IPR2017-01495, -01538 U.S. Patent No. 7,928,348
`
`’348 Patent
`
`Ex. 1001
`
`’348 patent, Ex. 1001
`
`1
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`’348 Patent
`
`Ex. 1001
`
`’348 patent, Ex. 1001
`
`1
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IPR2017-01495, -01538 Claims 24-27 Instituted
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`2
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IPR2017-01495, -01538 U.S. Patent No. 7,928,348
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over:
`
`• Bramm, Watterson – Slides 4-14
`• Zimmermann, Stephan, Neal ’554 – Slides 15-26
`• Gould, Neal ’554 – Slides 27-43
`• Umeda, Raible, Neal ’554 – Slides 44-57
`• Umeda, Stephan – Slides 58-61
`• Konishi – Slides 62-71
`
`3
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over Bramm And Watterson
`
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`Magnet
`
`Conductor
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 18-19, 48-53; -01538 Paper 30, 19-25; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 66-71, 169-191
`
`4
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 2
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Bramm Discloses
`Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 18, 59-71
`
`5
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm Discloses “A Magnetically Inducible Core”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 49; -01538 Paper 30, 19-20; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶ 171
`
`6
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm Discloses A Magnetically-inducible Core
`
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`Magnet
`
`Conductor
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 2
`Garris Deposition
`21
`figures
`2
`and
`at
`Bramm
`Q. So
`magnetically inducible core, correct?
`A. Yes.
`
`depicts
`
`a
`
`-01538 Ex. 1016, 49:16-18
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 49; -01538 Paper 30, 19-20; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶ 171; -01538 Ex. 1016, 49:16-18
`
`7
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm, As Modified, Discloses “A Monolithic
`Body Of Injection Molded Thermoplastic Material”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 49-51; -01538 Paper 30, 20-22; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 172-180
`
`8
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`It Would Have Been Obvious To Use Injection-molded Thermoplastic
`As Bramm’s Plastic, Particularly Based On Watterson
`
`Plastics
`
`Injection Molded
`Thermoplastics
`Watterson teaches using injection molded
`thermoplastics for blood pumps
`
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`Magnet
`
`Conductor
`
`-01538 Ex. 1009 (Watterson), 10:25-32
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 2
`-01538 Paper 1, 49-51; -01538 Paper 30, 20-22; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 172-180
`
`9
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm’s Fluid Pathway Is “Confined Within The Body”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 52; -01538 Paper 30, 22-24; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶ 183
`
`10
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm’s Fluid Pathway Is
`Confined Within The Monolithic Body
`
`Outlet
`
`Inlet
`
`Inlet
`
`Body
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 52; -01538 Paper 30, 22-24; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶ 183
`
`11
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm Discloses Or At Least
`Renders Obvious “Plumbing Fittings”
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 53; -01538 Paper 30, 24-25; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 186-191
`
`12
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Inlet
`
`Bramm Discloses A Fluid Inlet Or Outlet Formed In The Body
`Of Thermoplastic That Is In The Form Of A Plumbing Fitting
`
`Outlet
`
`Trumper Deposition
`A. . . . if you look at the
`[Bramm]
`reference,
`you
`can see fittings on the
`inlet and outlet . . .
