}IDJ!DllJLX kckck,!/ckck'1/!kW!k!kckW;lt,k!kckc�,f]Jl)1 77550
`JUL12
`ll05ill:2 .5003 72011111 1:91HTX32 D
`JW'SUIDEJU. LIDR8RY
`002711
`11 0:9:913
`roo11t
`
`n10 srnL v s-r
`li8LVESWH
`
`. U 77550 222i>
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 1
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`What extraordinary love looks like
`
`the most beautiful diamond
`rings so that
`has created
`Cartier
`
`can be.
`the love she inspires
`a woman can feel how extraordinary
`
`of the House
`the designers
`tradition,
`jewelry
`In the greatest
`
`to women.
`tributes
`new diamond rings as eternal
`of Cartier created
`
`ring reflects
`the Ballerine
`collection,
`Within the new Cartier
`
`of grace and creativity.
`balance
`a delicate
`
`of elegance.
`expression
`ring is a timeless
`four-prong
`The classical
`
`d'Amour ring, liberates
`The pure design of the Declaration
`
`its brilliance.
`maximizing
`light,
`all of the diamond's
`
`extraordinary creations
`and find the one
`all of Cartier's
`Discover
`
`that has a unique story to tell : yours.
`
`www.cartier.com - Fifth Avenue, Beverly Hills, Chicago, Bal Harbour, Palm Beach, South Coast Plaza, San Francisco - 1-877-cartier
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 2
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 3
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`Driving American Innovation
`
`ford.com/innovation
`
`Bill Ford
`Chairman and CEO
`Ford Motor Company
`
`•Escape Hybrid EPA estimated 36 city/31 hwy mpg, fron twheel drive, 15 gallon fuel tank.
`Your actual mileage will vary depending upon your driving habits. © 2005, Ford Motor Company
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 4
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`TIME
`
`W O R L D
`
`lnsurgentvs.lnsurgent?
`Those violently opposing the U.S.
`occupation may be splitting into
`two: Iraqi nationals and al-Qaeda
`foreigners. But can the U.S.
`capitalize on the division? .......... 34
`POLL: A new TIME survey finds
`Americans split over withdrawal ....... 38
`
`::::--,.._
`
`-
`·- . --
`
`:�r
`
`¥-- . .
`
`• ,... I � -., I!;",,.-� It, ',� ,� ..,�
`� ...... �-......--
`-
`. �
`
`---;_:
`
`---
`
`December 12, 2005
`Vol. 166, No. 24
`
`10 QUESTIONS: New Mexico's Bill
`Richardson on politics and baseball ..... 8
`LETTERS...
`.. ........ 10
`
`N O TE B O O K
`BUSH 'S BATTLES: The President may
`postpone tax reform; the White House
`fights p.r. skirmishes over the war ...... 23
`MILESTONES: A Congressman pleads
`guilty. Also: America loses a photographer,
`a former All-Star ballplayer and a co-
`creator of the Berenstain Bears .......... . 29
`IN THE ARENA: Joe Klein on a universal
`health-insurance plan-devised by a
`Republican Governor
`
`COVER: Steven Spielberg, in front of an
`enlarged AP photograph of an Arab terrorist
`at the 1972 Olympic Games in Munich.
`Photograph for TIME by Michael Grecco
`
`42 A An RQ-1 P redator lands, piloted by
`remote control, at Tallil air base in Iraq
`
`Long-Distance Shooter
`Meet Major Shannon Rogers, who
`controls deadly Predator drones in
`Iraq as he sits in a room near his
`suburban Nevada home ............... 42
`
`N ATIO N
`
`False Confessions? A
`gruesome Virginia murder case
`ignites debate over how cops get
`people to say"I did it".......
