IPR2022-01347
`
`So sensitive it was kept under
`Nee
`RATEDitstst
`feat yet—a story of terrorism atthe
`Olympicsandthe costof revenge
`NYTees
`NCRRAETFs
`
`1X 77550 2220
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 1
`
`an
`
`NBRBDILK AXRRAARAAAARARAAAAET PM 77 55D
`HO592 5883 720TD 191147%32 B
`JULI2
`ROSENBERG LIBRARY
`0027 #
`#09913
`P00176
`
`2310 SEALY SI
`GALVESTON
`
`

`

`What extraordinary love lookslike
`
`Cartier has created the most beautiful diamond rings so that
`
`a womancan feel how extraordinary the love she inspires canbe.
`
`In the greatest jewelry tradition, the designers of the House
`
`of Cartier created new diamond rings as eternal tributes to women.
`
`Within the new Cartier collection, the Ballerine ring reflects
`
`a delicate balance of grace and creativity.
`
`The classical four-prong ring is a timeless expression of elegance.
`
`The pure design of the Déclaration d'Amour ring, liberates
`
`all of the diamond's light, maximizing its brilliance.
`
`Discoverall of Cartier's extraordinary creations and find the one
`
`that has a unique story to tell : yours.
`
`www.cartier.com - Fifth Avenue, Beverly Hills, Chicago, Bal Harbour, Palm Beach, South Coast Plaza, San Francisco - 1-877-cartier
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page2
`
`DNAGenotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 2 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page3
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 3 of 38
`
`

`

`INNOVATION under the
`hood, 500 miles on a Tank:
`
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA GenotekInc.
`
`Page4
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNAGenotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 4 of 38
`
`“Ford developed the world’s first SUV hybrid, the Ford
`Escape Hybrid. Nowthe Mercury Mariner Hybrid. By
`2010, we will produce 250,000 hybrids a year. Ford
`is taking bold action to serve our customers and
`reduce America's dependence on foreignoil.”
`
`LDP
`
`:
`:
`a
`Driving American Innovation
`ford.com/innovation
`
`Bill Ford
`Chaiman and CEO
`Ford Motor Company
`
`15 gallon fuel tank.
`fron twheeldrive,
`city/31 hwy mpg,
`cope Hybrid EPA estimated 36
`tual mileage wil vary depending upon your driving habi
`©2005, Ford Motor Company
`
`

