IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`PATENT
`Attorney Docket No. 13087.0003-0200
`
`)
`)
`) Group Art Unit: 1742
`)
`) Examiner: Stella Kim YI
`)
`) Confirmation No.: 1088
`)
`)
`)
`)
`
`In re Application of:
`
`Kenneth TYLER
`
`Application No.: 15/267,956
`
`Filed: September 16, 2016
`
`For: METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR
`CONTINUOUS COMPOSITE
`THREE-DIMENSIONAL PRINTING
`
`Commissioner for Patents
`P.O. Box 1450
`Alexandria, VA 22313-1450
`
`Commissioner:
`
`REPLY TO OFFICE ACTION
`
`In reply to the Office Action mailed December 12, 2017 ("Office Action"), please amend
`
`and reconsider the above-identified application in view of the following.
`
`Claim Amendments begin on page 2 of this Reply.
`
`Remarks follow the Claim Amendment section of this Reply.
`
`Page 1 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`CLAIMS LISTING:
`
`The following listing of claims represents a current status of all claims in the application,
`including all amendments previously made to the claims:
`
`1. (Original) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional object,
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`bonding an end point of the path of composite material to an anchor; and
`
`moving the nozzle away from the anchor during discharging to pull the path of
`
`composite material out of the nozzle.
`
`2. (Original) The method of claim 1, wherein bonding the end point of the path
`
`of composite material to the anchor includes:
`
`placing the end point of the path of composite material on the anchor; and
`
`aiming a curing device at the path of composite material on the anchor.
`
`3. (Original) The method of claim 2, wherein aiming the curing device includes
`
`aiming at least one UV light.
`
`4.
`
`(Original) The method of claim 3, wherein aiming the at least one UV light
`
`includes aiming a plurality of lights from different angles around the nozzle.
`
`5. (Original) The method of claim 3, wherein aiming the at least one UV light
`
`includes aiming the at least one UV light from only a trailing side of the nozzle.
`
`6.
`
`(Original) The method of claim 1, wherein discharging from the nozzle the
`
`path of composite material includes discharging the path of composite material through a nozzle
`
`orifice having a diameter of about 2 mm.
`
`-2-
`
`Page 2 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`7. (Original) The method of claim 6, wherein the continuous strand material
`
`includes a plurality of strands arranged in at least one of a tow, a roving, and a weave.
`
`8.
`
`(Original) The method of claim 1, wherein directing the curable liquid
`
`material to the nozzle includes directing a filler material at least partially coated in the curable
`
`liquid material to the nozzle.
`
`9.
`
`(Original) The method of claim 8, wherein the filler material includes pieces
`
`of fibers.
`
`hollow.
`
`10. (Original) The method of claim 1, wherein the continuous strand material is
`
`11. (Original) The method of claim 1, further including:
`
`curing a first portion of the path of composite material;
`
`overlapping the first portion of the path of composite material with a second
`
`portion of the path of composite material that is uncured; and
`
`curing the second portion of the path of composite material while the first and
`
`second portions of the path of composite material are overlapped.
`
`12. (Original) The method of claim 1, wherein the overlapping includes wrapping
`
`the second portion of the path of composite material around the first portion of the path of
`
`composite material.
`
`13. (Currently Amended) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional
`
`object, comprising:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`bonding an end point of the path of composite material to an anchor;
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to cause the path of composite material to
`
`extend away from the anchor; and
`
`-3-
`
`Page 3 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`€t:lfffig exposing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material to a
`
`cure energy while the nozzle is moving such that the path of composite material is
`
`hardened at a fixed location in three-dimensional space without support at locations
`
`between the anchor and the nozzle.
`
`14. (Original) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional object,
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material; and
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to create tension in the continuous strand
`
`material that remains after curing of the composite material.
`
`15. (Original) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional object,
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`directing a filler material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material and the filler material at least partially coated with the curable
`
`liquid material;
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to create the three-dimensional object; and
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material.
`
`16. (Original) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional object,
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`-4-
`
`Page 4 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`aiming a curing device at the path of composite material to cure the curable liquid
`
`material;
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to create the three-dimensional object; and
`
`moving the curing device together with the nozzle.