`-01538 Ex. 2007, 28:16-20
`
`Inlet
`
`Body
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 53; -01538 Paper 30, 24-25; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 186-191; -01538 Ex. 2007, 28:16-20
`
`13
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Bramm Renders Obvious A Fluid Inlet Or Outlet Formed In The Body Of
`Thermoplastic That Is In The Form Of A Plumbing Fitting
`
`Outlet
`
`Inlet
`
`Inlet
`
`Body
`
`-01538 Ex. 1008, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 53; -01538 Paper 30, 24-25; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 186-191
`
`14
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over
`Zimmermann, Stephan, And Neal ’554
`
`Cooling Coil
`
`Core
`
`Resin
`
`Conductor
`
`-01495 Ex. 1103, Fig. 7
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 19-23, 27-42; -01495 Paper 25, 4-15; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 50-57, 60-100
`
`15
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Zimmermann In View Of Stephan and
`Neal ’554 Discloses Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01495 Paper 19, 32-46
`
`16
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Zimmermann, As Modified, Renders Obvious
`Using “Injection Molded Thermoplastic Material”
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 31-34; -01495 Paper 25, 4-11; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 71-80
`
`17
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`It Would Have Been Obvious To Use Injection
`Molded Thermoplastic In View Of Stephan
`
`Casted Epoxy
`Injection Molded
`Thermoplastics
`
`Stephan teaches using injection molded
`thermoplastics is preferred to encapsulate
`conductors in motors
`
`-01495 Ex. 1109, [0039]
`
`-01495 Ex. 1109, [0041]
`
`-01495 Ex. 1109, [0008], [0039], [0041]; -01495 Paper 7, 31-34; -01495 Paper 25, 4-11; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 71-80
`
`18
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Neal ’554 Discloses The Benefits Of
`Using Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Epoxy
`
`Thermoplastics
`
`Neal ’554 teaches that
`thermoplastic is preferable
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 5:40-44
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 6:26-34
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 1:62-2:2, 4:67-5:22, 5:27-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30,
`17:53-58, 18:4-10, 21:24-46; -01495 Paper 7, 31-34; -01495 Paper 25, 4-11; Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 71-80
`
`19
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Neal ’554 Discloses The Benefits Of
`Using Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Casting
`
`Injection Molding
`
`Neal ’554 teaches that injection
`molding is preferable
`
`Dr. Trumper and Dr. Garris
`agree that injection molding
`provides cost benefits for high
`production processes
`-01495 Ex. 2007, 38:13-39:3; -01495 Ex. 1138, 33:11-39
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 1:62-2:2, 4:67-5:22, 5:27-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30,
`17:53-58, 18:4-10, 21:24-46; -01495 Paper 7, 31-34; -01495 Paper 25, 4-11; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 71-80
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 21:24-46
`
`20
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Zimmermann and Neal ’554 Disclose the
`Same Requirements for the Monolithic Body
`
`Epoxy Casting
`
`Thermoplastic
`Injection Molding
`
`Important
`Material
`Properties
`
`High Thermal Conductivity
`Sealing Internal Components
`
`Zimmermann
`
`Neal ’554
`
`-01495 Ex. 1103, 4:33-38
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 6:26-28
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 18:2-7
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 1:62-2:2, 4:67-5:22, 5:27-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30, 17:53-58, 18:4-
`10, 21:24-46; -01495 Ex. 1103, 4:33-38; -01495 Paper 7, 31-34; -01495 Paper 25, 4-11; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 71-80
`
`21
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Alleged “Thick” Portions Do Not Prevent Forming
`Zimmermann’s Sheath From Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Regions of
`thick epoxy
`
`Coil/Stator
`
`First
`Housing Half
`
`IV’s Annotated Fig. 6 of
`Zimmermann (-01495 Ex. 1103)
`
`Rotor
`
`Second
`Housing Half
`
`Regions of thick
`thermoplastic
`Annotated Fig. 2 of
`Stephan (-01495 Ex. 1109)
`
`-01495 Paper 25, 8-11
`
`22
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Alleged “Thick” Portions Do Not Prevent Forming
