US011995685B2
`
`a2 United States Patent
`
`Proctor, Jr. et al.
`
`ao) Patent No.: US 11,995,685 B2
`
`(54)
`
`(71)
`
`(72)
`
`(73)
`
`)
`
`@1
`(22)
`
`(65)
`
`(63)
`
`(1)
`
`(52)
`
`EFFICIENT AND SECURE
`COMMUNICATION USING WIRELESS
`SERVICE IDENTIFIERS
`
`Applicant: Proxicom Wireless LL.C, Indialantic,
`FL (US)
`
`Inventors: James A. Proctor, Jr., Indialantic, FL.
`(US); James Arthur Proctor, III,
`Indialantic, FL. (US)
`
`Assignee: Proxicom Wireless LL.C, Indialantic,
`FL (US)
`
`Notice: Subject to any disclaimer, the term of this
`patent is extended or adjusted under 35
`U.S.C. 154(b) by 0 days.
`
`This patent is subject to a terminal dis-
`claimer.
`
`Appl. No.: 18/204,528
`Filed: Jun. 1, 2023
`
`Prior Publication Data
`
`US 2023/0325881 Al Oct. 12, 2023
`
`Related U.S. Application Data
`
`Continuation of application No. 17/942,197, filed on
`Sep. 12, 2022, now Pat. No. 11,687,971, which is a
`
`45) Date of Patent: *May 28, 2024
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`CPC ......... HO04W 4/80; HO4W 8/005; HO4W 4/02;
`HO4L 61/5038; HO4L 67/306; HO4AL
`61/6022
`(Continued)
`(56) References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`5,121,126 A 6/1992 Clagett
`5,541,604 A 7/1996 Meier
`
`(Continued)
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`CA 2506121 Al 4/1997
`CA 2218268 Al 5/1998
`(Continued)
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Mandate dated Oct. 27, 2023, United States Court of Appeals,
`Federal Circuit, Target Corporation v. Proxicom Wireless LLC.
`
`(Continued)
`
`Primary Examiner — Khaled M Kassim
`Assistant Examiner — Jason A Harley
`
`(74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — VLP Law Group, LLP;
`David J. Thibodeau, Jr.
`
`(57) ABSTRACT
`
`Systems and methods are provided for reducing communi-
`cations between servers and a mobile device and providing
`enhanced security and privacy to wireless beacon services.
`
`(Continued) This can involve a broadcast device transmitting a beacon
`transmission using a short range wireless radio, such a
`21545718 J12 (2009.01) Bh}etoqth or WiFi, and including.a MAC. address, a first
`unique identifier, and a beacon service identifier. The mobile
`GOIS 1/68 (2006.01) device then selects one or more unique identifiers from
`(Continued) received beacon transmissions, by filtering (that is, select-
`U.S. Cl. ing) those beacon transmissions which include the beacon
`CPC ......... G060 30/0261 (2013.01); GO6F 21/60 service identifier. The wireless device then takes further
`(2013.01); GO6Q 10/0875 (2013.01); action, if the first unique identifier is present among the
`
`(Continued) (Continued)
`
`Davice 1 detects Device 2 dentfer (DI2)
`
`Server detodts That accourt assaciated
`06 swith antity 2 wih D22 requasts content
`o be sent o davices In proximly.
`
`espanse: Yes,
`o7 |Device 2 Entiy ldentier €12}, |
`
`Entlly detalls (ame, etc)
`Request Dispiay: contant
`
`toplay content.
`
`505 | Requast permission from Devics 1 entty
`fom Device 2 eniity.
`
`905
`
`£
`
`Response:
`oo content 1 be played™ |
`
`Broadcast and mobile device interaction
`
`Google Exhibit 1001
`Google v. SecCommTech
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`
`Page 2
`selected one or more unique identifiers, using stored infor- HO4L 101/622 (2022.01)
`mation from the server. The stored information may be Ho4Ww 88/06 (2009.01)
`delivered to the wireless device in response to the wireless (52) U.S. CL
`
`device sending the first unique identifier to a server, or the CPC ... G06Q 20/202 (2013.01); GO6Q 20/3224
`stored information may have been previously downloaded. (2013.01); GO6Q 20/3278 (2013.01); GO6Q
`. . 20/385 (2013.01); GO6Q 20/4016 (2013.01);
`87 Claims, 14 Drawing Sheets G060 30/0207 (2013.01); GO6Q 30/0222
`(2013.01); GO6Q 30/0226 (2013.01); GO6Q
`30/0242 (2013.01); GO6Q 30/0282 (2013.01);
`s G060 30/0601 (2013.01); GO6Q 30/0623
`Related U.S. Application Data (2013.01); GO6Q 50/01 (2013.01); HO4L
`continuation of application No. 17/366,826, filed on 63/20 (2013.01); HO4L 67/306 (2013.01);
`Jul. 2, 2021, now Pat. No. 11,443,344, which is a HO4L 67/52 (2022.05); HO4L 67/54 (2022.05);
`continuation of application No. 16/817,896, filed on HO4L 69/18 (2013.01); HO4W 4/023
`Mar. 13, 2020, now Pat. No. 11,074,615, which is a (2013.01); HO4W 4/029 (2018.02); HO4W
`continuation of application No. 14/861,563, filed on HO4W 12/02 (2013.01); HO4W 12/04
`
`ation of application No. 13/775,435, filed on Feb. 25,
`2013, now Pat. No. 8,849,698, which is a continu-
`ation of application No. 13/212,723, filed on Aug. 18,
`2011, now Pat. No. 8,385,896, which is a continuation
`of application No. 12/364,828, filed on Feb. 3, 2009, (56)
`now Pat. No. 8,090,359.
`
`(58) Field of Classification Search
`USPC oo 370/329; 455/456.3
`See application file for complete search history.
