UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC,
`
`Petitioner,
`
`v.
`
`INTELLECTUAL VENTURES II LLC,
`
`Patent Owner.
`
`Inter Partes Review Case No. IPR2023-00032
`
`DECLARATION OF RANDALL C. SCHWARTZ
`FOR
`INTER PARTES REVIEW OF U.S. PATENT NO. 8,953,641
`
`Page 1 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`I, Randall C. Schwartz, do hereby make the following Declaration pursuant
`
`to 28 U.S.C. § 1746:
`
`1.
`
`I am making this declaration at the request of American Honda Motor
`
`Co., Inc. (“Petitioner”).
`
`2.
`
`I am the Founder and Principal Consultant of Wireless 20/20
`
`Consulting Group LLC, where I have been employed since 2005. I have worked as
`
`an electrical engineer since about 1983, and more specifically worked in the wireless
`
`field since 1992. I hold both an undergraduate and a graduate engineering degree
`
`from Dartmouth College.
`
`3.
`
`From 2003 to 2005, I served as Strategic Planning Manager at Intel
`
`Corp. In this capacity, and among other responsibilities, I led Intel’s 802.16
`
`standards effort. In connection with this work, I attended and participated in the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards, where I
`
`analyzed contributions of others in order to further the development of the IEEE
`
`802.16 standards.
`
`4.
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group is a public forum for collaboration
`
`and development of ideas among interested parties to develop standards and
`
`recommended practices to support the development and deployment of broadband
`
`Wireless Metropolitan Area Networks.
`
`-
`
`Page 2 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5. The IEEE 802.16 Working Group organized meetings periodically in
`
`conjunction with other IEEE 802 groups. As a matter of general practice, the IEEE
`
`802.16 Working Group meetings that were organized were open to members and
`
`the general public. The IEEE 802.16 Working Group had a website, i.e.,
`
`www.WirelessMAN.org, which could be viewed by members of the working group,
`
`IEEE members, or any other interested member of the general public. Information,
`
`agendas, and announcements about upcoming IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meetings were posted on this website. For each IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meeting (also called a “Session”), an attendance list was maintained to keep track
`
`of attendees for membership and credit purposes.
`
`6.
`
`As a matter of general practice, documents and contributions were
`
`submitted before or during the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings. During the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings, each of the submitted documents and
`
`contributions was presented, discussed, and when required, action was taken to
`
`determine the acceptance or viability of the contribution to the standard.
`
`7.
`
`Due to the high volume of documents and contributions submitted,
`
`physical “paper” copies were not handed out during IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meetings. Rather, the documents and contributions were made electronically
`
`available for download to attendees of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings
`
`by way of the IEEE 802.16 website. The documents and contributions were not
`
`subject to any confidentiality and could be freely disseminated by attendees to
`
`-
`
`Page 3 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`other interested persons of skill that had not attended the meetings. Because the
`
`documents and contributions were provided electronically, they were easier to
`
`share with interested colleagues or other interested persons – in fact, the IEEE
`
`802.16 Working Group encouraged disseminating the submitted documents and
`
`contributions to further the development of the standard.
`
`8.
`
`Also, during and after the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings, the
`
`submitted documents were publicly accessible on the IEEE 802.16 website. Active
`
`members of the work groups were encouraged to review each of the documents
`
`before and during the 802.16 Working Group meetings. Any members that were
`
`not in attendance at that session, or any other interested members of the general
`
`public, could also freely access and download submitted documents and
`
`contributions without restrictions on dissemination, in real time, similar to the
`
`access afforded the actual attendees of the work sessions.
`
`9.
`
`As a matter of general practice, after each IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meeting, a Session Report that included Session Minutes, and documents
`
`introduced at that session, was created by the Chair and posted on the IEEE 802.16
`
`website, to memorialize the specific meeting. These are also available on the 802.16
`
`website for the general public to review. These were generally available within a
`
`week of the completion of each Working Group Session meeting.
`
`-
`
`Page 4 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`10.
`
`Based on my experience with IEEE and the telecommunications
`
`industry, I would expect any person implementing a cellular network or device, e.g.,
`
`a UMTS network, to consult the corresponding Session Reports on the IEEE reports
`
`page, as well as other related documents. The whole purpose of IEEE’s online
`
`database hosting and making these reports available was so that engineers and other
`
`individuals would have ready access to them when developing and implementing
`
`cellular networks and devices.
`
`11.
`
`I was employed by Intel Corp. on March 15-18 of 2004, when the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group held the Session #30 meeting at the Hilton in the Walt
`
`Disney World Resort, in Lake Buena Vista (Orlando), Florida, USA. The Session
`
`#30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting was held in conjunction with the IEEE
`
`802 Plenary Session.
