IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
`
`CIVIL DIVISION——ASBESTOS
`
`MARLYCE TOTH, Executrix 0f the
`Estate of JAMES TOTH, Deceased, and
`MARLYCE TOTH, in her own right,
`
`CIVIL DIVISION - ASBESTOS
`
`GD No. 15-019197
`
`Plaintiffs,
`
`vs.
`
`BEAZER EAST, INC., et al.,
`
`Defendants.
`
`PLAINTIFFS’ CONSOLIDATED
`
`RESPONSE TO ALL DEFENDANTS’ M(
`
`FOR SUMMARY
`JUDGMENT AND BRIEF
`
`Vol u me 6
`
`Filed on Behalf of Plaintiffs.
`
`Counsel of Record for this Party:
`
`Cori J. Kapusta, Esquire
`PA ID. No. 91958
`
`GOLDBERG, PERSKY & WHITE,
`RC.
`
`1030 Fifth Avenue
`
`Pittsburgh, PA 15219
`(412) 471-3980
`Firm # 744
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`
`

`

`

`

`AFFIDAVIT
`
`COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
`
`COUNTY OF ALLEGHENY
`
`VVV
`
`SS:
`
`AND NOW COMES the undersigned Affiant, Elwood Gaither, who, being ofproper age and
`duly sworn, states the following:
`
`I
`
`PLAIN'HFF’S
`XHI
`
`1.
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`5.
`
`6.
`
`My name is Elwood Gaither and I live at 7049 Bennett Street, Pittsburgh, PA
`1 5208.
`
`I have been employed as a 449 steamfitter here 1972 until the present. I have not
`worked since April 14, 2011 due to my cancer diagnosis.
`
`I have never smoked cigarettes and I only started occasionally smoking a cigar
`within the last ten years. I do not inhale when I smoke the occasional cigar. My
`doctors have told me that the cigars did not cause my lung cancer.
`
`I was exposed to asbestos throughout my career in a variety of different jobs at
`many different facilities. This afifidavit does not list all of my exposures, but only
`the ones that I can remember as of now. Since I have been told that my
`deposition is coming up, Ihave tried to remember as many exposures as I can.
`The more and more I think about my career, the more I am able to remember. I
`am able to provide the name of some products at some locations, but for other
`products, I am able to testify about my use of the product, but I am not able to
`give a location.
`
`Steamfitters routinely work on valves, pumps and other equipment essaafial to
`piping. I have been exposed to asbestos from the work that [have done on the
`following equipment dozens of times from the early 19705 until the mid to late
`19805. To remove packing we would use a packing hook. This could take
`minutes or over an hour. We removed gaskets fiom the bonnet, the inside ofthe
`pump housing, and the flange with a wire brush, sometimes electric, sometimes
`hand held.
`
`I have been exposed to asbestos gaskets and packing floor the following valves.
`The gaskets were both on the flange and in the bonnet. The packing was inside
`the packing stem. Each of these companies supplied their own asbestos gaskets
`and packing at times. Other times, we used generic gaskets and packing.
`I _
`worked on the following valves dozens of times each, which exposed me to
`asbestos on each of those occasions:
`
`

`

`
`
`Cashco valves
`
`DeZurik valves
`Gn‘nnell valves
`
`Honeywell valves
`Crane valves
`
`Yarway valves
`Powell valves
`Milwaukee valves
`ITT valves
`
`Stockham valves
`
`
`
`“-m-H‘P‘snthe21.09'?
`
`I have been exposed to asbestos gaskets from the following steam traps. Each of
`these companies supplied their own asbestos gaskets at times. Other times, we
`used generic gaskets. I worked on the following steam traps dozens of times
`each, which exposed me to asbestos on each of those occasions:
`
`a. Armstrong
`b. Yarway
`c. Sarco
`
`I have been exposed to asbestos gaskets and packing from the following pumps.
`The gaskets were both on the flange and in the bonnet. The packing was inside
`the impellor. Each of these companiessupplied their own asbestos gaskets and
`packing at times. Other times, we used generic gaskets and packing. I worked on
`the following pumps dozens of times each, which exposed me to asbestos on each
`of those occasions:
`
`a. Goulds pumps
`DeLaval pumps
`Nagle pumps
`Ingersoll—Rand
`Buffalo Pumps
`BIaclcmer Pumps
`Armstrong pumps
`Durco pumps
`Dean pumps
`Peerless pumps
`Bell & Gossett pumps
`Aurora Pumps
`
`
`
`Pa‘v'r's‘qarm:19P‘
`
`In. Byron Jackson
`
`I have worked with Black Magic Cerbomndum grinding wheels to sharpen '
`tungsten. I have used other carborundum grinding wheels.
`
`

`

`
`
`10.
`
`11.
`
`12.
`
`13.
`
`14.
`
`15.
`
`16.
`
`17.
`
`I know that Pittsburgh Gage, Plotkin Brothers, George V. Hamilton and PB.
`Wright supplied asbestos products to many of my jobsites. I would see these
`suppliers delivering asbestos cloth, gaskets, packing and tools to many, many of
`the jobsites that I worked at over the years.
`
`I worked on Copes Vulcan soot blowers at Keystone Power Station and Cheswick
`Power Station. I was exposed to asbestos whenl changed out the packing in the
`poppet valves.
`
`I was exposed to asbestos on the coke batteries at USX Clairton and at J&L Steel.
`I was exposed to the rope packing on the doors of the coke ovens as well as the
`insulation on the pipes.
`
`I was exposed to United Conveyor Ash Handling equipment at Keystone Power
`Station. The plant workers used asbestos cement as seals on the equipment in my
`presence. They would mix the cement with water in a bucket and I breathed in
`dust when they dumped the cement.
`
`I have worked around air compressors manufactured by Ingersoll Rand and Joy
`that were being installed. This work exposed me to asbestos as they used gaskets.
`
`I have worked around other outside contractors while at many of my various
`jobsites. Their work at these jobsites
`
`- I have worked around Atlas, Dravo, Minnotte and McCarl‘s when they
`were ripping out asbestos pipe covering and gaskets when removing
`piping-
`
`. I worked around Eichleay as they tore out the blast finance.
`
`- I was exposed to asbestos from Foster Wheeler employees when they
`worked on their boiler at Bruce Mansfield Power Station
`
`- I worked around employees for Power Piping who exposed me to
`asbestos at various jobsites, including US Steel Clairton.
`
`I worked around the pouring of steel in the open hearth of 1&L South Side works
`in 1973 for about six months.
`
`When I worked at the different power stations and steel mills during the 19705
`and through the mid-19805, there were no warnings regarding the hazards of
`asbestos. At each of these facilities, the employees of the premises owner
`‘
`continued to perform their work in my presence, exposing me to different
`asbestos containing products.
`
`

