throbber
Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 1 of 27
`Case 1:13—cv—O6326—TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 1 of 27
`
`EXHIBIT 5
`
`

`
`
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 2 of 27
`/<% I"
`Case 1:13—cv—O6326—TPG Document_420—6 Filed 11/18/15 Page2of 27
`IHSIWIIHHIHII
`
`
`
`
`.
`
`g 9
`
`196991 357114
`
`
`
`Ferrzepallmfllafl npmzeypawypa
`Paccmfiicleovii G)e;1epaimIa1
`-
`yn. E. ,I(mrrpon:ca, 15:1
`Moan-Ba, Puccmx, FCH-3, 125993
`
`.03.2014 NE 35/87—9c—2014
`[
`
`~——-
`Ha Nb 182-44601 or 20.03.2014
`'—-~"—-~-—i—-:—-—--
`
`1\/[I«1HI«1ct::epcTP.o IOCTIrII[I/III
`COe,I[H}Ie}II{BIX HlTaToB AMBPHKH
`
`Jlnpelcropy Bmpo no
`M6}K,I[yHapOJIHI:IM ,"aI6JIaM
`
`I‘-}I{6 Mepia ’3JIJ1eH Bapaloy
`
`Office of Intemational Affairs
`U.S. Department of Justice
`1301 New-York Avenue, N.W.,
`Suite 800, Washington, DC 20005
`
`YBa>1caeMa.s1 rocnoxca ,1u»Ipe1cTop!
`
`}"eHepaJ1LHa$1 nporcyparypa Poccnficxofi Illenepamm 0BH,I[eTBJIBCTByB’I‘ onoe
`y13a>1ceHHe MHHI»IcTepcTBy
`IocTI»II.11«1IrI
`« CoeL:I»1HeHHLIx
`IJ_ITaToB AMepmcH H
`Hanpamvleur OTBST Ha. sanpoc o 11pa;BoBoI‘7I
`l'IOMO]1IIrI N2 -182-44601, a Taloice
`npnnaraemsle K HeMy MaTe-pl/IaJIZbI.
`co1:py;LHHI1ecTBo
`11.11o,zLoTBopHoe
`;[aJ1LHeI‘fm:tee
`BBIpa)ICa6M Ha,II;e31<,z[y Ha
`Mexcuy HaIJI[/IMI/I Be,)IOMCTBaMPI I10 o1ca3aH1/no npanosofi IIOMO]I[PI_310 yI‘0JIOBH]a]Iv.[
`,I:eJ1aM.
`
`1"[pI»IJIo>1<eH1»Ie: Ha 255 II.
`
`C y:aa>I<eHHeM,
`
`M6)I{,I[yH3pO,Z[H0"1'IpaBOBOI’0 COTpy,I[ E
`
`
`
`C.F.TETOB, 1:eJ1.+7(495)982~76~07, (bane. .+7(495)692-81-49 '
`
`A11 N32
`
`0.2111
`
`T5=HBpaJ1BHaa npolcypawypa Pocclmclcofi
`dyemzpaumt
`
`-._/'
`
`7»-21
`
`_,-«K
`
`

`
` >
`
`1Q)
`
`5EL
`
`I
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 3 of 27
`Case 1:13—cv—O6326—TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 3 of 27
`
`hm.
`
`I’E3Y.JII>TATIaI
`paccmorpemm sanpoca CHIA IIO ,21eJ1y «Prevezon Holdmgs»
`
`co;{EP>IcAH1zIE
`
`.....................................1
`..............................................................................
`......
`1'1PE,E[MET BAIEPOCA ...............
`OBCTOSETEJILCTBA JJEJIA .......................................................................................................................................2
`COCTOFITEJIBHOCTB PICKA ..............................
`................................................................................................5
`1'fl‘I/I‘IACTHOCT}’:= «PREVEZON HOLDINGS» PI KALEBIBA 11.11........................................................................ .12
`3A1<J11o1a:BHI»IE . ........................................................................................................................................................14
`
`IIPEJIMET BAHPOCA
`IVIHI-II/ICTBpCTBO IOOTKHHPI COBJIPIHGHHBIX HITaToB Amepnm o6paT1»1J1ocL K
`1"eHepaJILHoI‘/'1 npoxcyparype Poccrrfioxofi <I3e;[epa.m:»11«I 0 Xo1La1?a17IcTBoM 06 oIca3aHH1»1
`co;1e1?‘1cT33p1;1 B paCCJIe,2IOBaI-]Ir1_I[~I
`;n;eJ1a KoM1IaHHH «Prevezon Holdings», K Koropofi
`HPEIBI/I’I.‘6JIBGTBOM CIJIA npensasneu rpa)1<,t[aHcK1«Ii«’1 PICK 0 1coHc111xIcKa1m1«1.
`I/I3 1‘Ip6I[CTaBJIeHHBIX ,JJ;DKyMeHTOB cnegxyer, 111:0 HpaBIrIT6JILG’_I‘B0 CHIA B
`ceHTfi5pe 2013 r. O6paTIdJIOCL B cyn; IO)1<Horo orcpyra Hrrara HL1o—I7IopK K rpynne
`1<oMI1aHI»x1‘7I «Prevczon Holdings» H K Hx BJIa,E[eJII:I.Iy Kangmsy ,I[.1"I. c Tpe60Ba.HHeM o
`Kontbncxaunn KMy111ec1:Ba, Koropoe, 110 MHBHHIO CIIIA, 61a.IJ1o npno6peTeHo c
`uenmo nerannsatmu paHee IIOXI/IIIIGHHBIX ,E[eHB)KHBIX openers.
`B PICKOBOM 3am3J1emm yrsepxcnaerca,
`rrro upecrynuaz opraHH3a11mI,
`Blmroqaxomayx pocc1«11‘/1cI<1»1x KoppyMn:11poBaHH1f.1x ‘IHHOBHKKOB, O6MaHHLIM nyrem :3
`Iv1IoJ1e-,ueI<a,6pe 2007 r. OCyI]Z(e0TBI/IJIEI. Kpaalcy npnflangnexcamux Bpaygxepy V.CI>.
`poccuficmx Komnannfi
`<<PPIJI3H)1[>) (O00),
`<<1"[apc13eHI~xoH>> (O00), «Maxaon»
`(O00), ynpanmm KOTOPBIMH 3aBJIaILeJIa 5,4 MJ1p,I[. pyfi. HJIH 230 MJIH. nonnapoa
`CLLIA H3 poccuficyzoro Grogmcera, pause yIIJIa‘€{eI-IHBIX B Ka‘-IGCTBB Hanora Ha
`11p1»I6L1I1s.
`-
`flocne amro, KaK nollaraer HpEl.BIdT6JIBCTBO CIHA, '-IJIBHEI oprannsaumi I/I PIX
`l'IapTH6pI:I 33.1-]‘5I}II»ICI: OTMB]IBaHPI6M 1'IOX1/IILIBHHBIX ,z:eHer. B riacmoorxa, txepea ctxeara
`p5I,D;a MoJI;1aBcI<1»Ix §o1«1pM (<<Bunicon—Impex>> H <<E1enast-Com») om:/I B qmspane 2008
`r. nepetmcnnnn KOM1IaHII1?I «Prevezon Holdings» 857 THC. 1101131. CHIA, KOT0pLIe
`3aTeM norpamnn Ha rxoxcymcy He;:u3H>K1?1MocT1»x B H510-I7Iop1<e Ha 06I.U,'jfI0 cyMMy,
`1IpeB5Ima_1om;y1:o 22 MJIH. noun. CHIA.