`..45
`
`45 A All these men confessed to a N orfolk,
`Va., killing. But three now say they didn't do it
`
`CEO; Richard Ann S. Moore, Chairman, New York, N.Y 10020-1393. Rockefeller Center, TIME (ISSN 0040-781X) is published weekly, except for two issues combined at year end by Time Inc. Principal Office: Time & life Building,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Atkinson, Treasurer; John S Redpath Jr , Secretary Periodicals postage paid at New York, New York, and at additional mailing offices. <Cl 2005 Time Inc. All rights reserved Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`is prohibited. TIME and the Red Border Design are protected through trademark registration in the United States and in the foreign countries where TIME magazine circulales. The basic rate for a oneyear subscription to TIME is $59.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Subscribers: If the Postal Service alerts us that your magazine is undeliverable, we have no further obligation unless we receive a corrected address within two years. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to TIME, P.O. Box 30601,
`
`
`Tampa, Florida 33630-0601. CUSTOMER SERVICE AND SUBSCRIPTIONS-For 24n service, please use our website: www.time.com/customerservice. You can also call 1-800•843-TIME or write to TIME at P.O. Box 30601, Tampa,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Florida 33630 0601. Mailing List: We make a portion of our mailing list available to reputable firms If you would prefer that we not include your name, please call, or write us at P.O. Box 60001, Tampa, Florida 33630, or send us an
`
`e•mail at privacy@time.customersvc.com. Printed in the U.S.
`♦♦♦♦♦
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`5
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 5
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`B U SI N E S S
`XMA$: Why shoppers still splurge .. 48
`R E LI GI O N
` Why it's hard to
`LATTER-DAY VO W
`S :
`be Mormon and unmarried .......... 53
`SCIE NC E
`GL O BA L
`WA RMING: How it could
`actually cool Europe ...................... 54
`MEDICINE: A partial face transplant in
`France raises ethical questions ....... 58
`S OCIETY
`D OG BREEDING: A crackdown on
`...... 62
`heartbreaking puppy mills
`
`ST O RY
`C O VE R
`A Shot to the Heart Steven
`
`Spielberg's Munich features
`assassins and action. But it's
`also a complex human story of
`terrorism and justice ............... 64
`MUNICH
`'72: A new book examines
`what really happened at the
`Olympics that inspired the film . ... 68
`Q&A: Spielberg opens up .............. 70
`
`A R T S
`HER TRANS-FORMA TIO N: Felicity
`...... 72
`Huffman bends her gender
`Y O U R TIME
`M O NEY: A retail blacklist... ..
`.... .... 85
`HEALTH : Improving CPR ................ 86
`
`PEO PLE: Bouncing baby Bennifer .. 91
`ES SAY: Sullivan on gay priests ...... 92
`
`refugee
`62 A A
`from a puppy mill,
`in Intercourse, Pa.
`
`86 A Dr. Gupta
`on a better way of
`performing C PR
`
`64 A S pielberg aims the lens at actor Eric Bana on the set of the director's new film, Munich
`
`TIME ► YO UR FACE IN LIGHT S
`
`From now until Dec. 18, when we announce
`ONLINE EDITION TIME's Person of the Year, you can visit
`
`impoy.com and submit your image to a giant electronic display
`high above Times Square in New York City. Also at time.com/poy,
`tell us who you think should be Person of the Year and browse our
`
`archive of past choices.
`MORE O N MUNICH
`◄ Read the Sept. 18, 1972, issue of
`
`
`
`TIME recounting the grisly details of
`
`
`
`terrorism in Munich. For the entire
`
`
`collection of articles, go to
`time.com/munich.
`TELL US
`WH AT YO U THINK
`
`
`Saving Private Ryan, E.T.,
`Is itJaws,
`Schindler's List or War of the Worlds?
`
`Pick your favorite at time.com.
`
`Which Spielberg film do you like best?
`
`6
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`·
`
`r'I' TIME journalists
`appear regularly
`on PBS with
`
`interviewer Charlie Rose to
`
`discuss the events of the week,
`
`fascinating characters and
`major ongoing stories our
`
`
`journalists are following. Check
`out charlierose.com for up to
`
`date schedules, more program
`
`information, show transcripts
`and the Charlie Rose Show
`message board.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 6
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`HIGH QUALITY CHICKEN
`
`because,
`
`is a big part of what makes my days click.
`as every great multi-tasker
`knows, energy in means energy out. and a real, juicy
`"' gives me
`even if it is just a quick game
`
`
`
`Premium Chicken Breast sandwich from McDonald'swhat i need to
`
`stay on top of my ga,ne.
`of tag.
`
`it's what i eat and what i do™
`
`i'm lovi n' it™
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 7
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`IN T E R VIEW
`
`
`
`10 QUESTIONS FOR
`
`deal with both the push and
`pull of immigration.
`
`Bill RICHARDSON
`
`YOU HAVE NEGOTIATED WITH
`SOME OF THE WORLD'S TOUGH­
`EST LEADERS. WHAT'S THE
`SECRET TO GETTING WHAT YOU
`WANT OUT OF THEM? You've got
`to engage them personally. I try
`to get to know as much as I can
`about each of the people I'm ne­
`gotiating with before we start.