`Zimmermann’s Sheath From Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Heat Sink Inserts
`
`Windings
`
`Regions of
`thick epoxy
`
`IV’s Annotated Fig. 6 of
`Zimmermann (-01495 Ex. 1103)
`
`Regions of thick
`thermoplastic
`
`Monolithic Body
`
`Core
`Annotated Fig. 7 of
`Neal ’554 (-01495 Ex. 1104)
`
`-01495 Paper 25, 8-11
`
`23
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Alleged “Thick” Portions Do Not Prevent Forming
`Zimmermann’s Sheath From Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Heat Pipe Inserts
`
`Windings
`
`Regions of
`thick epoxy
`
`Regions of thick
`thermoplastic
`
`Monolithic Body
`
`Core
`
`IV’s Annotated Fig. 6 of
`Zimmermann (-01495 Ex. 1103)
`
`Annotated Fig. 7 of
`the ’348 Patent (-01495 Ex. 1001)
`
`-01495 Paper 25, 8-11
`
`24
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Zimmermann, As Modified, Renders Obvious
`An Inlet And An Outlet “Formed In” The Body
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 36-37; -01495 Paper 25, 11-15; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 84-86
`
`25
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Zimmermann, As Modified, Renders Obvious
`An Inlet And An Outlet “Formed In” The Body
`
`Cooling Coil
`
`Core
`
`Inlet
`
`Resin
`
`Coil/Core
`
`First
`Housing Half
`
`Conductor
`
`-01495 Ex. 1103, Fig. 7
`
`Rotor
`
`Second
`Housing Half
`
`Outlet
`-01495 Ex. 1109, Fig. 2
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 8, 20, 23, 36-37; -01495 Paper 25, 11-15; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 54, 56, 84-86
`
`26
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over Gould And Neal ’554
`
`Fluid Pathway
`
`Inlet
`
`Lower Housing
`
`Upper Housing
`
`Rubber Conduit
`
`Outlet
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 24-29, 41-56; -01495 Paper 25, 15-27; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 58-62, 101-132
`
`27
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Gould In View Of Neal ’554 Discloses
`Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01495 Paper 19, 46-56
`
`28
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould Discloses “Substantially
`Encapsulating At Least One Conductor”
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 46-49; -01495 Paper 25, 15-18; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 108-115
`
`29
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould Discloses “Substantially
`Encapsulating At Least One Conductor”
`
`Core
`
`Lower Housing
`
`Windings
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 46-49; -01495 Paper 25, 15-18; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 108-115
`
`30
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, 2:43-46
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould, As Modified By Neal ’554, Discloses “Substantially
`Encapsulating At Least One Conductor”
`Patent Owner does not dispute that it would be obvious to modify Gould’s lower
`housing 12 to be molded using injection molding based on the teaching of Neal ’554
`Heat Sink Inserts
`
`Windings
`
`Monolithic Body
`
`Core
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, Fig. 7
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 1:62-2:2, 3:43-51, 4:67-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30, 17:53-
`58, 18:4-10, 21:24-46; -01495 Paper 7, 46-49; -01495 Paper 25, 15-18; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 108-115
`
`-01495 Ex. 1104, 3:43-51, 7:50-57
`
`31
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 49-51; -01495 Paper 25, 18-22; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 116-118
`
`32
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or (ii)
`formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`-01495 Paper 12, 8
`
`33
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or (ii)
`formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`-01495 Paper 12, 8
`
`34
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`Fluid Pathway
`
`Inlet
`
`Lower Housing
`
`Upper Housing
`
`Rubber Conduit
`
`Outlet
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or (ii)
`formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 49-51; -01495 Paper 25, 18-22; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 116-118
`
`35
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or
`(ii) formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`pathway must be positioned
`in a particular location
`within the monolithic body
`
`Garris Deposition
`Q. Does the construction require that the pathway be
`in a certain location within the monolithic body?
`A. It does not.
`Q. Does it require that the pathway be near the
`[stator] or a conductor?
`A. No, does not.