`C yqerom aroro, Coe,t[HHeHHI.1e H1Ta:msI Amepmm npocm POCCHfiGKyIO
`CDe,z:epa11mo npe,tgoc'raB1aTL CBH33,I-II-1yI0 c H3J1o>I<eHm;IMI»1 B HCKB o6cTosrreJ1LcTBaMH
`c1)I»1HaHcoBy1o, 6aHKOBCKyIO H HaJIOI‘0ByI0 ;1oI<yMeHTa1:I«no, Marepnamax Gy,Il;e6HB1X
`sacenarmfi, peI'IrIOTpaI.IIrIOHHIaIC JI01CyMeHTBI poocl/11‘icK1a“x 1coMIIaHI«1i71
`PI
`,:LpyI*I»Ie
`,EI;aHHBIe.
`Poco1»I1‘z’1c1<o1‘«'I Clfienepaunn H3yqeH I/IOK
`11poKypaIypoI‘«’I
`FeHepaIILHoI‘?1
`HpaB1»1'reJ1LoTBa CIIIA K «Prevezon Holdings» H cBsx3aHHL1x c Hefi cTp3§KTyp.
`I’I’3JIO)KBHI-IBIS B HeM cBe,ueHH;1 co1Ioc'raBs1eH1sI c
`F0 j.H'c1
`
`
`
`:1/52
`
`
`

`
`./..»,._.
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 4 of 27
`case'1:13-c’v-06326-TPG Document420—6 Filed 11/18/15 F?age4of 27
`
`c1paH pa001101101aa111111. H01c010p1.10
`11py1121x
`p1111a
`11
`P0001111
`10pp1110p1111
`060101110111-,.01Ba, y1<a3a1111L10 13 11010,
`,Z[0IIOJIHPIT6JII:HO 11p0B0p01111 CJIBJIGTBBHHBIM
`11y10M.
`0011013113110 110011; 11c1<a 0001013115101 3010
`H0 1»1101aM yc1a11013110110, 1110
`11p0130p0H110;1 11 01'1p0130p111y1a11 1001: 11011111011 00p01111 ]3pay110pa V.<I>., 1101013011 1111
`0111131103110 11 11111p01<0 11»1pa>1<1«1py010;1 0 110111111 COKPBITI/DI 01300171 11p1»1t1a011100111 11
`00B0p1110H1110 B Po00111«’101c01?1 <I)0,110pa111111 101110 1111111111):
`r1p001y1I11eH111‘~’1 13 01110130
`31c0110M111c11 11 111101<p011111a111111 1IpaBOOXpE1I-IPITBJIBHBIX 11 cy11061151x 0p1a110B P0001111,
`pa0011011y1011111x ‘ 010
`11p001y1111y10
`JIBXTGJIBHOGTB.
`II0:-110My
`11p0111.111311011111.1e
`IIpaB111011Lc1B0M CIHA 1p060Ba1111s1 K «Prevezon I-Ioldings» 110 11pe1101a1111s1101
`0060171 11c1<a 13 10p1I,1111t10c1<0M CMLICJIB 31010 0110130. 01111 B1.101y11a101 1c13a31111c1<0M,
`IIOCKOJIBKY H0 00110p>1<a.1 CaMO0TOHT6J'I.EI-[BIX 00H013a11111'?1 11 110010B0p111.1X ,Z[ElHHBIX.
`II001<0111.1<y, K011
`131111110
`113 11010, CDGJIHI-IBHI-IBIG 11110151 AM0p1711c1»1 H0
`pac11011a1a101
`IIOJIHBIMH 11
`110c10130pH1.1M11
`11aH111.1M1»1 0 Bpay110pe VII).
`11
`110111c0111p0111.111.1x 0My 111111011,
`11 1010110 06 01130111111101:
`11 11x 01110111011111»: K
`06c10;110111.0113aM, CBH3aHI-IBIM c X1111101111011
`113
`61011111010 5,4 M11p11. py6.,
`l"0Hepa111:.Ha.s_1
`11p01cypa1yp_a
`P00c11I‘7101c0i71
`CI)0,110pa111111
`1101101001 Bo3M011cH1.1M
`00061111111. 0 p03y111.1a1ax 11p0B01101111010 Ha 00 10pp1110p11H pa0c110110Ba111«111.
`11c1cy
`B1s1111001M0q0HH00
`01110111011110
`P0c01»11‘»’101<01>i
`CI3011epa11111~1
`1c
`HpaBH1011L01Ba CHIA 11p0111B «Prevezon Holdings» 1300110110 11 1101c1110t11»110111.H0
`00110130110 Ha 06101<111BH1.1x ,D,’aHHBIX,
`1<01op1310 B 1110600 BpeM$I M01y1 61.111.
`11p0130p0HL1 11 110171111 0000 110111B0p11c11011110.
`
`OBCTOHTEJILCTBA JIEJIA
`Pac011011013a1111eM 11011101151-100111 Bpay110pa VH3. y01a11013J10H0, "010 B 1996 1.
`6y,11yL111
`IIO,IIJIaHHBIM C001111110HH010 K0p0110Bc113a B011111<06p111a111»11»1
`11
`011,
`CeB0p1101'1 LIpnaH11H11, B Hapy11;10H1I0 M:111jpa111101111010 3a1c011011a10111.c1:0a 11p1161.111 B
`-1. M001<Ba
`(P000111),
`110
`11p1«1115111
`130111011110
`3a111»1Ma11.c;1
`He3aKOH1-IBIM
`11p1106p010111»1e1v1 0111111171 p00c111‘»i01c11x 11p01111p115111»11‘?1, KOTOPBIG 6111111 3a11p01110111.1 11111
`111301101111»: 110p0311110111aM —— 1/1110011101-1111311/1 111111aM.
`111151 pea111»13a11H11 000111;: 111101101. Bpay110p VII). 111111311011 CDa:E10p010y11a I[.P.,
`Ma1H11101c010 C31. 11 11:py11«1x 111111, 1c010p1.10 pas-pa601a1111 111111 H010 11p0c1y11Hy10
`cxemy 30131101100101 a1<111«1s1M1»1 1<py11111.1x p0cc1«11}‘101<11x 1c0M11a11111‘«1, 0601a1110111111 30 01101
`11030110110010 06013010 01101 a1<11111}’1, 11031111101131 1101101013 11 111-1 MOIIIBHHI/I‘i6OKO1"O
`B0313pa1a 113 61011111010 P00c1»11‘«’101<01‘& <I)0110pa111111.
`P0cc1»113'101<01}’1
`10pp1110p1111
`B0
`11c11011110H110
`11p0c1y1111010
`111101121 Ha
`CI>0110pa111111 00y11a01111«11<aM1«1 y1<a3a11HL1x 111111 — V-I0p1<a00B1.1M PIC. 11 K1101‘»’1H0p0M
`BI‘.
`61.1110
`0p1a111»130Ba110
`yL1p0;1c110111»10
`§o111c111BH1.1x
`0611100113 — «Maxaon»,
`<<P11113H11», <<Hapq)e11110H», <<,Z[a11LHs1s1 010111)», <<Ca1yp11 I/IHB0c1M0H1c», <<KaM0:1>>,
`«P111311», <<Op110111—K» 11 11py111x, 1c010p1.10 61.11111. 3ap011101p11p00aH1s1 110 011110My
`a11p00y: P0011y611111<a Ka111v11.11c11;1, 1. 31111010, 301.
`JI0111«111a,
`11. 301, 1110 1.010110
`% 1111011111001 01110 01311110 0,11H01‘1 11110111111 pa3111»It1H1,1x 111111<11»1B11L1x 1c01v111aH1»11”1.
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 5 of 27
`Céée 1':13-cv-06326-TPG' Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 5 of 27
`
`/.?'_Je
`W
`
`.