`
`WHAT TIDBIT TURNED OUT TO
`BE THE MOST USEFUL? When
`I was negotiating with [former
`Iraqi Deputy Prime Minister]
`Tariq Aziz and Saddam Hussein
`for the release of two Ameri­
`cans, I found out that Aziz was a
`Chaldean Catholic. As a Catho­
`lic myself, the fact that I pro­
`posed that he and I attend a
`church service together was an
`advantage in connecting with
`him that allowed us to make
`the negotiations for the release
`of the Americans easier.
`
`YOU WROTE THAT FIDEL CASTRO
`HAD THE MOST DANDRUFF
`YOU'D EVER SEEN. DID YOU
`HAVE ANY PERSONAL-HYGIENE
`ISSUES WITH OTHER LEADERS?
`When the head Taliban took off
`his socks and with his knife
`started cutting his toenails, I
`didn't know whether to laugh,
`cry or stop my conversation.
`But I persisted.
`
`LAST MONTH YOU ANNOUNCED
`THAT, AFTER RESEARCHING THE
`MATTER, YOU DETERMINED
`THAT THE KANSAS CITY
`ATHLETICS HAD NEVER
`DRAFTED YOU. HOW COULD YOU
`MISREMEMBER THAT DETAIL
`FOR FOUR DECADES? I ha�
`been told by various scouts that
`I would be drafted if I signed.
`When it appeared in the official
`program of my tea:m that I had
`been drafted, I assumed it was
`correct. However, the mistake
`was mine. I should have
`checked. Obviously, it's become
`a little bit of an instance where I
`dropped the ball. Get it, Karen?
`I GET IT. I GET IT. Get that?
`Dropped the ball?
`
`■
`
`As
`
` a former U.N. ambassador, Bill Richardson, 58, has a knack for persevering
`in sticky situations. The New Mexico Governor, who titled his new autobiogra­
`
`phy Between Worlds The Making of an American Life, spoke with TIME's
`Karen Tumulty about his possible bid to become the first Latino President, the
`shocking grooming habits of some world leaders and his storied baseball career.
`
`YOU'VE BEEN SPOTTED IN
`PRESIDENTIAL RUN-UP PLACES
`LIKE NEW HAMPSHIRE. WHAT'S
`IT GOING TO TAKE FOR A
`DEMOCRAT TO WIN THE WHITE
`HOUSE AGAIN? First, we have to
`have a candidate who appeals
`to the South and the West and
`pockets in the Midwest.
`Otherwise, we will be relegated
`to being the Northeastern
`West Coast bicoastal party, and
`for sure we will lose. We need
`a candidate with strong
`national-security credentials,
`and we need somebody who
`will speak positively about
`issues and not just attack the
`Bush Administration.
`
`YOU SOUND LIKE YOU MIGHT
`BE DESCRIBING BILL
`RICHARDSON. No, no, I think
`there's a lot of good candidates
`out there. I do believe that,
`based on the party's history,
`Governors should have a better
`shot. I think the American peo­
`ple see Governors as budget
`balancers, as setting agendas,
`as managing.
`
`DO YOU AGREE WITH THE PRO­
`POSAL TO INSERT A COUPLE
`OF CAUCUSES BETWEEN IOWA
`AND NEW HAMPSHIRE, PLACES
`WHERE YOU'VE BEEN MAKING
`FRIENDS RECENTLY? Nobody
`should tamper with Iowa and
`New Hampshire being the ini­
`tial primaries or caucuses.
`That's God given and party
`given. But I see no harm in
`bringing other states with
`diverse populations early into
`
`the process. I don't believe
`quick-and-dirty early results
`are in the best interest of the
`Democratic Party.
`
`GIVEN THAT YOU DECLARED A
`STATE OF EMERGENCY IN NEW
`MEXICO OVER ILLEGAL
`IMMIGRATION, WHAT DO YOU
`THINK OF BUSH'S RENEWING
`HIS CALL FOR A TEMPORARY
`GUEST-WORKER PROGRAM? It's
`not realistic to deport 12 million
`undocumented workers. You
`have to bring them out of the
`shadows and then have a series
`
`of benchmarks and penalties
`for those who don't engage in
`proper behavior.