`

`last month
`
`Bet Daley em gyoe
`Alleged Iraqi
`insurgents in a
`LSFaire
`
`EDCI yesscaseraensbtmng 858 10
`
`NOSAUVHONYNYQOH
`
`December12, 2005
`Vol. 166, No. 24
`
`10 QUESTIONS: New Mexico'sBill
`Richardson on politics and baseball .....8
`
`BUSH'S BATTLES:The President may
`postpone tax reform; the White House
`fights p.r. skirmishes over the war......23
`MILESTONES: A Congressman pleads
`guilty. Also: America loses a photographer,
`a formerAll-Star ballplayer anda co-
`creatorof the Berenstain Bears ...........29
`
`IN THE ARENA:Joe Klein on a universal
`health-insurance plan—devised by a
`Republican Governor
`sessional
`
`
`COVER: Steven Spielberg, infront of an
`enlarged AP photographofan Arabterrorist
`at the 1972 Olympic Games in Munich.
`Photograph for TIME by Michael Grecco
`
`Insurgent vs. Insurgent?
`Thoseviolently opposingthe U.S.
`occupation maybesplitting into
`two:Iraqi nationals and al-Qaeda
`foreigners. But can the U.S.
`capitalize on the division?
`POLL: A new TIMEsurveyfinds
`Americans split over withdrawal....... 38
`
`All these men confessed to a Norfolk,
`Va., killing. But three now say they didn’t do it
`
`An RQ-1 Predator lands, piloted by
`remote control, at Tall air base in fraq
`
`Long-Distance Shooter
`Meet Major Shannon Rogers, who
`controls deadly Predator drones in
`Traqas hesits in aroom nearhis
`suburban Nevada home
`
`False Confessions? A
`gruesomeVirginia murdercase
`Sidhe
`dak
`h
`ignites debate Over : Ow copsget
`people to say“I didit”.......
`
`ocefelier Center, New York, N.Y 10020-1393. Ann S. Moore, Chairman, CEO; Richard
`cept for two issues combined at year end by Time inc. Principal Office: Time & Life B
`
`R
`s
`paid at New York, New York, and at additional mailing o
`«in part without written permission
`
`s prohi
`ar subscriptionto TIME is $59.
`through trademarkregistrationin the United States andin the fi
`
`
`
`TIME,
`P.O. Box 30601
`us that your magazine is undeliverable, we have no further obligation unless we receive a corrected address within two years.
`POSTMAS
`
`
`30-0601 CUSTOMER SERVICE ANDO SUBSCRIPTIONS—For 24/7 service, please use our website: www.time.com/customerservice. You can also call 1-
`Mailing List: We malea portion of our mailingist available b reputable firms
`if you would prefer that we not include your name, please call,
`or write us at
`60001, Tampa, Florida 33630,
`or send us an
`write to TIME at PO Box 30601, Tampa,
`
`oeeee
`me.customers\c.
`com. Printedin the U.S.
`
`TIME, DECEMBER 12, 2005
`
`PO. Box
`
`o
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page5
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 5 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`48 Williston, Vt.,
`
`,
`Arefugee
`from a puppy mill,
`in Intercourse, Pa.
`
`esse TS res
`
`
`
`a
`
`co
`4
`z
`
`Dr. Gupta
`on a better way of
`ing CPR
`-
`
`XMAS$: Whyshoppersstill splurge .48
`
`L ATTIR-DAYVOWS: Why it’s hard to
`be Mormonand unmarried...
`53
`
`GLOBAL WARMING: Howit could
`actually cool Europe ...................... 54
`MEDICINE:Apartial face transplantin
`France raises ethical questions
`.......58
`
`DOG BREEDING:A crackdown on
`:
`se
`heartbreaking puppy mills
`__.....62
`
`A Shotto the Heart Steven
`Spielberg’s Munich features
`assassins andaction. Butit’s
`alsoacomplex human story of
`terrorism andjustice...............
`MUNICH '72: A new book examines
`whatreally happened at the
`Olympics that inspiredthefilm.
`
`...68
`
`Q&A:Spielberg opens up.............70
`
`|
`