`
`:1
`
`
`
`
`
`;
`
`(<1-Iennitage Capital» I/I <<(I)ai71ep0T0yH Z{aH1.=ceH» B r. M001c13e.
`I<0MIIaHPISIMIrI
`PYKOBOJLIHTBJIGM Y‘-Ip6}KJJ;eHH]':D( 06111ec1B 11epB0Har1a111sH0 2131111110111 Bpayziep V111, a
`3a'1:eM 3-Ty 11011111110011; 3aH1«1Ma1111 11013epe11111.1e eMy 111:L1a —PeHq 11, 3711110011 M.,
`‘Iep1<a_c0B I/I.
`I/I0110111.3ys1 y1<a3aHH1.1e 06111ec1Ba 13 11peCTy1'IHBIX 11e1151x, Bpaynep VII).
`c1<p1.113a11 01 1<0H'rpa1"eHT013 11 pee01:p0,11ep21caTe11e171 a:1<111»1fi C-B06
`(1)aKTIdT'{6GKOe
`yt1ac1I~1e Ka1< Hepe3171,11eH'ra B c1cy111<e a1c11111?1 p00e1«11‘7101c1«1x 11pe1111p1»1r1T1»1171. C1cy11a51
`a1scL1;I»1I«1, c130pMa111.H0 Ha, p00c1«1fic1c1«1e 10p1zI1112111ec1<1«1e 11111121, Bpayzzep VII). y1c110111111cs1
`OT 11011yt1eH1»111 06;13a're111.H0r0 111151 11epe31111eH1013 pa3pe111e111«1£
`(IJe11epa111.H01‘«i
`1coM1vI001»I11 IIO I161-II-IBIM 6yMaraM 11 I1paBI/IT6J1BC»TBa P0001»117101c01"1 CI)e11epa111z11z1 11 13
`more 6e3 11x c0r1Ia01»111 B 11ep110,11 0 1999 110 2004 IIp0TPIB()1'IpaIBI-IO 1IpH06pe11 He
`Menee 131 574 722 a1c11111’1 OA0 «Fa311p0M>>.
`I‘Ia3BE1I-IHE.IMI/I 11e1>1c'17131121v111 Bpaynepa VII). 11 em c0yr1acT111»I1caMI»1 11p11qHHeH
`y111ep6 Ha cyMMy He Me1_1ee 2 MJIp,I{. 985 M1111. py6. H0 1(a11H0My q)a1<1y BO36y)i{,I[BI-IO
`11 pa0011e,11yeTc51 yro11013H0e ,1:1e110, 110 1<01*0p0My Bpaynep VII). 01 ,'n;aHI»I I101ca3aHIv1I‘?1
`YKJIOHHBTCH, 06‘B5IB3IeH 13 q1e11epa111.111s1i»’I 11 Me11c11;y11ap011111.1f& p03BICI(.
`I110
`B 2004 r0,11y 110 pe3y111.1aTaM HaJI01‘OBI:IX np0Bep01< 651110 BL151B11eH0,
`d:;0pMa111.H0
`3aper1»10Tp1a1p0Ba111~1L1e
`B
`Pe011y6111r11<e
`I{a111\1:5IK11sI
`06113;e0T13a,
`11e,<1Te111;H00'1:1»1 Ha 310171 T6ppI€[T0pHI/I He 13e11y'r,
`]':iHBaJ11PI,I[BI
`13 06111ecTBax He
`pa60Ta10T,
`0q30pM11eH1,1
`111111{1:12£BH0,
`B HwIOFOBBIfi
`0praH 11pe,1101:aB1151:11»I01s
`1101111e111.H1.1e
`cB1111eTe111.c'rBa
`pe31«111e1110B
`00060131
`31<0H0M11t1ec1<_01‘»’I
`30111.1,
`c011ep}1ca1111«1e r10,11110>1cH1.1e 11011011011 M11H1101pa 31<0H0M1211c1«1 Pec11y611111<1»1 KaJIMI:IKPI}I.
`B51110 yc1aH01311eH0, T110 1«10110111.3013aHHa;1 0XeMa Ha110r00611011ceH11:1 1103B0115111a
`1c0Mr1a111»111M Bpaynepa Y.(D. He3a1c0HH0 r1011y=1aT1.
`JIBFOTBI 110 y1111aTe HaJ101*0B,
`011111142111 01306 Ha110r0B0e 6peMz 0 35% 110 5,5 % TOJIBKO IIO Ha1101y Ha 11p1161.1111..
`I/Ic11011L3y51 pa3pa601aHHy10 MaTHHTGKHM C.JI. cxeMy yX0,1[a 01‘ Ha11or013,
`11p11Ha)111e>1ca1111z1e Bpaygggepy VII). KOMIIaHPIH HpB,D;CTaBJ'I}IJII€E 13 Ha110r01s1.1e 0pI‘aH'I:I
`P00c1»11>’1c1c0171 CI3e,1:epa111»11«1 110>1<111.1e cBe1:{eH1a111, I110 1103301111110 KOMIIELHPIHM Bpayguepa
`VII). (1(0M1'IaHPI5IM <<He1'1:nitage Capital») TOJILICO 321 0111111 11a1101*oB1s11‘«'1 11ep1»1011; 2001
`1"01[a yK110H11TL051 0'1: y1'I11aTL1 Ha1I0ra Ha 1Ip1161.I111. 13 pa3Mepe 522 5 95 514 py6.
`H0 1§aHH0My
`qnalcry
`B
`2004
`1*0,11y
`B036y>1c,11eHL1
`yro1IOBH1.1e
`11;e11a,
`pa0c11e1[0BaH11e 110
`ICOTOPBIM 11e011H01cpaTH0 '11p110cTaHaB111113a1100:e. B 01351311 0
`p03L1c1c0M Epaynepa VII). B 2012 1. pac01Ie,110Ba1111e 631110 3a13ep111eH0, 11;e110
`11epe1gaH0 B cy,11;.
`BcTy1111B1111«1M B 3a1c0HHy10 c1»111y 1'IpPII'OBOpOM TBepc1c0r0 pa1'Z10H110ro cy,1:[a 1".
`MOCKBBI
`0'1
`11
`11101151 2013 1011a Bpaypqep Y.CD.
`11p113HaH B1211-IOBHBIM B
`MH0r0MH11111«10HH0M y1\/11.111111011110111 y1<110HeHH11 01 y1111aTL1 Ha110ro13 11 HPHFOBOPBH 1c
`9 r011aM 11111111111115: 0130601111, OGBHLBJIGH B c11e1:1;epa111.HB11>’1 11 Me>1<11yHapo,11;H1.1171 p03LICK.
`Ta101ce ycTaH01311eH0,
`‘ITO H 110011e
`11p011a)1c1«1
`13 2006 1"0,1[y He3a1<0HHO
`npH06peTeH111ax a1<L111i‘1 00 Bee): 1'I0,T.1‘KOHTp0JIBI-IBD{ Bpaynepy V.(I). 1c0M11aH1«1fi, 31011
`me
`11))/11110131
`111111
`11p1«11v1e11;11111c1. HB3aI{0I-IHBI6 CXBME-I HaJIOI‘0O6JIO}KeHH5I,
`a
`B110c11e,110'r'B1»11»1 yIIJI2,1‘{eI-II-IBI6 110 1a.1c11M 0xeMaM 1131101311 Ha r1p1161.1111. B03Bpa111a111101.
`113 6101g>1<eTa 1v10111eH1'11»1r1ec1<111v1 11yTeM.