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`(60) Provisional application No. 61/095,359, filed on Sep.
`
`9, 2008, provisional application No. 61/095,001, filed g:g;(l):;% fi 1?;}33; Efi%fig et al.
`
`on Sep. 8, 2008. 5,745,037 A 4/1998 Guthrie et al.
`5,767,503 A 6/1998 Gloton
`
`(51) Int.CL 5,804,803 A 9/1998 Cragun et al.
`
`5,815,811 A 9/1998 Pinard et al.
`
`GOGF 21/60 (2013'01) 5,901,303 A 5/1999 Chew
`
`G060 10/0875 (2023.01) 5977877 A 11/1999 Mcculloch et al.
`
`G060 20/20 (2012.01) 5,987,011 A 11/1999 Toh
`
`G060 20/32 (2012.01) 6,002,918 A 12/1999 Heiman et al.
`
`G060 20/38 (2012.01) 6,043,747 A 3/2000 Altenhofen
`6,049,711 A 4/2000 Ben-Yehezkel et al.
`
`G06Q 20/40 (2012'01) 6,067,297 A 5/2000 Beach
`
`G06Q 30/0207 (2023.01) 6,081,629 A 6/2000 Browning
`
`G06Q 30/0226 (2023.01) 6,091,342 A 7/2000 Janesch et al.
`
`GO6Q 30/0242 (2023.01) 6,151,647 A 11/2000 Sarat
`
`G06Q 30/0251 (202301) 6,163,771 A 12/2000 Walker et al.
`
`6,188,681 Bl 2/2001 Vesuna
`
`G06Q 30/0282 (2023.01) 6,199,048 Bl 3/2001 Hudetz et al.
`G060 30/0601 (2023.01) 6,233,565 Bl 5/2001 Lewis et al.
`G060 50/00 (2012.01) 6.236,674 Bl 5/2001 Morelli et al.
`H04B /00 (2006.01) S22 Bl 712002 Coon
`
`R R ohen
`HO4L 9/40 (2022.01) 6,439,345 Bl 8/2002 Recktenwald et al.
`HO4L 67/306 (2022.01) 6446208 Bl 9/2002 Gujar et al.
`HO4L 67/52 (2022.01) 6,487,540 Bl 11/2002 Smith et al.
`HO4L 67/54 (2022.01) 6,487,601 B1 11/2002 Hubacher et al.
`HO04L 69/18 (2022.01) 6,493,550 Bl 12/2002 Raith
`HO4W 4/00 (2018.01) S3000 Bl 2003 Baardetal
`Ho4w 4/02 (2018.01) 6.587.034 Bl 7/2003 Heiman et al.
`HO4W 4/029 (2018.01) 6,601,040 Bl 7/2003 Kolls
`HO4W 421 (2018.01) 6,615,804 B2 9/2003 Matthews et al.
`HO4W 4/80 (2018.01) 6,616,049 Bl 9/2003 Barkan et al.
`
`6,629,149 Bl 9/2003 Fraser et al.
`
`Ho4w 8/00 (2009.01) 6.675.017 Bl 1/2004 Zellner et al.
`HO4W 8/26 (2009.01) 6,675,153 Bl 1/2004 Cook et al.
`HO4W 12/02 (2009.01) 6,700,535 B2 3/2004 Gilkes et al.
`HO4W 12/04 (2021.01) 6712274 B2 3/2004 Dvorkis ot al.
`,715, vorkis
`gzjg ;ij?g %8?%81) 6,716,101 Bl 4/2004 Meadows et al.
`(2018.01) 6.738.808 Bl 52004 Zellner et al.
`HO4W 88/18 (2009.01) 6,788,702 Bl 9/2004 Garcia-Luna-Aceves et al.
`
`HO4L 61/5038 (2022.01) 6,791,997 B2 9/2004 Beyer et al.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`
`Page 3
`
`(56)
`
`6,799,049
`6,837,436
`6,845,338
`6,857,021
`6,868,079
`6,901,270
`6,909,399
`6,909,721
`6,929,149
`6,934,535
`6,965,914
`6,970,850
`6,978,165
`6,990,587
`6,993,049
`7,003,283
`7,005,968
`7,010,267
`7,016,336
`7,020,106
`7,030,761
`7,030,812
`7,039,027
`7,039,358
`7,065,559
`7,126,926
`7,127,236
`7,142,120
`7,142,527
`7,151,764
`7,156,311
`7,158,756
`7,167,487
`7,173,922
`7,173,923
`7,174,031
`7,177,594
`7,181,521
`7,185,204
`7,194,438
`7,197,326
`7,200,132
`7,206,820
`7,207,480
`7,209,468
`7,213,742
`7,213,743
`7,221,668
`7,233,801
`7,233,960
`7,245,602
`7,246,149
`7,249,182
`7,254,406
`7,280,836
`7,280,847
`7,289,810
`7,302,256
`7,305,245
`7,313,120
`7,315,944
`7,322,043
`7,324,824
`7,324,957
`7,327,701
`7,330,112
`7,339,909
`7,340,438
`7,340,439
`7,342,876
`7,343,564
`7,346,341
`7,349,871
`7,359,674
`7,363,494
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`Bl
`B2
`Bl
`Bl
`Bl
`Bl
`Bl
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`Bl
`
`9/2004
`1/2005
`1/2005
`2/2005
`3/2005
`5/2005
`6/2005
`6/2005
`8/2005
`8/2005
`11/2005
`11/2005
`12/2005
`1/2006
`1/2006
`2/2006
`2/2006
`3/2006
`3/2006
`3/2006
`4/2006
`4/2006
`5/2006
`5/2006
`6/2006
`10/2006
`10/2006
`11/2006
`11/2006
`12/2006
`1/2007
`1/2007
`1/2007
`2/2007
`2/2007
`2/2007
`2/2007
`2/2007
`2/2007
`3/2007
`3/2007
`4/2007
`4/2007
`4/2007
`4/2007
`5/2007
`5/2007
`5/2007
`6/2007
`6/2007
`7/2007
`7/2007
`7/2007
`8/2007
`10/2007
`10/2007
`10/2007
`11/2007
`12/2007
`12/2007
`1/2008
`1/2008
`1/2008
`1/2008
`2/2008
`2/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`3/2008
`4/2008
`4/2008
`
`Zellner et al.
