FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO' 190114/2013
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`Exhibit B
`
`

`

`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`
`
`
`
`INDEX NO- 190/114/2013
`-
`u
`o-
`o 11
`- 1
`u .
`INDEX NO. 190114 2013
`
`LEMEEMMIKQWW RECEIVED NYSCEE; 06/19/2017
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`292
`NCEE DOC. No.
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/28/2015
`
`,
`
`‘
`
`’E‘é‘ééjéfi} {ffikfifiw
`‘
`.>
`SAME gas:
`m4
`‘
`ififi‘é",
`
`wilEiEflfii’EiiiW amaom’;
`
`PROPOSED JUDGMENT
`
`index No: £9GE E4/2633
`
`Hon. Martin Shufmzm
`
`SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
`COUNTY OF NEW YORK
`= a a ~ . _ ~ w ~ a w fi . ~ n w a . u a u u n w — u u a u u . u — u v a . . a u r n A
`
`IN RE: NEW YORK CITY ASBESTOS LITEGATION
`. . . . . . 1 . w o , . . . 1 . . v o 1 . . . . v . . . . . . . . . . 1 . . . 0 . . x
`
`RALPH P. NORTB,
`
`Piaintiff,
`
`~ against —
`
`AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS CORPORATION
`successor by merger to Buffaio Pumps, loo;
`BAYER CORPORATION, Individuain and as
`SUCCCSfiOI‘ m interest to Ruoo Polymer Corporation;
`BW/IP, INC, as succosaoruinvintercst to
`
`Byron Jackson Pumps;
`CBS CQRPORATIQN,
`f/k/a Viacom, Inc; Successor by merger
`to CBS Corporation, {YR/a
`Westinghouse Eieotric Corporation;
`4- CENTRAL HUDSON GAS 8:, ELECTRIC CORPORATION;
`CERTAINuTEED CORPORA'I‘JON;
`CHEVRON USA. INC;
`CLEAVBR-BROOKS, INC. f/k/a
`Cleaver-Brooks, a division of Aqua»(3hom, foo;
`CONSOLIDATED EDISON C-OMFANY OF
`NEW YORK, NO;
`+ COURIER & COMPANY, INC;
`CRANE (20.;
`1* EASTERN REFRACTDRIBS COMPANY INC;
`BCR WTERNA‘TIONAL; INC;
`ENTERGY CORPORATEON;
`T BXFM, INQ
`f/k/a Fisohbaoh & Moore, Inca;
`FLOWSERVE CORPORATION successor in interest to
`
`Duramctallic Corporation;
`FOSTER WHEELER ENERGY CORR;
`GARDNER DENVER, INC;
`GENERAL ELECTRIC COM9ANY;
`GEORGiA-PACWIC, LLC;
`GOULDS PUB/1%, INCORPORATED;
`+ HATZEEL & BUEHLER, ENC;
`{00354503.DOCX;
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEF DOC. NO.’ 413 '
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO- 190114/2013
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`HOBART BROTHERS COWANY;
`IV’I'ONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL) INC.;
`fl’k/a Aiiigd Signal, 100., successor-in-imcrcsi
`to the Bandix Corporation;
`IMO H‘IDPUSTRIESj INC;
`INGBRSOLLvRAND COMPANY;
`KENNY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY;
`+ KE‘YSPAN ENERGY COR?ORAT£ON;
`4» KING INSUEATEON COM?ANY, INCL;
`"1* LIK. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC;
`4. MBTROPOLLTAN LIFE WSURANCE COMPANY;
`MONSANTO COMFANY;
`+ NATEONAL GRID;
`4» NATIONAL GRID GENERATION, LLC;
`1* NRC} ERMA, LLC;
`+ O’CONNOR, CONSTRUCTORS, INC;
`OCCIIJEN'I‘AL CHEMICAL CORPORATION, individually
`and as successor in interest to Hooker Chemicals
`
`5?; Piaszic Corporazion;
`+ PFIZER, INC;
`RILEY POWER INC;
`STERLING FLUID SYSTEMS (USA), LLC;
`'I‘RANE US, ENC;
`g» TREADWELL CORPORATION;
`UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION;
`WARREN PUMPS, LLC;
`WBIL»MCLAEN COMPANY;
`YARWAY CORPORATION;
`YORK INTERNATIONAL CORPORATEON;
`ZURN INDUSTRIES, LLC;
`
`Defandants.