`
`SO DO YOU FEEL AS IF YOU
`TWO ARE PRETTY MUCH ON
`THE SAME PAGE? I think the
`President has made a good
`start. What he is unwilling to
`do, which I regret, is put polit­
`ical capital on the line to get
`an immigration bill passed. He
`seems to be catering too much
`to his ultraconservative wing
`that just wants heightened
`border security. You need to
`
`8
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 8
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`THE OOPS I J
`''REPLY ALL''
`
`Microsoft® Office has evolved. Have you?
`After all, the way we work has changed. Today,
`information is simply everywhere. Once it leaves
`your hands, anything can happen. That's why
`the latest version of Microsoft Office includes
`Information Rights Management technologies.
`Now you can put limits on the printing, copying,
`or forwarding of sensitive e-mail and documents.
`It's time to evolve the. way you work. Discover
`how at microsoft.com/office/evolve
`
`Microsoft•
`
`Office
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 9
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`L E T T E R s
`The Most Amazing Inventions of 2005
`
`Our annual roundup o f the best new products and technological innovations prompted readers to share
`their excitement about the cool things that await them in the future-maybe even under the Christmas
`tree. Some were troubled by the ethical implications of the cloned dog Snuppy
`
`I TRULY ENJOYED YOUR SELECTION OF
`the best new inventions [Nov. 21]. I liked
`the ENV hydrogen-powered motorcycle
`and the Shift tricycle, whose rear wheels
`move closer together at higher speeds
`and separate for balance at slower ones.
`But I was most impressed by the Life­
`Straw [a drinking tube with powerful
`filters that can prevent waterborne in­
`fections that kill millions of people in the
`developing world]. I've traveled to areas
`where clean water is not a given, so I can
`appreciate the LifeStraw's value. Thank
`you for opening eyes around the world to
`this wonderful device.
`RATHIKA RAMADOSS
`Gallup, N.M.
`CONGRATULATIONS ON "THE MOST AMAZ­
`ing Inventions of 2005:' Your package on
`new ideas, gadgets and gifts has become
`another eagerly anticipated feature, like
`your annual Person of the Year. Thanks
`for keeping TIME a leader.
`JIM TRACY
`Denver, Colo.
`SNUPPY, THE DOG CLONED BY SOUTH KO­
`rean scientists, was a disturbing choice
`for TIME'S Invention of the Year. The
`cloning of mammals has an extremely
`low success rate, and experience sug­
`gests that Snuppy may later suffer debil­
`itating illness. The purpose of the
`Snuppy experiment is clearly to put a
`cuter, more approachable face on the use
`of cloning technologies
`in humans.
`While there are people who might ap­
`prove of the use of more than 100 canine
`egg donors and 123 surrogate mother
`dogs to get one viable clone, I and many
`others consider this "invention" a cynical
`public relations stunt.
`JAYDEE HANSON
`INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR
`TECHNOLOGY AsSESSMENT
`Washington
`
`YOUR LIST OF INVENTIONS LEFT ME
`yawning. There weren't any great break­
`throughs to dazzle the imagination. Many
`of the items were trivial. It's not TIME's
`fault that the year didn't see the intro­
`duction of something fantastic. From
`the standpoint of new technology, it was
`a very dull year.
`Lou VARRICCHIO
`Middlebury, Vt.
`
`Mourning the Dead
`"HONOR AFTER THE FALL:' YOUR PHOTO
`essay on Marine Major Steve Beck and
`his mission of notifying families of the
`loss of a loved one in Iraq [Nov. 21], was
`one of the most powerful and poignant
`stories I've ever read in TIME. I wiped
`away tears trying to imagine the pain
`,,Fantastic! I haven't
`and loss felt by the families of the fall­
`en. I was also struck by the profession­
`seen so many things
`al and compassionate way in which
`Beck notified and supported those fam­
`I didn't know I couldn't
`ilies. I respect and admire him for per­
`forming that incredibly difficult but
`
`
`live without since I was
`sadly necessary assignment.
`WALTER (SKIP) WILSON
`
`an 8-year-old. Please,
`Irving, Texas
`
`Santa, please.,,
`I'M 41 YEARS OLD AND HAVE BECOME A
`THOMPSON LANGE
`little jaded over the years, but I was
`Carmel, Calif
`moved to tears by the images of Beck tak­
`ing care of families who have lost a loved
`one. I think he and the other service
`members performing that noble and de­
`pressing task deserve America's thanks.
`Not all heroes are overseas.