`

`
`
`18.
`
`As a steamfitter apprentice, Ihad six months of class room training for five years,
`as well as on the job training. We learned about the various piping systems,
`valves, pumps, etc. We learned about the use of asbestos on steamlines. Because
`so much of what we had to do involved steam, we always used asbestos gaskets
`and packing. That is what was necessary on steamlines, and so as to avoid an
`accident, we only carried asbestos gaskets and packing. Ifwe had to replace a
`gasket or packing frorn a valve on a cold water line or water pump, we would still
`use asbestos. The above described gaskets and packing all contained asbestos
`until the mid to late 19305.
`
`19.
`
`This Affidavit is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. § 4904 relating to
`unsworn falsification to authorities.
`
`
`
`Dae
`
`

`

`

`

`ILLWIKNHMHHER VOLUM'IC‘
`
`I‘,[ WOOD [Milli] R VOLUME I
`
`IN THE COURT CF C‘LMMCN FEEDS
`OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
`
`‘JIE‘EF-TAPEL
`DEPOSITION OF ELWOUD GAITHER - VOLUME I
`
`tn the Ponnsylvdnid Fules of Civil
`taken pursuant
`Frcrm‘luze, befmo Maziunnc Md:si]ic-, Feqislhipd
`Profnnsfiona] Pcportcr—Nmaiy Fuhlic In and I01 the
`Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. on Tunsday, Ortober
`£5 , EU:
`, at Lhfi offices cf Savinns, D'Amiro 5 Vane,
`3626 Gulf Tower. Pithburqh,
`
`15219, commencing
`
`PA
`
`CED GAITHEF,
`Plaintiff,
`
`US.
`.0. SMITH CCFPLRQTTC‘N,
`et a1”
`
`CIVIL " ASBESTOS
`No. Ll"012554
`
`T‘EPOSITICN
`
`VTDEOTAPED
`h‘U‘Dl’: GAITH‘SF‘.
`
`- VOLUME I
`
`Tuosday, chnhcr 25, 7011
`
`REPRODUCTION AND/OR DISTRIBUTION OF‘
`THIS TFANSCRTFT IS PROHIBITED WITHCIJT h'FITTf-‘N
`AUTHORIZATION FROM THE CERTIFYING AGFNITY
`
`at 10:00 o'clock a.m.
`
`
`[Jr-7284.220
`
`mum ( am mum Maw-Kc
`
`nlmllm Human nucl
`
`Mun-12314920
`
`Malnlmfiwml kqlmng s'cmu-
`
`malnécmmm m1
`
`3-1 WOOD IMII'HER VOLUMI- |
`
`ll WUOBIIAHHI‘R VOLUMI
`
`I
`
`On behalf of
`
`11m Plaintiff:
`
`John R, Kane, Esquire
`Savinis D'Amico 5. Fame
`3626 Gulf Tower
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`PA 15319
`
`On behalf of
`ElFFLIlC:
`
`\hv Defunddan Cranu Co., and Schneider
`
`Maqua Benson, Esquire
`PAL Gatrs, LLP
`K‘EL (3611,93; Center
`210 Sith Avenue
`
`Pittsburqh.
`
`PA
`
`On behalf of Lha Defendaan I.U. Noth Amnrica,
`chLnn, Catalytic ConstruCLiDn, Air .9 Liquid Syfitoms
`f/k/a Buffalo Pumps:
`William D. Hague, Esquire
`Wilbraham LawlPr
`Ii Euba
`
`17 Noth
`Two Gateway Center.
`Pittsburgh,
`PA
`15???
`
`tho Defendants First Energy, and
`On behalf of
`Penelnc, Inc.:
`:‘nsso. Esqlhre
`Anna MV
`willman & Silvagqln
`One Corporate Center
`5500 Ccl'paraie Drlvr‘, Suitr‘
`Pittsburgh,
`PA £5737
`
`1'10
`
`On behalf of th Defendants Search V. HamilTGn
`Inc., and Power Pipinq:
`Mirhap]
`FA Labick. Fuquire
`Willman J. Silvagqio
`()ne COLporate Center
`'1500 Corporate Drivv. SuiLO 150
`Pittsburgh,
`PA 15?17
`
`Inc., Allied
`
`On lwhnlf of H11“ Defendant}: Honeywnll,
`Glcve Ccrpcrazinn, and Bravo:
`Matthew J. 002, Esquire
`Quartz Campbell
`4750 U.S. GLcEl TC-HCI
`600 Gran! Street
`
`PiLsturqh,
`
`PA 15719
`
`1-377-715-620
`
`Mambo Cum Reporting 5mm
`
`mil-(I‘énm-n nel
`
`l-xfir728fi220
`
`Marmlm mm lit-[mung 5mm
`
`mnlm’gmmcm m1
`
`