`
`17. (Original) A method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material;
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to create the three-dimensional object; and
`
`selectively cutting the continuous strand material before the continuous strand
`
`material reaches the nozzle such that at least one portion of the path discharging from the
`
`nozzle contains only the curable liquid material.
`
`18. (Original) A method of manufacturing of a three-dimensional object,
`
`compnsmg:
`
`directing a curable liquid material to a nozzle;
`
`directing a continuous strand material to the nozzle;
`
`discharging from the nozzle a path of composite material containing the
`
`continuous strand material at least partially coated with the curable liquid material;
`
`adjusting a trajectory of the path of composite material after discharge from the
`
`nozzle; and
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material after
`
`adjusting.
`
`19. (Currently Amended) A method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object
`
`compnsmg:
`
`discharging from a nozzle a first path of composite material and a second path of
`
`composite material, the composite material of each of the first and second paths
`
`-5-
`
`Page 5 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`containing a continuous strand material at least partially coated with a curable liquid
`
`material;
`
`curing a portion of the first path of composite material;
`
`overla,pping mechanically interlocking the portion of the first path of composite
`
`material with an uncured portion of the second path of composite material; and
`
`curing the second path of composite material while the first and second paths of
`
`composite material are overla,pped mechanically interlocked.
`
`20. (Original) The method of claim 19, wherein discharging from the nozzle the
`
`first path of composite material and the second path of composite material includes
`
`simultaneously discharging the first and second paths of composite material.
`
`-6-
`
`Page 6 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`I.
`
`Status of the Claims
`
`REMARKS
`
`In the Office Action, the Examiner rejected claims 1-5, 7-9, 11, 12, and 15-20 under 35
`
`U.S.C. § 102(b) as being anticipated by U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2003/0236588
`
`("JANG"); and rejected claims 1, 6, 7, 10-14, and 18 under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b) as being
`
`anticipated by U.S. Patent No. 5,340,433 ("CRUMP").
`
`By this Reply, claims 13 and 19 has been amended, without adding new subject matter.
`
`No claims have been cancelled. Accordingly, claims 1-20 remain pending in this application.
`
`II.
`
`Claim Rejection (JANG)
`
`In the Office Action, the Examiner rejected claims 1-5, 7-9, 11, 12, and 15-20 as being
`
`anticipated by JANG. See Office Action at 2-3. Of these claims, claims 1, 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19
`
`are independent.
`
`Independent claim 1 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "bonding an end point of [a] path of composite material to an
`
`anchor" and "moving [a] nozzle away from the anchor during discharging to pull the path of
`
`composite material out of the nozzle" (emphasis added). Because JANG does not teach or
`
`suggest all features recited in independent claim 1, the rejection of independent claim 1 should
`
`be withdrawn.
`
`While JANG discloses a method of producing fiber reinforced composites, unlike the
`
`recited features of independent claim 1, JANG does not teach "moving [a] nozzle away from the
`
`anchor during discharging to pull the path of composite material out of the nozzle." To the
`
`contrary, JANG expressly teaches pushing a resin-impregnated fiber 18 through a dispensing
`
`head 22 onto a base member 40 using a complex system of spools 4 and rollers 6, 8, lOA, lOB,
`
`-7-
`
`Page 7 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`14, 16A, 16B to control the rate that the fiber is pushed out of the head 22. An annotated version
`
`of Fig. 3 of JANG, which shows the spool and roller system, is reproduced below.
