1»r;1.iV11,i:1g Szunc {:.f\»—’
`: 1'T(,’j Irw. No. §,f~ I z\.»64‘)
`
`Dem‘ ~) cazmthzm:
`
`I write c<>nccming nn “I5ln1ergz1ncy” Motion to Compczi Dapositions of §3’l3'Ii,.
`1\I<:>tii<:m, ycyu swught to simrtcn the time fox‘ SP1]; to respond by an indefinite. ammmt.
`\‘<7h_i1<:
`"I7<:.~:s<:r:1 emailed us 21 copy of that nmtion and 30m!-2 of the exhibits ycstmrday, T<::~:scr:>. did not 5.1:; or
`raczrvc :1 copy of your dcclarmfiicxn Lmtil October 8, 2008. Morc:oVe1', scvcéltal 0f the crchibits that
`’£"c.~;s;cra crmulcci were czgsrrupted and couid not be (wpcmd. Other exhibits were misxmmcd.
`’I"cs:'ac:ra
`<):1§§r provided rcpizzcemcxut copies this afterncmn.
`
`In that
`
`Given Tcsgcrzffs faflurc to 61:: or serve: the declaration and exhibits in support of its Mmim, I
`cailcd you this m<:m1i.ng I10 comfirln that service was caffccrivc tceday (and not yesrwciay).
`In response,
`‘I requested for the first time that SPIL stipulate to 3 shorrcmsd .1‘CSp0I1St‘ vn Setting asidc,
`for now, the fact; that Tcssera neither met 171017 can Ferred c(>m;e,sining this request prior to seeking
`such nzlicf, I imiicatszd that I would <:»:::r1sidc:1" the issue Ymu suggestcci that S]?’iiL should ag17<:e and
`:~:uggca:tcd that unk::’:s SPIL ccvuld pnn \vhy it needed the a<.idit:iCnmi, time, '1'<“:ssc:m would deem
`service (3? the m(>tiOI) effective as 0f October 7’, 3008 (notwit:hstanding the fact th21tTcs:<L‘ra had
`mzithcr filed nor scrrvcci the supporting dedaration as of that Pwnn
`
`C<‘mscqucntl_\;, I was CZ\ZtIT€H){‘:]y' surprised when 'I"<:sse.m filed yet another “c1nergencj."’
`nuomm mday and, once agzml, sought to shosgtcm the time far SPU. tr?) respond. Given the fact that
`we discmzstctal this issue hcmxs c:1r3i<:1‘,
`I’ do not undeifstancl yous: failure to mdicatc ti1at'ik*ssc.x*a
`im:<;-ndcd to do so. Yc2u1‘ attempt :0 cc>n\>inc:<: SPH, to agree (0 shorten time for the firs:
`“c1nc1‘gcn<:y” motion without disc:Io:;ing your iI1tcnrj011 to file. :1 second “e:11c.t'gc13cj;” motmn (_\vhir:h
`veil} (:>l3vi<'>usIy impact the amount of time: we have to xirzspond) i:< p:1rt,iCu1a:Iy rr()ub1'u1§;.
`Thus, SPH, wili :10: COflSi2I1Ii to sh0rtr“:n the time to respond to °.I’c;s;:scra’s Mmimz to Compcl.
`:‘\'lm'c:<;>x"¢:1?, grivcn §‘«:>ur faiiurc to file zmcfi serve the accc>1npanying <;i<:c:};z1'2u:ior: and the Eric: that scvcitzfl
`of the supporting c:<h_ibits were misnsamed and cmfld not be opened as p1'c>V-idcd by Tcsscrzz, sczwicc
`c,>i”l"<.x~:;sc,1tn";< Motion was n<:>t cffecttivc until OCtC)br'.‘1' 8, 2008. L?13,1,css the Court’ oxdcrs c)ther\vis;c, we
`will rcspmid in the time n tbisth by ‘the. Rules.
`
`
`
`Bar: dc: Blzmk
`
`{)3 IS \52’:‘s%.3fi¢>32?S78 I .1
`
`