`Swartz et al.
`Willins et al.
`Schuster et al.
`Hunt
`
`Beach
`
`Zegelin et al.
`Ekberg et al.
`Selfridge et al.
`Pyhaelammi
`Dowling
`
`Freeny, Jr.
`Martinez et al.
`Willins et al.
`Davies
`
`Hiltunen et al.
`Bridgelall
`Vanluijt et al.
`Soerensen
`Barnard et al.
`Bridgelall et al.
`Bekritsky et al.
`Bridgelall
`Shellhammer et al.
`Weiss
`
`Bjorklund et al.
`Khan et al.
`Charych et al.
`Garcia-Luna-Aceves
`Heinonen et al.
`Attia et al.
`
`Palin et al.
`Herrmann
`Beach
`
`Beach
`
`Rhoads et al.
`Burr
`Knauerhase et al.
`Narayanaswami et al.
`Sovio et al.
`Acampora
`Twitchell, Jr.
`Rhoads et al.
`Geddes
`Twitchell, Jr.
`Birch et al.
`Carlson et al.
`Twitchell, Jr.
`Winn
`
`Boris et al.
`Skubic et al.
`Dowling
`Heinonen et al.
`Beros et al.
`Fuccello et al.
`Goldthwaite et al.
`Jagadeesan et al.
`O’Hara et al.
`
`Alizadeh-Shabdiz et al.
`
`Ekberg et al.
`Dutta et al.
`Letsinger
`Smith et al.
`Boys
`
`Fong
`
`Emigh et al.
`Kotzin
`Nordman et al.
`Burger et al.
`Bellur et al.
`Othmer
`Costa-Requena et al.
`Labrou et al.
`Markki et al.
`Brainard et al.
`
`7,376,433
`7,379,920
`7,386,878
`7,403,120
`7,403,762
`7,412,246
`7,414,988
`7,433,649
`7,433,694
`7,434,723
`7,436,831
`7,440,781
`7,471,954
`7,492,254
`7,502,933
`7,509,131
`7,515,914
`7,522,058
`7,545,784
`7,546,141
`7,580,699
`7,590,246
`7,616,124
`7,620,026
`7,630,986
`7,647,024
`7,647,055
`7,661,132
`7,702,108
`7,711,100
`7,711,620
`7,714,712
`7,716,484
`7,729,326
`7,756,467
`7,768,415
`7,773,995
`7,774,231
`7,775,430
`7,822,000
`7,826,425
`7,836,512
`7,848,765
`7,876,701
`7,877,082
`7,886,962
`7,904,952
`7,936,736
`7,942,337
`7,952,481
`7,962,369
`7,963,441
`7,965,983
`7,991,644
`7,991,664
`8,005,465
`8,014,755
`8,024,272
`8,073,795
`8,089,405
`8,090,359
`8,112,794
`8,116,749
`8,121,917
`8,160,495
`8,185,133
`8,204,039
`8,205,240
`8,229,458
`8,233,841
`8,254,338
`8,275,359
`8,295,819
`8,321,913
`8,332,521
`8,352,323
`8,364,171
`8,369,842
`8,374,592
`
`5/2008
`5/2008
`6/2008
`7/2008
`7/2008
`8/2008
`8/2008
`10/2008
`10/2008
`10/2008
`10/2008
`10/2008
`12/2008
`2/2009
`3/2009
`3/2009
`4/2009
`4/2009
`6/2009
`6/2009
`8/2009
`9/2009
`11/2009
`11/2009
`12/2009
`1/2010
`1/2010
`2/2010
`4/2010
`5/2010
`5/2010
`5/2010
`5/2010
`6/2010
`7/2010
`82010
`8/2010
`82010
`82010
`10/2010
`11/2010
`11/2010
`12/2010
`1/2011
`1/2011
`2/2011
`3/2011
`5/2011
`5/2011
`5/2011
`6/2011
`6/2011
`6/2011
`8/2011
`8/2011
`8/2011
`9/2011
`9/2011
`12/2011
`1/2012
`1/2012
`2/2012
`2/2012
`2/2012
`4/2012
`5/2012
`6/2012
`6/2012
`7/2012
`7/2012
`82012
`9/2012
`10/2012
`11/2012
`12/2012
`1/2013
`1/2013
`2/2013
`2/2013
`
`Hose
`
`Leung et al.
`Fernando et al.
`Duron et al.
`Morgan et al.
`Lewis et al.
`Jones et al.
`Toulis et al.
`Morgan et al.
`White et al.
`Miller et al.
`Beach et al.
`Brachet et al.
`Bandy et al.
`Jakobsson et al.
`Krumm et al.
`Herrod et al.
`Light et al.
`Mgrdechian et al.
`Leon et al.
`Shaw et al.
`Calmels et al.
`Paessel et al.
`Anschutz et al.
`Herz et al.
`Wang et al.
`Gum et al.
`Ohkubo et al.
`Amon et al.
`Dennis
`Abifaker
`Emigh et al.
`Kaliski, Ir.
`Sekhar
`
`Bent et al.
`Blackadar
`Rappaport et al.
`Pond et al.
`
`Lin
`
`Sekhar
`
`Sekhar
`
`Mizuki et al.
`Phillips et al.
`Li et al.
`
`Eagle et al.
`Vawter
`
`Yeap et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Jain
`Shoarinejad et al.
`Rosenberg
`Emmons et al.