`
`As shown in the Fig. 3, the fiber 12 is pulled from a spool 4 through a resin bath 9 using
`
`rollers 6, 8, IOA, and IOB. After exiting the resin bath 9, the impregnated fiber (also called a
`
`"tow") is pushed into the dispensing head 22 and then pushed out of a dispensing nozzle 84 (see
`
`Fig. 4 of JANG) of the dispensing head 22 via rollers 16A, 16B. Explaining this process, JANG
`
`teaches that this spool and roller system is equipped with a motor means to "drive the movement
`
`of the fiber" into and out of the dispenser head 22 at a specified rate. See JANG, paragraphs
`
`[0072-0073]. JANG further teaches that relative movement of the base member 40 and the
`
`dispensing head 22 is coordinated using stepper motors or other means (id. at [0076-771), and
`
`that "[t]he rate at which the impregnated tow is discharged from the discharge orifice onto the
`
`based member is dictated by the linear speed of the fiber tow on the surface of the roller, which
`
`is driven by a motor." Id. at [0078] (emphasis added); see also id. at [0076-0077]. In this way,
`
`-8-
`
`Page 8 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`the roller system pushes the fiber through the dispensing head 22 and the motors coordinate
`
`relative movement of the base and dispensing head to allow for placement of the fiber at the
`
`desired location without affecting the dispensing of the impregnated fiber. Because JANG does
`
`not teach or suggest "moving [al nozzle away from the anchor during discharging to pull the path
`
`of composite material out of the nozzle," as recited in independent claim 1, the rejection should
`
`be withdrawn.
`
`Moreover, beyond failing to affirmatively disclose the "pulling" feature of independent
`
`claim 1, JANG expressly teaches to avoid pulling the impregnated fiber out of the dispensing
`
`head 22, because it can damage the part. Specifically, JANG teaches that, after pushing the
`
`impregnated fiber through the head to form the part, the fiber should be "cut off' prior to
`
`movement of the dispensing head, so that additional fiber is not inadvertently pulled out of the
`
`dispensing head. See JANG, paragraph [0022]; id. at [0029] (teaching that the "towpreg can be
`
`cut off from the dispensing nozzle" when the dispensing nozzle is moved to a new location to
`
`avoid "pull[ingl out any additional length of towpreg."). JANG explains that pulling
`
`impregnated fiber out of the dispensing head can damage the part by causing "erroneous or
`
`redundant disposition of towpreg along the traversal line" of the cross-section of the part. Id.
`
`Because JANG does not disclose every element of any of independent claim 1, the
`
`rejection of independent claim I should be withdrawn. Each of claims 2-5, 7-9, 11, and 12
`
`ultimately depend from independent claim I and, thus, are allowable for at least the same reasons
`
`as independent claim 1.
`
`Independent claim 15 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [al nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing [al continuous strand material and [al filler material at least partially coated with [al
`
`-9-
`
`Page 9 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`curable liquid material." Because JANG does not teach or suggest all features recited in
`
`independent claim 15, the rejection of independent claim 15 should be withdrawn.
`
`While JANG discloses pushing of an impregnated continuous fiber through the
`
`dispensing head 22, JANG fails to disclose any use of a filler, either alone or in combination
`
`with a continuous fiber and a common curable liquid material. In addition, while providing a
`
`background of existing technologies, JANG teaches that the use of a filler (e.g., short fibers)
`
`produces parts lacking in structural integrity. See JANG, paragraph [0007]. Because JANG
`
`does not teach or suggest "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material containing
`
`[a] continuous strand material and [a] filler material at least partially coated with [a] curable
`
`liquid material," as recited in independent claim 15, the rejection of independent claim 15 should
`
`be withdrawn.
`
`Independent claim 16 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing [a] continuous strand material at least partially coated with [a] curable liquid material;
`
`aiming a curing device at the path of composite material to cure the curable liquid material;
`
`moving the nozzle during discharging to create the three-dimensional object; and moving the
`
`curing device together with the nozzle" (emphasis added). Because JANG does not teach or
`
`suggest all features recited in independent claim 16, the rejection of independent claim 16 should
`
`be withdrawn.
`
`JANG does not teach "aiming a curing device at the path of composite material" or
`
`"moving the curing device together with the nozzle." To the contrary, JANG expressly teaches a
`
`use of heating elements 88 to control advancement of curing reactions. Fig. 4 of JANG, which
`
`shows the heating elements 88, is reproduced below.
`
`-10-
`
`Page 10 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`fr0. 4
`
`As shown in Fig. 4, the heating elements 88 are located around the nozzle 22. JANG
`
`discloses that the heating elements 88 heat the resin while the resin is inside of the nozzle 22, "so
`
`that the resin substantially "solidifies" soon after dispensing." See JANG, paragraph [0074].