`H0 01[H0My 113 q1a1<T013 yMBIJ".LIJI6H}I0 3aHI1;1ce111101e“1 GTaBI{]§{IM.§{,2L{6,}3}I{aHI/I$I~H;&J1:(5Fa
`Ha ,110x0111.1, B Mae 2007 1011a 6131110 B036y11c11eH0 yr0110BH0e §21011BE:'-'0T0‘1ji1f’
`
`5'
`
`
`
`/vx‘
`
`-....r"
`
`

`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 6 of 27
`Case 1:13—cv—O6326—TPG Document 420-'6 " Filed 11/18/15 Page 6 of 27
`
`..
`
`(
`
`.
`
`T{0p1c3003a E[.B., 3 X0110 pa001101103a1111;1 1c010p010 33111311011 y1L10p6 P000111'101<01‘!1
`CD0110pa111I1I 3 pa3M0p0 0110110 600 000 000 p3/6110131.
`_
`B X0110 pa001101103a111111 01010 310110311010 110110 3 11103130110 2008 10110
`11pa300xpa1111101131131M11 0pra11a1v111 P0001111 61.1110 33313110110, 1110 y1111ar101111310
`06111001331/111
`<<P111101111>>,
`«Maxa011»
`11
`<<IIap<110111101I»,
`1<0111p01111py01v131M11
`Bpay1:10p01v1 VIII, 110110111 Ha 11p1I631111. 0 11130110311 01011111 3 pa3M0p0 5,4 1v111p,11.
`py6110f1, 11y10M 330110111111 1101101033111 0131211103 B 3a611y>1(,1:10H110, 6311111 Ha 0011030111111
`301301100 110111:0103110111131:-1
`c13111c1113H31:x 00111001031111, 06pa3y1011111x y63I1KI1 y
`11033011113111 061110013 p0311:0 Ha 0yMMy y1111a110111131x 11a110r03, 110x111110H3I
`113
`p000111‘101<0r0 6101111010 11011 31111011 3033pa1a 1131111111110 y1111a11011H0r0 3011010 Ha
`11p11631113.
`.
`C p0a11113a111101‘«’1 111103110 310171 03101131 03113011 y110M111y131I71 3 110110 CHIA
`311113011 0 5,4 M1Ip11. py61101‘»'I.
`Pa001101103a11110 11a111131x 06010511033013 11011030110, 1110 K 11111110111110 5,4 M11p11.
`py6. 11p11L1a01Ha rpynna 111111, 00010111-m1a51 113 X1106H1I1c03a B.F., Map1<0J103a B.A.,
`Kyp0t11c1111a B.H., R'.0p0601‘»'111111c03a C.M., Fa0a1103a 01"., a 1a101<0 Ma11111101c0r0
`CJI. 11 Xafip0111111103a 3.M., 1101’101303a31u11x 3 11111013000); ]3pay110pa VII).
`1'I1IaH 1'10 11111110111/110 pa1100 y1111a'10H1131X 3 2006 r011y 110110103 01 11p011a31<11
`a1<11111‘~‘1,
`303111/11<1111«11'71 H0
`1103111100 M011 2007 1011a,
`11p011y0Ma1p113a11
`3a1v1011y
`311a110J131103 Ha.110101111a1011311111K03 — <<P1111:-11111», <<Maxa0H>>,
`<<1".Eapt]j101111011>> Ha
`11011010311312: 111111, q10p1v1a113110 111111311 110.03113aH1131x 0 11031-111160 113 «Hermitage
`Capital»,
`0
`10111,
`1110631
`0pra11113a10p31
`11p001y111101‘1
`0x0M31 M01113
`600np0m110130HH0 1101131111113 110 0110121 1<0111p01111py0M31x 111111 111111 30 py6011c01v1
`110x1111101111310 1101101111310 0130110130, .1 3 110011011y10I11;0M 301131113 0 111301110 y HHX 011131
`1<0Mr1a1111i»‘1, 10M 0aM31M 01300111 01 00651 1101103p0H101.
`B X0110 0030p1110H11s1 110330311010 11p001y111101111s1 11 0 11011310 001<p311131 y11a011»111
`B 3011 Bpaynepa VIII, 631110 00y11100131103a 0110113. 31101101131103 p000111‘1c1c11x
`061110013 1121 1101101a3H3Ix 111111 11y10M 110p00dp0pM110111I3 100 % 110110171 BTI/Di 061110013
`113 <<II11y1011» (000).
`111111 01010 1111p01c10pa1v111 1<1111p01<11x 1c01v111aH111‘«’1 «K0110
`Holdings» 11 «Glendora Holdings», 3x011>111111x 3 01py1<1ypy «I-Iermitage Capital» 11
`11p1111a1111011ca111:1Ix Bpay110py V.<I>., 2 11101111 2007 10110 331110113 11030p011H0013
`Fa0aHo3y 0.1". 0 1101IH0M0I11111M11 301011011313 01 11x 111101111 0110111111 0 11011513111 3
`y01a31131x 1<a:r1111a11ax 061110013, 3 TOM 3110110, 0a1\/10010111011330 0'11p0110111113 y011031111
`011011011. Ha 0011030111111 3101’: 11030p0H1100111 FacaH03 0.1‘. 3a1<111011a01 31 11101111
`2007 10110 11010301)
`1cy111111—1Ip011a11<11
`110110171 061110013 <<P111101111>>, <<Maxa011>>,
`<<1"Iapc}:1011110H» 0 1101101a31131M 111111011,
`t110pMa113H0 110 0311301133111 4 0 1110311031
`«Hermitage Capital» I/I Bpay110p0M Y.CI3.,
`1111110111, 110 110111c0H1p0113110My HM
`061110013031 «H11yT0H>>, 303r11a311s10M31M Map1101103311v1 B.A.
`II00110 110p00q10pMJ10H1111 yqp01111r0113H31x 1101<yM011103, 30 11011311100111
`1111p0K10p03 y1<a3aH1131X 061110013 6311111 Ha3HaT-IBHBI 11p1I3110t101111310 Fa0a110331M
`0.1". 1111110 — X1106111I1c03 B.F., Map1<01103 BA.
`11 Kyp0111<1111 B.I-I., 1c010p310 3
`r10011011y101110M 11pI1HI1Ma1111 1101100p0,110130HH00 yt1a.011I0 3 06110110 Ha110r0331§1
`11113 3033pa1110111151 paigefia1
`0pra1103 01300111031330 11a11111111;1 y 3111-:
`00110301-I1117'I
`y1111a11011110r0 11011010 Ha 111311631113 3 pa3M0p0 5,4 M11p11. py61101‘?1
`—
`‘T
`
`
`
`/“N.
`
`_r-"-*-\
`
`

`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 7 of 27
`Tfésee1:'1'§—Cv—O6326—TPG Document420—6 Filed 11/18/15 Page7of 27
`
`
`
`By,21yI11»1 COHCHOJIHPITBJIBM CXCMBI XHILIBHKE I/I pacnonarasx CBMBIMI/I IIOJIHBIMI/I
`,.E[aHHLIMH 0 t1)1»IHaHcoBofi zLe:»ITeJILHocTH <<Maxa0H>>, <<PmI3H,u;>>, <<1’Iapc1)eH1»1oH>>,
`Ma1"HI»ITcKHfi C.J1.