`

`H WEHL)(‘.AI‘I1£EI(VUI HM]
`
`I
`
`Flu'mD GANH) It \‘UJ [IMP-J
`
`I’uxri
`
`Incl,
`
`On behalf of Lhu Dofendantfi Allngheny anrqy,
`and West Fenn Fowvr Company:
`Nicholas J. Zidlk, E5qu:rP
`SuurLz Campbell
`4750 U.S. 51001 Tower
`6K0 GzanL Stroon
`
`Pittsburqh,
`
`PA 15219
`
`On hphalf of
`
`the flnfcndaan Clvdver Eroakfi,
`
`Inc.,
`
`.B. Writh Company at ?i*f§hulgh, Goulds, Hunzer
`Sales Cnrporatinn, and OSRnM/HTE:
`Edward J. Chiodo, Esquirw
`Groqan Graffam
`FLU: Gchwuy UenLe:
`lPLh Floor
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`PD.
`
`1522?
`
`the ancndants Industrial Holdinqs
`On behalf of
`Company, Milwaukee Valve, and Fuguuo:
`Terry A. Schrock, Esquirn
`Maren Piercn.
`'
`,
`
`Landmarks Building, Suite 25
`PiLsturgh,
`PA
`15719
`
`a
`'hp Defendant CBS Corprratjcn,
`in behalf of
`Delaware ccrrcxaticn,
`fPa Yiarcn,
`Incl, BUCCE
`mriqCF to CBS CorporaLion,
`a Pennsylvania
`corporation [kn WusLinqhousc Elechic Curp.
`Paul Di KrupE-r, Esquize
`Enkerr Roamans Cherin é MellotL,
`U.S. Sine! Towel,
`44Lh Floor
`600 Granl SLreet
`
`Pi
`
`burqh,
`
`PA
`
`the Defendants Aurora Pumps, DeZurih
`On behalf of
`and Safety Firul
`lnduerins
`DF-bcrah I“ lannamnrl‘lli, Esquire
`Maren Pihrce, ZLC
`Landmarks Building, Suite 750
`Pittshurqh,
`PA
`15219
`
`the Defendant Mine SafeLy Appliance
`
`On bnhalf at
`Company:
`Gregory C. Scheurtnq. Jr,, Esquire
`DavieS, McFarland & Carroll, P.R.
`One Ga'wway Center, TonLh Floor
`Pittsburgh,
`PA
`
`I a
`
`V‘flHClH
`
`Mummthquwmwhdwx
`
`Mklglvmbi net
`
`[73"‘7
`
`TMQM
`
`Mar mom aim-mug Savm
`
`mammmmnmm
`
`15222771416
`15719
`15222
`
`1} WI )1 mCiAlTHER VI )E 1 IMM
`
`FJ.WO0D UAT Tl HIR VIWLL'M'ET
`
`the fiofendant Inansollifiand Ccmpany
`On behalf of
`Francis D. Wymard, Esquire (via LPlnphone]
`Burns Wllj LO
`Nnrthshora Cancr
`:06 Isabella Srreet
`
`PLLLSbUIgh,
`
`PA 15212
`
`On bnhalf of :hn firtvndants ITT Ccrperation, Flctkin
`BruLherfi Supply, and Armstronq International
`Shannan E. Non'. Esquirn
`Dickie, Mrcamvy & ChilcoLP
`Two PPG Flare
`{mire 400
`
`PiLsturgh,
`
`PA
`
`15???
`
`Inc., and
`
`:hp vacndan15 Neale Pumps,
`On behalt of
`Armerong Pumps, Tncl:
`Adam Warh01d, Esquire
`Dickie, McCamvy E ChilcoLe
`Tun FFG Plano
`SuiLc 400
`
`Pittsburgh.
`
`PA
`
`mus
`the Deiendanis American Rilfrite, Fapoq
`On behalf of
`vulran, Sarto, Atlas. and Pairmont Supply:
`Amy BIJHkOS, Esquire
`Dickie, McCamey & ChilCoLe
`Two PPG Place
`Sui to 4 DD
`
`Pittsburqh,
`
`PA
`
`13“.?
`
`the Defendants RMI/Pzeminr
`On behalf of
`Refractories. and MCCarl's:
`
`RoberL H. Palumbi, Esquire
`Marks O’Neill O'Brinn a Courtney
`Suite T600 Gulf Tower
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`PA
`
`15219
`
`lnc.,
`On brhalf at LhC Defendaan Beaze: Rant.
`f/k/a
`Thiom/Universal, Treco Coneructicn Services,
`The Rust Engineering Company, and Champlain Cable
`Corpnration:
`Tim01hy J. Green, Esquire
`Pietraqallo Gordon nlfano Hosick & FaspanLi
`One Oxford CentrP, 38Lh Floor
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`FA
`
`I-a77r72ll6220
`
`Manna. ('nufl qunm Sauce
`
`mammgmmmnd
`
`LEW-7284a!“
`
`MaIslbo Confl anflmu Sumac
`
`mMIu-m'umuslnd
`
`
`
`

`

`H “(IUTHiAI'HH R \\ lll'K‘Li" I
`
`11151300 l'rAIIHI R \l >( l'Mil
`
`lww
`
`Pwufl
`
`and
`
`tho Defendaan WashingLon Group,
`On behalf of
`UniLed anlnnnra & Contrarwnn;
`Gary 1. Palint, $3quirn
`Marqclis Edelslcin
`EFT: William Penn Flare
`Suite i300
`PiLisburqh,
`
`FA lSZlfl
`
`On behalf of Lhe Defendant CashCD, Rlarknnr, Zunh
`Duramiztdllic, Flowscxvc and Jay Tenhnnlnqms,
`Inc.:
`[‘aiiiplle M.
`‘y‘uqrincvich, Esquire
`Ma:shall, Dennehey, Warner. Coleman & Goggin
`U.$. Steel Tower
`E00 USX Tower
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`PA 15219
`
`Inc.:
`
`the Detcndann Seali:e,
`of
`'51 ic w. Santos. Esquire
`Dinfimorc & Shohl, LLP
`Ono Oxford Cenlrn, Suite 2500
`3111 Grant Strnr‘l.
`
`PILsturgh,
`
`PA 15319
`
`On behalf of Lhe dcfvndant Eaton Ccrporaticn:
`11m Hinqsle‘f, Esquire (via tel-*phnm‘.)
`GnldhE-rq, Millrr 6 Rubin, P.C.
`The North American Building
`I?! Scuzh Broad Strpm
`Suiin 1500
`
`Phiiadeiphia,
`
`I xfijzwxn
`
`Mun-sum \‘uun Kqunmng 5mm:
`
`mmnmgumu m
`
`PA 19107
`PA 15.119
`
`FJMIN‘IHiAHIEl-RVUUIMEl
`
`hmzn
`On behalf of Lhe Defnndani Ajax Maqnathv:mic Corp.:
`C-irmnn A. Martucrti, Esquire
`Filvy Hewitt WiLtn L Fomano
`(NH) Washington Rndr‘l
`SuiLu 300
`
`Pillsburqh,
`
`PA
`
`l’:?2‘8
`
`On behalf of Lhe DufvndnnL Tasco InsulaLion,
`Pamela V. Collis, Enquire
`Walsh, Collin & B]ackmer P.C.
`Thr Gulf Tower, Suite 1400
`707 GranL SLreoL
`
`Inc.:
`
`Fillsturgh,
`
`PA
`
`On behalf of Lhe Defendants Insul, Eiuhleay, HcCann
`Shields:
`
`Dav1d Ryan, Esquire
`Zinmer Kunz
`Gill) Grant SLICC’L
`51111.0. 3300
`
`Pi Lsturgh,
`
`PA 15009
`PA 19103
`
`On behalf a!
`
`(h: Defendan‘ Hallunckrch US ZLC,
`
`incorrc Lly identified as Hallinckrodn Grcup.
`Travis McElhaney, Esqulrn (Via *PlehonU)
`Weber Gallagher Simpson ntaplpton
`Fires & Newhy
`Two Gateway Center, Cuitx:
`6U
`
`145C-
`
`Pittsburgh,
`
`15:???
`
`On behalf of Lilo Defendants Greene Tweed A Company,
`File; SLon: Corporatinn, and FDSLer whonlor:
`Yarhyrn L. John510n, Esquire
`Reed, Lure, Tosh, Wolfnrd 51 Douglass
`804 Turnpike Strspt
`Beavor,
`
`i-XT’YIKJQIU
`
`Mambo rum qunluw .x'u \ u
`
`urwulmaamuaxl M1
`
`FLWDIODGAI I‘HI R v: )I I'M“
`
`On behalf of Lhc Defendants M.5. Jacobs, Minnoth
`and McJunkin:
`
`Hgil
`
`Ryan A. Rel). Esquire
`Zimmnr Funz
`600 Grant Street
`Sui 1.0 330 {l
`
`Pittsburqh,
`
`On behalf of Lhc DcfendanL Amviican Optical:
`RobtrL Owen, Esquire
`Reed SmiLh
`Rued Smth Center
`
`P?5 Fifth Avenue, SUJLe 1300
`PiLt .‘shurgh.
`PA 1577?
`
`the DefendanL William Powell Company
`On behalf of
`R. SLoven Porreca. Esquire
`Chrstie Pabarue Hortensen and Young
`1880 JFK Boulevard
`lOLh Floor
`
`Philadelphia,
`
`l-BTTTNfiZZO
`
`MNMmflmnhwmmx&mu
`
`mill: titanium Ind
`
`LRTFflEH-hlm
`
`Mam'uo Cnun qumns sax-ac:
`
`mwnlm émmcm nu
`
`