`
`Accordingly, while the heating elements 88 of JANG might be considered a curing device that
`
`moves together with the nozzle 22, JANG does not teach or suggest that the curing device can be
`
`aimed, that the curing device is aimed at a path of composite material, or that the curing device is
`
`aimed at a path of composite material that has been discharged from a nozzle, all of which is
`
`required by independent claim 16. Because JANG does not teach or suggest all elements of
`
`independent claim 16, the rejection of independent claim 16 should be withdrawn.
`
`Independent claim 17 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing [a] continuous strand material at least partially coated with [a] curable liquid material;
`
`and selectively cutting the continuous strand material before the continuous strand material
`
`-11-
`
`Page 11 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`reaches the nozzle such that at least one portion of the path discharging from the nozzle contains
`
`only the curable liquid material" (emphasis added). Because JANG does not teach or suggest all
`
`features of independent claim 17, the rejection of independent claim 17 should be withdrawn.
`
`While JANG discloses a method of cutting a fiber reinforced composite, unlike the
`
`features of independent claim 17, JANG does not teach cutting a continuous strand material
`
`before the continuous strand material reaches a nozzle, much less doing so such that at least one
`
`portion of a path discharging from the nozzle contains only a curable liquid material. To the
`
`contrary, JANG expressly teaches cutting off a towpreg from a dispensing nozzle at a finishing
`
`point. See JANG, [0029]. Because JANG does not teach or suggest all elements of independent
`
`claim 17, the rejection of independent claim 17 should be withdrawn.
`
`Independent claim 18 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing [a] continuous strand material at least partially coated with [a] curable liquid material;
`
`adjusting a trajectory of the path of composite material after discharge from the nozzle; and
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material after adjusting" (emphasis
`
`added). While JANG discloses pushing of an impregnated continuous fiber through the
`
`dispensing head 22, JANG fails to disclose any trajectory being adjusted after discharge or any
`
`curing after trajectory adjusting. Because JANG does not teach or suggest all features recited in
`
`independent claim 18, the rejection of independent claim 18 should be withdrawn.
`
`Independent claim 19 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a first path of composite material
`
`and a second path of composite material; curing a portion of the first path of composite material;
`
`mechanically interlocking the portion of the first path of composite material with an uncured
`
`-12-
`
`Page 12 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`portion of the second path of composite material; and curing the second path of composite
`
`material while the first and second paths of composite material are mechanically interlocked."
`
`While JANG discloses the dispensing of a new layer of towpreg and the bonding to a
`
`previously deposited layer to form a multiple-layer object, JANG fails to disclose any
`
`mechanical interlocking of an uncured path of composite material with a cured path. Because
`
`JANG does not teach or suggest all features recited in independent claim 19, the rejection of
`
`independent claim 19 should be withdrawn. Claim 20 depends from independent claim 19 and,
`
`thus, is allowable for at least the same reasons as independent claim 19.
`
`III.
`
`Claim Rejection (CRUMP)
`
`In the Office Action, the Examiner rejected claims 1, 6, 7, 10-14, and 18 as being
`
`anticipated by CRUMP. See Office Action at 3. Of these claims, claims 1, 13, 14, and 18 are
`
`independent.
`
`As discussed above, independent claim 1 recites a method of manufacturing a three(cid:173)
`
`dimensional object that comprises, among other things, "bonding an end point of [a] path of
`
`composite material to an anchor" and "moving [a] nozzle away from the anchor during
`
`discharging to pull the path of composite material out of the nozzle" (emphasis added). Because
`
`CRUMP does not teach or suggest all features recited in independent claim 1, the rejection of
`
`independent claim 1 should be withdrawn.
`
`While CRUMP discloses a method of dispensing a liquified material as a solidified strand
`
`into free space, unlike the features of independent claim 1, CRUMP does not teach "moving [a]
`
`nozzle away from the anchor during discharging to pull the path of composite material out of the
`
`nozzle." To the contrary, CRUMP does not teach use of a composite material at all. In addition,
`
`CRUMP expressly teaches pushing the liquified material through a nozzle 4 and onto a base
`
`-13-
`
`Page 13 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`plate 10 using a complex arrangement of drive rod 52, pivot link 70, ratchet head 72, and ratchet
`
`teeth 74. An annotated version of Fig. 3 of CRUMP, which shows the arrangement, is
`
`reproduced below.