`
`-01495 Ex. 1138, 41:3-9
`
`-01495 Ex. 1138, 41:3-9; -01495 Paper 25, 19-22
`
`36
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or
`(ii) formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`pathway must be positioned
`in a particular location
`within the monolithic body
`
`IV incorrectly points to
`only the lower portion of
`lower housing 12 when
`addressing this limitation
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`Lower Housing
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`-01495 Paper 19, 52
`
`-01495 Paper 25, 19-22
`
`37
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or
`(ii) formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`
`pathway must be positioned
`in a particular location
`within the monolithic body
`
`IV incorrectly points to
`only the lower portion of
`lower housing 12 when
`addressing this limitation
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`Lower Housing
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`-01495 Paper 19, 52
`
`-01495 Paper 25, 19-22
`
`38
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “Confined Within The Body”
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 52-53; -01495 Paper 25, 22-24; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 121-122
`
`39
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Fluid Pathway Is “Confined Within The Body”
`
`Fluid Pathway
`
`Inlet
`
`Lower Housing
`
`Upper Housing
`
`Rubber Conduit
`
`Outlet
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 52-53; -01495 Paper 25, 22-24; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 121-122
`
`40
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Garbage Disposal Is A “Pump”
`That “Is Operable To Power Fluid Conveyance”
`
`’348 Patent, Claims 25, 26, Ex. 1001
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 54-55; -01495 Paper 25, 24-27; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 123-129
`
`41
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Garbage Disposal Is A “Pump”
`That “Is Operable To Power Fluid Conveyance”
`
`Impeller
`
`Inlet
`
`Fluid Pathway
`
`Lower Housing
`
`Upper Housing
`
`Rubber Conduit
`
`Outlet
`
`-01495 Ex. 1105, Fig. 1
`
`Trumper Deposition
`A. ...if
`you
`are
`running
`the water from the sink
`as you are supposed to,
`the
`large
`majority
`of
`the
`flow
`is
`down
`and
`then the impeller acts
`as
`a
`centrifugal
`pump
`and drives fluid out and
`down from the system.
`-01495 Ex. 2007, 52:17-21
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 54-55; -01495 Paper 25, 24-27; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 123-129; -01495 Ex. 2007, 52:17-21
`
`42
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Gould’s Garbage Disposal Is A “Pump”
`That “Is Operable To Power Fluid Conveyance”
`
`-01495 Ex. 1141
`
`-01495 Paper 7, 54-55; -01495 Paper 25, 24-27; -01495 Ex. 1132, ¶¶ 123-129; -01495 Ex. 1140; -01495 Ex. 1141; -01495 Ex. 1142
`
`43
`
`-01495 Ex. 1142, 1-2
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable
`Over Umeda, Raible, And Neal ’554
`
`Casing Cover
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`Body
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 13-16, 32-41; -01538 Paper 30, 9-19; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 61-65, 110-139
`
`44
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Umeda In View Of Raible And Neal ’554
`Discloses Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 18, 48-59
`
`45
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda, As Modified, Discloses “A Monolithic
`Body Of Injection Molded Thermoplastic Material”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 9-13; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`46
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Neal ’554 Discloses The Benefits Of
`Using Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Resin
`
`Thermoplastics
`
`Neal ’554 teaches that
`thermoplastic is preferable
`
`-01538 Ex. 1014, 5:40-44
`
`-01538 Ex. 1014, 6:26-34
`
`-01538 Ex. 1014, 1:62-2:2, 4:67-5:22, 5:27-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30, 17:53-
`58, 18:4-10, 21:24-46; -01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 9-13, -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`47
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Neal ’554 Discloses The Benefits Of
`Using Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Molding
`
`Injection Molding
`
`Neal ’554 teaches that injection
`molding is preferable
`
`Dr. Trumper and Dr. Garris
`agree that injection molding
`provides cost benefits for
`high production processes
`
`-01538 Ex. 2007, 38:13-39:3; -01538 Ex. 1016, 33:11-39
`
`-01538 Ex. 1014, 1:62-2:2, 4:67-5:22, 5:27-49, 6:26-59, 7:43-57, 8:8-24, 9:5-20, 10:27-61, 14:27-30, 17:53-
`58, 18:4-10, 21:24-46; -01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 9-13; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`-01538 Ex. 1014, 21:24-46
`
`48
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`It Would Have Been Obvious To Use Injection
`Molded Thermoplastic In View Of Neal ’554
`
`Monolithic
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 9-13; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`49
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Alleged “Thick” Portions Do Not Prevent Forming Umeda’s
`Body A From Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Regions of
`thick resin
`
`Windings
`
`Heat Sink Inserts
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`
`IV’s Annotated Fig. 1 of
`Umeda (-01538 Ex. 1004)
`
`Regions of thick
`thermoplastic
`
`Monolithic Body
`
`Core
`Annotated Fig. 7 of
`Neal ’554 (-01538 Ex. 1014)
`
`-01538 Paper 30, 11-13
`
`50
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Alleged “Thick” Portions Do Not Prevent Forming Umeda’s
`Body A From Injection Molded Thermoplastic
`
`Regions of
`thick resin
`
`Windings
`
`Heat Pipe Inserts
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`
`IV’s Annotated Fig. 1 of
`Umeda (-01538 Ex. 1004)
`
`Monolithic Body
`
`Core
`Annotated Fig. 7 of
`the ’348 Patent (-01538 Ex. 1001)
`
`Regions of thick
`thermoplastic
`
`-01538 Paper 30, 11-13
`
`51
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda Discloses “Substantially
`Encapsulating At Least One Conductor”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 13-15; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`52
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda’s Conductors Are Substantially Encapsulated
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`Body
`
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 16
`
`Monolithic Body
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 33-36; -01538 Paper 30, 13-15; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 114-125
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`
`53
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 36-38; -01538 Paper 30, 15-19; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 126-131
`
`54
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`Monolithic
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 36-38; -01538 Paper 30, 15-19; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 126-131
`
`55
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or
`(ii) formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`IV incorrectly does not
`consider combined Body A
`and Resin pump casing 11
`
`Conductor
`
`Body
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`-01538 Paper 30, 15-19
`
`pathway must be positioned
`in a particular location
`within the monolithic body
`
`Resin pump casing
`
`Stator Core
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`
`Resin stator with high
`thermal conductivity
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`-01538 Paper 18, 49
`
`56
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Umeda’s Fluid Pathway Is “At Least Partially
`Embedded In And Integral With The Monolithic Body”
`
`“a fluid pathway at least partially (i) fixed within and
`formed by the material of the monolithic body or
`(ii) formed by a conduit fixed within and integrally
`surrounded by the material of the monolithic body”
`IV incorrectly does not
`consider combined Body A
`and Resin pump casing 11
`
`Conductor
`
`Body
`
`No alleged
`fluid pathways
`
`-01538 Paper 30, 15-19
`
`pathway must be positioned
`in a particular location
`within the monolithic body
`
`Resin pump casing
`
`Stator Core
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`
`Resin stator with high
`thermal conductivity
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`-01538 Paper 18, 49
`
`57
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over Umeda And Stephan
`
`Casing Cover
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`Body
`
`Magnet
`
`Rotor Core
`-01538 Ex 1004, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 13-14, 17, 41-48; -01538 Paper 30, 25-28; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 61-63, 72-73, 140-168
`
`58
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Umeda In View Of Stephan Discloses
`Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 28, 6-18
`
`59
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`It Would Have Been Obvious To Use Injection
`Molded Thermoplastic In View Of Stephan
`Similar to Neal ’554, Stephan teaches using
`injection molded thermoplastics is preferred
`to encapsulate conductors in motors
`
`Thermoplastics
`
`Resins
`
`-01538 Ex. 1011, [0039]
`
`-01538 Ex. 1011, [0041]
`
`-01538 Ex. 1011, [0008], [0039], [0041]; -01538 Paper 1, 41-45; -01538 Paper 30, 26-27; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 144-157
`
`60
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`It Would Have Been Obvious To Use Injection
`Molded Thermoplastic In View Of Stephan
`
`Resins
`
`Thermoplastics
`
`Stephan teaches using injection
`molded thermoplastics to
`encapsulate conductors
`
`Monolithic
`Body
`
`Stator Core
`
`Conductor
`
`Rotor Core
`-01538 Ex. 1004, Fig. 1