`

`I'LWI XIJHIAETHEK Vi il l 'Ml'. I
`
`ILWVIXJUUATHIIIR VI \U'NEE I
`
`I‘ngt' n
`On bvhdlf cf the hofendanL Hrdman Rescurrvs Limited,
`
`Union Pa:tide Ccrpc avion, and FMC Corporation :n
`behalf of
`iLs Fearless Pump business,
`improperly
`sued as;
`l—‘MC,
`individually and on behali or
`jLs
`Peerlnsn Pump lJIJ‘illIFSE!
`Anna Wilcox LEI-His, Esquire
`Holley Jason»; McGowan Spinvlli
`Allegheny Building
`4.“? Forbes :‘wvnue
`Suite 13F?
`
`is Hanna, LLP
`
`;’ii,sturqh,
`
`PA
`
`15219
`
`a
`On behalf of the Defendants l-‘m'ro Engineering,
`Di‘Jision of CN Marine Sczvic‘l‘s Company,
`a Drelawa:c
`Corporation, and United Convnynr Cozpoial ion:
`Fliristcpher Mi More-Lind, Esquire
`Fawle 6. Henzlv'rson
`
`The: Henry WV Oliver Building
`SuiLP 1000
`EiLsturqh,
`
`RA
`
`'
`
`‘
`
`On bnhalf of
`
`thv Defendant MoL—Pro Corporation:
`
`Aaron Mi ncrfzaun, Esquire
`Raule é. Hondcrson
`The Henry W. Oliver Building
`:Sui’rn ll’lnfl
`Fictshurqh,
`
`FA
`
`Cn hnhalf of Llw hpfenddnl, TMO Indust,ric-s:
`Natalie M. Frazer, F‘squire
`Rawle L Handersnn
`
`The Henry ln‘. Oliver Building
`SuiLc 1000
`
`Piifisbiirqh,
`
`On behalf of Llw Defendant. 11.5. Steel
`Ann E. Riro, Esquirr
`Unired SLate
`:ecl
`florpnrazicn
`
`(toxporarinn:
`
`1’}: [eet-Focm 1500
`600 Gran:
`Fittshurqli,
`PA
`
`l ii“-‘:M:m
`
`Mambo Court Rep-mm \a‘flu
`
`mmllfidinnlxfl m
`
`H‘s-"23mm-
`
`Mambo llnun “mining Sauce
`
`WWI” :J'u‘rmm M
`
`1-1 WI I'll.) UAl'l'lIl k V( ll llMl'l
`
`I.'l WIX’JI‘J GAl‘llil-k VHJJIME!
`
`On behalf cf thv Enfondant
`
`J.M. E‘cs:cx:
`
`On hflhalf of LilP. Defendant. Jendoco:
`
`1522:?
`PA 191m
`
`:‘mroda, Enquire
`John R.
`Tierney Law Offices
`1125 Land Tizle Builciinq
`lOO South Broad. Srrnnl
`Philadelphia,
`PA 19110
`
`tho Defendan: Grinnell:
`On huh-31f of
`Haley Pfoifer, Esquiro (via Lel-‘phcnel
`
`Morgan Lewis
`1111 Pennsylvania AVI‘_, NW
`Washington, DC ECGC4*?‘E41
`
`Visinnqrapher:
`
`Josh Caldwpll
`
`Anqcla Winslow, Esquirr
`Pion Johnston
`1500 One Gfllt‘wd',’ CFnlt‘r
`9
`Pittsbu: h,
`FR
`5???
`
`tho liofendanL MallE‘y Cooling Tower:
`On bnhalf of
`Jamie KV minisky, Esquire
`Wimcr Law Offices
`
`655 Allcthny Avenue
`Oakmcnt, Mi
`15139
`
`On behalf of Lhe llvfendanr Milton Roy Company:
`Thomas A. Smolinski, Esquire (via lclephonel
`Malone Middleman Pic,
`117 VI? Drivn, Suit? 310
`Wexfar'
`, F1 150510
`
`On behalf of
`
`the vaendanl' BWJIP:
`
`Jnhn A. Tlirlik, Esquizs‘
`Regal MCCambridqe
`1813 Market GLreet, Suilm 2600
`Philadelphia,
`
`117777224220
`
`Mafillm Com Rl-pnrliru same
`
`lawman-mum
`
`1-877-728-6120
`
`Wu ('nufl eruntmg Scrvwe
`
`unwillm-acumul m
`
`
`
`