`. x . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . k _ w . , . _ . w . . 0 . v W . v . . . , . . w . X
`
`WHEREAS i’iaintiff Ralph North, having milked and discontinued the actions agaénst
`CENTRAL IRIQSON OAS é’c ELECTREC, CHEVRON USA. ENG, FOSTER WHEELER
`ENERGY CORP., NRG REMA, LLC, O‘CONNOR, CONSTRUCTORS, ENC, OCCEDENTAL
`CHEMICAL CORPORATION, INDIVEDUALLY AND AS SUCCESSOR IN, INTEREST TO
`HOOKER. CHEMICALS $2 PLASTICS CORPORANON, and aiso having settled his claims
`against CBLOTEX ASBESTOS SETTLEMENT TRUST, EAGLEPECHER INDUSTRIES,
`INC. PERSONAL INJURY SETTLEMENT TRUST, FIBREBQARD ASBESTOS PERSONAL
`INIURY TRUST, {3-1 HOLDINGS lNC‘ ASBESTOS PERSONAL WfURY SETTLEMENT
`TRUST,
`JOHNS MANVTLLE PERSONAL INJURY SETTLEMENT TRUST, KEENE
`{60354503.DOCX5
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`2017 09:51 I
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NOu
`413
`v
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`CREDITORS TRUST, OWENS ILLINOIS, and US MINERAL PRODUCTS COMPANY
`ASBESTOS PERSONAL INJURY SETTLEMENT TRUST wish the aggregate sum of 3H
`settIcmcnI amounts paid, or recited to be paid,
`to Plaintiff being Pour Hundred Sixty-Six
`Thousanci, Eighty~Niuo, and 04100 1303in (3546698904);
`AND the Court having dismiosed PIaIntiffs’ actions against AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS
`CORPORATION, successor by merger to BuffizIo Pumps, Ina; BW/IP, INCL, as successor-Em
`interest to Byron Jackson Pump-s; CBS CQRI’GRATIQN,
`Viaoom, Ina; sucoossoz by
`merger to CBS Corporation,
`f/Ida Westinghouse EIoctric Corporation; CERTAINJEEID
`CORPORATION; CLEA’VER~SROOKS, INC, f/k/a CIeaver~B-rooks, a division of Aqua»€hom,
`1mm CONSOUDATED EDSON COMPANY OF NEW YORK,UW1;COURTER &
`COMPANY,
`INC; CRANE (3C).; EASTERN REFRACTORIES COMPANY INC; ECR
`INTERNATIONAL, INC; ENTERGY CORPORATION; EX~F’M, INC,
`fi’k/a Fischbach &
`Moore, Ina; FLOWSERVE CORPORATION successor in interest to Dummomiiic Corporation;
`GARBNERDENVERJNC;GBNERALELECTRKZCOM?RNY§GEORGBkPACWKLLLC;
`GOULDS PUMPS, INCORPORATED; HATZE‘L & BUEI-ILER, INC; HOBART BROTHERS
`COMPANY; HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC, f/k/a Aléiod Signai, Inc, suoccsoorwin-
`inmost
`to
`the Bondix Corporation;
`IMO INDUSTRIES,
`INC;
`II‘IGERSOLL-RAND
`CONWANY;
`KENNY”
`CONSTRUCTKfiI
`COMPANY;
`KEYSPAN
`ENERGY
`CORPORATION; KING INSULATION COMPANY, INC; L.K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY,
`INC; MONSANTO COMPANY; PFIZER, INC; RILEY POWER INC; STERLING FLUID
`SYQfififlS(USAL LLC;TRANE Ufi DKQ TREADWELL CORPORKUONgIfiflUN
`CARBIDE CORPORATION; WARREN PUMPS, LLC; WEIbMCLAIN COMPANY;
`YAKWAY CORPOKKHUN;YORK RWERNKHONAL CORPORKHON;3MIZURN
`INDUSTRIES, LLC upon Defenéants’ DIG—Opposition Summazy Judgment Motions and the
`partics’ stipulations to dissentinuance therefore;
`,
`
`AND tho actions against BAYER CORPORATION, Individuaiiy and as successoniw
`iniorest to Russ» Polymer Corporation and METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
`having been discontinued and/or abandoned due to the lack of identification of this defendants”
`
`products as a source ofpiaimiff's exposures and/or for other legal reasons;
`AND the
`triad of
`this