`
`12.
`
`For the March 2004 Session #30 meeting, announcements were
`
`posted on the IEEE website that included information about the date and location of
`
`the meeting. Attached as Appendix A is the IEEE WirelessMAN 802.16 website
`
`snapshot from the WaybackMachine that evidences that at least as of February 7,
`
`2004, the Session #30 meeting date and location information was announced
`
`publicly. I obtained Appendix A by first accessing the WaybackMachine page, at
`
` http://archive.org/web/, next performing a search for www.wirelessman.org,
`
`opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink for the year “2004,” next clicking on the
`
`-
`
`Page 5 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`hyperlink for February 7, then downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`Appendix H is a declaration from the Internet Archives that corroborates this.
`
`13.
`
`Also, attached as Appendix B is a copy of the Session #28 Report
`
`dated November 18, 2003, evidencing that the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meeting was publicly announced in that report. Specifically, Session #28
`
`Report includes a section entitled “Future Meetings” which announces that the
`
`“IEEE 802.16’s Session #30 will take place in Orlando, FL, USA on 15-18 March
`
`2004 in conjunction with the IEEE 802 Plenary Session.” I obtained Appendix B by
`
`first
`
`accessing
`
`the
`
`IEEE
`
`802.16
`
`reports
`
`page,
`
`at
`
`h ttp://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next opening (or clicking on) the
`
`hyperlink labeled “Report” in the same row as “#28,” then downloading and
`
`printing the resulting webpage.
`
`14.
`
`I attended the March 2004 Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meeting on behalf of Intel Corp., as evidenced by Appendix C, which provides the
`
`list of meeting attendees. I obtained Appendix C by first accessing the IEEE 802.16
`
`reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next opening (or
`
`clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink
`
`labeled “attendance list,” and then downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`15.
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting attendees generally included
`
`IEEE 802.16 members as well as members of the general public who were interested
`
`-
`
`Page 6 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`in the subjects of the papers being discussed. Appendix C evidences that 222
`
`individuals signed up for the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting, of
`
`which 180 were granted participation credit. Participation credit was granted to those
`
`attending six of the eight session intervals, provided that registration fees were
`
`paid.
`
`16.
`
`As already noted, as a matter of general practice, copies of meeting
`
`documents and contributions were made available electronically to attendees and the
`
`general public on the IEEE website before and during the meeting, without a
`
`password or restrictions. The IEEE 802.16 Task Group d Document list, identified
`
`as Appendix D, includes an electronic index which indicates that, among other
`
`documents, document “IEEE C802.16d-04/19” entitled “A New Frame Structure for
`
`Scalable OFDMA Systems” by Inseok Hwang, Jaehee Cho, Sanghoon, Sung Hun
`
`Huh, Soon Young Yoon, Panyuh Joo, and Jaeweon Cho was submitted on March
`
`11, 2004 (Ex. 1004). This document was made publicly available before and during
`
`the Session #30 meeting. I obtained Appendix D by first accessing the IEEE 802.16
`
`reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next opening (or
`
`clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink
`
`labeled “document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task Group
`
`d Documents,” and then downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`17.
`
`As already noted, as a matter of general practice, the IEEE did not
`
`place any restrictions on dissemination of submitted documents. Consistent with
`
`-
`
`Page 7 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`this is the cover page of the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (Ex. 1004) which
`
`includes a “Release” clause granting an irrevocable license to the IEEE to
`
`disseminate the material contained in the contribution and to make the contribution
`
`public. I obtained IEEE C802.16d-04/19 (Ex. 1004) by first accessing the IEEE
`
`802.16 reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next
`
`opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the
`
`hyperlink labeled “document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled
`
`“Task Group d Documents,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “IEEE
`
`C802.16d- 04/19,” and then downloading and printing the resulting document.
`
`18.
`
`Attached as Appendix E is a copy of the March 19, 2004, Task Group
`
`d (TGd) session minutes, which were created by the TGd Chair. The Session #30
`
`TGd Minutes at page 3 indicates that document IEEE C802.16d-04/19 (Ex. 1004)
`
`was discussed during the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting. I
`
`obtained Appendix E by first by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next opening (or clicking on)
`
`the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled
`
`“document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task Group d
`
`Documents,” next opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “IEEE
`
`802.16d¬04/03” of the “Task Group d: Session #30 Minutes” and then
`
`downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`-
`
`Page 8 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`19.