`Swan et al.
`Bryant et al.
`Stone
`Salokannel et al.
`Sun et al.
`Doran et al.
`Honisch
`Piersol et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Little et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Insolia et al.
`Khedouri et al.
`Billmaier et al.
`Beach et al.
`Ansari et al.
`Busch
`
`Griffin et al.
`Anschutz et al.
`Drennan
`Kaplan et al.
`Turnbull et al.
`Chang et al.
`Fisher
`
`Busch
`
`Proctor et al.
`Proctor et al.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`
`Page 4
`(56) References Cited 2004/0243519 A1 12/2004 Perttila et al.
`2004/0245332 Al 12/2004 Silverbrook et al.
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS 2004/0260608 Al 12/2004 Lewis et al.
`2004/0264404 Al 12/2004 Zegelin
`8,385,896 B2 2/2013 Proctor et al. 2004/0264466 Al 12/2004 Huang
`8,385,913 B2 2/2013 Proctor et al. 2005/0038876 Al 2/2005 Chaudhuri
`8,478,300 B2 7/2013 Kuehnel et al. 2005/0047385 Al 3/2005 Otsuka
`8,543,500 B2 9/2013 Ogilvy 2005/0054350 Al 3/2005 Zegelin
`8,559,968 B2 10/2013 Frank et al. 2005/0068928 Al 3/2005 Smith ... HO04W 48/16
`8,576,846 B2 11/2013 Kumar et al. 370/338
`8,599,814 Bl 12/2013 Vleugels et al. 2005/0086211 Al 4/2005 Mayer
`8,688,570 B2 4/2014 Jones et al. 2005/0096031 Al 5/2005 Sugaya et al.
`8,780,945 B2 7/2014 Gips et al. 2005/0099291 Al 5/2005 Landau
`8,787,575 B2 7/2014 Laaksonen et al. 2005/0113090 Al 5/2005 Sharony
`8,825,538 B2 9/2014 Insolia et al. 2005/0114654 Al 5/2005 Brackett et al.
`8,959,187 B2 2/2015 Li et al. 2005/0124359 Al 6/2005 Willins et al.
`9,038,129 B2 5/2015 Proctor et al. 2005/0131837 Al 6/2005 Sanctis et al.
`9,137,012 B2 9/2015 Bailey et al. 2005/0136845 Al 6/2005 Masuoka et al.
`9,161,164 B2 10/2015 Proctor et al. 2005/0136891 Al 6/2005 Wang et al.
`9,264,991 Bl 2/2016 Vleugels et al. 2005/0156026 Al 7/2005 Ghosh et al.
`9,373,001 Bl 6/2016 Belser et al. 2005/0165667 Al 7/2005 Cox
`9,646,319 B2 5/2017 Hammond et al. 2005/0174975 Al 8/2005 Mgrdechian et al.
`9,659,285 B2 5/2017 Hunter et al. 2005/0180367 Al 8/2005 Dooley et al.
`9,734,198 B2 8/2017 Taylor 2005/0185615 Al 8/2005 Zegelin
`9,805,347 B2 10/2017 Hurry 2005/0187873 Al 8/2005 Labrou et al.
`10,133,527 B2 11/2018 Chang et al. 2005/0187959 Al 82005 Jung ..o, HO04L 67/14
`10,140,072 B2 11/2018 Chang et al. 2005/0188062 Al 8/2005 Li et al.
`10,387,087 B2 8/2019 Chang et al. 2005/0213553 Al 9/2005 Wang
`10,489,096 B2 11/2019 Chang et al. 2005/0243737 Al 11/2005 Dooley et al.
`10,639,552 B2 5/2020 Vock et al. 2005/0243781 Al 11/2005 Vesuna et al.
`10,642,576 B2 5/2020 Chang et al. 2005/0250552 Al 11/2005 Eagle et al.
`10,873,906 B2 12/2020 Vleugels et al. 2005/0266868 Al 12/2005 Fuccello
`11,012,934 B2 52021 Vleugels et al. 2005/0273440 Al 12/2005 Ching
`11,074,615 B2 7/2021 Proctor et al. 2006/0003785 Al 1/2006 Zatezalo
`11,122,504 B1 9/2021 Vleugels et al. 2006/0022038 Al 2/2006 Hewlin et al.
`11,252,659 B2 2/2022 Vleugels et al. 2006/0029024 Al 2/2006 Zeng et al.
`2001/0003191 Al 6/2001 Kovacs et al. 2006/0030335 Al 2/2006 Zellner et al.
`2001/0036200 Al 11/2001 Nelson et al. 2006/0032901 Al 2/2006 Sugiyama et al.
`2002/0032746 Al 3/2002 Lazaridis 2006/0045042 Al 3/2006 Sethi et al.
`2002/0061009 Al 5/2002 Sorensen 2006/0046709 Al 3/2006 Krumm et al.
`2002/0065720 Al 5/2002 Carswell et al. 2006/0047835 Al 3/2006 Greaux
`2002/0073027 Al 6/2002 Hui et al. 2006/0050728 Al 3/2006 Sung et al.
`2002/0077083 Al 6/2002 Zellner et al. 2006/0069922 Al 3/2006 Jelinek et al.
`2002/0077118 Al 6/2002 Zellner et al. 2006/0079284 Al 4/2006 Lu et al.
`2002/0101993 Al 8/2002 Eskin 2006/0085419 Al 4/2006 Rosen
`2002/0123965 Al 9/2002 Phillips 2006/0089134 Al 4/2006 Moton et al.
`2002/0128932 A1 9/2002 Yung et al. 2006/0089876 Al 4/2006 Boys
`2002/0131445 Al 9/2002 Skubic et al. 2006/0094447 Al 5/2006 Zellner
`2002/0161666 Al 10/2002 Fraki et al. 2006/0095348 Al 5/2006 Jones et al.