`
`In the Matter ofCERTAIN SEMICONDUCTOR CHIPS WITH MINIMIZED CHIP PACKAGE
`SIZE AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING SAME (IV)
`Inv. No. 337—TA-649 (DN 2616)
`
`US. International Trade Commission
`
`Before the Administrative Law Judge Theodore R. Essex
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I, Mimi Sagmit, hereby certify that the attached RESPONDENTS SILICONWARE
`PRECISION INDUSTRIES CO., LTD., AND SILICONWARE U.S.A., INC'S
`OPPOSITION TO COMPLAINANT TESSERA'S MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME TO
`
`RESPOND TO MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITIONS AND COSTS has/have been
`
`served on all parties via service method as indicated below on October 9, 2008.
`
`Marilyn R. Abbott, Secretary
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`
`500 E. Street, S.W., Room ll2A
`
`Washington, DC 20436
`Telephone:
`202.205.2799
`(VIA ELECTRONIC COURT FILING)
`
`Kecia J. Reynolds, Staff Attorney
`Office of Unfair Import Investigation
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`
`500 E. Street, S.W., Room 401-A
`Washington, DC 20436
`Telephone:
`202.205.2580
`
`Tamara Lee, Attorney Advisor
`Office of Unfair Import Investigation
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`
`500 E. Street, S.W., Room 40l—A
`
`Washington, DC 20436
`Telephone:
`202.205.2580
`
`The Honorable Theodore R. Essex
`
`Administrative Law Judge
`US. International Trade Commission
`
`500 E. Street, S.W.
`
`Washington, DC 20436
`Telephone: 202.205.2681
`(2 COPIES VIA OVERNIGHT MAIL)
`
`El
`El
`
`E]
`
`El
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email
`
`l<ecia.reynolds/&Dusitc.,;_.,>“ov
`
`EEJEJEIEI
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email
`
`Tamara.Lee@usitc. gov
`
`OHS West:260463345.l
`
`

`
`COUNSEL FOR TESSERA, INC.
`
`El
`El
`
`El
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`
`El
`
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`TesseraGPTeam@goodwinprocter.com
`
`El
`1]
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`[21
`El
`
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`tessera649@gibsondunn.com
`
`Tessera-ITC-649@irell.com
`
`J . Anthony Downs
`Lana S. Shiferman
`
`David J. Goldstone
`
`GOODWIN PROCTOR LLP
`Exchange Place
`53 State Street
`Boston, MA 02109
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`617.570.1000
`617.523.1231
`
`Scott L. Robertson
`
`Jennifer A. Albert
`
`Christopher C. Campbell
`David M. Young
`GOODWIN PROCTER, LLP
`
`901 New York Avenue, N.W.
`
`Washington, DC 20001
`Telephone:
`202.346.4000
`Facsimile:
`202.346.4444
`
`Wayne M. Barsky
`Jason C. Lo
`
`GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, LLP
`2029 Century Park East
`Los Angeles, CA 90067
`Telephone:
`213.229.7000
`Facsimile:
`213.229.7520
`
`H. Mark Lyon
`Hsin Y. Ernest
`
`Sarah E. Piepmeier
`GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, LLP
`1881 Page Mill Road
`Palo Alto, CA 94304
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`650.849.5300
`650.849.5333
`
`Mark N. Reiter
`
`GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, LLP
`2100 McKinney Avenue, Suite 1100
`Dallas, TX 75201
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`214.698.3100
`214.571.2900
`
`OHS West:260463345.1
`
`_ 2 _
`
`