`HER TRANS-FORMATION:Felicity
`Huffman bends her gender__...... 72
`
`MONEY: A retail blacklist..... 85
`
`HEALTH Improving CPR...
`
`86
`
`PEOPLE:Bouncing baby Bennifer..91
`ESSAY:Sullivan on gaypriests ......92
`
`YOUR FACEIN LIGHTS
`From now until Dec. 18, when we announce
`ONLINE EDITION TIME’s Person ofthe Year, you can visit
`impoy.com and submit your image toa giantelectronic display
`high above Times Square in New York City. Also at time.com/poy,
`tell us who you think should be Personof the Year and browse our
`archive of past choices.
`
` TIME recountingthegrisly details of
`
`=
`
`y
`
`MORE ON MUNICH
`
`
`ReadtheSept. 18, 1972,issueof
`/
`terrorism in Munich. Forthe entire
`‘Airy
`collectionofarticles, goto
`Gs] time.com/munich.
`TEL LUS WHATYOUTHINK
`Which Speers film do youlike best?
`, -
`‘ 4
`neSart, eee Pannen, ET,
`:
`Schindler's Listor Warofthe Worlds?
`Pickyour favoriteat time.com.
`
`message board.
`
`
`
`TIME journalists.
`appear regularly
`a.
`on PBS with
`interviewerCharlie Rose to
`discuss the events of the week,
`fascinating characters and
`major ongoing stories our
`journalists are following. Check
`out charlierose.comfor up to
`date schedules, more program
`information, show transcripts
`and the Charlie Rose Show
`
`o
`as
`ea u
`ow a t eae
`=
`
`6
`
`TIME, DECEMBER12, 2005
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page6é
`
`DNAGenotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 6 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`LIL
`
`iee ee on ae
`dl
`
`Cine /
`
`: ea Were
`aie
`
`-
`
`HIGH QUALITY CHICKENis a big part of what makes my daysclick. because,
`as every great multi-tasker knows, energy in means energy out. and a real, juicy
`Premium Chicken Breast sandwich from McDonald’s® gives me whati need to
`stay on top of my game.evenifit is just a quick gameof tag.
`
`\
`
`it’s what i eat and what i do
`
`®
`
`’'m lovin’it..
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page7
`
`DNAGenotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 7 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`10 QUESTIONS FOR
`
`
`
`sa former U.N. ambassador,Bill Richardson, 58, has a knack for persevering
`in stickysituations. The New Mexico Govemor, whotitled his new autobiogra-
`phy Between Worlds The Making ofan AmericanLife, spoke with TIME’s
`Karen Tumulty abouthis possible bid to becomethefirst Latino President, the
`shocking groominghabits of some worldleadersandhis storied baseball career.
`
`YOU'VE BEEN SPOTTED IN
`PRESIDENTIAL RUN-UP PLACES
`LIKE NEW HAMPSHIRE. WHAT'S
`IT GOING TO TAKE FOR A
`DEMOCRAT TO WIN THE WHITE
`HOUSE AGAIN? First, we have to
`have a candidate who appeals
`to the South and the West and
`pockets in the Midwest.
`Otherwise, we will be relegated
`to being the Northeastern
`West Coast bicoastalparty, and
`for sure we will lose. We need
`a candidate with strong
`national-securitycredentials,
`and we need somebody who
`will speak positively about
`issues andnotjust attack the
`Bush Administration.
`
`YOU SOUNDLIKE YOU MIGHT
`BE DESCRIBING BILL
`RICHARDSON. No, no, I think
`there’s a lot of good candidates
`out there. I do believe that,
`based onthe party's history,
`Govemors should havea better
`shot. I think the American peo-
`ple see Governors as budget
`balancers, as setting agendas,
`as managing.
`
`DO YOU AGREE WITH THE PRO-
`POSAL TO INSERT A COUPLE
`OF CAUCUSES BETWEEN IOWA
`AND NEW HAMPSHIRE, PLACES
`WHERE YOU'VE BEEN MAKING
`
`shadowsand then havea series of benchmarks and penalties