`2002/0188565 Al 12/2002 Nakamura et al. 2006/0095349 Al 52006 Morgan et al.
`2002/0188656 Al 12/2002 Patton et al. 2006/0099966 Al 52006 Moton et al.
`2003/0021250 Al 1/2003 Willins et al. 2006/0104200 A1~ 52006 Park
`2003/0028481 Al 2/2003 Flitcroft et al. 2006/0104243 A1 52006 Park
`2003/0045272 Al 3/2003 Burr 2006/0106850 Al 5/2006 Morgan et al.
`2003/0053484 Al 3/2003 Sorenson et al. 2006/0111045 Al 5/2006 Orlassino et al.
`2003/0074259 Al 4/2003 Slyman et al. 2006/0114104 Al 6/2006 Scaramozzino
`2003/0100328 Al 5/2003 Klein et al. 2006/0116160 Al 6/2006 Fuccello
`2003/0134650 Al 7/2003 Sundar et al. 2006/0125631 Al 6/2006 Sharony
`2003/0149874 Al 8/2003 Balfanz et al. 2006/0141932 Al 6/2006 Lawrence et al.
`2003/0158959 Al 8/2003 Jayapalan et al. 2006/0153085 Al 7/2006 Willins et al.
`2003/0195808 Al 10/2003 Brown et al. 2006/0171341 Al 82006 Wang et al.
`2003/0200140 A1 10/2003 Hars 2006/0193258 Al 8/2006 Ballai
`2003/0200489 Al 10/2003 Hars 2006/0200843 Al 9/2006 Morgan et al.
`2003/0220835 Al 11/2003 Barnes 2006/0217131 Al 9/2006 Alizadeh-Shabdiz et al.
`2003/0224787 Al 12/2003 Gandolfo 2006/0229058 Al 10/2006 Rosenberg
`2004/0019564 Al 1/2004 Goldthwaite et al. 2006/0234631 Al 10/2006 Dieguez
`2004/0023640 Al 2/2004 Ballai 2006/0240840 Al 10/2006 Morgan et al.
`2004/0030601 A1 2/2004 Pond et al. 2006/0245373 Al 11/2006 Bajic
`2004/0076136 Al 4/2004 Beach 2006/0245393 Al 11/2006 Bajic
`2004/0082343 Al 4/2004 Kim et al. 2006/0245404 Al 11/2006 Bajic
`2004/0093268 Al 5/2004 Ramchandani et al. 2006/0264212 Al 11/2006 Sekhar
`2004/0097243 Al 5/2004 Zellner et al. 2006/0268746 Al 11/2006 Wijting et al.
`2004/0137886 Al 7/2004 Ross et al. 2006/0268765 Al 11/2006 Bajic et al.
`2004/0167837 Al 82004 Reel et al. 2006/0268834 Al 11/2006 Bajic
`2004/0186768 Al 9/2004 Wakim et al. 2006/0270412 Al 11/2006 Willins et al.
`2004/0190468 Al 9/2004 Saijonmaa 2006/0282738 Al 12/2006 Sohn et al.
`2004/0203895 Al 10/2004 Balasuriya 2006/0287813 Al 12/2006 Quigley
`2004/0205198 Al 10/2004 Zellner et al. 2007/0001904 Al 1/2007 Mendelson
`2004/0208151 Al 10/2004 Haverinen et al. 2007/0002833 Al 1/2007 Bajic
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`
`Page 5
`(56) References Cited 2008/0097851 Al 4/2008 Bemmel et al.
`2008/0097879 Al 4/2008 Sadowski et al.
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS 2008/0099552 Al 5/2008 Grillion
`2008/0102856 Al 5/2008 Fortescue et al.
`2007/0004427 Al 1/2007 Morgan et al. 2008/0104227 Al 5/2008 Birnie et al.
`2007/0004428 Al 1/2007 Morgan et al. 2008/0108308 Al 5/2008 Ullah
`2007/0010278 Al 1/2007 D’Agostino et al. 2008/0109302 Al 5/2008 Salok_annel et al.
`2007/0015549 Al 1/2007 Hernandez et al. 2008/0109741 Al 5/2008 Messing et al.
`2007/0025287 Al 2/2007 Goren et al. 2008/0109843 Al 52008 Ullah
`2007/0026818 Al 2/2007 Willins et al. 2008/0114647 Al 5/2008 Singer et al.
`2007/0030824 Al 2/2007 Ribaudo et al. 2008/0114699 Al 5/2008 Yuan et al.
`2007/0032225 Al 2/2007 Konicek et al. 2008/0114834 Al 5/2008 Miyazaki
`2007/0043828 Al* 2/2007 Famolari ............... HO4L 51/214 2008/0119136 AL 52008 Khazi _
`709/219 2008/0132170 Al 6/2008 A_llzadeh-Shadez et al.
`2007/0049297 Al 3/2007 Gopalan et al. 2008/0132223 Al 6/2008 Lin et al.
`2007/0050258 Al 3/2007 Dohse 2008/0132252 Al 6/2008 Altman et al.
`2007/0060105 Al 32007 Batta 2008/0133336 Al 6/2008 Altman et al.
`2007/0060117 Al 3/2007 Fishman et al. 2008/0133403 Al 6/2008 Hamzeh
`2007/0061487 Al 3/2007 Moore et al. 2008/0136621 Al ~ 6/2008 Malik et al.
`2007/0078851 Al 4/2007 Grell et 3.1 2008/0136845 Al 6/2008 Nakanlshl ............ G09G 3/2025
`2007/0081503 Al 4/2007 Mower 345/690
`2007/0091859 Al 4/2007 Sethi et al. 2008/0139114 Al 6/2008 Ranganathan
`2007/0094084 Al 4/2007 Rau et al. 2008/0139217 Al 6/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz et al.