`action having proceeded against NATIONAL GRID
`GENERATION, LLC, before the Honorabyie Martin Shuiman, a Justice of mm Com, and a jury,
`at IAS‘ I’m I, at Room 325 of thia Court mm at the Courthouse thoreo‘f, at 60 Centre Streot, New
`Yorks New York, on or obou: September, II, 2014, and on certain dates and in proceedings
`occurring Ihrough September 29, 2034, arid Plaintiff, having duly apps:de by his attorneys,
`Lovy Konigsbcrg, LLP, and Maurie Raichio Har‘ficy French & Mudd, LLC, and NATIONAL
`GRID GENERATION, LLC, by its attorneys CuIIon & Dykman, LLP;
`AND Plaintiff’s action agaéngt NATIONAL GRID GENERATION, LLC, having been
`tried to a verdict rendered September 29, 20M,
`in favor of Piaintiff and against NATIONAL
`{msmmocm
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`GRID GENBRATION, LLC, and the jury having apportimncd one hundred percent {160%} of
`the fault to NATIONAL GRID GENERATlON, LLC;
`AND the jury havng Found NATIONAL GRLD GENERATION, LLC,
`with reckless digregard for the safety of others, pursuant to CPLR § 1602(7);
`AND the jury having rendered a. compensatory damage award in favor of Ralph North For
`his past pain and suffering in the amount of Three Million, Five Hundred Thousand and 00/ 100
`Dallas {$3,300,099} and his fumm pals: and suffering in
`animal 9:” “Elyse Mi’llien; Elva
`Hundmd Thousand and 00/ l 00 Dollars ($3,500,000);
`AND the Court, upon the post~trial motion of NATIONAL GRID GENERATION, LLC,
`far judgment notwithsmnding the verdict, fit in the alternative: for a new trial, or in the altsmativc.
`for remittimr of the verdict, havng denied said motion;
`
`to have acted
`
`0
`
`1”? i3 GRDEREEADEUBGED and DEGREE!) that, pursuant to 0.0L. § 15408, the
`net verdict be and is hereby reduced by Four Hundred Sixty~81x Thousand, Bighiy‘Nim and
`04/100 Dollars ($466,089.04)
`to Six Million, Five: Hundred filmy—"I‘le Thousand, Nine
`Hundred Ten and 96/100 Dollars ($6,533,910.96); and
`‘i’l‘
`1‘3 FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AN}? DECREED that costs and
`disbursements are laxeé in thf: sum of One Thousand, Three Hundred, Seven and 00/100 Dollaw
`($1,307), bringing the total 116$ verdict to Six Million, Five Hundred Tliirtwalve Thousand, TVs/0
`Hundred Sevantécn and 96/?00 Dnllars ($6,535,217.96) (Proposed Bill 0f Cosls attached as
`Exhibit A); and
`
`IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJU‘DGED and DECREED thatpost‘vardict interest
`(am said net verdict of Six Million, Fiva Hundred Thirty-Five Thousand, Ten and 96/100 Dallars
`$6,535,010.96» pursuant to CPLR §§ 5002 and 5004 is awarded at nine percen: (9%) per
`annum Simple interest in the. amount of
`_
`
`1%
`33 “if? “I {a
`~0‘ g
`, bringing the total award to
`., 72-?
`‘l 8 7 . D- ‘l
`Dollars; and
`IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUBGEB anti DEGREE!) that Plainiéff Ralph
`North, 4 Mangoun Rd, West Isl§p, New Yer}: 11795, has final juégmcnt against NATEONAL
`GRLD GBNERATIQN, LLC, E75 East Old Country Road, Hicksville, New York llSOl, if} said
`amount of
`
`£9.
`
`‘$ 9 a"? 3 l
`
`Z“? ‘fl 0*}!
`
`Dollars, and has execution maroon.
`
`Judgment Signedthis m dayof
`
`‘ UQL%V , @015
`
`FHMED
`
`ENTER:
`
`,
`
`_
`
`_
`
`JAN 2 8 29:3
`
` {06354593.
