Kevin B. Laurence
`
`5 F
`
`rom:
`Sent:
`To:
`
`Greg H. Gardella
`Friday, April 11, 2014 1:13 PM
`Rosato, Michael
`
`Cc:
`
`Subject:
`Attachments:
`
`Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer; Dianna DeVore
`(DDeVore@ariosadx.com); Sarah (Sally) Brashears (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com); anaini@raklaw.com
`RE: deposition in IPR2013—00276/277
`RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`As shown in the attached email, we offered two dates: April 9th and 17th. We contacted you on April 15‘, even before
`we filed our reply, to offer you the opportunity to depose our declarant on these dates. Since then we reached out to
`you several additional times in an effort to elicit an answer to whether you intended to proceed with the deposition. At
`this juncture — six days prior to the second of the offered dates — you have still not confirmed whether you intend to
`proceed, sent out the required deposition notice, or proposed alternative dates. The rules require 10 days notice and
`we, as an accommodation, allowed you until noon six days prior to the offered date. Having received no deposition
`notice, confirmation or counterproposal, Dr. Morton is no longer being offered for deposition on the 17th.
`
`Greg H. Gardella | Oblon Spivak LLP | Direct: 703—412-6396 l Cellular: 703—470—5522 | Admitted in MN, lL and USPTO only
`
`From: Rosato, Michael [mailto:mrosato@wsgr.com]
`Sent: Friday, April 11, 2014 11:41 AM
`To: Greg H. Gardella
`Cc: Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer; Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com); Sarah (Sally)
`Brashears (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com); anaini@raklaw.com
`Subject: Re: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Greg,
`
`You've offered one date.
`a legitimate offer.
`
`I don't consider the day extended before you even filed your briefing, then quickly withdrawn
`
`If it is necessary for your planning you can plan for deposition on the 17th and we will promptly notify you upon
`confirming on our end. Alternatively, you can explore other dates of availability with you reply witness to provide some
`reasonable degree of flexibility.
`
`— Mike
`
`On Apr 11, 2014, at 7:34 AM, "Greg H. Gardella" <GGardella@_oblon.com> wrote:
`
`Patent Owner has been offered two dates on which it could depose Dr. Morton and has had over a week
`to decide whether it will take Dr. Morton’s deposition.
`Patent Owner must provide reasonable advance notice of its intent to take Dr. Morton’s deposition and
`today is just four business days prior to the offered date. Dr. Morton and the rest of our team will hold
`open the offered date only until noon Eastern today.
`
`For a conference with the Board, we could do Tuesday at 1:00 or 3:00 Eastern.
`
`1
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 1
`|PR2013-00277
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 1
`IPR2013-00277
`
`

`

`Greg H. Gardella l Oblon Spivak LLP l Direct: 703—412-6396 [ Cellular: 70341705522 | Admitted in MN, IL and
`USPTO only
`
`From: Rosato, Michael [mailto:mrosato@wsgr.com]
`Sent: Friday, April 11, 2014 9:55 AM
`To: Greg H. Gardella; Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: 'Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com)'; 'Sarah (Sally) Brashears
`(sbrashears@_convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)'; anaini@raklaw.com
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Greg,
`
`Thank you. We have not made a decision, and that timing deadline doesn’t work for us. We will keep
`you apprised of any decision.
`
`Also, please let me know times of availability for a conference call with the Board on Tuesday or Wed of
`next week. We will be requesting authorization for a motion to strike Dr. Morton’s reply declarations
`and the newly introduced material as, inter alia, untimely attempts to cure the deficiencies in the prima
`facie obviousness case that were noted in our opposition as missing from the petition materials.
`
`Best regards,
`
`— Mike
`
`From: Greg H. Gardella [mailto:GGardeila@oblon.com]
`Sent: Thursday, April 10, 2014 7:47 AM
`To: Rosato, Michael; Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: 'Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com)'; 'Sarah (Sally) Brashears
`
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)’; anaini@raklaw.com
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Mike -— As a courtesy, we will hold the date open until noon Eastern tomorrow. Kindly advise before
`that time whether you intend to proceed.
`
`Greg H. Gardella I Oblon Spivak LLP | Direct: 703-412—6396 l Cellular: 703—470—5522 l Admitted in MN, IL and
`USPTO only
`
`From: Rosato, Michael lmailto:mrosato@wsgr.coml
`Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2014 7:38 PM
`To: Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: 'Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@_ariosadx.com)'; 'Sarah (Sally) Brashears
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)'; Greg H. Gardella;
`anaini
`raklaw.com
`
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Kevin,
`
`Thank you for following up. We have not made a decision regarding Dr. Morton’s deposition, as we are
`still making our way through materials to some extent. At this point, we should keep the date
`reserved.
`i understand the 10 day notice is coming up tomorrow, but we are ok with filing the
`deposition notice within the 10 day period if necessary.
`
`2
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 2
`IPR2013-00277
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 2
`IPR2013-00277
`
`