`2007/0096909 Al 5/2007 Lally 2008/0140714 Al 6/2008 Rhoads et al.
`2007/0100651 Al 5/2007 Ramer et al. 2008/0167961 Al 7/2008 Wentker et al.
`2007/0106612 Al 5/2007 O’Brien et al. 2008/0167988 Al 7/2008 Sun et al.
`2007/0117576 Al 5/2007 Huston 2008/0176583 Al 7/2008 Brachet et al.
`2007/0118748 Al 5/2007 Edney 2008/0177668 Al 7/2008 Delean
`2007/0121534 Al 5/2007 James et al. 2008/0181154 Al 7/2008 Sherman
`2007/0121550 Al 5/2007 Wada 2008/0182591 Al 7/2008 Krikorian
`2007/0133453 Al 6/2007 Sethi et al. 2008/0182592 Al 7/2008 Cha et al.
`2007/0143348 Al 6/2007 Rosenberg 2008/0188261 Al 8/2008 Arnone
`2007/0161382 Al 7/2007 Melinger et al. 2008/0189394 Al 82008 Ross et al.
`2007/0173248 Al 7/2007 Sekhar 2008/0195621 Al 8/2008 Tedesco et al.
`2007/0178886 Al 82007 Wang et al. 2008/0205340 Al 8/2008 Meylan et al.
`2007/0178907 Al /2007 Gopalan ef al. 2008/0208762 Al 82008 Arthur et al.
`2007/0179792 Al 8/2007 Kramer 2008/0214116 Al 9/2008 Leung et al.
`2007/0187491 Al 82007 Godwin et al. 2008/0214166 Al 9/2008 Ramer et al.
`2007/0190494 A1 8/2007 Rosenberg 2008/0220746 Al 9/2008 Ekberg
`2007/0201417 Al* 82007 Malik .......ccooooo..... HO4W 84/12 2008/0222711 Al 9/2008 Michaelis
`370/338 2008/0248815 Al 10/2008 Busch
`2007/0204158 Al 8/2007 Hatashita et al. 2008/0249928 AL 102008 Hill et al.
`2007/0211727 Al 9/2007 Sethi et al. 2008/0255947 Al 102008 Triedman
`2007/0230441 AL 10/2007 Sethi et al. 2008/0261564 AL~ 10/2008 Logan
`2007/0233367 Al 10/2007 Chen of al. 2008/0262928 Al 10/2008 Michaelis
`2007/0237321 Al 10/2007 Bloebaum et al. 2008/0283408 AL 1172008 Jacobsen
`2007/0242643 Al 10/2007 Chandra et al. 2008/0301102 Al 122008 TLiang
`2007/0242765 Al 1012007 Parizhisky et al. 2008/0305738 AL 1272008 Khedouri et al.
`2007/0244633 Al 10/2007 Phillips et al. 2008/0306825 AL 12/2008 Schick et al.
`2007/0244811 Al 10/2007 Tumminaro 2008/0313079 Al 12/2008 Van et al.
`2007/0255653 Al 11/2007 Tumminaro et al. 2008/0313082 AL 12/2008 Van ef al.
`2007/0264968 Al 11/2007 Frank et al. 2009/0016248 AL 172009 Li et al.
`2007/0264991 Al 11/2007 Jones et al. 2009/0016250 AL 12009 Li et al.
`2007/0270099 Al 11/2007 Le Gars 2009/0016255 AL 112009 Park
`2007/0280269 Al 122007 Rosenberg 2009/0016315 AL 172009 Laroia et al.
`2007/0281634 Al 12/2007 Rao et al. 2009/0016353 AL 112009 Li et al.
`2007/0286111 Al 12/2007 Corson et al. 2009/0016524 Al 1/2009 Park et al.
`2008/0002641 Al 1/2008 Hong et al. 2009/0019168 AL 1/2009 Wu et al
`2008/0008117 Al 1/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz 2009/0022096 AL 1/2009 Walley et al.
`2008/0008118 Al 1/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz 2009/0037286 AL~ 2/2009 Foster
`2008/0008119 Al 1/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz 2009/0061901 Al 3/2009 Arrasvuori et al.
`2008/0008120 Al 1/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz 2009/0063624 AL 3/2009 Nordstrom et al.
`2008/0008121 Al 1/2008 Alizadeh-Shabdiz 2009/0085806 AL 4/2009 Piersol et al.
`2008/0009307 Al 1/2008 Sekhar et al. 2009/0099961 AL 4/2009 Ogilvy
`2008/0010190 Al 12008 Rackley et al. 2009/0143104 AL 672009 Toh et al.
`5008/0025282 Al 1/2008 Hong 2009/0170559 Al 7/2009 Phillips
`2008/0036653 Al 2/2008 Huston 2009/0177530 AL 7/2009 King et al.
`2008/0037487 Al 2/2008 Li et al. 2009/0197681 Al 8/2009 Krishnamoorthy et al.
`2008/0039020 Al 2/2008 Eskin 2009/0219132 Al 9/2009 Maytal et al.
`2008/0045236 Al 2/2008 Nahon ef al. 2009/0234728 Al 9/2009 Willuns et al.
`2008/0051033 Al 2/2008 Hymes 2009/0270120 Al 10/2009 Park
`2008/0051059 Al 2/2008 Fisher 2009/0271211 A1 10/2009 Hammad
`2008/0052109 Al 2/2008 Boys 2009/0281904 Al 11/2009 Pharris
`2008/0056215 Al 3/2008 Kopikare et al. 2009/0282130 Al [1/2009 Antoniou et al.
`2008/0070593 Al 3/2008 Altman et al. 2009/0285119 Al 11/2009 Horn et al.
`2008/0071874 Al 3/2008 Roodman et al. 2009/0287827 Al 11/2009 Horn et al.
`2008/0080397 Al 4/2008 Niranjan et al. 2009/0288012 Al 11/2009 Hertel et al.
`2008/0089519 Al 4/2008 Ekberg 2009/0291909 Al 11/2009 Henderson et al.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`Page 6
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`Phillips
`
`Den et al.
`Phillips
`Holloway et al.
`Narayanan et al.
`Haverty
`Magnusson
`Park et al.
`
`Park et al.
`
`Park et al.
`Zaks
`
`Davis et al.
`Matotek et al.
`Gallagher et al.
`Rose et al.
`Royyuru et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Silverbrook et al.
`Bonar et al.
`Behrens
`
`Karam et al.
`Robertson et al.
`Laroia et al.
`Bucuk
`
`Gore et al.
`Haddad et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Carmichael et al.
`Ramer et al.
`Altman et al.
`Kasslin et al.
`
`Lawson-Brown et al.
`
`Choi et al.
`
`Li et al.
`
`Roth
`
`Hillier
`
`Locke et al.
`Proctor et al.
`Middleton et al.
`Samuelsson
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`(56)
`2009/0303250 Al 12/2009
`2009/0303926 Al 12/2009
`2009/0307132 Al 12/2009
`2009/0307133 Al 12/2009
`2009/0310517 Al 12/2009
`2009/0311963 Al 12/2009
`2009/0313105 Al 12/2009
`2009/0323647 Al 12/2009
`2009/0323648 Al 12/2009
`2009/0325601 Al 12/2009
`2010/0020746 Al 1/2010
`2010/0030638 Al 2/2010
`2010/0030651 Al 2/2010
`2010/0041402 Al 2/2010
`2010/0049615 Al 2/2010
`2010/0051685 Al 3/2010
`2010/0062758 Al 3/2010
`2010/0063867 Al 3/2010
`2010/0096450 Al 4/2010
`2010/0124196 Al 5/2010
`2010/0138481 Al 6/2010
`2010/0141437 Al 6/2010
`2010/0201536 Al 8/2010
`2010/0250673 Al 9/2010
`2010/0274859 Al 10/2010
`2010/0284447 Al 11/2010
`2011/0039592 Al 2/2011
`2011/0119733 Al 5/2011
`2012/0066043 Al 3/2012
`2012/0066199 Al 3/2012
`2013/0217332 Al 8/2013
`2015/0200811 Al 7/2015
`2015/0249637 Al 9/2015
`2015/0257104 Al 9/2015
`2015/0281939 Al 10/2015
`2015/0296347 Al 10/2015
`2016/0025837 Al 1/2016
`2016/0093184 Al 3/2016
`2017/0011425 Al 1/2017
`2017/0131994 Al 5/2017
`2019/0250239 Al 8/2019
`CA 2564287 Al
`CA 2235002 Al
`CA 2766024 Al
`CA 2766184 Al
`CA 2688189 Al
`CN 1759620 A
`CN 101036061 A
`CN 101233722 A
`EP 0156856 Al
`EP 1098477 Al
`EP 1207654 A2
`EP 1296155 Al
`EP 2332126 Al
`EP 1908235 Bl
`FR 2752347 Al
`FR 2798749 Al
`JP 2003-152739 A
`SE 0702686 L
`SG 134837
`WO 85/01373 Al
`WO 01/58098 A2
`WO 01/73575 Al
`WO 2007/047181 A2
`WO 2007/081356 A2
`WO 2007/084973 A2
`WO 2008/069446 Al
`WO 2009/050322 Al
`WO 2009/063272 Al
`WO 2010/028182 Al
`
`5/1998
`12/1998
`8/2002
`8/2002
`12/2008
`4/2006
`9/2007
`7/2008
`10/1985
`5/2001
`5/2002
`3/2003
`6/2011
`1/2018
`2/1998
`3/2001
`5/2003
`6/2009
`10/2007
`3/1985
`8/2001
`10/2001
`4/2007
`7/2007
`7/2007
`6/2008
`4/2009
`5/2009
`3/2010
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Judgment dated Sep. 20, 2023, Document 42, United States Court
`of Appeals, Federal Circuit, Target Corporation v. Proxicom Wire-
`less LLC.
`
`Judgment dated Sep. 20, 2023, Document 41, United States Court
`of Appeals, Federal Circuit, Target Corporation v. Proxicom Wire-
`less LLC.
`
`Order dated Dec. 4, 2020, Case No. IPR2020-00978, United States
`Patent trial & Appeal Board, Target Corporation v. Proxicom
`Wireless LLC.
`
`Duflot, et al., “A Formal Analysis of Bluetooth Device Discovery”,
`School of Computer Science, University of Birmingham, 1-16.
`Feldmann, S., et al., “An indoor Bluetooth-based positioning sys-
`tem: concept, Implementation and experimental evaluation,” Insti-
`tute of Communications Engineering.
`
`Fernandez, T., et al., “Bluetooth Sensor Network Positioning Sys-
`tem with Dynamic Calibration,” Dept. of Electronics & Systems,
`University of Coruna, Spain, IEEE 2007, pp. 45-49.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,369,842.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,370,955.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,374,592.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,385,896.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,385,913.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,849,698.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 9,038,129.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 9,161,164.
`
`File History for U.S. Pat. No. 8,090,359.
`
`File History of U.S. Appl. No. 60/814,254, filed Jun. 16, 2006, 44
`pages.
`
`File History of U.S. Pat. No. 7,936,736.
`
`Final Office Action received for U.S. Appl. No. 17/366,826, dated
`Dec. 13, 2021, 42 pages.
`
`Final Office Action; U.S. Appl. No. 12/364,819; dated Jun. 28, 2011.
