`
`UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`EASTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA
`
`
`
`THE CHICKASAW NATION,
`
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`
`v.
`
`
`1. CVS CAREMARK, LLC;
`2. CAREMARK PHC, LLC;
`3. CAREMARK PCS HEALTH, LLC;
`4. CAREMARK, LLC;
`5. CAREMARK RX, LLC;
`6. AETNA, INC.;
`7. AETNA HEALTH, INC.;
`8. OPTUMRX, INC.;
`9. OPTUM, INC.;
`10. UNITED HEALTHCARE SERVICES,
`INC.; and
`11. UNITEDHEALTH GROUP, INC.
`
`Case No. 6:20-cv-00488-PRW
`
`
`
`
`Defendants.
`
`PLAINTIFF’S CONSOLIDATED RESPONSE TO
`DEFENDANTS’ NOTICES OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (ECF NOS. 105, 106)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`6:20-cv-00488-PRW Document 107 Filed in ED/OK on 07/12/21 Page 2 of 6
`
`Plaintiff, the Chickasaw Nation (the “Nation”), hereby submits the following Consolidated
`
`Response to Defendants’ Notices of Supplemental Authority (ECF Nos. 105 and 106)
`
`(collectively, the “Notices”).1 For the reasons herein, as well as those set forth in the Nation’s prior
`
`briefing (ECF Nos. 81, 82, 99, 100, and 104), the Nation respectfully requests this Court disregard
`
`the Notices, grant the Nation’s Cross-Motion, and deny Defendants’ Motions.
`
`ARGUMENT
`
`In reaching its decision—which the Nation intends to appeal—the Arizona Court wrongly
`
`assumed its own conclusion: that the parties entered into a clear and binding arbitration agreement
`
`(they did not). As the Arizona Court acknowledges, arbitration is a matter of contract and “depends
`
`upon whether the parties agreed to arbitrate that dispute.” Order at 3 (citation omitted). In
`
`concluding the delegation clause vested arbitrators with the power to decide whether the parties
`
`agreed to arbitration, the Order simply assumes there was a valid arbitration agreement in the first
`
`place, and hence a valid delegation clause. But there was no such agreement and no valid
`
`delegation clause.
`
`The Arizona Court ignored the fact that the Nation’s pharmacies never signed any
`
`document with any Caremark entity that actually contained an arbitration provision (much less a
`
`delegation clause). Nor did the Arizona Court even cite, much less discuss, the only Supreme Court
`
`decision involving agreements to arbitrate by Native American tribes, C & L Enterprises, Inc. v.
`
`
`1 As used herein: (i) “Defendants” collectively refers to CVS Caremark, LLC; Caremark PHC,
`LLC; CaremarkPCS Health, LLC; Caremark RX, LLC; Aetna, Inc.; Aetna Health, Inc.; OptumRx,
`Inc.; Optum, Inc.; United Healthcare Services, Inc.; and UnitedHealth Group, Inc.; (ii) the
`“Motions” collectively refers to the Caremark/Aetna Defendants’ Motion to Stay (ECF No. 61)
`and the Optum/United Health Defendants’ Motion to Stay (ECF No. 59); (iii) the “Cross-Motion”
`refers to the Nation’s Cross-Motion for an Order or Declaratory Relief that its Claims are not
`Subject to Arbitration (ECF No. 82); (iv) the “Arizona Court” refers to the District of Arizona
`referenced in Defendants’ Notices; and (v) the “Order” refers to the Arizona Court’s Order
`Compelling Arbitration (ECF No. 105-1).
`
`
`
`1
`
`