`

`Thanks,
`
`- Mike
`
`From: Kevin B. Laurence [mailtozKLaurence@oblon.com]
`Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2014 1:44 PM
`To: Rosato, Michael; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: 'Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com)'; 'Sarah (Sally) Brashears
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)'; Greg H. Gardella;
`anaini@raklaw.com
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Mike,
`
`I don’t think that we have heard from you regarding the scheduling of Dr. Morton’s deposition. Please
`let us know by 12:00 PST tomorrow whether you plan to depose Dr. Morton on April 17.
`
`Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Oblon Spivak i 1940 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314 1 General: 703—413—3000 | Direct: 703-413-
`6561 1 Cellular: 801—598-6262 i klaurence@oblon.com i www.0blon.com
`
`From: Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Sent: Friday, April 04, 2014 9:12 AM
`To: 'Rosato, Michael'; 'Skubatch, Maya'; 'Smolen, Jennifer'
`Cc: 'Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com)'; 'Sarah (Sally) Brashears
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com) (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)'; Greg H. Gardella
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Mike,
`
`Dr. Morton indicated that she is still available on April 17. She is no longer available on April 9 but is
`available on April 8.
`
`Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Oblon Spivak l 1940 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314 i General: 703-413—3000 I Direct: 703-413-
`6561 | Cellular: 801—598-6262 I klaurence@oblon.com l www.0blon.com
`
`From: Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Sent: Thursday, April 03, 2014 4:31 PM
`To: 'Rosato, Michael‘; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com); Sarah (Sally) Brashears (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com); Greg H. Gardella; Naini, Amir (ANaini@irell.com)
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Mike,
`
`0k. The declarant is Dr. Morton.
`
`Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Oblon Spivak l 1940 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314 I General: 703-413—3000 l Direct: 703-413—
`6561 | Cellular: 801-598-6262 1 klaurence@oblon.com l www.0blon.com
`
`3
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 3
`IPR2013-00277
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 3
`IPR2013-00277
`
`

`

`From: Rosato, Michael [mailto:mrosato@wsgr.com]
`Sent: Tuesday, April 01, 2014 7:15 PM
`To: Kevin B. Laurence; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com); Sarah (Sally) Brashears (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)
`(sbrashears@_convergentlaw.com); Greg H. Gardella; Naini, Amir (ANaini@irel|.com)
`Subject: RE: deposition in IPR2013-00276/277
`
`Kevin,
`
`Thank you for trying to get out ahead of this issue. Without knowing the source and content of the
`testimony, we can’t say whether cross is appropriate. We will review your papers upon filing and follow
`up as needed.
`
`Thanks,
`
`— Mike
`
`From: Kevin B. Laurence [mailto:KLaurence@oblon.com]
`Sent: Tuesday, April 01, 2014 11:11 AM
`To: Rosato, Michael; Skubatch, Maya; Smolen, Jennifer
`Cc: Dianna DeVore (DDeVore@ariosadx.com); Sarah (Sally) Brashears (sbrashears@convergentlaw.com)
`(sbrashears@convergentlaw.com); Greg H. Gardella; Naini, Amir (ANaini@irell.com)
`Subject: deposition in IPR2013—00276/277
`
`Mike,
`
`When we file our reply, it will be accompanied by a declaration. The declarant will be available on April
`9 or 17 at our office in Alexandria. Please let me know which date works best.
`
`Kevin B. Laurence
`
`Oblon Spivak l 1940 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314 I General: 703413—3000 1 Direct: 703-413«
`6561 I Cellular: 801-598-6262 l klaurence@_oblon.com l www.0blon.com
`
`This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential
`and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is
`prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact Oblon, Spivak by reply email and
`destroy all copies of the original message. If you are the intended recipient, please be advised
`that the content of this message is subject to access, review and disclosure by the sender's Email
`System Administrator.
`
`This email and any attachments thereto may contain private, confidential, and privileged material
`for the sole use of the intended recipient. Any review, copying, or distribution of this email (or
`any attachments thereto) by others is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,
`please contact the sender immediately and permanently delete the original and any copies of this
`email and any attachments thereto.
`
`4
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 4
`IPR2013-00277
`
`Ariosa Exhibit 1047, pg. 4
`IPR2013-00277
`
`