`IIp0PI3Be3I pacqer pa3Me-pa 511C051’:-I
`IrI3J1I/IIJII-I6 y1IJ1aIIeHHoro B
`6xo;p1<eT Hanora,
`IIBPOTOBPIJI
`HBJIOCTOBSPHBIB Hanoroxame
`;1e1<J1apa;Lrm«1
`1»:
`lI0,11TBepJK,I(a.IOIIIPI6 Hx 11epB1«1qHL1e 6}/XI‘aJITepCI{PIe ,1Z[OKyMCHT]E-I, y,:[oeIoBepI«IJI Hx
`,I1y6JII4EI(aT8.MIrI Heqarefi, 1IoeJIe qero IIep6,[[aJI EX FacaHoBy 0.1‘. II Mapxenony B.A.,
`K0'1‘0pBI6 OHI/I co13MecTHo c KypoI1KI/IHLIM B.H. H XJIe6HHKOBLIM BI‘. I«IcIIoJIL30BaJII»I
`111151 BBe,r:eHmz B 3a63Iy>1c,n;eHHe HaJIoroBLIx opraHoB 11 3aBJ'.[a,I[E5HH5I 5,4 Mnpzzu. py6.
`B CBOIO
`oqepens
`_Kopo6ei7IHm<oB C.M.,
`HBIDIHCB
`BIIa,II;6.?I15IIeM KB
`<<VHI«IBepcaJILHL11‘7I 6aH1c c6epexceHI/H7I>>, 1Ip6,E[OCTaBI/IJI ctIe'ra 3IoI‘»’I OpI‘aHIrI3aT.IIrII/I,
`IIpPIeM Ha HIIX rxsmrmx I/I3 Gxomicera non BPIJIOM Bo3BpaTa Hanora IEGHBI‘ I/I HX
`1IOCJIE:,ILyIOI.T_IyI0 nerannaaumo (1Iepe1-2021 B xzpyme 6aHjE{OBCKHe I/I name I{p6,I[HTI-IBIS
`y"{p6}I{,II6HPUI Poccnficxofx <1)eJ1epaI1I»1H I/I nocJIe;:LyIoH1:«II‘71 BI>IBO,E[ pr): 33. py6e3I<).
`Ha
`ocHoBaHm»1
`HOJIFOTOBJICHHBIX MarHm:cKHM (3.11.
`JIOICYMBHTOB,
`HHcneKn;HH CI3e;:LepaJ1LHofi Hanoronofi CJ1'y}I{6BI N2 25 PI 28 IIpI»I‘H$IIII/I pen1eH1~1s1 0
`Bo3BpaTe HaJIoroB B cyMMe 5 409 503 006, 48 py6., Koropme 26.12.2007
`ynpamxefine
`t1>e;1epaJILHoI‘o
`xa3Ha11e1‘«icTBa MHHHGTBpGTBa
`dg1»IHaHcoB
`P<I>
`Hepe‘1I/ICJIPIJIO Ha crIe1:a o61L:ecTB.
`Ocoénasax, 111:0 BI:IIJ.IByI{33aHHa5I npecTy1IHa.>1 ,I£e5ITeJ£BHOCTL Bpayzzepa V11). 1»:
`1'£OI_[KOH'I‘p0JIBHBIX eMy 111111, MODKBT
`613mg.
`13L1s1BJ1eHa. npaBooxpaHHTeJ1r.HLnvrH
`opraHaMH Poccpm, 01:11}: H3 a,zu3oI<aToB Epaygrepa VII). - XaI7IpeT,::HHoB 3.M.
`Hat11«1HaeT OCYITICCTBJISITB 3apaHee IIpe,I[yCMOTp6HHI:I6 1'Ip6CTy1'IHB1M IIJIElHOM Maps: K
`BBIBOJIY Bpaynepa Yd). H3 ‘EIPICJIB. mm, Koropme M01111»: 6LI'I‘B 3aI‘.[O,EL03peH]':I B
`x1«1LLreH1»II»I 5,4 M.TIp,H. py6.
`C )1eKa6p51 2007 rogxa OH paC1IpOCTpaI-DIET cBe;1eHIa51 0 XHm;eHmI y Bpaygxepa
`(y «Hermitage Capital») Ha3BaHHBIX L1mpM I/I Q npHqacTHocTH K BTPIM
`VICE.
`co6L1T1«1>1M
`corpymmxcon
`poccnficmx
`lIpaBO0XpaHPITBJILHBD(
`opraI~IoB,
`O60CHOBBIBa}I 3T0 TeM,
`rrro 13
`I/IIOHG 2007 1?. OHI/I B xozze 05BICKa I/I3'B5IJIE
`y‘Ip6,I[IrITeJ'II>HBIB
`J;EOKyMeHTLI
`«PI/IJI3HI[>>,
`<<MaxaoH»,
`<<IIapcpeHI«mH>>
`H B
`nocnegxyxomem I/ICIIOJIBBOBEIJIII EX 1:315 Hepeoqaopmneflwz amx (1)1/IpM Ha xzpyrtax 11211:.
`Hocne oqepegmofi C-M61-IBI HOMI/IHEIEIBHOFO BJIa,Z[e.1I]5I_Ia o5111ecTB «PI/DI'3H,I[>),
`<<MaxaoH», <<1"Iapc]_JeH1«IoH» (<<HJI}’TOH)>) Ha HOBO6 1'I0,IEC'I3aBJI6HH06 1111110 1<oM11aHmo
`«Boily Systems» (]3pI»1'raHcme
`BI/Ip1‘IrIHCICI/I6
`ocTpoBa) XaI71peT;:[I21HoB 3.M.
`opraHH3oBLIBaeT Tafifloe Hsrmrne B HaJIO1"OBBD{ opranax 1/1 nocnenyxomee XpaHeHI»Ie
`y (:66): l'I01IJIO)KHT:-IX 1Io1cyMeH'roB, KOT0pBIe 6513111 HBFOTOBJICHBI MarHHTcKHM C.JI. I/I
`ncnoJIL3oBaHLI 1"aca.HoBL1M OI‘. II MapKeHOBBIM BA. 1131:; conepmemeza XHIIIBHI/I51
`5,4 MJIp,I[. py6. Home o6Hapy;KeHns1 psma K3 yKa3aHI~1L1X HEUIOPOBBIX ;:oKyMeHToB B
`xo,u;e o6LIcKa y Xa1>ipeT,uHHoBa 3.13/1., 1'.[OCJIB,I{HHi7I onemno noxcpmyn Teppmopmo
`PoccHI}’IcKo17I CDe;Lepa:11I«IH P1 110 HMeIo1:U,eI7IcH I»IH¢a0pMaD:I»II«I 2.10 CHX HOP HaX0,Z[IrITC5£ B
`BB}II»1K06pPITaHPIH, me c 2006-2007 roguga CKPBIBEIIOTCH 6oJ1LmHHcTBo JIHU, H3
`rpynnm
`Bpaynepa VIII,
`3a11e;7IcTBoBaHHL1x
`KM
`13
`MHoroJ1eTHe1‘z’I
`oIrIcTeM:Ho-op1"aHI»I3oBaHHoI‘ZI MOI.T_I6HHIvI‘IeCKOI7I ,2xe:1TeJILHocTH.
`HpHroBopaMI»I TBepcI<oro pafioHHoro cyna r. MOCKBBI or 28.04.2009" V
`
`
`10.03.2011 Maplcezton B.A. H XJIe6HHKoB 13.1‘.
`IIRI,/Iii}
`”‘”"‘“"‘”"W"WWnmfmj
`
`aHBI
`"B H.O1?gI§I(T:-IM$I~~
`g gm _; ,:_:..
`OOB6pII.IBHI/1‘.PI
`rIpecTyImeHKs[,
`1Ipe,11yCMOTp6HHOI‘O
`‘H14
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 8 of 27
`Ca'§é'fL'i13—'CV—U6326—TPG Document420—6 Filed 11/18/15 Page8of 27
`
`(Mo11IeHHHqecTBo, coBep11IeHHoe Ipynnofi mm; B oco6o Icpy11HoM pa3Mepe). HM
`Ha3Ha'-IBHO HaI<a3aHHe B Bmze n1«1meH1»I;1 CB060,I[}3I CPOKOM Ha 11;n:L JIST. B noxop;
`roeyzzapcrna o6paI11eH1:.: ,ueHe>1cHLIe cpegtzcma Ha cyMMy 685 024 893, 29 py6.