`
`As shown in the Fig. 3, a supply rod 42 is pushed by the drive rod, pivot link, ratchet
`
`head, and ratchet teeth arrangement into a heating head 84, where the supply rod 42 is melted.
`
`The liquified material is then pushed through a flow passage 94 to an orifice 98 in the nozzle 4.
`
`Because CRUMP does not teach or suggest "moving [al nozzle away from the anchor during
`
`discharging to pull the path of composite material out of the nozzle," as recited in independent
`
`claim 1, the rejection of independent claim I should be withdrawn. Each of claims 6, 7, and I 0-
`
`-14-
`
`Page 14 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`12 ultimately depend from independent claim I and, thus, are allowable for at least the same
`
`reasons as independent claim 1.
`
`Independent claim 13 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from a nozzle a path of composite material; and
`
`exposing a curable liquid material in the path of composite material to a cure energy while the
`
`nozzle is moving such that the path of composite material is hardened at a fixed location in three(cid:173)
`
`dimensional space without support at locations between an anchor and the nozzle" ( emphasis
`
`added). While CRUMP discloses "instantaneous solidification of [a] material, even in free
`
`space," it is accomplished by "the use of coolant." See CRUMP, col. 21, ll. 19-23. CRUMP
`
`does not teach or suggest exposing anything to a cure energy to cause it to harden, much less a
`
`curable liquid material in a path of a composite material. In contrast, CRUMP teaches the
`
`removal of energy from a material to cause its solidification. Because CRUMP does not teach or
`
`suggest all features recited in independent claim 13, the rejection of independent claim 13 should
`
`be withdrawn.
`
`Independent claim 14 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing; and moving the nozzle during discharging to create tension in [a] continuous strand
`
`material that remains after curing of the composite material" (emphasis added). As described
`
`above, CRUMP does not teach or suggest discharging a composite material, but instead only a
`
`liquid material that solidifies upon discharging. In addition, there is no teaching or suggestion
`
`within CRUMP of tension creation or tension that remains in a continuous strand material after
`
`curing. Because CRUMP does not teach or suggest all features recited in independent claim 14,
`
`the rejection of independent claim 14 should be withdrawn.
`
`-15-
`
`Page 15 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`

`

`Application No.: 15/267,956
`Attorney Docket No.: 13087.0003-02000
`
`Independent claim 18 recites a method of manufacturing a three-dimensional object that
`
`comprises, among other things, "discharging from [a] nozzle a path of composite material
`
`containing [a] continuous strand material at least partially coated with [a] curable liquid material;
`
`adjusting a trajectory of the path of composite material after discharge from the nozzle; and
`
`curing the curable liquid material in the path of composite material after adjusting" (emphasis
`
`added). CRUMP fails to disclose any trajectory being adjusted after discharge or any curing
`
`after trajectory adjusting. Because CRUMP does not teach or suggest all features recited in
`
`independent claim 18, the rejection of independent claim 18 should be withdrawn.
`
`IV.
`
`Conclusions
`
`In view of the foregoing remarks, Applicant respectfully requests reconsideration and
`
`reexamination of this application and the timely allowance of all pending claims.
`
`If the Examiner believes a telephone conversation might advance prosecution, the
`
`Examiner is invited to call Applicant's undersigned representative at 202.641.7683.
`
`The Office Action contains numerous characterizations of the claims and the cited
`
`references with which Applicant does not necessarily agree. Unless expressly stated, Applicant
`
`declines to subscribe to any of these characterizations in the Office Action.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Dated: December 20, 2017
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By /Ryan C. Stockett/
`Ryan C. Stockett
`Reg. No. 53,642
`
`-16-
`
`Page 16 of 16
`
`Markforged Ex. 1004
`Markforged v. Continuous Composites, IPR2022-01218
`
`