`
`The Session #30 TGd Minutes (Appendix E) at page 3 also indicate
`
`that the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (Ex. 1004) was withdrawn. Frequently,
`
`documents are submitted for review and discussion at the meeting and thereafter,
`
`during the meeting, withdrawn from consideration for inclusion in the standard. It
`
`was general practice to stamp the word “WITHDRAWN” on the front cover of a
`
`withdrawn document, but to not modify its contents before reposting the withdrawn
`
`document on the IEEE website. In contrast, regarding documents that were modified,
`
`it was general practice to include for each revision a number and a date. To illustrate
`
`by way of example, referring back to Appendix D, the IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2
`
`document underwent two revisions and the posting indicates the following: “IEEE
`
`C802.16d-04/36r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/17; Rev.: 04/03/13)).”
`
`20.
`
`As noted above, it was general practice for the Chair to create a
`
`Session Report and post it on the IEEE 802.16 website, to memorialize the specific
`
`meeting. In connection with the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting,
`
`on March 30, 2004, the Chair created and posted a Session #30 Report, attached to
`
`this declaration as Appendix F. The Session #30 Report provides a hyperlink to the
`
`“Session #30 document list” that “includes references to over 170 session
`
`documents,” including the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (Ex. 1004). I obtained
`
`Appendix F by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`h ttp://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html, next opening (or clicking on) the
`
`-
`
`Page 9 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`hyperlink labeled “Report” in the same row as “#30,” then downloading andprinting
`
`the resulting webpage.
`
`21.
`
`Also, attached as Appendix G is the IEEE WirelessMAN 802.16
`
`website snapshot from the WaybackMachine, which evidences that at least as of
`
`April 2, 2004, the Session #30 Report was available on the IEEE website for
`
`download by the general public. I obtained Appendix G by first accessing the
`
`WaybackMachine page, at http://archive.org/web/, next performing a search for
`
` www.wirelessman.org, opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink for the year “2004,”
`
`next clicking on the hyperlink for April 2, then downloading and printing the
`
`resulting webpage. Appendix H is a declaration from the Internet Archives that
`
`corroborates this.
`
`22.
`
`I declare under penalty of perjury that all statements made herein are
`
`of my own knowledge and are true and correct. I further understand that willful false
`
`statements and the like are punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both.
`
`Executed on October 11, 2022.
`
`Randall Schwartz
`
`-
`
`Page 10 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`APPENDIX A
`APPENDIX A
`
`Page 11 of 51
`
`Page 11 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:21 PM
`
`10101 ~ -< ))) "802.16" ((( >- ~ 10101
`
`The Wayback Machine- https://web.archive.org/web/20040207050144/http://www.wirelessman.org:80/
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group on
`°
`°
`oN IEEE /’ e Broadband Wireless Access Standards
`IEEE WirelessMAN’
`° NW BO2.16 “©—developing the IEEE 802.16 WirelessMAN™
`e °
`Standard for Wireless Metropolitan Area Networks
`
`oe
`
`.*
`
`6
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards develops standards and
`recommendedpractices to support the development and deployment of broadband Wireless Metropolitan Area
`Networks. 802.16 is a unit of the IEEE 802 LAN/MANStandards Committee, the premier transnational forum
`for wireless networking standardization.
`
`People often take the view that standardization is the enemy ofcreativity. But I think that standards help make creativity
`possible -- by allowingfor the establishmentofan infrastructure, which then leads to enormousentrepreneurialism,
`creativity, and competitiveness.
`
`
`-Vint Cerf, TCP/IP co-developer and Internet pioneer, in Fast Company, April 2000.
`
`News
`Session #29 Report summarizes session of 12-15 January 2004 in Vancouver, BC, Canada
`Session #30: 15-18 March 2004 in Orlando, FL, USA
`IEEE 802.16/Conformance02 Approved as an IEEE Standard
`802.16 Project Development Milestone Schedules
`802.16 Project Status Summary
`IEEE 802 NewsBulletin: Jul 2003 Issue
`
`General Information
`
`Background Information on IEEE 802.16
`Tutorials
`Published IEEE 802.16 Standards and Drafts
`Download some IEEE 802.16 Standards under Get IEEE 802™program
`Liaisons and External Organizations
`What People Are Saying about IEEE 802.16
`
`Details (mainly for participants)
`
`Upcoming Meetings (and previous ones)
`Working Group Documents (also see TG & Liaison pages)
`Task Groups and Committees
`Working Group Letter Ballots
`
`Key Development Resources
`
`
`Legal Issues
`Submitting Documents
`Search 802.16 Webspace
`
`
`This site was updated on 03 February 2004 (and probably since then) by:
`
`Roger B. Marks, Ph.D.