`PaccJIe;[oBaHHe B oTHomeHHI»1 Kypo'»I1<1/ma B.H., KOp06eI7IHIrIKOBEl. C.M.,
`Tacanoea 0.1“. II ].VIEt1“HI€[TCI{O1"O CJI. 1'10 05CTOETeJIBCTBaM xmnxemrsr I/IMPI 5,4 MJIp,Z[.
`py6. IIpeICpaI.1IBHO B CBSISPI co GM6pTLIO. XaI>’1peT,:[1»IHoB 3.M. O6’.BfIBJ1eI-I B p03BICK.
`
`HECOC'I‘Ofl’I‘EJII:nHOCTI> PICKA
`
`HM
`BLISIBJIBHHBIB HecooTBe’rcTBI~I:1 Bcex KJIIEOTIBBLIX H eoHyTcTByro1L:I«1X
`o6cT0;1TeJ1LcTB coBep1IIeHI»I5{ XI/IIHBHKSI 6I0,IpIceTHsIX_ Cpe):[CTB B 2007 rogxy B
`PoocHI7IcKefI
`q3e,[[Bpa]'_II»II/I
`pe3yJIBTaTaM paCOJ1B,E[OBaHPI5I,
`1IO,JITB6p}K,J_'{eHHI’:IMI/I
`BCTYHPIBIIII/IMH
`B
`3aKOHI-IyIO
`clmy
`pe1HeHK:1MI»I
`cy,n;oB,
`yKa3I>IB8.I0'I‘ Ha
`HCCOCTOETBJIBHOOTL HCK8. 1“[paB1»ITeJILcTBa CHIA.
`
`*-.4“
`
`1) YTBep3Ic,21eH1»1;1 o coBepmeHHH x1a111eHm1 5,4 M.TIp,E(. py6. <<pocc1aficIcof1
`npecTy1IHo1?i
`op1*aHH3auI~Ie17I,
`Bxunoqaromefi
`IcoppyMIIHpoBaHH51X
`upaemsemscnaennsxx ‘-IPIHOBHI/IKOB)), He CO0TBeTC«'I‘By.[OT ,11eI'7IcTB121TeJIr.HocTH.
`
`CJ1e;[c1:B1»1eM YCTEIHOBJIGI-IO, 11170 K yKa3aH1-IoMy 11pecTyrIJIeHI~neo Hpnqacrna
`rpynna JIPIII, c0eTo;1B111as1 I/I3 Bpayglepa V.CI)., Mammrcxoro C.JI., XJIe6H3E1KOBa. B.F.,
`Maplcenosa B.A., Kypo*11<I»1Ha B.‘H., Kopo6eI‘»iHIr1KoBa C.M., 1"acaHoBa 01‘. H
`XaI7IpeT)1PIHOBa 3.M., KoTopLIe ,I[0JDKHocTHLIMH JII/IIIaMIrI He HBMHHGL.
`B }_(0,n;e paOCJIel[OBaHH5I 1'£p0BepH.TIaCL 1‘IpI/I‘iaC-THOGTI-.« K XIIIJIEGHI/USO 5,4 MJ1‘p,1I.
`py6. corpymmxcos HEIJIOFOBBIX opraHoB. OHH nomaepranucs ,u;o11pocaM PI OHHLIM
`CTaBKaM. Ho MBCTY HX pa6oTL1 1:1 >KIrITeJ'IBCTBa 1‘.lpOBO,.T[BH15I 06BICKa H BBIBMKI/I.
`Ooymecrsnefl I{OHTp0JIB Te-J1ec};aoHHLIx pa3r‘0B0poB coorsercrsyxoxunx mu. O;[Ha1<o
`)1OKa3aT6JIBCTB ozexsn ,I[OJI}I(HOCTHBIX mm c BL1nIeHa3BaHHofI npecrynnofi rpyunofi
`He I-Ia.I7I,Z[BHO. B MoMeHT npI»IH;1'rw1 pemeHm?’I 0 Bmnnare 5,4 MJIp,I{. OHH Haxomelnncb
`H091 BHKHHPIGM o6MaHa.
`Hpnqacmocrs IIHLIX JII/ILI, B TH. GOTpy,Il',HI»II(0B 0pI‘aHOB BHy’]L‘p6HHPIX gen 4
`Kapnosa FLA. I/I Ky3HeuoBa A.K., 'Ta1<}1ce r1poBepeHa Ii r1o,uTBep>K,ueHH;1 He Hamsxa.
`YcTaHoBJIeHo,
`rrro HMGIOHIBCCFI y HEX nMym;ecTBo 11pHO6peT6HO I/IMI/I H HX
`po;1cIBeHHp1KaM1»1 3a ctrer openers,
`IIOJIy‘=IeHHI:IX H3 JI6TaJIBH]5IX ncrotxnmcos,
`1»:
`
`31~Iaq1«1'reJ1£.Ho pansme coaepmerma xmuenmz.
`2)
`,Z[oBomsI o TOM, trro ‘-IJIBHBI <<opraH1a3a111zm>> — Kapnoe ILA. H Ky3He1:oB
`A.K., c IIBJIBIO XHIIIBHPIFI <<K.opnopaTm3Horo o6p’a3a I<oMrIaHI»I17I «I-Iermitage
`Capital»,
`1«IHHnHHpoBam»1
`rrpoBe21eHHe B cepe,J1HHe 2007 1". O6I>ICKa B
`poccm7IcKoM oqmce
`q>oH,1;ra «Hermitage Capital»,
`B
`xo;::e KOTOPOTO
`eoTpy;zH1»1I<I«I HIIOJII/ILII/II/I
`IcoH¢:1»1cI<oBaJ11«1 ILom11«1HHHe Ixetiairzxr, HaJIOI‘OB]3I6 H
`y‘Ipe,E[PITBJIBHBIB ,11oI<yMeHT1sI (<PI»IJI3H,E[>>,. «Maxaon», <<HapqaeI51IzIoH>>, a 3aT6M
`Hc11oJ1L3oBam»1 142: mm nepepemerpaxzurm emx o6111ecTB Ha HMH TpBX ‘IJIBHOB
`<<opraHH3am«1H>>, SIBJDIIOTCH He)1oc'roBepHL1M1»1.
`'
`
`‘-ITO KapI1oB HA. pemem/I171 0 nponasogxome
`CJ1e,z{cTB1»:eM ycTaHoBJ1eHo,
`05BICKa, a TaK}K6 06 I/I3'InHTIrIIrI _yKa3aHHz.1x 1'1p6)1[MB’I‘0B H ,I[0KyM6HTOB He 11pI»1H1iMaJ'I‘;‘B
`CaMOM 06I:ICKB He y‘IaCTBOBaJI. K MoMeHTy npHH51THs1,mp,g1,e,;19§§Te3IeM Kapncgfargfm
`ILA.
`CDDTBBTCTBYIOIIIBTO
`jzroJ1oBHorQ
`JIBJIB.
`14 I
`a
`'
`' M
`K
`
`
`
`

`
`
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 9 of 27
`Case’1:13'¥c\}-063020-TPG'
`t3b'cument42o-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page9of 27
`
`US
`
`p6I‘I/ICTPEILUKIOHHLIG EOKYMGHTBI H 1101101121 ((PHJI3H,Z[)>, ((MfiXa0H>>, <<1'Iapq)e1111011» YDKG
`6]-I:IJIIvI
`I/I3TB5ITJE-I
`11p0113111y1:r111M GJIQEEDBEITBJICM PI XpaHIIJIPICE B YIIBICOBBHHOM I/I.
