throbber
MRR-11-2884
`
`16141
`
`RDPES & GRRY
`
`F'.B1
`
`' HUPES
`
`ROPES E: GRAY LLP
`
`ONE INTERNATIONAL PLACE
`
`BOSTON. MA 02110-2624
`
`617-951-7000
`
`F 617-951-7050
`
`BOSTON
`
`NEW YORK
`
`SAN FRANCISCO
`
`WASHINGTON, DC
`
`FAX TRANSMITTAL LETTER
`
`IMPORTANT: PLEASE DELIVER THIS DOCUMENT IMMEDIATELY!
`
`IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE ALL PAGES, PLEASE CALL: (617) 951-7790
`TOTAL NUMBER 01-‘ PAGES INCLUDING THIS TRANSMITTAL LETTER: 12
`
`Name
`
`To:
`
`Ms. Angela
`Campbell
`
`From: Dawn M. Corey
`
`Comments:
`
`F
`
`Fax Number
`
`Phone Number
`
`USPTO
`
`703 746 7068
`
`703 308 9300
`ext. 125
`
`Unumprovident Corporation (0pposer)
`
`vi
`
`OneBeacon Insurance Company, 1'/k/a
`CGU Insurance Company (Applicant)
`
`Angela,
`
`Opposition No. 91156694
`Application Serial No. '76/265,227
`
`As we discussed, the TTAB, by means of a communication dated March 6, 2004, did not receive
`a copy of the Complaint as referenced as an nttacllment to Applicant’s earlier Stipulation to Suspend. As
`ordered, Applicant is attaching hereto :1 copy of said Complaint. We respectfully request that you proceed
`with making a copy of this Complaint of record for this opposition proceeding.
`
`Thank you for your assistance.
`
`
`Please contact me with any questions.
`PLEASE COMPLETE WHEN SUBMIT'l'l'NG To FAX DEPARTMENT
`
`Date: March 11, 2004
`
`File Symbol: ECU-TOP-O03
`
`Time: 11:44 AM
`
`Personal ID Number:
`
`
`
`Submitted By: Phone:
`
`THIS FAX MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT Is PRIVILEGED, CONFIDENTIAL AND EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE.
`IT IS INTENDED FOR use ONLY BY THOSE To WHOM rr IS ADDRESSED.
`IF THIS FAX IS NoT ADDRESSED TO
`YOU. OR IF You RECEIVED IT IN ERROR, YOU MAY NOT DISCLOSE, DISTRIBUTE, cow op. use THIS FAX on Am
`INFORMATION IN IT.
`INSTEAD, PLEASE CALL us COLLECT AT (617) 951-7000 To ARRANGE FOR ITS
`DESTRUCTION on RETURN.
`
`PAGE 1l12 * RCVD AT 311 1l2004 4:26:22 PM {Eastern Standard Time] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-2l0 " DN|S:7467068 * CSID: * DURATION (mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`MRR_1 172%“
`
`15‘ 42
`
`RUPES :3. saw
`
`I
`
`Q .9 5
`
`O I
`
`I
`
`P .
`
`J11-.‘B5-2331
`
`153 15
`
`R0953 3. Gflfly
`
`‘
`
`G
`
`PI
`
`STATE OFRHODE ISLAND ANT} PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS
`PROVIDENCE.SC.
`SUPERIORCOURT
`
`THE BEACON NIUTUAL INSURANCE
`COMPANY.
`
`Plaintiff
`
`V.
`
`ONEBEACON INSURANCE GROUP.
`Dcfvsndanl
`
`CA‘ "(L
`
`
`
`1.
`
`Haimifr, TheBeacnn Mutual hasurmmeCompany, is a corpomion specially
`neral Asmnbiy as a domestic mutual insurer and maintains its
`Warwick. Rhoda Island (hiemlnafter "PIa'xnliff“
`
`chmered by the Rhoda Island Gc
`principal place of business at but Beacon Ccutrc,
`
`or “Thu Beacon").
`
`2.
`
`of business located I! On
`
`Is a corpnration with its principal plaza
`Dafandanl. oncneacon Insurancu: Group.
`nnfcer "Defendant").
`e Eeaccm s1rc:.~.1.Bos1on.
`Musaachusatta (herei
`Upon infnmmticn andbelicf, O
`5 underthe name
`ne-Beacon xmw.-ance Group, whlch does business
`“oneiaencon Insurance.“ is licensed as a property and casualty insurance companyby
`IslandDepartment of Business Regulation mils angugcd in the business ofinsurance in the
`State :21 Rhode Island.
`ndzmt maintains sumcient minimum contacts with the sum: ofRhode Island
`
`this Rhoda
`
`3.
`
`Def:
`
`so that this court has jurisdiction ovct its pcxsnn.
`
`PAGE 2112 " RCVD AT 3111120114 4'26'22 PM
`-
`-
`
`'
`[Eastern Standard Time] * SVR'USPTO-EFXRF 210 * DN|S'?4670
`'
`'
`-
`
`‘
`'
`58 * CSID: * DURATION (mm-ss):0348
`
`

`
`
`
`MRR-11-22184
`
`15:42
`H "
`
`RDPES & mm
`
`‘CM! DIV!