`Chair, IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards
`NationalInstitute ofStandards and Technology, U.S. Department of Commerce
`Boulder, CO, USA tel: +1 303 497 3037
`https://web.archive.org/web/20040207050144/http:/Awww.wirelessman.org/
`
`Page 12 of 51
`
`4/2
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 12 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:21 PM
`
`10101 ~ -< ))) "802.16" ((( >- ~ 10101
`
`Page 13 of 51
`https://web.archivé.org/web/20040207050144/http://www.wirelessman.org/
`
`2/2
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 13 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`APPENDIX B
`APPENDIX B
`
`Page 14 of 51
`
`Page 14 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:22 PM
`
`802.16 Session #28 Report
`
`IEEE 802.16 Session #28 Report
`
`e* % 6
`
`©IEEE 47’ «
`WirelessMAN"
`* A 80216 *
`“ese” |
`
`Summary
`
`Session #28 of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access took place on 10-13 November
`2003 in Albuquerque, NM, USA,along with the IEEE 802 Plenary Session. The site was the Hyatt Regency
`Albuquerque. 116people attended.
`
`Second Conformance Draft Submitted for Approval
`On 14 November, the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) agreed to forward the final P802.16/Conformance02
`draft to RevCom. With RevCom endorsement, approval of the draft as an IEEE standard is anticipated on 10
`Purposes for the 10-66 GHz WirelessMAN-SCAirInterface.It is the second of an expected series of
`conformance test documents. Separately, the third project in the series, P802.16/Conformance03, completedits
`
`Working Group Letter Ballot and was forwarded for Sponsor Ballot by vote of the 802 EC. It specifies the Radio
`Conformance Tests (RCT) for 10-66 GHz WirelessMAN-SCAir Interface. Finally, the WG submitted, and the
`802 EC forwarded, a PAR for a new P802.16/Conformance04 project for PICS Proformaat frequencies below
`11 GHz.
`
`Revised RecommendedPractice P802.16.2 Forwarded to RevCom
`On 14 November, the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) agreed to forward the final P802.16.2-REVa draft to
`RevCom.The draft, approved unanimously during SponsorBallot, is a revision of IEEE Standard 802.16.2-2001
`("Coexistence of Fixed Broadband Wireless Access Systems"). The revision updates the content, adding new
`material addressing 2-11 GHz operation and coexistence with point-to-point systems. The content applies only
`to licensed-band operation.
`
`Revision of IEEE Standard 802.16 Progresses through Working Group Ballot
`The 802.16 Working Group completedits initial ballot of the IEEE P802.16-REVd, a comprehensiverevision of
`IEEE Standard 802.16 ("Air Interface for Fixed Broadband Wireless Access Systems"), including amendments
`IEEE 802.16a and IEEE 802.16c. Many comments were resolved. The workis expected to progress rapidly,
`since it is supported by previousballots on the technical content. However, the draft was not forwarded for
`SponsorBallot, and the development schedule will be revised. A recirculation is planned.
`
`Comment Resolution Continues on Mobile WirelessMAN (P802.16e) Draft
`A fourth Task Group Review wasconcluded in the P802.16e project, which is developing an enhancementofthe
`WirelessMANair interface to support mobile as well as fixed users. Many comments were resolved. The
`Working Group then voted to conduct a Working Group Review. The development schedule will be revised
`accordingly.
`
`Working Group Liaison Activities
`
`e The IEEE wasgranted the status of SectorMember,as an international organization, in the International
`
`Telecommunication Union - Radiocommunication Sector (ITU-R), as of 31 October 2003.
`
`e 15 of 51
`P
`https://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/mtg28/report.html
`
`1/2
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 15 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:22 PM
`
`802.16 Session #28 Report
`
`e The 802.16 WG approveda liaison statement to ITU-T SG 15 in responseto liaison statements received
`
`from SG 15 regarding cooperation and standardization plans.
`e The 802.16 WG approveda Letter to ITU-R in response to an ITU-R input.
`
`Documents
`The Session #28 documentlist indexes the session documents.
`
`Minutes and Motions
`The Working Group minutes are available as IEEE 802.16-03/55. Significant motions presented at the Closing
`Plenary are embedded in the Closing PlenaryAgenda.
`
`All of the Working Group's requests at the 802 LMSC Executive Committee meeting of 14 November were
`approved.
`
`Future Meetings
`
`e
`
`e
`
`IEEE 802.16's Session #29 will take place in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada on 12-15 January 2004
`in conjunction with sessions of the other IEEE 802 groups.