`STEVEN NIREN
`Edina, Minn
`
`I WAS A BIT UNNERVED BY YOUR REFER­
`ring to Snuppy as an invention. The
`cloning technique is remarkable, without
`a doubt, but I believe it is wrong to classi­
`fy a cloned creature as an invention.
`Doing so somehow implies that a clone is
`different and inferior to other living crea­
`tures merely because the method of cre­
`ation has changed. A clone is just another
`member of its species.
`LAURA WHITE
`Folsom, Calif
`
`A Search for Respect
`IN HIS ESSAY "WHAT THE UPRISING GEN -
`eration Wants;' Charles Krauthammer
`wrote about the alienated young Arabs
`in France and their prospects for assim-
`
`TIME
`ARCHIVE
`
`timearchive.com
`
`The festive holiday season is generally accompanied by nagging angst that
`■
`overindulgence in food and drink will result in weight gain. In TIME's Jan. 16, 1995,
`cover story, we pointed to one culprit behind our ever increasing girth: giant servings.
`We wrote, "Food that used to be delivered in modest quantities is now dished out in
`humongous portions that would satisfy Godzilla." Read more at timearchive.com.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 10
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`MICHAEL WALTRIP, two-time Daytona 500 champion (2001 & 2003)
`
`UNSTOPPABLE.
`
`ECO-DRIVE Calibre 8651
`
`M I C HAEL WALTR I P I S .
`
`S o i s his Citizen Eco-Drive.
`
`Fueled by light,
`it never needs a battery.
`
`IT'S U N STOP PABLE.
`
`Just like the people who wear it.
`
`CIT
`E CO-
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 11
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`"I don't care what it is, I want it." *
`
`Wallpaper*
`
`* the international lifestyle magazine for
`
`
`
`/ Entertainment / and yes, even lamps
`
`Architecture / Interiors / Fashion / Travel
`Visit www.wallpaper.com/lamp to subscribe
`
`
`
`
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 12
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`I
`
`1 04 East 40th Street, Suite 903 , New York, NY 1 00 1 6 2 1 2-557-8000
`1 66 East Superior, Suite 502. Chicago, IL 606 1 1
`•
`3 1 2-642-8400
`Concern Worldwide is on international humanitarian organization, dedicated to the relief, assistance and advancement of the poorest people throughout the world Founded
`in Ireland in 1 968. Concern now has a team of 3,700 personnel working in 30 countries throughout Africa, Asio and Caribbean Concern Worldwide U.S. Inc supports
`projects carried out in the field by Concern Worldwide, regislered in Ireland. Design donated by NCS Advertising lld. and placement generously donated by this publication
`
`WORL D W IDE
`---- (U.S.) Inc
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 13
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`12
`
`PEOPLE&
`THINGSW
`LOVETHIS
`SUMMER
`
`THE
`MU
`LI
`
`PLUS
`Jdman
`leroster
`keGyUenhaal
`JesslcaAlba
`ckOemPMY
`JonSteWart.
`Coldplay
`esaa.nd<>lfi nl
`'l(ln&Kont
`
`MosOef ...
`
`eNewCOS.
`
`ilation and success [Nov. 21]. I was star­
`tled by his assertion that France needs
`"the kind of self-reformation that
`America [had] in the 1960s, when it fi­
`nally began welcoming African Amer­
`icans into mainstream society:' Is he
`forgetting the 1960s riots, led by unem­
`ployed and disenfranchised blacks, that
`engulfed the U.S.? I don't call that self­
`reformation. When black people took
`to American streets, they finally got a
`little respect. I suspect that the unem�
`ployed Arab and black youths in France
`want nothing less .
`
`BOB KUZMA
`Holly, Mich.
`
`KRAUTHAMMER SAYS APPEASEMENT OF
`the Arab world has not helped the
`French resolve the issues of its Arab citi­
`zens. How are the French appeasing the
`Arab world by enforcing a law that strict­
`ly bars young girls from wearing Muslim
`head scarves in public schools? That is
`not appeasement; that is self-interest.
`
`LEADING BY EXAMPLE
`
`In addition to expressing admiration
`for the 18 Global Health heroes TIME
`profiled in its special report [Nov. 71 ,
`readers were impressed by the
`leadership of celebrities in the
`· campaign to improve health care
`worldwide. Dotti Nie from Flint, Mich.,
`singled out Bill Gates: "Here is a man
`brought up with middle-class values,
`and he chooses to spend his wealth
`not nurturing selfish dreams and
`desires but working to ensure that
`even the poorest people will have
`their basic medical needs met." Wrote
`a Seoul reader: "Bono and Bill and
`Melinda Gates are remarkable people
`with a clear vision of how to make a
`quantum difference. THIS IS NOT
`ABOUT GIVING MONEY BUT ABOUT
`HAVING AN INSPIRATIONAL EFFECT
`ON OTHERS." And a Kathmandu
`journalist praised the interview with
`Bill and Melinda Gates as "one of the
`best I've ever read. It gave so much
`insight into the lives of the couple.
`They send a message to everyone:
`each person's contribution, big or small,
`makes a difference. Every individual
`can help save a life-one life."
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`Like all other multicultural nations,
`France will have to effectively integrate
`minorities into society. The problem is an
`internal socioeconomic one, and it has
`nothing to do with Islam or the broader
`problems of the Middle East.
`MURAD ELSAIDI
`Little Rock, Ark.
`
`YOUNG FRENCH PROTESTERS WANT TO
`get a job, be integrated into society and
`be treated like everyone else. They
`protest and burn cars, as French people
`in the past fought against inequality and
`stormed the Bastille. France's young
`Arabs are fighting for equality-a French
`ideal. I hope they succeed.
`MAGUELONE IVAL
`Corvallis, Ore.
`
`AS A FRENCH PERSON LIVING IN THE U.S.,
`I want to point out that those who believe
`that all the rioters in France are Muslim
`are mistaken. The protesters are a mixed
`population of immigrants. Many are
`Muslim, some belong to religions other
`than Islam and some are not religious.
`What is happening in France has nothing
`to do with Muslim extremism or al­
`Qaeda. The riots are the result of
`France's failure to absorb and integrate
`its immigrant population. Period.
`ANNE H. PESLIER
`Houston
`
`Torture of a Prisoner
`YOUR PIECE ON IRAQI PRISONER MANADEL
`al-Jamadi, nicknamed the Iceman, who
`died at Abu Ghraib while in U.S. custody,
`should alert all conscientious Americans
`that a gestapo-style secret police is oper­
`ating in our society [Nov. 21]. The CIA
`orders unannounced midnight abduc­
`tions of suspected insurgents and tor­
`tures prisoners, sometimes to death.
`Your article should make all of us scream
`at our elected officials that Americans
`never condone torture in any form, by
`anybody. Our government should do
`what its citizens want. I am afraid of what
`we would find if we opened up the can of
`worms that is the CIA.
`
`RICHARD SNIDER
`Cumberland, Md.
`
`DIDN'T OUR PRESIDENT VOW TO FREE THE
`Iraqi people from the kind of terrorism
`practiced under Saddam Hussein? Yet
`our own government condones terrorist
`tactics, torture and murder when they
`suit its purpose. I pray we never again al­
`low a President to hold office who con-
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 14
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 15
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`siders the physical, spiritual, emotional
`and psychological destruction of another
`person to be just and right.
`PAUL G. SHANK
`Santa Barbara, Calif
`
`WERE SADDAM'S TORTURE CHAMBERS
`worse than ours? The Iraqis must be
`longing for the good old days before their
`country was destroyed.
`EDAN MILTON HUGHES
`San Francisco
`
`"is exceptionally good at
`what he does . . . indeed,
`right now in this country,
`nobody does it better."
`
`MEGAN SMYLIE
`Vernon Hills, Ill.
`
`H O W T O R E A C H U S
`
`Who Shall Live?
`IN THE ARTICLE ABOUT A NEW METHOD OF
`screening fetuses for Down syndrome in
`the frst trimester [Nov. 21], TIME asked,
`"Is a life with the syndrome worth liv­
`ing?" We pride ourselves on our toler­
`ance. Yet encouragement to terminate
`less-than-perfect pregnancies will surely
`-The Washington
`Post
`lead to more discrimination against the
`living handicapped. Can we praise our­
`selves as a nondiscriminatory society
`"Like a meticulous
`when we question whether people who
`are not the most highly functioning are
`debuting
`magician
`worth saving-let alone worth tolerating
`a fancy trick, Grisham
`or protecting?
`takes great care
`creating his setup."
`®
`-People
`
`TIME
`■ Our e mail address is /etters@tJme.com.
`"A fast-pace
`d, fun
`Please do not send attachments
`■ Our fax number is 1 212-522-8949
`read with echoes of
`■ Or you can send your letter to: TIME Magazine
`Letters, Time & Life Building, Rockefeller
`something deeper . . .