`0110v1a1a11Ho1v1 311,110, 3 110Mem;e111111, 11p11011000611eH110M 111111 1111011011113 1133111010
`111v1y111e013a. V11a1c031<11 Kap1103 II.A. 110 301cp1.13a11 11 110 11011033303011 y1<a3a11111.10
`11130111110131 11 11;01<yM011131.
`1‘.[p03011011111.11v.11/1 31<0110p11131M11 11001101103a111111M1«1 y01a1103110110, 11110 0111101111
`1101131011 <<P1111:-1H11>>, <<Maxa011>>, <<l'Iap<110H11011>> 3 1101<y1v10111aX, 1co10p310 6311111
`11000333030331 11p11 0030p1110111111 1111111031111 5,4 M11p11. py6., 33111011110113: 110 1011111
`11011011111111, 1<010p310 6311111 113351131 01101:103a1011111v11»1 1\/[B11 3 p000111’101<11x 011111031:
`1c0M11aH111‘«’1 <<H0r1nitag0 Capital» 11 <<€IDa1’10p010y11 ,I[aI11<0H».
`H1111 0030p1110111111 M0m0H111310013a 110110111.303a111101. 1_1y6111»11<a11.1, 1<010p1.10,
`KEIK r1p1«13Ha11 0aM 1\/Ia1"1111101<1»11‘1 C.}I., 011 110 y1ca3a111110 py1<030,11013a 1<0M11a11111>'1
`113101031111 1100110 11p0301101111>1 11pa3o0xpa111110111.111.11v111 0pra11aM11 063101<a. 3111
`11y611111<a131,
`00111210110
`1:101ca3a111111M Ma1H11101c0r0 C.JI.,
`Hax01111111103
`3
`pa0110p1111<0111111
`001py11;11111c03
`«<IJa1“10p010y11 ,IIa1~'11c011», 3 1011 11110110 0011010
`MaFHHTCKOF0 C.JI.
`
`11.1‘
`
`-...,_
`
`M
`
`
`
`13
`
`11
`
`3) V13ep11c11;0111»111 0 1011, 1110 y11a.01111I1c11 <<0pra11113a111111>> 0030p111111111 Kpaxcy
`11p1111a,1111011ca11111x 11014110111111 <<H01'1nitag0 Capital» 061110013 ~ <<MaXa0H>>,
`<<P11.1131111», «Hapq10111«10H>>, Ha 001103aH1111 p01110111«111 1p0101‘»101c0ro 0y11a 111111
`000 «l[0101<0» 01 15 11101111 2007 10110, 1131113 3 110110 063101103 4 11101111 2007
`10110
`1111
`y11p01L11110113H310
`1101<y1v1011131
`11
`110110111,
`1»10110111.3y11 1c010p310
`r10p0p011101p11p03a1111 0611100130 Ha 11pyr11x 111101103 «0p1a11113a111«11»1» 11 3
`11001101113/101110M 1100033303033 3111
`<1111p1v11.1
`111151
`1111111031111
`6101:p1c01H1.1x
`0p011013, 110 00013e1013y101 1101710131»110113110011»1.
`<<P11113111.1>>,
`11pa3 Ha
`Pa00110,1103a11110M y01a1103110110,
`T110
`x111110111«151
`«Maxa011», <<1'Iap1110111»1011» 110 631110. C00'1a31101}’1 11001310 111101121 11111110111111 5,4 11113111.
`py6110f1 113119111301. 0110110 31131101131103 p0001117101<11x 061110013.
`(Da1<1 11331111111 011e,110130H1131M11 0pra11aM11 yt1p0,1111101131131x 1101<yM011103 11
`1101131011 061110013 4 11101111 2007 11 0q10pM11011110 01101103 1cy111111-11p011a:;1c11 110110171
`,11a101’1 31 11101111 2007 101121 110330111111 Bpay110py VII). 110,111cp0111111. 03010 3011012110 0
`111301110 y
`<<H01111itag0 Capital» p0001117101<1«1x 061110013,
`11y61111r1H0
`30113113 0
`r1p1111a011100111 K 3101/1y 001py1111111co3 11pa300Xpa1111101131131X 0pra1103.
`O 1011, 1110 1110101 11331111151 11 11110110111111 001jpy11111«I1<a1v111 I1pa30oxpa.111110111.1131:x
`0pra1103
`1101011103103
`11
`110t1a101‘1
`«P1111311,11»,
`«Maxa011»,
`«IIap:1101111011>>
`110110111.303a11011 3 111110p00ax Bpayzzepa VII). JIIrIIIaMPI 113 6111111<a1?i1110r0 01<py11<0111151,
`11011130p>1c11a11 11 Mar1111101c11171 C.JI. 3 0301111 1101ca3aH11s1X.
`Ey11yt111 11011p01110H111.11v1
`110 y101103110My 11011y 3 011101110111111 011303310
`Xa1‘:’1p011111H03a 3.M., Mar1111101<111>’1 CJI. 3 1110110 2008 10110 11011332111, T110
`01101103010111. I{ap1103 FLA. 01110 3 110116110-1101»:0.6p0 2007 10113 10103 63111 30p11y11.
`110110111 11 1101cy1v101111.1
`<<P1«1113111:>>, «Maxa011>>, «IIap11101111011», 113331310 3 110,110
`06310101 4 11101111 2007 10113, 01111330 K1101>’1110p BI. 11 ‘{0p1ca003 I/I.C. 11p001111’11
`11011y11aT3. 11x 110 1010 M0M0111a, 110143 011011013110 110 3036y1rg11___y101103H00--
`051111500
`1111 11:0 30113110111110 0 1cpa>I<0 y rpy111131 Bpay110pa VID. p0:0pIII7IGKH10t1c0i
`
`!‘°‘
`11 3.,‘
`
`"‘
`
`

`
`E=;
`:2‘.
`
`
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 10 of 27
`‘
`Iled ll/18/15 Pa99 10 Of 27
`'
`-
`.G Document 420 6
`F‘
`
`.r'
`
`.‘
`»-1
`"fix:
`
`IIo3;1;Hee eiyam-Haxovkneflna y cnenersus ytxpemnrenbrllt-.1X JIOKYMBHTOB H
`neqarefi <<PIdJI3H,T_[)), «Maxaol-1», <<Hapd3eH1»1oH» rpynnofi Bpaynepa. V.CD. 6y;1eT
`I»1C1‘IOJI}330BaTIaO5{ Kalfi exumereennoe 06OCHOBaHI:1B npmiacwaocm co1:py;J1Hm<oe
`npaeooxpafimenmslx opranoe K 5112406131
`coBep1I1eHHoi»’I KPEDKG y (<1-Iermitage
`Capital» poccnfiemaxo6m;ecTB P1nocnenoeasmemy3aammXIIIIIBHHTEO 6I0}1}KE!TH’.f:IX
`openers.OTcyTcTB1»1e xmn;eH1«15I pooc "
`
`Tpe6oBaHm1M11,
`y1IpaBJ1eI-IPIH Han po
`ap6HTpa}KHL1X gxen Jmua, KOHTP
`H11 B 0I[HOM H3 emx
`SRCD.
`(1<oM11aHH;rM1«1 «I-Iermitage Capital»), He 3a.s1B:r15mI»1,
`calemcn, no KOT0pBIM czsatxaaia.31.07.2007 BJIRIEBJIBLIBMo6mecu:B crrano «IIJ1y'1:oH», a
`3a'reM c 08.02.2008 ~ KOM1‘IaI-II/I51 «Boily Systems», H ‘1T0 )]',0B6pBI-IHOCTB, no
`Koropofx 651211»: 3flKJIIO‘IeHI:I enenm, HMH He Bsmaeanaos.