`
`
`
`COUNTY CLERK’S OFFlGE
`
`NEW YORK
`
`Mg
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEF DOC. NO: 413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`NO- 1&14/2013
`MWMW
`‘
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
`COUNTY OF NEW YORK
`. w . u . . . . ~ » a . . w » . ~ . . . . . . . w . w . . . . . . . . . . . . . -wx
`IN RENEW YORK CITY ASBESTOS LITTGATION
`.
`w . . . y . 0 . . . . . . . . . . u . ~ w . . . a . . . 1 . . . . . . . . . ~ w --x
`
`REQH 13‘ FORTH.
`
`~ against -
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`‘
`
`AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS CORPORATION
`successaf by mergfi i0 Buffaw Pumps, may: at El.
`
`Defendants.
`
`:
`
`2
`
`. . . . . . . . . .
`
`COSTS for:
`
`Enéax N520: 2%1 1412913
`
`'
`
`COSTS OF F’LAENT‘EFF
`
`Proceedings before Note of 153w: is fiiad ($200) w CPLR § 8281(1)
`Proceedings after Note of Issue: is 6100 ($200) w CPLR § 8201(2)
`Triai ($300) —~ CPLR § 8201(3)
`Inquest ($300) » CPLR § 8201(3)
`ASsessmcnt of damages ($300} —- CFLR § 820l(3)
`Additiunal aflowances in reaf property actions » CPLR § 8302(0), {13), (d)
`Motion (fixad by com, not exceeding $100) —~ CPLR § 8202
`Appcai to Appeiiatc Division ($250 unless couri awards £05332“ amount) —~ GE’LR § 8203
`Appcai from County Court to Appsllats Term m CPLR § 3203(a)
`Appcai to (3mm of Appeais ($500 uniess court awards “3536! amount) ~— CPLR § 8204
`Friveious claims and counterclaims in actiong 10 recovcr damages f0: personai injury,
`mqu to property or wrongful death (awarded by couré) ~ CPLR § 8303(a)
`
`$200
`$200
`$300
`
`SUBTOTAL:
`
`$709
`
`FEES AND DISBURSEMENTS for:WW
`
`Affidavim 031115, acknowkcdgmsms, Certification and cxempkificatiou - CPLR § 8009
`Index number of mum}! ciexkfi ~ CPLR § SOKS
`Filing note 0f issue/placing case on czfiendar ~ CPLR § 8020(a)
`
`$210
`$30
`
`*00354503‘DW
`
`
`
`va-
`E
`
`: HEREBY CERTWY THAT : HAVE
`ADJUSTED mg 53m 0?: cams AT
`1%.. w i7 :0...€i..£>w
`*‘
`
`
`
`W cam-:51:
`NJWE ngaw
`
`
`JAN 2 a 2335
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED NEW 10111; COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEE DOC. NO. 413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`I
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`,INDEX,N0. 190114/2013
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`$65
`
`Fiiing demand for jury triad CPLR § 8020(0)
`Stemgraphcrg - CE’LR §§ 8301 and 8002
`Witnesses -— CPLR §§ 8301(a)(1) and 8001
`Referees - CPLR §§ 8301630) and 8003
`Officers - CPLR § 8301(3XE)
`Commissioners taking dcpositimg (reasonabis compensation) ~ CPLR § 8301(a)(2)
`E‘ubéécaiien dirggtad pursuant t0 Law — CPLR §§ 83 ‘E(a){3) and 8007
`Certified 00p}! of a paper 060053.211”in Obtained for use on trial - CPLR § 8301(a){43
`Securing copiss- of opinions and chargesofjudges w CPLR § 8301(a){5)
`Priming papars for avhcaring (reasenable expenses) - CPLR§ 83010005)
`Entering and awake-ting the judgment (prospective charges) MCPILR §§ 83010300)
`and 80 NSC21X?)