`IEEE 802.16's Session #30 will take place in Orlando, FL, USA on 15-18 March 2004 in conjunction with
`the JEEE 802 Plenary Session.
`e A decision was made to hold IEEE 802.16's Session #31 in Shenzhen, China in May 2004. Thesite
`selection process also considered proposals to hold the session in Seoul (Korea), Washington (USA), and
`
`IEEE 802 suggested that high-level discussions between IEEE-SA and Chinese standardization bodies be
`co-located with Session #31.
`
`About IEEE 802.16
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards has developed and is enhancing the
`WirelessMAN™™Standard for wireless metropolitan area networks. IEEE 802.16 is a unit of the IEEE 802
`LAN/MAN Standards Committee, the premier transnational forum for wired and wireless networking
`standardization. A list of IEEE 802.16 standards and drafts is available on-line,as is a project milestone
`summary.
`
`With the approval of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group,this report was drafted and edited (18 November 2003
`edition, considered complete) by:
`
`Roger Marks(r.b.marks@ieee.org)
`Chair, IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards
`tel: +1-303-497-7837
`
`Return to 802.16 Session #28 Page
`
`Page 16 of 51
`https://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/mtg28/report.html
`
`2/2
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 16 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`APPENDIX C
`APPENDIX C
`
`Page 17 of 51
`
`Page 17 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`
`Attendance List: IEEE 802.16 Session #30
`15-18 March 2004
`
`Thisis the attendancelist for Session #30 (with 222 names, 180 of which are granted participation credit):
`
`
` [usa|
`USACcC n> [
`
`Aa
`
` Cc
`
`i P
`
`u=
`aeoe
`
`—SSAdiga|Agrawal niesitsu :
`refitoejose
`
`
`
`Andrew
`
`Afflerbach
`
`Telecommunications||Columbia
`Corp.
`
`[ves[Mario[Aliota[Siemens|__|
`er
`
`[NoAsher[Aman[InteCorp.[__usa
`
`[esDov[AndeanBnvaraLtd.Isr
`[ves__[Gordon[Antonello|WELANne,[Calgary
`
`
`[NoMikio[AokiTRDAIne[|__|[JUS
`Cc
`[vesSanjeev_[Athalye_J]QUALCOMMIne_[SanDiego
`JSA
`
`esER__——JaviviWavelPLea,____[Yokneam|Cs
`rael
`[res]Raja—_[BanerjeaProximSumnyvate_]
`SA
`
`CG SA
`
`q SA
`
`No[CastaBata—]ffeoson_——].[|
`
`|[
`[[[ [
`
`Corp.
`Frisco
`Broadband Mobile
`Barber
`Phillip
`Yes
`Technologies
`
`USA
`[esKevin[Baum|Motorotatne[|
`USA
`
`esichar——JBentow
`SA
`
`
`[ves]Roger_[Bensohmann_SiWorksme|__|
`Canada
`NesRajest[Bhatia]ZTFSanDiego [SanDiego
`USA
`[NoNecloy[BhattacharyyaCableTVTeen.|__|
`es[Simon[Brand[Philips[_—
`aee
`BeamReach
`[esJamie_[Bumsted_Bvertene.|
`[vesfeanpiere[Burvenich |Belgacom |_|
`[esJSeanai ZTE Sin Diego
`|__|
`
`||=[
`[[
`
`iuli
`
`;
`
`Inc.
`
`:
`
`Cassina de'
`
`[pesngiors
`casa
`[pase18bf nn18
`[0
`https://www.iPa .org/1DESLintgaoreatsthtml
`1/8
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 18 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`Markham
`
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`
`Yes
`
`
`
`Yes
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 Attendance List
`
`
`PevotCo.,Ltd.
`ChangSE
`
`Samsung
`Electronics Co., Ltd.
`
`Suwon-si
`
`Suwon-si
`
`Incorporated
`Siemens[Prinoeton
`Chindapot
`
`[ves[fweweon[Cho[Samsung|__|E__|Korea
`
`Ormeaux
`
`ooChouinard |ommunications
`HinYongte
`
`[vesfosé___Costa_____NoneNetworksOnawa|
`Referer[emer pocovausarami
`
`Inc.
`
`Wavesat Wireless,
`
`~ a
`
`r
`
`foin[DringConsultant [SanJoseSS——
`—==renfEtkayamTechlogiesLedLtd.
`Re
`ee
`Phe
`fe
`es(Harvey) EsvinoraADRCoPoratonof
`
`
`yes aver .Espinoza |,BOXCorporationof ofavier
`Nexius WilesIne |]
`[ves[PeretzFeder Lucent Technologies]|
`
`[No|Reed[Fisher [OkiAmerica,Ine. Suwanee
`[ves[Mo-tfan[Fong _NonetNetworks |__|
`Redline
`Communications
`Inc.
`
`fsa
`=e
`
`Bogdan
`
`Franovici
`
`
`
`eseeomen|FreedmanPageYeae9K ae|Hexagon System Petah-Tikva
`
`https://www.ieee802.0rg/1DESLintgaoreatsthtml
`
`Israel
`
`2/8
`
`
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 19 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`
`
`Brian
`
`Kiernan
`
`InterDigital
`Communications
`
`King of
`.
`Prussia
`
`PA
`
`USA
`
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`
`a[EngineeringLtd.|
`
`aa
`
`[NoMarianna[GoldhammerAlvarionid.[etaviv|.Ise
`Fujitsu
`
`[Nofomn[GrahamIpicoChip|_|Usa
`[vesOle—_Grondaten_|felenor___Fomebu|.Norway
`
`esQiang[GuoMotorola,ne.—_[Liberyvile [IL_——‘[USAic___[usa__
`PesFenPitotee|_|
`[ves[ang[Fah[InveCorp.[Flsboro—[.JUSA
`[NoNeil[HamadyBermai,ine|__|.JUsA
`[vesJfunHanZTESanDiego|_|.JUsA
`[No[Chris[MansellComp.[USA
`[vesfohn[HoskinMicrosoR[Redmond
`[NoMichaet—_[Hoghooght_Motorola|__|USA
`[vesChristian—_[Hoymann—JRWTHAachen[Aachen_[._[Germany
`
`
`[es[SeangKufiwang—JerRr___——|__|[Korea_|
`[ves[Prakash—[lyer__[InveCorp.|JOR[USA
`
`
`[NoYoungMan[fangDaesungNewTeoh||_Korea
`Moo Ryong
`DoCoMo USALabs||San Jose
`
`
`[ves[Clarence[fon[Agere|usa
`
`
`[ves[Brian___[fohnson|None Networks _|Germantown
`[No[Davidotnston Intel Corporation
`
`[Hillsboro _JOR USA[oR[sa
`Samsung
`
`
`
`esa[Rate [Atvarion Led, [Tetaviv|esco
`2eeine,
`ft
`
`Kelman spanNetworksNetworks
`casa
`
`|[SanTose
`
`m=
`feefe|
`
`esaaaaa
`
`epe_foweton_
`2.0rg/1besteamhtml
`
`https://www.iEa
`
`fo
`3/8
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 20 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`Inc.
`rofe|
`Yes|ulesPierPierre Lamoureux$=SeeDorval
`Lamoureux|NavesatWireless,|(Montreal)a LGElectronicsInc. ira) PO
`
`Inc. soryfe|
`
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`
`KoreaFe
`=“—__|ieo—tik|:oeRishonLe
`pefefeeFe
`
`=s
`
`a
`
`Gyeonggi-do
`[usa|
`.
`BeachReach
`
`.
`
`Samsung
`
`.
`
`
`
`acrnKalek_AaseSyncs [Allentown [PA USA_
`
`ee
`
`Se
`
`= G
`
`yeonggi-do
`
`Wavesat Wireless,
`
`Samsung
`
`.
`
`fm|
`esSingstofeeerrr
`___[Rorea
`as
`Seong-
`.
`
`SOLiD
`
`.
`
`.
`
`Runcom
`
`Rishon
`
`= C
`
`
`
`A
`
`teeevn
`
`Yes|DonaldLeimer Proxim|RanchoProxim= Rane Verdes USA
`
`=<a
`
`Lewis
`
`Communications
`
`Lightwater
`
`Lingjie
`
`Communications
`
`Markham
`
`yes ieinodons .aaComp.nefo
`
`.
`
`.
`
`Samsung
`
`[fsa
`
`oxfem
`
`Cpe
`[Korea
`
`Gyeonggi-do
`
`OTTTTTDSrs|a|
`4/8
`
`.
`
`Samsung
`
`Lon:
`
`https://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/mtg30/reglist.html
`
`Page 21 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 21 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

` TxJ0sa_
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`
`[Erik—|[Lindskog|Yes
`
` sn sBrikaaLoes:Inc.Inc. |USA|——France
`
`aee
`
`
`——
`
`Marvell
`
`
`
`Nortel Networks [Richardson [TX USA_
`
`[es____Seang Joo [MaenSamsung|__|
`_—_—[Rorea
`
`
`[ves]David___Maez_—____NaviniNetworks Richardson|TX[usa
`Jeflrey
`Network Consulting ersatem
`.
`Streetwaves
`
`Yes
`
`Kevin
`
`Mankin
`
`Theta
`Microelectronics,
`
`San Jose
`
`[vesflan[MeCalium[nelCorp.[Vaughan
`anada
`
`[ves]Russelt_[MeKown|MacPhyModemsRichardson|
`CcN>
`
`[ves[Seon[Migalai|Motoofa,ne.Schaumburg]
`GI||A>||>
`[ves[Hem[Mitehet_[ImelCo.|__|
`No
`Rishi
`Mohindra
`Maxim Integrated
`Products
`
`Dong-Il
`
`Associates
`
`>
`
`ISA
`
`>OS=ACcS°=G5©
`Inc.
`QING]=¢omBilZB33>|>Q,
`Cc Dn>
`
`fo|
`[es[Ronald[MursWeCANne,[Calgary
`Canada
`[vesKenieni—_[Nakamura|Fujisu[|__|E_[rapan
`
`
`[yesRobent[Nelson|MacPhyModems[Richardson|
`
`No[Paulusa|__[Nawen[Disa|
`
`Yes
`Gunnar
`Nitsche
`PhilipS
`Dresden
`Semiconductors
`Weston[OrewyeM
`[vesPaul[Odlyeko_|Motorot,ne
`[No]Hiroyo[OgawaJORE____Yokosuka
`University of
`
`—r
`
`etane_
`
`[[rapan
`
`_—
`
`S H
`
`ONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`intel Cop
`|)
`Prine
`No|Mehmet Ozdemirndemir|emieesiyofSouthofSouth
`Page 22—_—51
`a/Iwww.ieee802.0rg/1HBoonho[Park—_html
`
`Page 22 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`[No[Rwanwoo[ParkEGBleoroniesne.[|__|Korea
`[vesNamhoonParkeJBTRI_____—_|[[YKorea
`
`[ves|Soon-foon[Park[LGElectonicsne.[__|__[Korea_
`
`[vesJtounok[Park[errr(‘ira|
`Beceem
`Communications,
`Inc.
`ArrayCommIne
`
`Yes
`
`Trevor
`
`Pearman
`
`USA
`
`
`
`
`
`[SanTose
`
`[ves[Cart[PostnumaLucentTechnologies][|[USA
`
`[vesose[PuthenklamntlCorp.___[illsboro [OR JUSA
`
`[NoAjey|RaumarLucentTechnofogesWhippany—|
`
`[ves]RonaidResnickIntelCorp.[Hillsboro
`[No[Francis[Remasothie[CableTVTe.[|_____|USA
`
`[vesRuss[Reynolds[Proxim[CAUSA
`[ves_|Maximiian_[RegetSiemens[Munieh_[__[Germany
`[vesDesmond__Ring[neCorp.|__|Usa_
`
`[vesYannRochefortFranceTeleoom[France
`
`[ves{Claude[RoyerNoneNetworks[|__|[Canada
`
`[vesMichaet—[Rylanoe_NextNetWireless|. USA_
`
`
`[iesRiseon[RyuEGeotoniesme|__|[Korea
`[esAndrew[SagoBTExact[Ipswich
`
`[vesAtal_[SalvekarInetCorp. [SanJose
`[ves[MichelSanderson[Alvarion|__|USA
`[ves[Randatt_[Schwarz[ntoCorp.[|[USA__
`.
`Runcom
`Rishon Le
`
`Yes
`
`Radu
`
`Selea
`
`Redline
`Communications
`Inc.
`
`[ves_|Mohammad_|Shakourt_AlvarionLed. [SanJose
`
`Markham
`
`ON
`
`Canada
`
`=ae
`
`_——————JungJe
`
`Son
`
`peky
`Samsung
`_——
`
`https://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/mtg30/reglist.html
`
`Page 23 0f 51
`
`Korea
`
`6/8
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 23 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`Yes
`
`Kevin
`
`Suitor
`
`Communications
`Inc.
`
`Stanwood esembne|
`Redline
`fiesioteFenianuse
`
`Teik-Kheong
`
`Philips
`
`=a
`
`heheee
`No]laiking[feeSamsung|__|
`fifusa
`FesfrenfonRetnaox
`
`
`
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`PFlectronics Co., Ltd. |__|]
`Samsung
`.
`
`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`
`Ld
`
`Gyeonggi-do
`
`
`aaperoNeworks[MilpitasNokiaNetworks JMC"
`[casa
`of
`—_=s
`sa
`
`[Yes[Frederick[Nook|Motorofaine_|_|
`
`i
`
`[vesling[WangZTESanDiego [SanDiego
`[resist[Wang|WELANTne.[Calgary
`cs
`
`.
`
`Technology,Inc.
`BeamReach
`
`[es JAlred_[WieezorekMotorolane,|][usa
`
`
`
`fetfeiePark
`No[Randolph[WonlenSBC|__—
`sa
`
`[ves]Hassan_¥aghoobiJie!Comp.fsa
`
`
`[ves]Vladimir—JanoverAlvarionLed.[eralyasre
`[ves[Choong-[Yeh_[ETRI_____[Deajeon
`[Korea
`[Korea
`os
`
`re
`htipesiwwwie3eet 2.2abest
`
`Fd
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 24 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`IEEE 802.16: Session #30 AttendanceList
`5/9/22, 2:24 PM
`Korea
`ETRI
`|/Yun
`| Mi Young
`[Yes
`Meoeee
`
`*Session #30 "participation" credit was granted to those participating in six of the eight session intervals, provided
`that registration fees were paid.
`
`Return to Session #30 Page
`
`e 25 of 51
`P
`https://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/mtg30/reglist.html
`
`8/8
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 25 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`APPENDIX D
`APPENDIX D
`
`Page 26 of 51
`
`Page 26 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:26 PM
`
`IEEE 802.16 Task Group d
`
`IEEE 802.16 Task Group d
`
`IEEE 802.16's Task Group d developed, under IEEE PAR 802.16-REVd,a revision of IEEE Standard 802.16
`("Air Interface for Fixed Broadband Wireless Access Systems") as modified by IEEE Stds 802.16a and 802.16c.
`Its work began under IEEE PAR 802.16d, which was an amendmentrather than a revision. The work
`transitioned to a revision effort when P802.16-REVd was approved on 11 September 2003 as a replacement for
`
`P802.16d. The standard developedin this project was approved by the IEEE-SA Standards Board on 24 June
`2004 and will be published as IEEE Standard 802.16-2004, replacing IEEE Standards 802.16-2001, 802.16c-
`and 802.16a-2003.
`2002,
`
`IEEE-SA Project Authorization Request(PAR) 802.16-REVd (as approved on 11 September 2003 by
`IEEE-SA Standards Board)
`Emailreflector: "stds-802-16" (see Subscribing to the IEEE 802.16 email reflectors)
`Email reflector archive (or previous Email reflector archive)
`
`TGd Upload Directory (temporary file storage)
`
`IEEE P802.16-REVd Development Schedule
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #13
`Results of Letter Ballot #13
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #11 (obsolete)
`Results of Letter Ballot #11
`
`
`Click to skip down to Contributed Documents.
`
`Official Documents
`
`IEEE 802.16d-04/05
`Maintenance Ad Hoc Minutes for Session #32
`IEEE 802.16d-04/04
`Task Group d: Session #30 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-04/03
`Task Group d: Session #30 Minutes
`IEEE 802.16d-04/02
`Task Group d: Session #29 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-04/01
`Task Group d: Session #29 Minutes
`IEEE 802.16d-03/17
`Task Group d: Session #28 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-03/16
`Task Group d: Session #28 minutes
`IEEE 802.16d-03/15r1
`Task Group d: Session #27 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-03/14
`Task Group d: Session #27 minutes
`IEEE 802.16d-03/13
`Call for Comments: Editor's Draft Consolidation of IEEE 802.16/802.16a/802.16c (P802.16-2003/D0)
`IEEE 802.16d-03/12
`Figure and Table Numbering in IEEE 802.16 2003 Edition, Editor's Draft (P802.16-2003/D0)
`IEEE 802.16d-03/11
`Editor's Notes on IEEE 802.16 2003 Edition, Editor's Draft (P802.16-2003/D0)
`IEEE 802.16d-03/10
`Task Group d: Session #26 minutes
`a 2of 51
`P ge
`
`https://www.ieee802.o0rg/16/tgd/index.html
`
`1/11
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDAV. IV
`
`Page 27 of 51
`
`HONDA 1010
`HONDA V. IV
`
`

`

`5/9/22, 2:26 PM
`
`IEEE 802.16 Task Group d
`
`IEEE 802.16d-03/09
`Task Group d: Session #26 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-03/08
`Task Group d: Session #25 Report
`
`IEEE 802.16d-03/07rl (Rev. 0)
`Task Group d: Session #25 minutes
`IEEE 802.16d-03/06
`Task Group d: Session #24 minutes
`802.16d-03/05
`(no document)
`IEEE 802.16d-03/04
`Task Group d: Session #24 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-03/03
`Task Group d: Session #23 Report
`IEEE 802.16d-03/