`EIEHHCTBBHHBIM OCHOBBHIIBM mm cynefinoro Bosspanra
`}1BJI5FIJIOCI> I-I6El1IOCTPIJII’Ip0BaHI/IE7 ILOBBPBH
`noeamcs B ap6I«1Tpa31<H51x
`B 0133314 0 o1:Ka3aMI.»I or
`
`EM 100 % pxonefa
`HOC-TH Ha Tacafioea
`
`My paeoMoTpeHHoMy no cymecrey J18-JIY o Ilpaeax Ha JZLOIIH
`memos.
`nepa VII). 0'1:
`<<IIapcpeH1»1oH», no 1<o'ropoMy ICOMIIHHI/III Epay
`Ho e;:;1»1HcTBeHHo
`aTeI1LHo B Mae 2011
`<<PymeH3J;>>, «Maxaon»,
`ucxa He otmcasanncs, eyn eHat1aJ1a B 2010 roguy, a 3atreM osofltx
`rona yeTaHoB1~1J1, rrro nepexon upae H6. poccuficsue 06II.EBCTBa OT KI«IIIpCK1/Di
`KoMnaH1»fiE1 «Kone Holdings» H «Glendora Holdings» K <<1'IJ1yToH», a 3aTeM OT
`<<IIJ1yToH»
`K
`1coMI1aHI»1I»I
`«Boily Systems»
`oeyn1ee'r1aJ1eH 13
`pesyslyrare
`Bonensmenenns
`IcoM1IaHm“~I
`«Kone Holdings»
`121
`«Glendora Holdings»,
`B1E:Ipa3I{BHHOI‘0 HMH B JIOBBPBHHOGTI/I
`ow: 02.07.2007, Bs1;[aHHoI‘/1 rpayiolannny
`I‘acaHoBy O.F., 3a.1o11o11m3n1eMy cneancn re Ex mrrepecax 1»: no I/IX uopyqenmo.
`Heanoernmponafine me :1oBepeHHoeT1»1 Ha Faeaflosa OI‘, IIOJICDKBHHOB B
`ocHoByKGKOBBIXTpe6oB
`naH1~11‘3«KoneHoldings»I/I«GlendoraHoldings»,
`name npnHannrum11p1»13HaH1»1sL1«1o1<a co croponrsx OTBBT‘-IIEIICB. (xouetmoro Bnaneneua
`guonefi - Komnanmx «Boily Systems»), syn; He npusflan HapyI11eHHeM Tpe6oBa1m17I
`M631C)1yHap0J3',HOI‘0 1»: poccnfiesoro sanonoxnarenscrsa, 14 noosonmcy sassnennfi o
`1rIHo1‘»'I nomemm ,11oBepeHHoeT1»1 I«IeTuaM1«I He easnansmoos, a
`I/IHE-IX ,ILOB0;J1()B o HeynoJ1HoMoI1eHHocTrI Faeanoea 0.1". He
`I[pIriB0,I[IrIJIOCB,
`nocTaHoBJ1eH1«IeM lleesrroro ap61~ITpa>I<Horo a1'IeI1JI$iI_‘LI/IOHHOI‘0 cyna or 31 Max 2011
`rozga. no ;1eJ1y N9. A41-8992/09 B PICKS 651110 oT1<a3aHo. 2IaHHL11‘»’1 ey;u;e6HLII7I am:
`OCTaBJIBI-I 6e3 HSMBHBHIIH BOBMH OY,I(66HB1MPI 1«1HcTaI-11m;IM1rI, BIIJIOTI: no Bmomero
`Ap6mpa>1<Horo Cyna PCD.
`oomecrte
`Qasmqecxu,
`ILOJIII
`
`HassleEIBMBIC IIpaB1»1TeJ1LcTBoM CHJA <<1copnopaT1«1B
`He TOJIBKO He 651311»: 11OXHI11;BHI:I'.~.-
`«I-Ierm'1tage Cap'1ta1»,
`
`<<I1apt1)e}1_1.»1oH»,
`f’
`
`axmfi KOM
`
`t1>aJ1I:c21®1I1<aum1 mm
`
`

`
`3
`
`
`
`
`
` Eig
`
`.13
`
`I
`T
`
`‘
`
`Case 1:13-cv-06326-TPG Document 420-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 11 of 27
`Case 1:13-cv-O6326—TPG Document42'o " "
`-6 Filed 11/18/15 Page 11 0f27
`
`:’{=%‘i"_:€7)
`
`Capital», H0 H PIMH DKB 65131»: 1Iepeocbop1v,meHL1 CHElHaJIa Ha <<HJ1y'reH>>, a. 3aTeM Ha.
`«Boily Systems», OCTaBa5{CB Bee 3T0 Bpem non KOHTPOJIBM Bpayznepa VII).
`Bee Cy,I];e6HBIe ans: ap61»1'1:pa}I<HoI‘«i c1~Io1:eML1 ej/31013 Poccuficxofi CDe;1epaI11«I1»I
`pa3MemeHL1 Bmecrre e KapTo'reIco171 m31»1>KeHHs1 CO0TBBTCTBy}0IJIPIX zxen B 0TKpL1’I‘0M
`gxomzyne Ha 0(i)IrIU;IrIa}1LI-[OM eafrre BepXoBHoro Cygza Poccnficxoiix (I36J]',BpaI]‘,I/IIII
`(Www.kad.arbitr.1'u).
`4)
`,:[0B0)J;BI 0 TOM, E110 yI1acTH1«11c11<<opraH1i3a1m1«I>> — ‘-II/II-IOBI-IIIIQI E[aJIO1"0BBIX
`opranon yTBE>p,D;HJ1H Tpe50BaHH}I 0 B03BpELT6 Hasmra B TOT race JIGHB, 1cor;u;a
`OHH 6513111 IIOILBHBI,
`1»: qepes msa.
`111191 y‘-IaCTHHK3.M <<opraH1»13a111»11»I>> 651110
`Bmznnaqeno 230 MJIH. nomx. CIHA, He GO0TBeTC’I‘ByIOT )3;e1‘7rcTB11'reJILHocT1»1.
`I/I3 MaTep1«1aJ1oB one
`.17., MapKeJ1oB B.A. H
`JICTBPISI cnenyer, I110 XJIe6HHKoB B
`Kyp0‘{I<I/IH Bl-I. ofipawumcs B HaJI01"OBLIe op1*aH
`B1 c yToIIHeHHL1MH HaJ1o1“oB1e.1M1»1
`,Z[eKJIapaIlPIfiMH, I‘IO)11‘_OTOBJIeHHBIMI/I MarHH'rc1c1«1M C..TI., B oKTs£6pe—Ho>16pe 2007 I‘.,
`M Ha:IoroBL1M1»1 0pI‘B.HaMH 6513111 nppxnsma
`110JIO}‘£CH'I‘eJ1]':-I-[L16 p61II8I-IHSI 110 KOTOPBI
`TOJIBKO 26.12.2007.
`opm He 6e3;:e1‘»’IcT13oBaJ11»I, Karc 06
`B yKa3aHHL11‘«'1 nepnop; Hanorosue HHcne1cT
`3TOM 6e3ocHo13aTe31LHo yTB6p}K,I[a6TGSI B 1>1e1<e, a B COOTBBTCTBHI/I c HaJIoroBL1M
`ICOILGKCDM Poecn1‘»’1cI<I«1I‘7

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket