`__________________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`__________________________
`
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD. And
`GOOGLE LLC
`Petitioner,
`
`v.
`
`IRON OAK TECHNOLOGIES, LLC,
`Patent Owner.
`
`___________________________
`
`IPR2018-015531
`U.S. Patent No. 5,699,275
`___________________________
`
`PATENT OWNER’S DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS
`
`1 Google LLC, who filed a petition in IPR 2019-00111, has joined as a petitioner in this proceeding.
`
`
`
`In addition to the items below, Patent Owner Iron Oak Technologies, LLC,
`
`identifies the demonstrative exhibits filed by Petitioner as demonstrative exhibits
`
`Patent Owner may use during Oral Argument.
`
`Dated: October 30, 2019
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`By: /Al Deaver/
`Albert B. Deaver, Jr.
`Reg. No. 34,318
`Lead Counsel for Patent Owner
`
`2
`
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.6(e), I certify that an electronic copy of the
`
`foregoing PATENT OWNER’S REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT was served
`
`along with any accompanying exhibits via the Patent Review Processing System and
`
`via email to Petitioner’s counsel.
`
`PH-Samsung-IronOak-IPR@paulhastings.com
`
`Date: October 30, 2019
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`By: /Al Deaver/
`Albert B. Deaver, Jr.
`Reg. No. 34,318
`Lead Counsel for Patent Owner
`
`
`
`1
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`PatentOwner
`
`IPR2018-01553
`IPR2018-01552
`
`SamsungElectronicsCo.,Ltd.
`
`andGoogle,LLC
`
`IronOakTechnologies,LLC
`
`v.
`
`
`
`2
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`MobileUnit
`“selectivepatching”oftheFirstMobileUnitbutnottheSecond
`UnitandaSecondMobileUnitoperablyarrangedtoachieve
`•Claim1isasystemclaimcomprisingaManagerHost,aFirstMobile
`patchableMobileUnits
`•Claim1isdirectedtoasystemfor“selectivepatching”oflessthanall
`•7Claimsets(42claimstotal),butonlyClaim1ischallenged
`InAMobileUnit
`•SystemAndMethodForRemotePatchingOfOperatingCodeLocated
`
`USPatent5,699,275
`
`
`
`3
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1001at14&Decisionat5-6
`
`thesecondmobileunit.
`discretepatchmessageistransmittedtothefirstmobileunitbutnotto
`beginningtransmissionofthemessagesuchthattheatleastone
`mobileunittosendtheatleastonediscretepatchmessagebefore
`whereinthemanagerhostisfurtheroperabletodecidewhichspecific
`operatingcode;and
`inthesecondmobileunitandtoswitchexecutiontothepatched
`operatingcodewithoutreplacingthecurrentoperatingcodelocated
`operatingcodebyincorporatingtheatleastonepatchintothecurrent
`message,thesecondmobileunitfurtheroperabletocreatepatched
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheatleastonediscretepatch
`operatingcode;and
`inthefirstmobileunitandtoswitchexecutiontothepatched
`operatingcodewithoutreplacingthecurrentoperatingcodelocated
`operatingcodebyincorporatingtheatleastonepatchintothecurrent
`message,thefirstmobileunitfurtheroperabletocreatepatched
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheatleastonediscretepatch
`definingatleastonepatch;
`communicationnetworkofatleastonediscretepatchmessage
`amanagerhostoperabletoinitiatetransmissionthroughawireless
`unit,comprising:
`1.Asystemforremotepatchingofoperatingcodelocatedinamobile
`
`discretepatchmessage
`toaddresstheatleastone
`managerhostisfurtheroperable
`
`withcurrentoperatingcode
`mergingtheatleastonepatch
`
`withcurrentoperatingcode
`mergingtheatleastonepatch
`
`theBoard
`Claim1AsConstruedby
`
`
`
`4
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`thepatchedoperatingcode;and
`thesecondmobileunitandtoswitchexecutionto
`replacingthecurrentoperatingcodelocatedin
`patchintothecurrentoperatingcodewithout
`operatingcodebyincorporatingtheatleastone
`mobileunitfurtheroperabletocreatepatched
`leastonediscretepatchmessage,thesecond
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheat
`operatingcode;and
`unitandtoswitchexecutiontothepatched
`currentoperatingcodelocatedinthefirstmobile
`currentoperatingcodewithoutreplacingthe
`byincorporatingtheatleastonepatchintothe
`furtheroperabletocreatepatchedoperatingcode
`onediscretepatchmessage,thefirstmobileunit
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheatleast
`
`code”
`thecurrentoperating
`atleastonepatchinto
`Byincorporating“the
`
`way.
`code”inaspecific
`patchedoperating
`operableto“create
`MobileUnitsmustbe
`Boththe1stand2nd
`
`
`
`5
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`thepatchedoperatingcode;and
`thesecondmobileunitandtoswitchexecutionto
`replacingthecurrentoperatingcodelocatedin
`patchintothecurrentoperatingcodewithout
`operatingcodebyincorporatingtheatleastone
`mobileunitfurtheroperabletocreatepatched
`leastonediscretepatchmessage,thesecond
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheat
`operatingcode;and
`unitandtoswitchexecutiontothepatched
`currentoperatingcodelocatedinthefirstmobile
`currentoperatingcodewithoutreplacingthe
`byincorporatingtheatleastonepatchintothe
`furtheroperabletocreatepatchedoperatingcode
`onediscretepatchmessage,thefirstmobileunit
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheatleast
`
`Unit.
`required2ndMobile
`code”cannotbethe
`thecurrentoperating
`leastonepatchinto
`“incorporatingtheat
`code”by
`patchedoperating
`cannot“create
`AMobileUnitthat
`
`
`
`6
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`thepatchedoperatingcode;and
`thesecondmobileunitandtoswitchexecutionto
`replacingthecurrentoperatingcodelocatedin
`patchintothecurrentoperatingcodewithout
`operatingcodebyincorporatingtheatleastone
`mobileunitfurtheroperabletocreatepatched
`leastonediscretepatchmessage,thesecond
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheat
`operatingcode;and
`unitandtoswitchexecutiontothepatched
`currentoperatingcodelocatedinthefirstmobile
`currentoperatingcodewithoutreplacingthe
`byincorporatingtheatleastonepatchintothe
`furtheroperabletocreatepatchedoperatingcode
`onediscretepatchmessage,thefirstmobileunit
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheatleast
`
`literallyrequired
`operatingcode”as
`intothecurrent
`theatleastonepatch
`codebyincorporating
`patchedoperating
`“operabletocreate
`leastonepatch”isnot
`Codefrom“theat
`PatchedOperating
`alreadycreated
`AMobileUnitthathas
`
`
`
`7
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`tothesecondmobileunit.
`transmittedtothefirstmobileunitbutnot
`atleastonediscretepatchmessageis
`transmissionofthemessagesuchthatthe
`patchmessagebeforebeginning
`unittosendtheatleastonediscrete
`operabletodecidewhichspecificmobile
`whereinthemanagerhostisfurther
`
`currentoperatingcode”
`onepatchintothe
`incorporatingtheatleast
`operatingcodeby
`“createpatched
`the2ndMobileUnitcan
`MobileUniteventhough
`message”tothe2nd
`onediscretepatch
`notto“sendtheatleast
`beoperabletodecide
`TheManagerHostmust
`
`
`
`8
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1004at102
`
`thewithheldPatch
`OperatingCodefrom
`createPatched
`MobileUnitthatcan
`recitedinclaim1”—a
`“secondmobileunit
`message”tothe
`“theatleastonepatch
`decidesnottosend
`ManagerHostthat
`priorartdidnotshowa
`patentablebecausethe
`Claim1wasfound
`
`
`
`9
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Claim1mustbeconfirmed
`
`ifnot,
`
`TheArgumentsandEvidencepresentedinthePetition
`
`mustestablishunpatentabilityofClaim1byPPE
`
`
`
`10
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`SugitaaloneandwithWortham
`
`Grounds1and2
`IPR2018-01552
`
`
`
`11
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Pet.at40
`
`transmissionofaPatchMessage
`Host”thatcaninitiate
`“MobileUnit”anda“Manager
`allegedlyshowaBattery–Powered
`Worthamwasreliedonto
`
`byClaim1
`thePatch,asRequired
`thatisupdatablewith
`PatchtoaMobileUnit
`disclosesnotsendinga
`whetherSugita
`Worthamisirrelevantto
`Petitioner’srelianceon
`
`SugitaaloneandwithWortham
`
`
`
`12
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`updatedwiththewithheldPatch
`disclosesnotsendingapatchtoaMobileTerminalthatcouldbe
`ThePetitiondoesnotpresentargumentorevidencethatSugita
`
`
`
`13
`
`Pet.at36
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`
`
`
`
`ma0mHm.HOQmUZmQSmHOZ-tmzrvfim>_H<~CmZO_>_m_n_
`
`
`
`
`
`mason—3:32E“2835358FEESv.39:35oEaimEEooo<A6.0E
`
`
`
`
`
`A.§_.<.X_couoom3,922::250E
`
`
`
`
`
`...HE:252:6:33...am_atmfi.E33.3%ALE:252:3::3E8?2t2
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`63-3.“mm-_mnamimmfrr3woo?,NoE.xm:.3850we.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`wig—2.:.3335?3:2.2:.33.asup:wfiwnofi3~63$5.22.:33an83.3S9353335.5..
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`mhmdoofi.02E33
`
`323M323%3::Eu3:3;
`
`
`
`:5.253:"E38a....33353:3933...?93
`
`
`
`53..aa...233..E9332.:3::232:9.33a:G
`
`
`
`
`
`3.353“Eu:5.239:.5:332:E3.323.3
`
`
`
`LE5”2.3winging:33:2.2:333:33
`
`
`
`a5.3%s...agwoz.“N2:2m:SEE:2i883%sag
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`HE:P.Au:EoEBo.53033.3%armam.Ana—4.x—:ocuumE032333:36
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`14
`
`Pet.at37
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`
`
`EHmUZmQSmPOZ-tszvGm>F<mhmZO_>_m_n_
`
`
`
`nmE.5;“a:a2ommmmoE:83228:.25an“:a2:$82582222?m_FEE.
`
`
`
`2Ho::3a:Hows“2:=0Enigma2:no258Fowmmmufi:33228525
`
`
`
`Swag—«E...mm:25;832::2:33.3%35%f5:2:=08:3:3.an
`
`
`
`53.BLmason:Paiaano33883EOEhouse9.85%E.>_w=__:ooo<
`
`
`
`
`
`mnmdgfi62E83
`
`32>“;—mmtcmLEE5%zoszom
`
`35......fl.3.—39235a...£22.»!3:2:awammue:33333:.2:.any..a2:$9.353939.2...
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`m_«933:.5:2.293$.25.23.E2::2:
`
`
`
`2:33:=5:5.232:.2:2:312:523.:
`
`
`
`RE...232:3:33
`
`
`
`.xm:.32333:86mm£3395an“:EESEES:£5mumoEmE3:95.
`
`
`
`émoéo—Er.mco.
`
`
`
`
`
`9593..5:85SmANS?“moo..xm:4:5252:3:832:B::5JE:252:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Pet.at38-39
`
`m.”
`
`
`
`mm-wm.m.5.
`
`15
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`
`
`muzm.n__>m...OZ-.._m_Ixm.m.>_..<w...mZO_>.m.n_
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:8:09.38..:88.89.88..8....23..ao...$9.3...
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.893959.35......m..2...Bugs...2..59.8.3:3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`m.«9.38..:8...893m...9::.23..a8..2....
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`8..8.2.=53....23:5.2...8..a.58.255...
`
`
`
`.....:=83...:2.3%
`
`
`
`
`
`.5..322.Ragga...m:a...»PE.28..aE:o......:...E...88.3....c...m..m.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`25833.35.an83...:2.5.82..a...:263.5....38.-..83
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`5352....:8...
`
`
`
`
`
`:..::0.50:.383:8..o..o::5LE:0.52:3......o...a.re.6:...a.:REES.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Ema—8&3.8:2,.3....2..:2:33.8...Saab6300...8....9.25-9-05.S.:.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`888...2.0.30.2....3.3.2.:82...:8...:.oo:oammo.....w:o.2:82...m.F52.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`a....::.=...8.8...ao.3...:55...m.$88.22.82.9.2..:2::25romance::83
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`355.8233a.o:.2.ALE:0.32:5......D..a:...>...:.3.win...3382...m.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“moo..xm:52::25:5.583...D.33.36:.8.gm:338.......o:m.a...
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`16
`
`Ex.1005at3-4
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`un-updated
`MobileTerminalisleft
`canbepatched—no
`MobileTerminalsthat
`disclosespatchingall
`evidencebecauseSugita
`presentargumentor
`ThePetitionfailedto
`
`
`
`17
`
`Ex.1005at7
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`updatedbythePatch.
`IndividualID,itcannolongerbe
`withthePatchwhetherbyGroupIDor
`OnceaMobileTerminalisupdated
`
`thePatchisnotsentthePatch.
`Terminalthatcouldbeupdatedwith
`ThereisnodisclosurethataMobile
`
`GroupIDsandthenIndividualIDs.
`MobileTerminalsareupdatedusing
`Figure1ofSugitaclearlyshowsthatall
`
`
`
`18
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1002at¶101
`
`update.
`Terminalsaresentthe
`thatlessthanallMobile
`paragraphsectiontoopine
`singleparagraphofamulti
`parentheticalclauseina
`ThePetitionreliesona
`
`
`
`19
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`fromthewithheldPatch.
`PatchedOperatingCode
`Patchwasoperabletocreate
`allegedlyisnotsentthe
`thataMobileTerminalthat
`arguesorpresentsevidence
`ButthePetitionnowhere
`
`
`
`20
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`code;and
`switchexecutiontothepatchedoperating
`createpatchedoperatingcode…andto
`secondmobileunitfurtheroperableto
`atleastonediscretepatchmessage,the
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivethe
`patchedoperatingcode;and
`mobileunitandtoswitchexecutiontothe
`currentoperatingcodelocatedinthefirst
`operatingcodewithoutreplacingthe
`atleastonepatchintothecurrent
`patchedoperatingcodebyincorporatingthe
`mobileunitfurtheroperabletocreate
`leastonediscretepatchmessage,thefirst
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheat
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`mobileunit]]
`locatedinthesecond
`currentoperatingcode
`withoutreplacingthe
`currentoperatingcode
`leastonepatchintothe
`[[byincorporatingtheat
`
`MobileUnit
`elementsinthe2nd
`Sugitaevisceratesclaim
`constructionrequiredby
`Petitioner’sclaim
`
`
`
`21
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Pet.at40
`
`BallardandShimizuCombination
`
`IPR2018-01552
`
`Ground3
`
`
`
`22
`
`Pet.at67-68
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`UnitrequiredbyClaim1
`evidenceofthe2ndMobile
`presentargumentor
`ThePetitiondoesnot
`
`sameevidentiarydefects
`Combinationsuffersthe
`TheBallard/Shimizu
`
`
`
`23
`
`Pet.at68
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`fromthewithheldPatch
`PatchedOperatingCode
`Unitthatcouldcreate
`thePatchtoa2ndMobile
`Host“decides”nottosend
`evidencethattheManager
`presentargumentor
`ThePetitiondoesnot
`
`sameevidentiarydefects
`Combinationsuffersthe
`TheBallard/Shimizu
`
`
`
`24
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`thisIPR
`•ThisfailureofevidencepreventsthePTABfrominvalidatingClaim1in
`OperatingcodefromthewithheldPatch.
`Patchtoa2ndMobileUnitthatisoperabletocreatePatched
`Ballard/ShimizudisclosesaManagerHostthatdecidesnottosenda
`•ThePetitionfailedtoprovideevidenceorargumentthatSugitaor
`operabletocreatePatchedOperatingcodefromthewithheldPatch.
`HostthatdecidesnottosendaPatchtoa2ndMobileUnitthatis
`•Claim1wasgrantedbecausethePriorArtdidnotdiscloseaManager
`
`CONCLUSIONREIPR2018-01552
`
`
`
`25
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Hapka/ParrilloCombination
`
`Ground1
`
`IPR2018-01553
`
`
`
`cosmEgEouo___.:mn_\3ngH9580
`
`mmmfio-wfiommm:
`
`
`
`26
`
`Pet.at54
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`UnitrequiredbyClaim1
`evidenceofthe2ndMobile
`presentargumentor
`ThePetitiondoesnot
`sameevidentiarydefects
`Combinationsuffersthe
`TheHapka/Parrillo
`
`
`
`27
`
`Pet.at55&57
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`fromthewithheldPatch
`PatchedOperatingCode
`Unitthatcouldcreate
`thePatchtoa2ndMobile
`Host“decides”nottosend
`evidencethattheManager
`presentargumentor
`ThePetitiondoesnot
`
`sameevidentiarydefects
`Combinationsuffersthe
`TheHapka/Parrillo
`
`
`
`28
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`code;and
`switchexecutiontothepatchedoperating
`createpatchedoperatingcode…andto
`secondmobileunitfurtheroperableto
`atleastonediscretepatchmessage,the
`asecondmobileunitoperabletoreceivethe
`patchedoperatingcode;and
`mobileunitandtoswitchexecutiontothe
`currentoperatingcodelocatedinthefirst
`operatingcodewithoutreplacingthe
`atleastonepatchintothecurrent
`patchedoperatingcodebyincorporatingthe
`mobileunitfurtheroperabletocreate
`leastonediscretepatchmessage,thefirst
`afirstmobileunitoperabletoreceivetheat
`
`Ex.1001at14
`
`mobileunit]]
`locatedinthesecond
`currentoperatingcode
`withoutreplacingthe
`currentoperatingcode
`leastonepatchintothe
`[[byincorporatingtheat
`
`MobileUnit
`elementsinthe2nd
`evisceratesclaim
`Hapka/Parrillo
`constructionrequiredby
`Petitioner’sclaim
`
`
`
`29
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Hapka/Parrillo/WorthamCombination
`
`Ground2
`
`
`
`cosmcEEouEmcto>>\o___.:mn_\3ngN9580
`
`IPR2018-01553
`
`mmmfio-wfiommm:
`
`
`
`30
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`Pet.at61-64
`
`“MobileUnit”
`allegedlyshowaBattery–Powered
`Worthamwasreliedonto
`
`byClaim1
`thePatch,asRequired
`thatisupdatablewith
`PatchtoaMobileUnit
`disclosesnotsendinga
`Parrillocombination
`whethertheHapka/
`Worthamisirrelevantto
`Petitioner’srelianceon
`
`Hapka/Parrillo/Wortham
`
`
`
`31
`
`DEMONSTRATIVEEXHIBIT-NOTEVIDENCE
`
`•Thepatentabilityofclaim1shouldbeconfirmed
`
`•ThePetitionsfailedtocarrythisburden
`
`OperatingCodefromthewithheldPatchMessage
`PatchMessagetoa2ndMobileUnitthatcouldcreatePatched
`thepriorartdisclosesa“ManagerHost”thatdecidesNOTtosendthe
`•ThePetitionswererequiredtoprovideargumentandevidencethat
`
`CONCLUSION
`
`