`

`11“: I): a (pm Htk VULL‘l-El
`
`ELWDI‘JDGAIUU R Vl’ll'M} |
`
` n
`
`1U
`11
`
`l?
`14
`
`lb
`
`
`
`ELWO’W3 GLITHER
`
`33): AM TN “TI-1')” E‘i'
`HS .
`Iii-1W1 f‘.
`RYAN
`
`EXHIBITS
`
`GaiLhnr DDpCEi‘LiCn Exhihit No.
`
`tam-7:341:20
`
`anw l um Kqunmp 5011::
`
`mnlmhu.mmm
`
`I N (i S
`E T]
`P R O C F.
`{10:11 C'rrlmflr. 3.1:.)
`
`I‘m making a special
`MR. HAGUE:
`appearance today.
`My prrsflnuc dDOS not waive any
`applicable dufpnnes related 10 the Servirn at my
`clients.
`
`MR. KANE: Understood.
`MR. RYAN: Could we make that
`
`fnr
`
`everyone?
`
`MP. FAME: Absolutnly.
`
`Tho daLe Loday is OCLober
`VIDHOGFAPHER:
`
`, and 1119.
`time in anil a.m. This is
`75th, 701
`Lhc video dnpcsiticn cf Elwuod Gaicher
`:akrn 1n
`the matter at Gather vernus A.C. Smizh
`
`Corpura1ian, 0L a1., filed in Lhe Cour: of Common
`Pleas of Alloqhonv County, Pvnnsylvania.
`This :lnpasition is bring held at, Savinls,
`D'Amicc & Faun,
`located aL 7&7 Grant STrret, Suite
`3626, Fithburqh, Pennsylvania 15219
`My nama is Josh ('ialdwrll, and I'm lht‘ Video
`specialst.
`The court repurlor is Marianna
`
`Mar5111c.
`
`lrMT‘VYINAZL'U
`
`Marsha Com anmmu .\crl M
`
`WMEméulmul rid
`
`1
`
`
`l-lWLK IT! I iAE'l HI k Vul UME[
`
`}'.|.WUU[)(}A[UH k V1 Il.l th]
`
`CCUHFF: frr :hv p u;n:iff '5 uhn Pane,
`Avanrlte cunnrv.
`‘.
`. be ncfei rm :hv
`srvh'qrugh-c record.
`Irpcrrer p'va :
`HZ,Z :hu cunr'
`dwpmnvn: and we may piuruvdv
`
`:uear in the
`
`F'foll' NEITHER,
`huszq l“vfl
`f_rsx
`11:1»!
`1:;
`[cchwiuz
`EXAM [ NAT ION
`
`BY MS. H-‘NlS:
`(«ch msrrii
`
`Hood ncrn'nq.
`My liFW'e
`is farirw :awis, and I‘I‘I qr-Ll'iq 1C be
`5:,
`askinu yuu a 13: 01 QUUHllCnS.
`l m qh‘ he Lhe only
`persnn asking you qnonr on: Luday.
`A,
`Okay.
`Bu:
`T havu t" ~r
`Uhuhnh.
`
`'
`
`nw {J as u::h you
`
`.
`
`,
`
`):(:L“p;e on th!‘
`Wu havt-
`' ahau'. a liE‘FlCJElTlCH.
`u.
`:n thS room.
`So it's
`phunv and we have ;01 HT peep e
`rea.
`.npcrLun:
`:ha: yin kvvp ycqr '
`rv upl Okay?
`lWi'noss ncdd,:q head.)
`
`"
`
`'nq down everythtnu 'ha: We
`lune :'
`Mar
`‘
`1 Lu:
`:C Spn‘u‘r 4'.
`the
`Sc we 1mm!
`:
`Say.
`Ankznq yna :h‘nn.
`'th nay
`:ame :,ny.
`I‘w JCth :0
`become Iupoii‘ivv a: you may nn'iripate wha‘
`l'm qcinq
`.c ask you.
`Just
`let me qv: my quusLjun nu! vvvn
`.bouqh yrn lnnw where ff'n going before you answer so
`car.
`'_.si-:I‘ " \inwn. aw} ‘i'mn
`[
`i
`.
`.
`the same
`I an hPYS hefcrv 1 mi} an:
`IL
`is ’h.:'. fair?
`'[huL'si
`f'lns.
`
`IL
`
`If you don'L unders:and a qnnn.
`Okay.
`Q.
`because I’m wr'k_ng on
`=65 e s;eep ‘hig
`and l nigh
`be 5'
`[in I Like :C 1:»,
`..,
`you do:
`L unde
`and my ques ion. and
`it) [l‘fihrdfifi it
`;n a runner
`in whirh will
`
`need a quak,
`
`n: he kn-' ‘ha:
`
`rvuu qr LreaKs
`you know,
`take a break
`2‘
`weLL.
`lunvhvan rpcess.
`reporter and }robably a
`for our FOUY'
`Eu: if ynu nvvd a break for any other reafion at
`any
`:ine, vou
`:
`'
`me knrw.
`lr's no:
`a hardiban.
`
`We're here
`ur ccn'onzfinwe.
`” 2
`nnvd ‘c Sicp
`
`1.271.723.5120
`
`Mum." ('Illlfl qumng 5am:
`
`Wampum»: m
`
`m'mzmzzo
`
`Mmmlia Cnurl Nqumm; Sauce
`
`anwmlm gamma nd
`
`
`
`

`

`-\1 IE” k W IiL'MIEI
`
`I] WEflINiAI'E] II'R \'E )i (Wu-'1
`
`any, we can n'np. Okay?
`.‘w ’W‘IEFIS
`]|(;.l\i m: headfl
`KI'J h
`
`"
`
`a perfem.
`
`ion".
`"1
`i‘m ncxx;
`,‘Ou nuan‘ m
`.mJ
`um;
`,inc Au».
`p,.mc ..
`don't vvvn remember what
`[ had fun .unvh yesterday
`“{ dhn'i
`know"
`I nu,
`
`r “numb.
`
`A:e you Ta}'ho unyfhznq whivn nag :npa r yrur
`'25::
`
`-1Licn in .1 Lu:r.lr':l-m‘e mom.
`1 1hc hearinq,
`
`[r ynu
`
`.1
`'udge, no:
`'!‘(".]l wnfl-‘ozs '
`.".'-* End 1
`
`.inpm‘,
`:(pr
`
`havn yru over been
`
`.'l]*;i Sr: yitu Hum, Thu:
`Have ycu Frvr ¢vnu
`
`take nyrnn-
`nigh',
`{1.1
`
`n snwefimeu
`lee;
`,me
`
`.
`
`yru ever hum .vx-sclved _':
`
`nssuro fied';.nv.
`Jus’ b‘vwd 5
`No.
`Sure. Havv you nvnr givnn a dnposition
`
`in'ury I had wi.h my bark.
`a
`LhdL a whwkurp
`
`MR. KANE:
`
`rvi uticn
`
`0f
`2
`qh‘fi, pcsser‘
`{Law yrtu ever .‘ii‘l‘u'l‘d
`N‘r
`.
`
`
`
`Tran.
`
`And what cffensr warn you convjzlvd n1:
`
`m?‘ may)
`
`Mann... um ummmg 5mm
`
`man-sum sum-m m
`
`W-xr-Tthm
`
`Marsala Cam pruflmx \cnur
`
`amalmégwmcmm
`
`HM'UI 5111.!“ I Iii-R UNLIMJ
`
`ELWmDGAH'EiFR VI IE UM} l
`
`Ll.
`A.
`
`And when was
`"1'11:
`I dcrn':
`
`.H-m'nher.
`
`'
`
`-
`
`:~
`
`lurk in 11w:
`
`Ffiflekhut“ 'n :he ear y
`gL
`U‘her
`:han uank‘nq w::h ycur a"crnay. ML
`Kane, did you do anythwm (55:? :‘o {-rv'mrv [CL your
`ion Loday?
`
`tr'mi
`span:
`'5
`unLOn n9nhv::.
`exruuo mu,
`A.
`NC,
`I hdeH'I.
`
`.4
`
`remember v'.‘vr‘,"hinq.
`
`or,
`
`Q.
`prndm"
`
`Were you shuwn or did ycu ruvivw any
`
`t4
`
`..
`
`R1d you zevivw any pi
`NC.
`
`urve n: prmduc_g.
`
`I havp ymu address
`Sir.
`Fitzsruzqh, FOnneu van a”
`Thii's ccrruv‘.
`Wha‘ area it 1hr u'
`That‘s Homuwrrd.
`
`licw long haw ynu I
`Uh, about
`1H years
`
`VET-1‘) Bennett
`
`this .Jddress?
`
`l “77.134220
`
`ml... (‘man {mum-g Sam:
`
`mum-MINA: [.91
`
`
`
`.1 O
`
`dame any fl‘I'iC‘iQ-'Uq Cr
`r“;
`
`this her-m:
`
`
`A.
`Nu.
`
`
`
` O.
`Hnuv you ever dunv any home [omndv\‘nq or
`repaLIS 1r any hcne :ha. ynu've lived
`
`
`A.
`N
`
`
`
`Arr you or q.nu‘.y always from
`
`
`
`
`
`
` H A. 'fl-n. I've - I havwn': always I
`
`
`
`
`
`frcn thv finnewncd area.
`
`
`
`1s
`Q.
`_-.. yau eve: bean prt2'°‘.n'. when
`
`
`.: hmme where
`M
`rencdelzm; m repairs were L‘s-1m; done a:
`
`15
`you were ELVinq or SZdylnq?
`
`16.
`A.
`Nu,
`
`17
`13-
`
`0.
`A.
`
`3"?
`N)
`
`O.
`A.
`
`.“.r.
`
`I have Zhd'.
`
`
`
`re £5 years; (I
`
`
`
`
`fan-i yt'ur bir'h-iay war:
`Yl‘b.
`
`IU/E?
`
`
`
`
`
`
`And vcu were burn in the year 195]?
`Q.
`11
`
`7)
`A.
`C(UHIPE.
`
`[Rn-i
`13.9
`If)
`
`
`
`Hm 72mm
`nmamlia am we!
`MnrulmOum qurlmg Scrl'lu:
`
`
`
`