`Center, New York, N.Y. 10020
`■ Letters should include the writer's full name,
`crisp, sharp prose."
`address and home telephone and may be
`edited for purposes of clarity and space
`-The Boston
`Globe
`
`LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
`
`CUSTOMER SERVICE AND CHANGE OF ADDRESS
`■ For 24/7 service, please use our website:
`www.tJme.com/customerservice. You can also
`call 1-800-843-8463 or write to TIME at
`P.O. Box 30601, Tampa, Fla. 33630-0601
`
`" [THE BROKER is]
`Grisham living up to
`BACK ISSUES
`■ Contact us at help.single@customers
`vc.com,
`his reputation as a
`or call 1-800-274-6800
`great storyteller
`."
`REPRINTS AND PERMISSIONS
`■ Information is available at the website
`www.time.com
`/time/reprints
`-USA Today
`■ To request custom reprints, photocopy
`permission or content licensing, e mail
`or fax
`timereprints us
`@timeinc.com,
`1-212-522-1623
`
`The Last Juror • Bleachers • The King of Torts • The Summons • A Painted House
`The Brethren • The Testament • The Street Lawyer • The Partner • The Rainmaker
`The Runaway Jury • The Chamber • The Client • The Pelican Brief • The Firm • A Time to Kill
`
`1■1
`
`D e 1 1
`
`Wherever paperbacks are sold • www.jgrisham.com
`Also available in Random House Audio and Large Print Editions
`
`ADVERTISING
`■ For advertising rates and our editorial calendar,
`visit timemediaki
`t.com
`
`SYNDICATION
`■ For international licensing and syndication
`requests, e-mail syndicat
`ion@timeinc.com,
`or call 1-212-522-5868
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 16
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`D on't take h ig h
`
`car i nsura nce rates
`
`lyin g down.
`
`ge1co.co11 1
`
`Ca l l now for a FREE rate quote
`
`1 -800-624-8312
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 17
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`Contact G EICO today and you could
`
`save 1 5°/o on car insurance!
`
`easy and convenient. B ring your car to a
`
`Hundreds of dollars back in your pocket.
`
`GEICO-recommended shop and we can guarantee
`
`
`In a recent survey, new GEICO customers report
`
`
`your claim repairs for as long as you own the car.
`
`
`
`average annual savings over $500. And that's just
`
`
`one reason over 3 million drivers switched to
`GEICO last year.
`
`the Protecting drivers since 1936. GEICO is
`
`
`
`
`nation's fourth-largest auto insurer, and we've
`earned a solid reputation. In fact, A.M. Best
`Helpful service 24/7. Want to update your
`
`
`
`
`Company - leading independent analysts of the
`
`
`policy on a Saturday? Need to file a claim on
`
`
`insurance industry - consistently awards
`
`Thanksgiving Day? No problem! You can call or
`
`GEICO with an A++ (Superior) rating for
`
`
`
`visit us online any time of the day, any day of the
`
`financial stability.
`
`
`
`
`year and receive courteous and efficient service
`every time.
`
`See how your current
`
`Call or visit us online.
`
`
`
`
`premium matches up against low GEICO rates.
`Fast, fair claim handling. Our claims process
`
`
`
`
`
`For the fastest service, grab a pencil, your current
`
`
`begins the moment you contact us. This enables
`
`
`car insurance policy and all driver's license and
`
`us to settle many claims within 48 hours of
`
`vehicle ID (VIN) numbers.
`
`hearing from you. With over 1 ,800 facilities
`
`
`across the country, we make handling your claim
`
`YOUR
`CURRENT COVERAGE
`
`YOUR
`CURRENT PREMIUM
`
`GEICO
`PREMIUM
`
`YOU
`SAVE
`
`Bodily Injury:
`Per Person
`Per Occurrence
`
`Property Damage:
`Per Occurrence
`
`Personal Injury Protection
`or Medical Payments:
`Per Person
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`Uninsured Motorists:
`Per Person
`Per Occurrence
`Property Damage CAR 2
`
`CAR 1
`
`Comprehensive (Your Car):
`Deductible
`
`Collision (Your Car):
`Deductible
`
`Emergency Road
`Service:
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`CAR 1
`
`CAR 2
`
`Government Employees Insurance Co. • GEICO General Insurance Co. • GEICO Indemnity Co. • GEICO Casualty Co.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`These companies are subsidiaries of Berbhire Hathaway Inc. Average savings information based on GEICO
`
`
`
`
`New Policyholder Survey data through February 2005. GEICO auto insurance is not available in Mass.