`IPR2022-01347
`
`deal with both the push and
`pull of immigration.
`
`YOU HAVE NEGOTIATED WITH
`SOME OF THE WORLD'S TOUGH-
`EST LEADERS. WHAT'S THE
`SECRET TO GETTING WHAT YOU
`
`WANT OUT OF THEM? You've got
`to engage them personally. I try
`to get to knowas muchas I can
`abouteach of the people I’m ne-
`gotiating with before westart.
`
`WHATTIDBIT TURNED OUT TO
`BE THE MOST USEFUL? When
`I was negotiating with [former
`Iraqi Deputy Prime Minister]
`Tariq Aziz and Saddam Hussein
`for the release of two Ameri-
`cans, I found out that Aziz was a
`Chaldean Catholic. As a Catho-
`lic myself, the fact that I pro-
`posedthat he and I attend a
`church service together was an
`advantage in connecting with
`him that allowed us to make
`the negotiationsfor the release
`of the Americanseasier.
`
`YOU WROTE THAT FIDEL CASTRO
`HAD THE MOST DANDRUFF
`YOU'D EVER SEEN. DID YOU
`HAVE ANY PERSONAL-HYGIENE
`ISSUES WITH OTHER LEADERS?
`Whenthe head Taliban tookoff
`his socks and with his knife
`
`started cutting his toenails, I
`didn’t know whetherto laugh,
`cry or stop my conversation.
`ButI persisted.
`
`
`
`| GET I. Get that?
`1 GET IT.
`Droppedthe ball?
`
`a
`
`
`
`the process. I don’t believe
`quick-and-dirtyearlyresults
`are in the bestinterest of the
`Democratic Party.
`
`for those who don't engage in
`properbehavior.
`
`LAST MONTH YOU ANNOUNCED
`THAT, AFTER RESEARCHING THE
`MATTER, YOU DETERMINED
`THAT THE KANSASCITY
`ATHLETICS HAD NEVER
`DRAFTED YOU. HOW COULD YOU
`MISREMEMBER THAT DETAIL
`FOR FOUR DECADES? | had
`beentold byvariousscouts that
`SO DO YOU FEEL AS IF YOU
`I would be draftedif I signed.
`TWO ARE PRETTY MUCH ON
`GIVEN THAT YOU DECLARED A
`Whenit appearedin theofficial
`STATE OF EMERGENCY IN NEW
`THE SAME PAGE?| think the
`program of myteam thatI had
`MEXICO OVER ILLEGAL
`been drafted, I assumed it was
`President has made a good
`IMMIGRATION, WHAT DO YOU
`correct. However, the mistake
`FRIENDS RECENTLY? Nobody
`start. What he is unwilling to
`THINK OF BUSH'S RENEWING
`was mine.I should have
`should tamper with Iowa and
`do, whichIregret,is put polit-
`HIS CALL FOR A TEMPORARY
`NewHampshire beingtheini-
`ical capital on the line to get
`checked. Obviously, it’s become
`GUESTWORKER PROGRAN? It’s
`a little bit of an instance where I
`tial primaries or caucuses.
`an immigration bill passed. He
`That’s God given and party
`droppedtheball. Getit, Karen?
`notrealistic to deport 12 million
`seemsto be catering too much
`undocumented workers. You
`given. But I see no harm in
`to his ultraconservative wing
`bringingotherstates with
`have to bring them out of the
`that just wants heightened
`diverse populations early into
`bordersecurity. You need to
`
`8
`
`TIME, DECEMBER12,2005
`
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Exhibit 2005
`
`Page 8
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 8 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`IPR2022-01347
`
`or forwarding of sensitive e-mail and documents.
`It's time to evolve the way you work. Discover
`how at microsoft.com/office/evolve
`
`Microsoft® Office has evolved. Have you?
`
`After all, the way we work has changed. Today,
`
`information is simply everywhere. Onceit leaves
`your hands, anything can happen. That's why
`the latest version of Microsoft Office includes
`
`Information Rights Managementtechnologies.
`Now you can putlimits on the printing, copying,
`
`We're using Office 2000.
`Should we upgrade?
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page9
`
`