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 30, 2021,
`IPR2020-00934, U.S. Pat. No. 8,385,896 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (55 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 30, 2021,
`IPR2020-00977, U.S. Pat. No. 8,369,842 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (45 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 30, 2021,
`IPR2020-00979, U.S. Pat. No. 9,161,142 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (51 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 30, 2021,
`IPR2020-00980, U.S. Pat. No. 8,385,913 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (47 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 8, 2021,
`IPR2020-00904, U.S. Pat. No. 7,936,736 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (48 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 8, 2021,
`IPR2020-00931, U.S. Pat. No. 8,090,359 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (51 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 8, 2021,
`IPR2020-00932, U.S. Pat. No. 8,090,359 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (40 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 8, 2021,
`IPR2020-00933, U.S. Pat. No. 8,374,592 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (38 pages).
`
`Final Written Decision per 35 U.S.C. 138 dated Nov. 8, 2021,
`IPR2020-00903, U.S. Pat. No. 9,038,129 B2, Target Corporation v.
`Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C. (41 pages).
`
`Gao et al.,, The Advanced Health and Disaster Aid Network: A
`Light-Weight Wireless Medical System for Triage, ArticlE in IEEE
`Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems—Oct. 2007, 15
`pages.
`
`Gao, J., etal., “P2PPaid: A Peer-to-Peer Wireless Payment System,”
`Proceedings of the 2005 Second IEEE International Workshop on
`Mobile Commerce and Services (WMCSO05), 10 pp. (2005).
`Giaglis, G., et al., “On the Potential Use of Mobile Positioning
`Technologies in Indoor Environments,” 15th Bled eCommerce
`Conference eReality: Constructing the eEconomy, Bled, Slovenia,
`June 17-19-2002, 18 pp.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US 11,995,685 B2
`Page 7
`
`(56) References Cited
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Golle et al. “Universal re-encryption for mixnets”. In: Topics in
`Cryptology-CT-RSA 2004. Springer, 2004, pp. 163-178.
`
`Hallberg, I., et al., “Positioning with Bluetooth,” Lulea University
`of Technology, Dept. of Computer Science & Electrica Engineering,
`IEEE 2003.
`
`Hari Balakrishnan, et al “Cricket Location System” “Cricket Pre-
`sentation”, 31 pages (2005).
`
`Harrison, B. et al., “Bridging Physical and Virtual Worlds with
`Tagged Documents, Objects and Locations,” Xerox PARC, CHI 99
`May 1-20, 1999, pp. 29-30.
`
`Heeger, David, “Signal Detection Theory Handout,” University of
`Stanford, 1998, www.psych.stanford.edw/.about.lera/psych115s/notes/
`signal/, 7 pages.
`
`Hochmair, H., “1 PDA-Assisted Indoor-Navigation with Imprecise
`Positioning: Results of a Desktop Usability Study,” Dept. of Geog-
`raphy, St. Cloud State University.
`
`Honkanen et al., “Low End Extension for Bluetooth,” Radio and
`Wireless Conference, 2004 IEEE, pp. 199-202.
`http://www.ietf.org/tfc/rfc4793 txt; The EAP Protected One-Time
`Password Protocol (EAP-POTP); 77 pages, Feb. 2007; retrieved
`from Internet Mar. 21, 2012.
`http://www.smartcardalliance.org/resources/lib/Proximity.sub.--
`Mobile.sub.- --payments.sub.--200709.pdf; “Smart Card Alliance”
`39 pages, Sep. 2007; retrieved from Internet Mar. 21, 2012.
`Hunn, Nick, “EZURIO—An Introduction to Wibree” Nov. 2006, 7
`pages.
`
`Huomo et al., PowerPoint Presentation—Project: IEEE P802.15
`Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANSs),
`Submission Tille: [Nokia MAC Proposal for IEEE802.15 TG4], Jul.
`2001, 50 pages.
`
`IEEE Standard for Information Technology Part 11: Wireless Medium
`Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) Specifications,
`IEEE SID 802.11, (2007) 1232 pages.
`
`IEEE Standard for Information Technology Part 15.4: Wireless
`Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) Speci-
`fications for Low-Rate Wireless Personal Area Networks (LR-
`WPANS), IEEE Std 802.15.4, Oct. 1, 2003, 679 pages.
`
`Iftode, L., et al., “Smart Phone: An Embedded System for Universal
`Interactions,” Rutgers University Dept. of computer Sciences, pp.
`1-12 (2004).
`
`International Search Report and Written Opinion dated May 11,
`2018 for Related PCT/US18/12277.
`
`Ismail Guvenc, et al., Enhancements to RSS Based Indoor Tracking
`Systems Using Kalman Filters, Global Signal Processing Expo
`(2003).
`
`Jakobsson et al., “Security Weaknesses in Bluetooth,” D. Naccache
`(Ed.): CT-RSA 2001, LNCS 2020, 2001. ¢ Springer-Verlag Berlin
`Heidelberg 2001, 16 pages.
`
`James Bickers, A Giant of a Self-Service Rollout, Kiosk Market-
`place (Nov. 28, 2005), https://www.kioskmarketplace.com/articles/
`a-giant-of-a-self-service-rollout-3/.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement filed May 22, 2020 with the
`United States District Court, Middle District of Florida, Orlando
`Division.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated Jun. 15, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00934, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-6.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated Jun. 15, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00977, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-6.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated Jun. 15, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00978, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-6.
`
`Order dated Dec. 4, 2020, Case No. IPR2020-00978, United States
`Patent trial & Appeal Board, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom
`Wireless, L.L.C.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated Jun. 15, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00979, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-6.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated Jun. 15, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00980, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-6.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated May 22, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00903, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-28.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated May 22, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00904, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-28.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated May 22, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00931, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-cv-1886-RBD-LRH; pp. 1-28.
`
`Joint Claim Construction Statement, dated May 22, 2020; Case No.
`IPR2020-00932, Target Corporation vs. Proxicom Wireless, L.L.C.;
`C.A. No. 6:19-