`
`4'
`
`'
`
`3“-‘°3'3%1 13=19
`
`was 2. cm?
`
`I- ma
`F'.EI3
`
`P.8d
`
`931133111.
`
`‘Fee
`
`aiu*Co
`
`"n
`
`writer of workers‘ ccmpcnsalion inaurancc in the N10 07
`as me Stat: Cmnpcnsaticn Insurance Fund. adopted
`Rhoda Island. Th: Beacon, fnrmcfly known
`"The ‘Beacon Mutual Insurance Company.’
`se service marks and
`
`4.
`
`Piaimiff is the iargcst
`
`the servicc marks and trade. names uf
`
`lnsurnncc" and "The Beacon" in My.
`
`' “Beacon
`
`1992 and has cominuousiy usad the
`151%! tim-.. In addition. The Beacon adopted and
`
`uadc names in the State of Rhode Island since
`515- used the service marklogo ofn liginhouscon an ofits corporate
`
`has continuou
`
`an‘:lcncrhs§t€L.i.!L!5fl_._______,____
`
`displays the logo, is attached hereto as 3_;,mi;i;,,A_,
`5.
`Since July. 1992. Plainnfl’has'udoptnd and uscd. andcontinues*0 use. H8 5=Wi==
`rnmerce in conncciion with the advertising, offering for5816. find
`marks and trndc. names in en
`acxuai sale oflnsurancc pmductc and services, includingbut notlimited inW°f|¢<=rS'
`
`compensation insurancc.
`andtrade names 6II=1\15iV°1Y
`:2 July, 1992, Piaintiffhns used its scwice marks
`niif‘i"s snics revenues for such insurance products and
`as uxpcndcd significant sums to advcnise
`cred xindcr the name ‘Th:
`
`services
`
`sine
`5,
`forinsuruncc products and sewiccs. Pia!
`have been substantial. In addition. lflainliff h
`iy or its Insumncc pmducta and services rend
`"Beacon 1mmmncc" and “The Beacon." as well as thc
`H: availability oi’ its insurance products and
`
`and promote the avaiiubili
`
`Beacon Mutual Insurance Company"
`
`services under i
`
`Is trade names and scrvicc Iaurks in various media. including telephone
`and on the inuemet where Plaintiff maintains n
`
`directories. newspapers. magazines. newsletters.
`
`PAGE 3112* RCVDAT 3I11I20044'26'22 PM [Eastern standard Time
`-
`-
`
`.
`-
`-
`]*SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-2m‘DNIS'?467068*csID'*DURATION
`
`(mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`I
`
`L
`
`MRR-11-2884
`
`15-42-
`
`RDPES 3. GRQY
`
`'
`
`"'”~‘°5'9°‘31
`
`15=19
`
`RDFES 2. ennv
`
`P.a4UV
`
`P as
`
`the mail and various bfoudnast media
`
`ones have become
`
`of an advertisement. printed
`
`web page at .mm. Plaintiff uiso uses
`to advertise and promote its products and sewicce.
`7.
`As the direct andproximal:result ofPlaintiffslung and continuous use of its
`with the ativenising, offering for sole
`service mtttits and trade ntttnes in cotnmcrce ‘in connection
`said service marks and mid: no
`and sale of its insurance products and sorvicot,
`in the mind of the purchasing public and are
`distinctive and acquired a strung secondary meaning,
`gion of the country. Substantial
`Plaintiff’5 insurance business in this to
`good will hasbeen developed at thedi
`me. money and
`not result ofPlaintiffs investment of ti
`
`. is C0‘-it~ In early June. 2001.P1aintt cum -
`
`
`itsname to Oneiieacon Insurance and adopted alighthouse logoinconnectionwith the
`promotion anti stile ofits insuranco products and services. A COP?
`_;i, on or about June 15.1-!00t.is attached hereto as
`in the insutnnce trade publication D
`1E_i;hjb_i;Ji. Since thattime,Defendant has extencivoty advertiseti its name change.
`nt directly coinpetos with P1-'15nut!in the Rhoda island insurance market.
`ii"s Ions. prior and continuous use of its service marks
`and services, Dofcntittnt. Without the
`
`uniquely associated with
`
`8
`
`9.
`
`1!).
`
`Dofonda
`
`Notwithstanding miliflti
`
`and trace nan
`
`consent of Plaintiff. has adopted
`
`test in connection with insurance pnoducts
`and it using in ccmmetco the name One
`
`Beacon insurance and I1
`
`similar to Plaintiff‘
`
`deception among consumers and pro
`
`description or representation within the mounting
`
`spectivc purchcaters.
`of Section 43th) of the Lattham Trademark Act.
`
`ts U.S.C. 5 t t2.5(a).
`
`-
`.