`
`COUNSEL FOR TESSERA, INC.
`
`F. David Foster
`Kames B. Altman
`
`David F. Nickel
`
`Jacqueline L. Ferrand
`MILLER & CHEVALIER CHARTERED
`
`El
`Cl
`
`E]
`
`Cl
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`
`655 Fifteenth Street, N.W., Suite 900
`
`tessera649@milchev.com
`
`Washington, DC 20005
`Telephone:
`202.346.4000
`Facsimile:
`202.346.4444
`
`Tom M. Schaumberg
`Michael L. Doane
`
`Gregory F. Geary
`ADDUCI, MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG L.L.P.
`1200 Seventeenth Street, N.W., 5th Floor
`Washington, D.C. 20036
`Telephone:
`202.467.6300
`Facsimile:
`202.466.2006
`
`Cl
`El
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`El
`[3
`
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`
`TESS—4@adduci.com
`
`COUNSEL FOR SILICONWARE PRECISION
`
`INDUSTRIES CO., LTD AND SILICONWARE (USA) INC.
`
`Jeffrey A. Dunn
`Rebecca Goldsmith Lombard
`
`Jeffrey Eichen
`VENABLE LLP
`575 7th Street, NW
`Washington, DC 20004
`Telephone:
`202.344.4000
`Facsimile:
`202.344.8300
`
`E]
`Cl
`
`Via Hand-Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`E]
`[3
`
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`Venable—649—dist@venable.com
`
`OHS West:260463345.l
`
`_ 3 _
`
`

`
`COUNSEL CHIPMOS TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
`
`AND CHIPMOS TECHNOLOGIES (BERMUDA) INC.
`
`El
`[1
`
`El
`1:]
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`
`seyfarth~649-dist@seyfarth.com
`
`Alan L. Unikel, Esq.
`Michael R. Levinson
`
`Joseph R. Lanser
`Brian S. Clise
`Jason P. Stiehl
`
`Matthew A. Werber
`SEYFARTH SHAW LLP
`
`131 South Dearborn Street, Suite 2400
`
`Chicago, IL 60603
`Telephone:
`312.463.2400
`Facsimile:
`312.460.7000
`
`Misty C. Blair
`SEYFARTH SHAW LLP
`
`700 Louisiana Street, Suite 3700
`
`Houston, TX 77002-2797
`Telephone: 713.225.2300
`Facsimile:
`713.225.2340
`
`COUNSEL FOR ASE, INC; ASE TEST LIMITED AND ASE (U.S.) INC.
`
`Steven J. Rizzi
`THELEN REID BROWN RAYSMAN & STEINER, LLP
`875 Third Avenue, 10th Floor
`New York, NY 10022
`Telephone:
`212.603.2000
`Facsimile:
`212.603.2001
`
`E1
`1]
`1:]
`1:]
`
`ase itc
`
`Via Hand-Delivery
`Via US Mail
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`thelencom
`
`TesseralV_lTC service@weil.com
`
`Robert E. Camors, Jr.
`
`Papool S. Chaudhari
`TIIELEN REID BROWN RAYSMAN & STEINER, LLP
`225 West Santa Clara Street, Suite 1200
`
`San Jose, CA 95113
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`408.292.5800
`408.287.8040
`
`OHS West:260463345.1
`
`.. 4 -
`
`

`
`COUNSEL FOR STATS CHIPPAC (BVI) LIMITED; STATS CHIPPAC LTD; STATS
`CHIPPAC, INC.; ASE INC.; ASE TEST LIMITED; AND ASE (U.S.) INC.
`
`David A. Hickerson
`David N. Southard
`
`Michael R. Franzinger
`Azra Hadzimehmedovic
`Robert T. Vlasis
`
`WEIL, GOTSHAL& MANGES, LLP
`1300 Eye Street, N. W., Suite 900
`Washington, DC 20005
`Telephone:
`202.682.7000
`Facsimile:
`202.857.0940
`
`David J. Ball
`
`Ramy E. Hanna
`WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES, LLP
`767 Fifth Avenue
`
`New York, NY 10153
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`212.310.8000
`232.310.8007
`
`Steven S. Cherensky
`WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES, LLP
`201 Redwood Shores Parkway
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`
`Telephone:
`Facsimile:
`
`650.802.3000
`650.802.3100
`
`Cl
`El
`
`[:1
`El
`
`Via Hand—Delivery
`Via US Mail
`
`Via Facsimile
`Via Overnight Mail
`Via Email Distribution List
`
`TesseraIV ITC service@weil.com
`ASE—649—dist@weil.com
`
`ðwÃn
`‘
`)
`E
`E
`
`Mimii‘S“ag"m1t
`
`OHS West:260463345.1
`
`_ 5 _