`-01538 Ex. 1011, [0008], [0039], [0041]; -01538 Paper 1, 41-45; -01538 Paper 30, 26-27; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 144-157
`
`Magnet
`
`61
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Claims 24-27 Are Unpatentable Over Konishi
`
`Windings
`
`Thermoplastic
`
`Stator Core
`Body
`
`Conductor
`
`Windings
`
`Rotor
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 2
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 10-13, 24-31; -01538 Paper 30, 3-9; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 75-109
`
`62
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`IV Challenges That Konishi Discloses
`Particular Limitations In Claims 24-27
`
`’348 patent, claims 24-27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 18, 32-47
`
`63
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Discloses “A Monolithic Body Of
`Injection Molded Thermoplastic Material”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 26-27; -01538 Paper 30, 3-6; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 80-89
`
`64
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Teaches Integrally Forming The Stator Molded Portion 5
`And Stator Can 51 Out Of Injection-molded Thermoplastic
`
`Windings
`
`Thermoplastic
`
`Stator Core
`Body
`
`Conductor
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 2
`
`Windings
`Rotor
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, [0016]
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, [0016], [0028], [0030], [0037], [0038]; -01538 Paper 1, 26-27; -01538 Paper 30, 3-6; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 80-89
`
`65
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, [0030]
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, [0038]
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Dr. Garris Admits that the Stator Molded Portion 5
`May Be Formed Out Of Injection-molded Thermoplastic
`Garris Deposition
`Q. So the stator molded portion seals the stator
`core, correct?
`A. Yes.
`Q. And Konishi lists thermoplastic resins as one
`resin that can be used to seal the stator core,
`correct?
`
`* * *
`A. Yes, it can be used – it can be used to seal the
`stator core
`Q. And paragraph 37 mentions that an example of
`methods used in sealing the stator core include
`injection molding as one of them, correct?
`A. It does say injection molding, yeah, can be – can
`be used. . . .
`
`-01538 Ex. 1016, 57:8-58:2
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, [0016], [0028], [0030], [0037], [0038]; -01538 Paper 1, 26-27; -01538 Paper 30, 3-6; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 80-89;
`-01538 Ex. 1016, 57:8-58:2
`
`66
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Discloses “Substantially
`Encapsulating At Least One Conductor”
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 26-27; -01538 Paper 30, 6-7; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 80-89
`
`67
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 24, Ex. 1001
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Discloses Electrical Conductors That Are
`Substantially Encapsulated By The Monolithic Body
`
`Windings
`
`Thermoplastic
`
`Stator Core
`Body
`
`Conductor
`
`Windings
`Rotor
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 2
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 26-27; -01538 Paper 30, 6-7; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 80-89
`
`68
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Discloses Or At Least
`Renders Obvious “Plumbing Fittings”
`
`’348 Patent, Claim 27, Ex. 1001
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 30-31; -01538 Paper 30, 7-9; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 102-109
`
`69
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Discloses A Fluid Inlet Or Outlet Formed In
`The Body Of Thermoplastic That Is In The Form Of A Plumbing Fitting
`
`Windings
`
`Thermoplastic
`
`Windings
`Rotor
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 1
`Trumper Deposition
`A. There is a readily attachable/detachable sealed connection
`between for instance the End Block 8 and the Body 5. . . . So
`within the scope of the ’348 patent that could well be
`considered a plumbing fitting.
`-01538 Ex. 2007, 63:3-11
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 30-31; -01538 Paper 30, 7-9; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 102-109; -01538 Ex. 2007, 63:3-11
`
`70
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
`
`Konishi Renders Obvious A Fluid Inlet Or Outlet Formed In
`The Body Of Thermoplastic That Is In The Form Of A Plumbing Fitting
`
`Windings
`
`Thermoplastic
`
`Rotor
`
`Windings
`-01538 Ex. 1003, Fig. 1
`
`-01538 Paper 1, 30-31; -01538 Paper 30, 7-9; -01538 Ex. 1002, ¶¶ 102-109
`
`71
`
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT - NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Toyota/Aisin Ex. 1145
`IPR2017-01495 & IPR2017-01538
`
`
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