`Sheriff‘s fees forwceiving and rctumirtg order 0f attachmcnt - C?“ R §§ 86‘: 1(3)
`and SOiZ
`Sheriff‘s fees for receiving and returning one execution w CPLR §§ 8301(a)(8)
`and 80“ (a), (‘0'), (C) 300 (d) and/8012
`Taking, and making two transcripts of testimony on an Examination Befom Triai
`(not acceding $250 in any action) w CPLR § 830103303)
`Searches manic by title insurance companies - CPLR § 830 E (3X1 0)
`Searches made by abstract companies ~ CPLR §,830‘1{a)(§ 0)
`Searches made by searching companies ~ CP‘LR § 8301(a)(10)
`Search-es made by a, public officm autberized'to make officiai search“ and certify t0
`the same ~ CPLR § 8301(3X10)
`Searches made by attorney for party t0 whom costs are awarded (not exceeding cast
`of” simiiar official searches) v CPLR § 83010000)
`Securing an undertaking to stay enforcamcm of a judgment subsequentiy reversed
`{reasonable expanses actuafiy incurred) ~ CPLR §y830yi{a)(i 1)
`Other (reasonabic and necassary expenses awarding to course and practice of court,
`by cxpmss provision of law or by court ordar) ~ CPLR § 8301(am2)
`Postage - CPLR § 838$(a)(12)
`Appeai to Court of Appeais (ci'erk’s flies) ~ CPLR § 8301(ax‘12)
`Motion (reasonabia and necessary expenses awarded upon motion of party or Upon
`{mum’s own infitiative}
`Party not awarded costs in an action er an appeal or in an action for a sum of monay
`where party recovers at least $50 - CPLR § 8301(0)
`Service pcrfomcd, other than a search {masmabie sum actuafiy anti necessariiy
`expended if iris usua’: charge made by private persons) ~ CPLR § 830%)
`Serving summons and complaint or summons with notice ~ CPLR §§ 830i(d)
`
`{0035450343009
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK, COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 A
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`L
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`‘
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`and 80H
`Serving subyocna ~ CPLR §§ 8301(é) and 80k 101)
`Request for Juciicial Inigrvantion
`
`’
`
`$207
`$95
`
`$607
`
`$1307
`
`SUBTOTAL
`
`TOTAL
`
`{0035451)}.DOCX)
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 062017 09:51 ‘
`NYSCEF DOC. N I
`o
`413
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`INDEX NO- 190114/2013
`’
`'
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`ATTORNEYS AFFilWATION
`
`55:
`
`) )
`
`)
`
`State of‘N‘ew York
`
`County of New York
`
`The undersigned Jarome Block, an atmmey duiy admitted to practice kaw in thfi courts of
`the: State of New York, hereby affirms the fofiawirzg unfier penalty 0:” perjury:
`E am wunsei with
`Law Konigsberg, LLP, attorneys for 'Piaintiff, and-as such, am fully famiiiar with the facts and
`circumstances of the above~¢apiioned actien; ma: thefcregoing casts are (correct and were
`necessarily incurred in this action and am reasonable in maxim; and that {he services for which
`fees have been charged were actualiy and necessariiy performed and are reasonable in amount.
`
`Dated:
`
`January 26, 20 i 5
`Mew Yerk, New York
`
`Attorneys for Plaintiff
`800 Third Avenue, 11‘“ Fiaor
`New York, New York 1002?.
`T:
`212605-6200
`F:
`212-605~6290
`Mock 16v lawcom
`
`
`
`{00354503.DOCX}
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/19/2017 09:51 AM
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 413
`1; é »
`3.x
`
`:5
`“flex
`
`INDEX NO. 190114/2013
`V190114/2013
`
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/19/2017
`
`3a
`
`9‘3
`
`$ .mmr‘éfifikd‘ifii’i).
`
`,»$waon:u9g
`
`>3,;5;},yyak».
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`..W
`
`
`
`a,awgfiaffiécxx._1,.,.,N.a.VAWFasuDfiknfi,,..,,V,,_,z,.,.3g.
`
`
`
`
`
`yi:.,.,.,.,fax?,17fi‘,,_“«yttrefigw»
`
`é\T
`
`V.x»:._x_
`
`gt
`
`é»?
`
`,an,wmxii
`
`’3,
`
`»«fpfik
`
`i7%.
`
`mszvmyh
`
`*
`
`w a
`«aye/«13v»«w
`
`1&1
`“x
`m»
`x? U “
`Wmawwwawwmmww '
`
`