`
`GEICO: Washington. DC 20076 «> 2005 GEICO
`
`THIS MUCH
`
`GEICO SAVES YOU $
`Start enjoying the savings - get a quote today!
`
`1 -800-624-8312
`
`or check the yellow pages for an office near you .
`
`ge1co.com
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 18
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`MUSICIAN *ACTIVIST*SURVIVOR
`
`M ELISSA ETHERIDG E
`
`G REATEST H ITS THE ROAD LESS TRAVELED
`0
`
`(.f'j
`
`VI :1 r-- --
`
`tJJ _j w > rf •
`0 .: 0 0.: w w
`Cl I 0 •­i'i: w
`w �
`t iB :::;
`
`* CD/DVD DELUXE EDITION
`
`Also Available
`
`* Available Now
`
`Cl)
`� I
`-------I I­
`Thousands of Possibilities �
`C uMe
`WWW.MELISSAETHERIDGE.COM ;�';g;.a,rnw•-·
`
`1/)J 2005 UNIVERSAL MUSIC ENTERPRISES, A DIVISION OF UMG RECORDINGS, INC.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 19
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`Advertisement
`
`F O R U M
`
`To help us make the selection,
`asked prominent individuals,
`TIME
`including previous Persons of the Year, whom they would choose
`
`Some Past Honorees Give
`Their Picks for This Year
`Who
`wi be
`the
`2005
`TIME.
`
`M I K H A I L G O R B A C H E V
`Former President of
`the Soviet Union, 1987
`Man of the Year, 1989
`Man of the Decade
`I note that Ted Turner
`has nominated Bono. I
`would like to endorse that.
`' 8 9 Wehavemetonseveral
`1 9 8 7 ,
`occasions, and I have been impressed by
`his actions. He has been a voice for the
`poor, for the environment, for peace-and
`for the emerging global civil society.
`
`Person
`of the
`Yea r?
`
`J A M E S L O V E L L
`One ofthreeApoUo 8
`astronauts, pioneers on
`the epic quest for the nwon
`I suggest special counsel
`Patr ick Fitz gerald. In
`this age of cover-ups,
`political intrigue,
`corporate greed and
`1 9 6 8
`not knowing whom to believe, it is
`refreshing to see a person who
`searches for and uncovers misdeeds,
`unencumbered by any partisanship.
`
`Let your voice be heard at
`TIME.com/POV
`
`Where you can:
`
`• Vote in the Person of the Year Poll
`
`• Post your POY nomination
`
`• Check out the POY choices of
`leading commentators
`
`• Take the ultimate POY quiz
`
`C H R Y S L E R
`
`����-�-
`
`CHRYSLER.COM
`
`Inspired Presenter of the
`Person of the Year Poll
`
`C Y N T H I A C O O P E R
`Former WorldCom
`auditor ( one of three
`"whistleblowers"TIME
`honored in 2002)
`I would nominate M ot her
`N at ur e. Mother Nature
`brought important
`2 O O 2
`issues of ethics, poverty,
`race, global warming and disaster
`preparedness to the forefront of our
`thinking, probably resulting in changes
`that will have a positive impact on our lives
`and those of future generations.
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`F . W . D E K L E R K
`FormerSouthAfrican
`Presiden� one ofl993s
`four "peacemakers"
`My nomination is for
`Africa as Continent of the
`Year. In 2005 global
`attention was focused on
`theplightofher people.
`1 9 9 3
`Africa needs a fair break from the rest of
`the world and the determination to
`address its own problems. It is essential
`that all humankind join in the march for
`democracy, prosperity, peace and stability.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit 2005 Page 20
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc. IPR2022-01347
`
`

`

`-
`
`n oon
`
`,el
`
`the
`
`on
`e.
`,f
`
`,r
`lity.
`
`C H R Y S L E R
`
`INSPIRATION COMES STANDARD
`
`"CH RYS L E R AUTOMO B IL E S WILL OFF E R
`
`P E R FORMANC E AND EXC ELLENC E
`
`AT A LOW COST."
`
`Walter P. Chrysler, Person of the Yea r, 1 92 8
`
`C H RYS L E R 3 0 0 C. The inspiration : Walter P Chrysler. The result: A company that