`

` ELWOOD E HA“ I link VUI.1'M}'
`
`
`l
`
`IZLWfNHNiAT'HWR VOIJ‘MF]
`
`These are :hv Gnly LHO vanfl yr
`
`
`
` two jaugnters 7
`
`Regina Pumas?
`Fith.
`And do you know her age?
`Regina's 43.
`Bo ycu knew where she JivnsT
`I don'l, knew lhf' Correct Address, but she
`
`light up hrire on the H111.
`In 1110 H111 District?
`Yeah.
`who was: her mother?
`Run Dumas .
`
`Is Ann 51111 lxving?
`I don’L realJy know.
`Dc ynu knnu if Foana has any children?
`She doesn't.
`
`Do you know how Regina's health is?
`know of.
`5 good, as far as I
`Dces she have any lung :1?
`
`Lgnuxfim
`
`Mambo mm Rq-mng 5mm
`
`mwntmiflun-m‘l m
`
`are .7411?
`mmlwr
`
`
`711.1": r'qht.
`
`
`never
`tm-n ruin LA .1.’
`
`
`
`
`
`ELF."
`imen 1U
`Lon"
` ynu
`any .cng
`
`
`
`
`Th
`
`Justin-r permm,‘ 3;.
`where
`
`
`
`yczu he.) mu who :.hv>:u~ might have bean?
`
`
`
`Teiy,
`
`
`
`
`
`[forum —
`I dvru '.
`I GI‘Ir-‘T'Ilh‘f
`
`‘h
`
`any of
`
`
` I
`
`
`
`live u !h Behbiv'.‘
`
`
`
`
`'.1' 3:01;” .
`.-.'-_- bF-Au
`
`
`where armmd
`
`
` 2364. $3.
`
`
`
`wi l h Donna?
`1“
`U.
`And when did you Ign-
`
`
`
`Mambo L'uufl Kqumng 5mm
`
`ammnhuuumlul m
`
`I K"-
`
`23(«0210
`
`l':reaLhinq problems;
`ey.
`
`
`
`F] “'1’! >I‘HEAIIIIFR VOLUMP |
`
`LLWOOD ( MI I'HPR Vlll'Hl I
`
`thaV
`
`you’re aware of?
`A ,
`Na.
`
`Ts she financially dependent. on you in any
`
`0.
`A.
`O.
`A.
`0.
`
`O.
`A.
`
`0.
`Regina?
`A.
`
`Did you ever
`
`live in the same homo with
`
`NO.
`
`Has anina avvr wcrknd with you?
`No.
`
`Ts Roqnna married?
`NO.
`
`I have that you have another dauqhten
`BrnLtany Gainher?
`n.
`YES.
`
`in Fncxunllc, PA?
`
`And she was born on June 4th, 1989?
`ClnxuuL.
`And fihP livvfi
`quhf'.
`And she works aL The thoese Cake Factory?
`Right .
`How Ifi her
`
`hea11h?
`
`She's in good health.
`
`Does nhu have any vhi;drvn?
`
`th ,:§ F"ri::am,":3 mathvr
`Her name is Dinah Horns.
`Ann?
`Dinah.
`
`(:kay.
`Dinah.
`The mam! addre
`
`And when» doc—:5 Dirmh live?
`.n Kan)“
`
`Have yau ever
`NC.
`
`L'."’I'i w:
`
`‘
`
`And .5 F1;:Tany linanclai
`
`y deandvn: on yflu
`
`I help with books
`lining to ::('hcn'\.
`She-'5:
`:ha' nature.
`'5 goinq ’o Connurltty
`
`art-1 your parents living?
`Sir,
`My nothvr L5
`my HCTher'a deceased.
`r fa:her
`ng?
`My fathvr's SL-I:
`living.
`Okay. WhaL Lfi your
`[aihw:'s name?
`Hen
`Zntkley.
`
`How dn y-nu spa}. his ids!
`L O-C V.
`I,
`
`E-Y,
`1.5"
`
`name?
`
`:nqfi cf
`Zu‘qe.
`
`Q.
`A.
`
`E
`
`'
`
`L 117172345220
`
`Mmmn Cum-r: Heparung Saws:
`
`mlummnnm nfl
`
`l-XTP-‘IES-hllfi
`
`MummfiuHMwMukmm
`
`umsdn-{Lmnxmm
`
`

`

`l-‘LWCMJEHIA l THIEK VIJll‘M'F- 1
`
`And how old ls he?
`
`I'm nnl quitn sure how old my father is,
`he's down sou h.
`
`DD you know hcu Nxs heal‘h is?
`Ckay.
`It's qocd.
`Did you ever work with your fath;?
`No.
`
`Did you ever
`NO.
`
`llve wJLh ynur fa1hnr?
`
`E0 you know if you: dad has a hintcry cf
`canror, hearL problEmS,
`Inspiraiory problums?
`A.
`No.
`You dcn': knnw or he doesn't?
`
`He daman't havc any.
`And your mothnr's name?
`My moLhcr's nqmn is Ymma Gaither
`
`How old was your mDLher when she
`I
`think, 74.
`was he: Cause cf dnath?
`
`Aneurysm.
`Bld your mstlwct
`No.
`
`smoke?
`
`LI W001) BAI'IHT'N VUll'Ml'
`
`I
`
`9.
`
`[WWW
`OLhcr
`than aSLhfld, did she have any cLhe:
`respiJ aLcry prublcmfi?
`A.
`NC.
`
`Dld. she ever harp a h‘51\”r',' cf caln‘oz?
`ND.
`
`Did she have any heart. problems?
`No.
`
`Do you have any sabllngs?
`Yes.
`'h‘har are their namozs?
`AlberI Gaither.
`
`Okay.
`Faymnznd GaiLhcr.
`Okay.
`Is that
`it?
`ThaL'n lt, yflah.
`T wasn't sure if"
`
`there why? more.
`
`ThaL's okay. You’re goan a good
`How old is your brother, Albert?
`My hrozher, Allfif‘lL. would be 55.
`How is his health?
`Good.
`
`Any lung 0‘: rnspmatcry problems?
`NO.
`
`In“.
`
`fill-till]
`
`Mamlm mm Repumng Senn'z
`
`mllfl («'erlliM m1
`
`l-H ‘T-Tlh-ollfl
`
`httslim Cum liq-11mg $51M:
`
`amylmuunmm m1
`
`HJNOIJDGAH NPR VDLK'M} I
`
`”WOOD mmu'k Vfil‘M‘l—J
`
`
`1 ham-u nr;
`
`idea.
`
`Okay. Miss hn. 5’: K.
`As
`far
`a."
`I Pnr‘w at.
`
`Do you know wlmrc- he livvn’.‘
`Ne.
`
`
`She had as1.hma.
`
`
`you grow up with Albert?
`
`lived in the Same house?
`
`ho ever smoke?
`
`you ever work wirh Albert?
`
`No.
`
`living?
`whaL does he do for a
`The lmsL I heard, he was dning mag
`publishing magazines.
`0.
`Where does he livp?
`A.
`In
`what
`is iL? Virginia. Rirhmond,
`bcljevel
`I haven't Lalked to hlm in a while.
`
`I
`
`0.
`A.
`
`how old is he?
`And your brother, Raymond,
`T 'vn never
`He would be
`I'm not sure.
`
`He always ]1ved down south.
`really lived with him.
`He's older than me.
`I’d venture LO say 65
`Is hn a full blood brothnr?
`NC. Neither one of
`them were.
`is he a halt hrOLher cn your father or L0
`My mm her.
`Okay.
`who did he live with down south?
`
`l‘cw 31':- hnai'h
`lic yrq Hm».-
`a Couplv
`Well, he was up more ubuul
`seemed Ln gccd .‘ImaLLh
`:0 :W.
`;
`no yCu vncw what he aces Inf
`N0.
`{Tunerhjnq with computers.
`dcn‘:
`tnnwl
`
`manh:
`
`ivihg?
`I-‘xar‘tJy what
`
`Haw. wvre ycu rui:wd Ly ynur nuths:
`Yes.
`
`qrnuzng up, nrhur :han
`.'-- .
`J
`1 you .ive
`
`Q.
`when you
`Ckay.
`your
`mn’he: and yiur bra:
`with anybody H2 52:?
`A,
`n
`in:
`I
`livud with my Aunt
`g.
`Ckay.
`Fund what was her rune?
`Resaieo Reedy.
`Is shv snl'l
`living?
`Yes.
`WnerF dves she ..ve?
`
`She Jivvc ;n Linrc n anlnqtonl #hat's whvrv
`
`I 407-728-6210
`
`Mamlm l‘nufl chmmg Sen'lu
`
`Mu‘ynmnm
`
`lJlTl'Hl-ollfl
`
`Millhlm 12m Rrwmhg 5mm
`
`malmfiummlfl m1
`
`

`

`1'1 “:1 IIUHAHIU R \DLUMIEI
`
`Fl“.'00Dt"u<\l'l1Uk \‘I E “W [
`
`\h-‘rt‘v
`Hwy live out
`Has your huH‘ H‘sa1ee,
`
`Cthvr
`I nndvyn'dnw.
`vkuy‘
`your uu’fu-r, and ywur
`lnz':hpr, Alburw , ynu didn't
`wilh nuyhoay else grnwinq up?
`“:
`NFA
`“Lnn 1':
`
`Frcnably whun l was 3
`Where d;d you qv i've?
`with Mr:. Rnudy.
`iécsw Long
`
`y
`fam'
`‘r, as far aw yuur
`thezv an, «'LHT fani'y
`
`Lutury, Lo ynur
`
`No .
`
`Hoar“ prulzim
`NC.
`
`Inn; CI rn:;'1.rw~:y prcbiunx,
`
`ano.
`A.
`1 undoratand LhJL you went Lo Westinghouse
`O.
`High Schca]7
`A.
`I did.
`
`Did you q:aduaLc?
`ND.
`
`a GED over?
`
`Mud you get
`Yrs,
`I did.
`Whvn did ycu gr! ycur GE
`'7].
`I believe it. was
`'71.
`
`Ynu've never served in Lhe military?
`No.
`
`erv you ever dvnlvd miliLary swrvare?
`NIL
`
`0PO30b0b0
`
`:4
`
`I undersLand rhat you Joined the loral
`Q.
`steamfiLtors mm 1972, buL did you ,, that would have
`been when you ware 21 years old.
`Is that
`true?
`A.
`That‘s corrECL.
`
`fv‘rnm Th? :ImG‘ ycu were in lhe‘ ZQLh
`I‘l'ay,
`C,
`grade and ycu left school until
`the timo you were 21
`and joinvd Lho sLeameLLers union, did you have any
`jobs?
`
`
`
`Mum“ Lnun qumllg 5mm
`
`amasulx- awn-mu net
`
`I I7? 723 (‘22:)
`
`Malulm (mm kqunmx 5mm
`
`allwungmtthle n5
`
`LIWUI “HEATHII‘R VOLUME]
`
`FLWCDD GAlTIiFR W )l l'ME I
`
`A.
`I'm 5L
`
`whdL
`washed
`thr@ chd
`.ghed
`
`in
`
`:hun Al Maqu HospiLai.
`jobs you
`Ia Lhat
`the an y
`1‘
`.
`*.
`. While a'
`a
`
`Mcde' Ecx?
`Yeah.
`Where is
`was
`
`:
`
`'V
`
`r ZL‘h and Penn
`
`-. ’hey db there?
`:ardbndrd boxes,
`
`wonnv. What did you dc
`JIJ boxéF.
`
`'hnrv
`A.
`
`.,
`n
`
`‘;
`.
`
`L
`
`:»
`
`,-
`
`
`
`‘:
`
`vfu
`in
`‘
`no speviuLly.
`1 have In nak the
`
` q: r;gh; dhnaJ.
`
`I: m'gh:
`
`seem Ohvznnfi, but sometxnuu
`
`at‘LUI
`
`'har, H
`
`In)
`
`(1
`
`es and
`
`Fax, d.d you work unywhvre e.sei
`Nu,
`
`MIL iv you UCIU warming dishes
`.Levo 'hai ycu wcu d have worked
`"Cn‘ain;ng _|.rr 1m:
`‘
`
`AA
`
`No.
`
`Whvn ycu weIP WALhinq diShEF an :hn Maqee
`Q.
`HDSpiLd;, dd you believe that yau wou1d have worked
`:h er around any asb
`
`preducLs?
`
`You go:
`Oh,
`
`— any dures‘os—ccn:aznznq
`LU luW mv ch my quest1nn aurA
`
`I warned yen ubcnr how
`‘his ;5 whn!
`999,
`I
`'hnngh? ycu wv!n inne. Cazry
`ThnnksV
`when ynu wnrked a: Mvdn‘
`w:rh or around any unbuchs—ronru‘nznq
`
`hr» you furs yml'lv dcne win; ngl'w Hru‘npttai?
`
`1 477-73962!)
`
`Mwmwtmmkqnmdeww
`
`Willa-[KIWI]! ncl
`
`1-!(77-723-0220
`
`Mambo lerl Rq’llmlul 5cm“
`
`unnuslhb'émlmmnfl
`
`