`

` S T
`
`L RT.
`
`FF
`
`awe.
`
`OR
`
`he Most Amazing Inventions of 2005
`
`Our annual roundupofthe best new products and technological innovations promptedreaders to share
`their excitement aboutthe coolthings that await them in the future—maybe even underthe Christmas
`tree. Some weretroubledbythe ethical implications of the cloned dog Snuppy
`
`‘TORTURECASE"EST&WORSTGOVERNORS*CLOGRETSNEWFUCK
`|
`
`we
`
`YOUR LIST OF INVENTIONS LEFT ME
`
`yawning. There weren't any great break-
`throughsto dazzle theimagination. Many
`of the items weretrivial. It’s not TIME’s
`fault that the year didn’t see the intro-
`duction of something fantastic. From
`the standpoint of new technology,it was
`a very dull year.
`
`Lou VARRICCHIO
`Middlebury,Vt.
`
`Mourning the Dead
`“HONOR AFTER THE FALL;” YOUR PHOTO
`essay on Marine Major Steve Beck and
`his mission of notifying families of the
`loss of a loved one in Iraq [Nov. 21], was
`one of the most powerful and poignant
`stories I’ve ever read in TIME. I wiped
`away tears trying to imagine the pain
`and loss felt by the families of the fall-
`en. I was also struck by the profession-
`al and compassionate way in which
`Beck notified and supported those fam-
`ilies. I respect and admire him forper-
`forming that
`incredibly difficult but
`sadly necessary assignment.
`WALTER(SKIP) WILSON
`Irving, Texas
`
`I’M 41 YEARS OLD AND HAVE BECOME A
`little jaded over the years, but I was
`moved to tears by the images of Beck tak-
`ing care of families who have lost a loved
`one.
`I think he and the other service
`members performingthat noble and de-
`pressing task deserve America’s thanks,
`Notall heroes are overseas.
`STEVEN NIREN
`Edina, Minn
`
`4éFantastic! | haven't
`seen so manythings
`| didn’t know | couldn't
`live without since | was
`an 8-year-old. Please,
`Santa, please.77
`THOMPSON LANGE
`Carmel, Calif.
`
`
`I WAS A BIT UNNERVED BY YOUR REFER-
`
`ring to Snuppy as an invention. The
`cloning technique is remarkable, without
`a doubt, butI believe it is wrongtoclassi-
`fy a cloned creature as an invention.
`Doing so somehow implies thata cloneis
`different and inferior to otherliving crea-
`tures merely because the methodof cre-
`ation has changed. Acloneis just another
`memberofits species.
`
`A Search for Respect
`IN HIS ESSAY “WHAT THE UPRISING GEN-
`eration Wants,” Charles Krauthammer
`LAURA WHITE
`wrote aboutthe alienated young Arabs
`in France andtheir prospectsfor assim-
`Folsom, Calif.
`
`I TRULY ENJOYED YOUR SELECTION OF
`the best new inventions [Nov.21]. I liked
`the ENV hydrogen-powered motorcycle
`and the Shift tricycle, whose rear wheels
`move closer together at higher speeds
`and separate for balance at slower ones.
`But I was most impressed bythe Life-
`Straw [a drinking tube with powerful
`filters that can prevent waterbomein-
`fections that kill millions of people in the
`developing world]. I've traveled to areas
`where clean wateris not a given, so I can
`appreciate the LifeStraws value. Thank
`you for opening eyes around the world to
`this wonderful device.
`RATHIKA RAMADOSS
`Gallup, NM.
`
`CONGRATULATIONS ON “THE MOST AMAZ-
`
`ing Inventions of 2005.” Your package on
`new ideas, gadgets and gifts has become
`anothereagerly anticipatedfeature,like
`your annual Person of the Year. Thanks
`for keeping TIME a leader.
`
`Jim TRACY
`Denver, Colo.
`
`SNUPPY, THE DOG CLONED BY SOUTH KO-
`rean scientists, was a disturbing choice
`for TIME’s Invention of the Year. The
`cloning of mammals has an extremely
`low success rate, and experience sug-
`gests that Snuppy maylatersuffer debil-
`itating illness. The purpose of
`the
`Snuppy experimentis clearly to put a
`cuter, more approachable face onthe use
`of cloning technologies
`in humans.
`While there are people who might ap-
`proveof the use of more than 100 canine
`egg donors and 123 surrogate mother
`dogs to get one viable clone, I and many
`others considerthis “invention” a cynical
`public relations stunt.
`
`JAYDEE HANSON
`INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR
`TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT
`Washington
`
`TIMEQ
`
`ARCHIVE
`
`timearchive.com
`IPR2022-01347
`
`§ The festive holiday season is generally accompanied by nagging angst that
`overindulgence in food and drink will result in weight gain. In TIME's Jan. 16, 1995,
`coverstory, we pointed to one culprit behind our everincreasing girth: giant servings.
`We wrote, “Food that used to be delivered in modest quantities is now dished out in
`humongous portions that would satisfy Godzilla.” Read more at timearchive.com.
`
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Exhibit 2005
`
`Page 10
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 10 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`MICHAEL WALTRIP, two-time Daytona 500 champion (2001 & 2003
`
`
`
`UNSTOPPABLE.
`
`MICHAEL WALTRIP IS.
`Sois his Citizen Eco-Drive.
`
`ECO-DRIVE Calibre 8651
`
`==i
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Fueled by light,
`it never needsa battery.
`
`IT’S UNSTOPPABLE.
`
`Just like the people who wear it. GOR DON'S JEWELERS
`
`eesHs8)Bes
`
`Page 11
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 11 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`
` “| don’t care whatit is, | want it.” *
`
`Wallpaper*
`
`* the international lifestyle magazine for
`Architecture / Interiors / Fashion / Travel / Entertainment / and yes, even lamps
`Visit www.wallpaper.com/lamp to subscribe
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 12
`
`DNAGenotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 12 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

` 4
`
`9 =
`
`“ly ae
`
`~
`
`=
`
`~~
`
`—
`
`af
`>_<" 5 ,
`
`Gatti2.)eh J)
`
`WORLDWIDE
`—————(US.)
`inc
`
`312-642-8400
`166 East Superior, Suite 502, Chicago, £ 6061!
`©
`212-557-8000
`104 Eost 40th Street, Suite 903, New York, NY 10016
`Concem Worldwide is on international humanitarian organization, dedicated to the relief, assistance and advancementofthe poorest peaple throughout the word Founded
`in Ireland in 1968, Concern now has a team of 3,700 personne! working in 30 countries throughout Africa, Asia and Caribbean Concen Workdwide U.S.
`lac supports
`projeds carted out in the field by Concern Worldwide, registered in Ireland, Design donated by MCS Advertising lid. and plocement generously donated by this publication
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 13
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 13 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA GenotekInc.
`
`

`

`
`
`E
`
`ue
`
`nite
`
`
`
`
`aaoe
`
`ilation and success [Nov. 21]. I was star-
`tled by his assertion that France needs
`“the kind of
`self-reformation that
`America [had] in the 1960s, whenit fi-
`nally began welcoming African Amer-
`icans into mainstream society.” Is he
`forgetting the 1960sriots, led by unem-
`ployed and disenfranchisedblacks, that
`engulfed the U.S.? I don’t call that self-
`reformation. When black people took
`to American streets, theyfinally got a
`little respect. I suspect that the unem-
`ployed Arab and black youthsin France
`want nothingless.
`
`Bos KuzMA
`Holly, Mich.
`
`KRAUTHAMMER SAYS APPEASEMENT OF
`
`the Arab world has not helped the
`French resolve the issuesofits Arabciti-
`zens, Howare the French appeasing the
`Arab world byenforcing a lawthatstrict-
`ly bars young girls from wearing Muslim
`head scarves in public schools? Thatis
`not appeasement;
`that
`is self-interest.
`
`ean
`teh| i Si *.
`
`
`FRISHMAN—TIMELIFEPICTURES/GETTY
` RICH
`
`in addition to expressing admiration
`for the 18 Global Health heroes TIME
`profiled in its special report [Nov. 7],
`readers were impressed by the
`leadership of celebrities in the
`campaign to improve health care
`worldwide. Dotti Nie from Fint, Mich.,
`singled out Bill Gates: “Here is a man
`brought up with middle-class values,
`and he chooses to spend his wealth
`not nurturing selfish dreams and
`desires but working to ensure that
`even the poorest people will have
`their basic medical needs met.” Wrote
`a Seoul reader: “Bono and Bill and
`Melinda Gates are remarkable people
`with a clear vision of how to make a
`quantum difference.
`
`Like all other multicultural nations,
`France will haveto effectively integrate
`minorities into society. The problem is an
`internal socioeconomic one, and it has
`nothing to do with Islam or the broader
`problems of the Middle East.
`MuraD ELsaIDI
`Little Rock, Ark.
`
`YOUNG FRENCH PROTESTERS WANT TO
`
`get a job, be integrated into society and
`be treated like everyone else. They
`protest and burn cars, as French people
`in the past fought against inequality and
`stormed the Bastille. France's young
`Arabsarefighting for equality—a French
`ideal. I hope they succeed.
`MAGUELONE IvAL
`Corvallis, Ore.
`
`AS A FRENCH PERSONLIVINGIN THE US.,
`I wantto pointoutthatthosewhobelieve
`thatall the rioters in France are Muslim
`are mistaken. The protesters are a mixed
`population of immigrants. Many are
`Muslim, some belongto religions other
`than Islam and someare not religious.
`Whatis happeningin France has nothing
`to do with Muslim extremism or al-
`Qaeda. The riots are the result of
`France’s failure to absorb and integrate
`its immigrant population. Period.
`ANNEH. PESLIER
`Houston
`
`Torture of a Prisoner
`YOURPIECE ON IRAQI PRISONER MANADEL
`al-Jamadi, nicknamed the Iceman, who
`died at Abu Ghraibwhile in US. custody,
`should alert all conscientious Americans
`
`that a gestapo-style secret police is oper-
`ating in our society [Nov. 21]. The cia
`orders unannounced midnight abduc-
`tions of suspected insurgents and tor-
`tures prisoners,
`sometimes to death
`Yourarticle should make all of us scream
`at our elected officials that Americans
`never condonetorture in any form, by
`anybody. Our government should do
`whatitscitizens want. I am afraid of what
`we would find if we openedup thecan of
`wormsthatis the CIA.
`
`RICHARD SNIDER
`Cumberland, Md.
`
`DIDN’T OUR PRESIDENT VOWTO FREE THE
`
`And a Kathmandu
`journalist praised theinterview with
`Bill and Melinda Gates as “one of the
`best I've ever read It gave so much
`insight into the lives of the couple.
`They send a message to everyone:
`each person's contribution, big or small,
`makes a difference. Every individual
`can help save a life—one life.”
`
`TIME, DECEMBER12, 2005
`
`Iraqi people from the kind of terrorism
`practiced under Saddam Hussein? Yet
`our own governmentcondonesterrorist
`tactics, torture and murder when they
`suitits purpose. I pray we neveragainal-
`low a President to hold office who con-
`
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 14
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 14 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`
`
`Use your MasterCard" this season and you'll be automatically entered in our
`“A Home For The Holidays” Sweepstakes:’* You even get double entries when
`you shopat participating Sears. So maybe you'll win a new home sweet
`homeand you can invite everyone over. Go to winanewhouse.com.
`there are some things money can’t buy. for everything else there’s MasterCard.”
`
`a home
`for the: holidays
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`‘Abbreviated Rulos. No Purchase Necessary To Participate, Enter, Win, or Receive a Prize. PIN-Based & International Transactions Not fae Cnee Purchasing Will Not
`Increase Your Odds of Winning. Begins {1/1/05 at 12:00:01AM Central Time (“CT”) & ends 12/31/05 at 11:59:59PM CT(“Promotion Period’) OyeaeECOUgo US, BC, & PR, 18+. For
`50 US & DC automatic entry during Promotion Period, receive: One entry tor each US based MasterCard transaction; One additional entry for each MasterCard transaction at participating US based
`Sears branded stores
`of online at sears.com; & one additional entry for each US based PayPass tap or swipe transaction. To entar without purchase & receive three entries, hand print your name.
`complete mailing address, age & phone ona 3°x 5° piece of paper & mailit in a sealed envelope to be rec'd by 1/9/06 to: MasterCard A Home for the Holidays” Sweepstakes, PO. Box 15183
`hseOUTERMOU Rebel eae RCMLma rm CMsre Ml MosCm MeRmsCl
`obligation) (ARV=$350,000). Odds of winning depend on numberof eligible entries rec'd. Taxes are winnor's sole responsibility Void whore prohibited, Fortull Official Rules, participating Sears
`locations, & complete details,
`send an SASE to: MasterCard A Home for
`the Holxtays™ Sweepstakes Rules, P.O. Box 13108, Bridgeport, CT 06573-3106 or visit wweemastercard.com or
`PASEpsctReet MAM RMNeLme NecLmurlod Meesarate anaitoecman:Me)RUM alec meetmeCee
`Plain Road, Danbury, CT 0681 1/www-projectsupport.com.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 15
`
`

`

`THE #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER—
`DTMETlrLe
`
`
`
`
`4BAY
`
`“is exceptionally good at
`what he does... indeed,
`right now in this country,
`nobody doesit better.”
`
`—The Washington Post
`
`“like @ meticulous
`
`takes great care
`creating his setup.”
`—People
`
`“A fast-paced, fun
`read with echoesof
`something deeper...
`crisp, sharp prose.”
`—The Boston Globe
`
`siders the physical, spiritual, emotional
`and psychologicaldestruction of another
`person to be just and right.
`PauL G. SHANK
`Santa Barbara,Calif.
`
`WERE SADDAM’S TORTURE CHAMBERS
`worse than ours? The Iraqis must be
`longing forthe good old days beforetheir
`country wasdestroyed.
`EDAN MILTON HUGHES
`San Francisco
`
`WhoShall Live?
`IN THE ARTICLE ABOUTA NEW METHODOF
`
`screeningfetuses for Down syndromein
`the first trimester [Nov. 21], TIME asked,
`“Is a life with the syndromeworth liv-
`ing?” We pride ourselves on ourtoler-
`ance. Yet encouragement to terminate
`less-than-perfect pregnancies will surely
`lead to more discrimination against the
`living handicapped. Can wepraise our-
`selves as a nondiscriminatory society
`when we question whether people who
`are not the most highly functioning are
`worth saving—let alone worth tolerating
`or protecting?
`
`MEGAN SMYLIE
`Vernon Hills,Ill.
`
`LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
`Our e mail address is fetters@time.com.
`Please donot send attachments
`Our fax numberis 1 212-522-8949
`Or you can send yourletter ta TIME Magazine
`Letters, Time & Life Building, Rockefeller
`Center, New York, NY. 10020
`Letters should include the writer’s full name,
`address and home telephone and maybe
`edited for purposes of clarity and space
`CUSTOMER SERVICE AND CHANGE OF ADDRESS
`For 24/7 service, please use our website:
`wwwtime.com/customerservice. You can also
`call 1-800-843-8463 or write to TIMEat
`PO. Box 30601, Tampa, Fla. 33630-0601
`BACK ISSUES
`Contactus at help.single@customersvc.com,
`or call 1-800-274-6800
`REPRINTS AND PERMISSIONS
`Informationis available at the website
`wwwtime.com/time/reprints
`To request custom reprints, photocopy
`permission orcontentlicensing, e mail
`timereprints us@timeinc.com,or fax
`1-212-522-1623
`
`
`
`|
`NEW YORK TIMES BESTSE|TOce
`
`
`
`SRST
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“[THE BROKERis]
`
`Grisham living up to
`
`his reputation as a
`great storyteller.”
`
`
`—USA Today
`
`Look for all of John Grisham’s blockbusters in paperback:
`
`
`
`The Last Juror ¢ Bleachers « The King of Torts « The Summons « A Painted House
`The Brethren ® The Testament ¢ The Street Lawyer © The Partner ¢ The Rainmaker
`The Runaway Jury «© The Chamber e The Client e The Pelican Brief ® The Arm @ A Time to Kill
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`
`
`= Wherever paperbacksare sold * www.jgrisham.com
`pet! Also available in Random House Audio and Large Print Editions
`
`ADVERTISING
`For advertising rates and our editorial calendar,
`visit timemediakit.com
`SYNDICATION
`For international licensing and syndication
`requests, e-mail syndication@timeinc.com,
`or call 1-212-522-5868
`
`
`
`
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Exhibit 2005
`
`Page 16
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 16 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`Dont take high
`car Insurance rates
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 17
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 17 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`lying down.
`
`geico.com
`
`Call now for a FREE rate quote
`1-800-624-8312
`
`

`

`Contact GEICO today and you could
`save 15% on car insurance!
`
`Hundreds of dollars back in your pocket.
`In a recent survey, new GEICO customers report
`average annual savings over $500. And that’s just
`one reason over 3 million drivers switched to
`GEICOlast year.
`
`to update your
`Helpful service 24/7. Want
`policy on a Saturday? Need to file a claim on
`Thanksgiving Day? No problem! You can call or
`visit us online any time of the day, any day of the
`year and receive courteous and efficient service
`every time.
`
`Fast, fair claim handling. Our claims process
`begins the moment you contact us. This enables
`us to settle many claims within 48 hours of
`hearing from you. With over 1,800 facilities
`across the country, we make handling your claim
`
`to a
`easy and convenient. Bring your car
`GEICO-recommended shop and we can guarantee
`your claimrepairs for as long as you ownthecar.
`
`Protecting drivers since 1936. GEICO is the
`nation’s fourth-largest auto insurer, and we've
`earned a solid reputation.
`In fact, A.M. Best
`Company — leading independent analysts of the
`insurance
`industry — consistently awards
`GEICO with an A++ (Superior)
`rating for
`financial stability.
`
`Call or visit us online. See how your current
`premium matches up against
`low GEICOrates.
`For the fastest service, grab a pencil, your current
`car insurance policy and all driver’s license and
`vehicle ID (VIN) numbers.
`
`
`
`
`Bodily Injury:
`Per Person
`
`Per Occurrence
`
`
` Property Damage: |CAR 1
`
`
`
`
`Per Occurrence| | CAR2 |
`
`) Personal injury Protection
`CAR1 |
`
`or Medica! Payments:
`
`
` Per Person CAR2 |
`
`Uninsured Motorists:
`
`Per Person
`
`Per Occurrence
`
`Property Damage|CAR 2
`Comprebensive {Your Car):
`CAR 1
`
`Deductible
`CAR2
`
`Collision (Your Car):
`|CAR1
`
` Deductible CAR2
` Emergency Road
`
`
`
`Service:
`CAR2
`Goevment Enployces newmceCo. *GECO Genera owanceCo. * GEICO betemmityCo.» GHCO Casmatty Co
`
`
`
`These companies are subsidiaries of Berkshire itathaway inc. Average savings mfamation based on GEICO
`GEICO SAVES YOU
`THIS MUCH
`$
`New Polcybokier Sarveydate through February 205. GEC0auto emmrance is ont avedable in Mans.
`GEICO Washmgtan, DC 20076 © 205 GEICO
`
`
`
`CARI
`
`Start enjoying the savings — get a quote today!
`1-800-624-8312
`
`or check the yellow pages for an office near you.
`
`GEICO.
`geico.com
`
`IPR2022-01347
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 18
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 18 of 38
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`

`

`MUSICIAN * ACTIVIST ® SURVIVOR
`
`MELISSA ETHERIDGE
`GREATEST HITS] THE ROAD LESS TRAVELED
`
`* CD/DVD DELUXE EDITION
`
`o>
`
`g—J
`
`
`MELISSAETHERIOGE
`IPR2022-01347
`
`a eeLid
`ao
`Thousands of Possibilities
`
`WWW. MELISSAETHERIDGE.COM ==... cowany
`005 UNIVERSAL MUSIC ENTERPRISES, A DIVISION OF UMG RECORDINGS. INC
`
`DNA Genotek Inc. Exhibit2005
`Spectrum Solutions L.L.C. v. DNA Genotek Inc.
`
`Page 19
`
`DNA GenotekInc. - IPR2023-01424
`
`Exhibit 2011 - Page 19 of 38
`SpectrumSolutions L.L.C. v. DNA GenotekInc.
`
`

`

`Advertisement
`
`Who
`will be
`the
`2005
`TIME
`Person
`of the
`Year?
`
`Let your voice be heard at
`TIME.com/POY
`
`Where you can:
`® Vote in the Person of the Year Poll
`
`® Post your POY nomination
`* Check out the POY choices of
`leading commentators
`® Toke the ultimate POY quiz
`
`CHRYSLER
`= >_ ae
`2
`
`CHRYSLER.COM
`
`Inspired Presenter of the
`Person ofthe Year Poll
`
`
`
`
`Some Past Honorees Give
`Their Picks forThis Year
`
`asked prominentindividuals,
`To helpus maketheselection,
`including previous Personsof the Year, whom they would choose
`
`ALL32
`
`Former President of
`the Soviet Union, 1987
`Manofthe Year, 1989
`Man ofthe Decade
`I note that Ted Tumer
`I
`has nominated
`wouldlike to endorse that.
`We have metonseveral
`occasions, and I have beenimpressed by
`hisactions. He has been avoiceforthe
`poor,for the environment, forpeace—and
`for the emergingglobalcivil society.
`
`OneofthreeApollo 8
`astronauts, pioneerson
`theepic questforthemoon
`I suggest special counsel
`In
`this age of cover-ups,
`political intrigue,
`corporate greed and
`19
`not knowing whom tobelieve,itis
`refreshing to see a person who
`searches for and uncovers