`

`FLWOUD (5M 1 I“ R VUL UMP]
`
`a
`T have
`- a;
`11'. P):
`
`:4
`
`:21"..th .1
`
`-_
`
`am: f'r:l unc, Muvianne.
`{.jn.'..?'.er
`[ft—upm'fiicn F'xh:2"
`
`:[f-.‘rr"\’ place:-
`\“’I;
`
`u
`
`but
`
`may not
`
`tau-5:?) 1cm,
`rnmemner
`'hrcuqh 'hum.
`PHJ
`KJI.
`
`.
`
`zenvn‘tu-r scnonlw‘}, HO... move am,
`do you r1< n
`And EOFM‘ if 5h :'
`1
`.
`, thd
`
`:wc
`Ir:
`union in prrember.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`rue
`
`to road a
`
`.rik, L‘r‘ldt“.
`I
`ham-H
`.
`
`.: paw-err
`, yam 'u:ned
`Wfifi” was whvn
`
`Hannah)
`
`Mambo Conn sec-mung berm-x
`
`“unmet-"mm n4
`
`
`
`
`FLWOOIJ HA] [ HI'N VOLUM] I
`
`Here an
`1*,
`!J._'.
`
`
`ThanL you, sir.
`How did you cnmv 1o fain :Iu
`
`mi
`thv H‘m‘k Ccn::'.rw
`
`
`g); Truk you in 'r: dc,
`-, preiapprcn:
`
` ".m .
`
`, (in pref
`
`and
`tzadv unions,
`
`
`
`
`?
`
`
`‘hah wcu'd have bevn unmeLLnu
`
`
`
`
`
`3...“
`.-_..;-_-;
`swore -
`Izth-
`
`
`1'. war. riassrrmn work.
`
`
`
`5C; ynu d 1 nc‘.
`[-
`
`
`
`
`
`aim-rwlse,
`'0 mm you .h:
`
`A.
`212‘,
`um,
`rev,
`
`
`
`
`Ai‘l
`I
`have
`
` L2.
`hq-i
`.m cppor'un.
`
`
`
`
`
`1.}:‘173X4C1FJ
`
`Mmmuupu1kqunmgsavm
`
`mm]mauml.1\l m
`
`,
`
`ELWDIDI ) 1 ‘IA Fl HFR VOLL'MF [
`
`H.Wll(')l)i}Al 1 “Hi VUHIMI'I
`
`‘urzed 2n:
`'13.
`
`'he 2&‘11.
`rm wm:
`job I was“
`ytu work-"vi Icr '
`'H‘urqh
`
`g.
`Hm,h.zn:.
`
`.. I
`
`T‘ha‘
`n.
`They :w'rn'. hr-
`
`their wimp an N.I::hwng1.0n Huulevard.
`’he‘r 1%.:3‘.
`::
`MP. KANE:
`I
`.i ycu w‘r‘v, a: “he Heap?
`‘I'Hl‘ WITNFTF“
`1
`(Ltd. Hm. work a! Lhe
`
`Shup.
`ET MI', LEWIS:
`
`Did ynu lake vinsses ThvrP?
`Q.
`No.
`‘Ihs‘y j'
`'_ wen: HP
`'hwre :c 1:2:er
`A.
`1" rs:
`VL‘df 4-; u 11,;EL‘,
`.uil
`’hPy Jrna
`ytsu‘rv a
`you 06: L’Ie shalt, and Hal-H :hey':.
`smnd you '0
`aiflvten: th rites.
`U-
`Okay.
`.hen
`gonv!h1nq athL d ——
`A.
`I
`(nmamher why fch 5:50;;
`'c kncw .hi:
`fish “1
`(5.
`Sure.
`Fi'.‘ :ergh Mcrh.m:cal?
`Yes.
`
`this was,
`
`wax"
`
`if yum
`
`They lzrs: sen: me
`
`to m mgheny (Enraeral
`
`And yum were on (ha:
`
`'jch um L1 0:?
`
`g.
`A.
`
`No?
`NC.
`5
`
`Z
`
`J
`
`I worked ihvre} 3;”
`fitoe;
`:n ‘hw Sou:
`
`Okay.
`Scnvwhvre arcund March a:
`
`ey tranxferxoj we
`
`teLievu,
`:ht-Z' Sunth 51:19.
`'Fi?
`O.
`In Marrh of
`I: wnu d he 7 L,uss ycu
`yeah,
`it would 111*
`'73.
`Fe 3.14.: Worked .J‘ ASH C031
`0.
`Sepzvnher Zfi'h unf:i Marvh cf
`‘TF,
`E, South Side?
`
`, yeah.
`
`iuurnusl' Hm"
`and :59?
`
`Riqhz.
`w=re ',':‘11 over a:
`Sc, nizd (-a'er
`.9 L South Side fcr
`J
`'I'hen YDU barn? at
`Un‘i',
`[ was
`.aid off, whzv'h L:
`find".
`:3 Sop‘r-nher 144:,
`HR. KANE:
`"/37
`"'HF WITNFSS:
`
`7
`
`IrfiT771286210
`
`Mlmlm (um qumng Sen-m
`
`Irwsilm-qummnfl
`
`mm 72mm
`
`Mambo am kmm Scnicc
`
`”WWW”. m
`
`

`

`I‘LWOOD GABEER VHLUME l
`
`EEinI)D 1EAmIER VULl.IME I
`
`Okay.
`'oaking cn Lhe
`MR. KANE: Anne, you're:-
`You should he looking on the right.
`IEWJS:
`NC.
`J
`is I see.
`
`see where it says layoi: dates.
`5 and layoffs.
`I see how they
`jammed up there a: the beginning, and
`
`{L's all
`
`really is, yeah.
`1 was looking torward to talking in you about
`it so 1 could make sense of it myself. Okay.
`Hell,
`le
`. talk abou:
`the job for Pi::sburgh
`Mechanical for six months at AGE
`
`Okay.
`A.
`What did you do?
`Q.
`I worked on pumps.
`let's see.
`1 was new.
`A.
`You unloaded trucks.
`You
`-
`I worked with a couple
`guys who were,
`like, pump techs and stuff like Lhat.
`You‘re an apprentice, you go and just do little stqu
`whatever they tel. you to do.
`Q.
`Were you asstqned to a specific journeyman on
`that job?
`A.
`
`A: different times.
`
`Do you know any of their names?
`I
`remember larry Steigerwald, because he was
`A.
`the oldest guy on LhQ job, and i nev