`-
`-
`TIme]*sVR:UsPT0-EFXRF-2I0*DNIs'7467068*csID'*DURAT
`PAGE4I12*RcVDAT iI11I20044'26'22 PM [Eastern Standard '
`
`ION (mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`MRR-11-28214
`
`15:43
`
`RUPES & GRRY
`
`F285
`
`As adirect and proximateresuu of mi} acts ofDefendant as allegedherein.
`11,
`Plaintiff has suffered and will continueto suffcrsrcm damagetnits 1=us1nm- 3°04WI“-
`nnd profits. The precise amount of such damage cannot be.nscorminI=d 01'predicted 1!!
`reputation
`fact of injury has occuxred.
`this time. but there is no question that the
`rnedy at law ag€iinB1D6feI1dant’s unfair com981it‘°fi-
`UnlessDefendantis preliminarily and pennamemiy enjoinedbythis mun.PlaintiffWin 511736!‘
`
`Plaintiff has no adequate to
`
`12.
`
`irroporable harm.
`
`Sfilliilll
`
` __www 13. Plaintiff repoets on eg ' _ lhmv 13. as if
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`_____"________§____
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`fully set forth herein.
`' Piaintiffs Li‘ado names and sewior: marks are inherently distinctive and have
`
`14.
`
`u: "0neBew:on Insurance" and of a lighthouse
`
`acquired a strong secondary meaning. .
`15.
`Defendants wmngiulluse of the nam
`ring for solo of its insurance products and
`
`lhs advertising and uffe
`eivc me pubiic into believing that there is 1: com:
`
`WIN?‘
`
`logo in connection with
`services as alleged herein is‘likely to doc
`between Defendant and Plaintiff when, In fact, 1.hL‘rv.‘: is
`is.
`Defendant has unfaidy competed with 1'-‘ioimiff in viola
`go deceptively similarto Plaintiff‘: scwice marks and trade
`common law by using a name and to
`names withthe intent to inducethe public intobeiieving that it is somehow sponsored by or
`ectcd with Plaintiff. and tiwreby is trading upon the substantial good will and reputation
`service marks and trade names. ail to Plaintiff’s detriment.
`
`no such connection.
`
`tion of Rhode island
`
`GUN’!
`
`inherent in Plaintiff‘ s
`
`-
`-
`Ime] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-2m * DNIS'?467068* cSID' * DURATION
`PAGE 5112 * RCVD AT 3I11!2004 4'26'22 PM [Eastern Standard T‘
`-
`-
`
`(mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`MQRL11-2884
`
`16143
`
`RDPES 8. GRQY
`
`'1 uvt
`
`- n
`
`m—'a5"3°°1
`
`15‘:-”3
`
`RDPES 2. GRHY
`
`F’. 86
`ll U0
`
`\V
`P .7
`
`As a direct and proximate, result of the acts of Defend
`17.
`Plaintiffhas suffered and will continue to sum: great damage to its business. good will.
`
`am as alleged herein. the
`
`reputation and profits.
`iii.
`The Plaintiffhas no adequate ofmnedy at law againstthis unfair competition.
`Plaintiff will suffer
`Unless Defendant is proliminaiiiy and pctmnnently enjoined by this court,
`
`irrcparablc harm.
`I‘).
`In acting as alleged heroin, Defendant has acted with oppmssion, fraud and malice
`
`toward Pittinn’
`
`.
`
`exampic and by way of punishing
`
`Defcndant for its outrageous behavior.
`
`
`
`20.
`
`Plaintiff repeats and reallcges the allagations ofParagraph 1 through 19 as if fix“)!
`
`sci forth herein.
`
`Plaintiff has used its snrvice marks and trade names in connection with the
`ii.
`advertising and sale ofinsuranceproducts and services in commerce for almost nine i'W5- said
`public with Plaintiffs
`marks have become extensively known and ussociatcd in the minds of tho
`
`Plaintiff’ 5 Se
`
`business and services.
`22.
`Defendant hna ildoplcd and used names and logos deceptively similar to
`rvicc marks and trade names in connection with the advertising and offering for salt:
`rvlcca as alleged hetcin with intentional tiisncgard ofPlaintiff's
`tights. As a rosult ofsuch acts. Defendant is misleading the public intobelievingthat its services
`are somehow sponsored by or connected with Plaintiff when. in fact, there is no such connection,
`in violation of Rhode Island common law concerning the protection oi‘ setvice marks.
`
`of its insurancc products and sc
`
`
`
`
`
`PAGE 6i12* RCVD AT 311112004 4'26'22 PM [Eastern Standard Time- -
`
`]*SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-210 * DNIS'T46T068 * CSlD' * DURATION
`-
`-
`
`(mm-ss):0348
`
`

`
`
`
`MRR-11-224
`
`16:43
`
`RUPES 8. GRRY
`
`‘
`
`.
`
`..
`
`.
`
`JT.L"96'-2331
`
`15123
`
`Rgpgs 3 ‘mm;
`
`F‘.B'?
`
`F589
`
`As a direct and proximatc result of the acts ofDefendant as alleged herein,
`23.
`Plaintiff has suffered and will continue IO suffer grant damage to itsbusiness. 8°04Will»
`
`reputation and profits.
`24.
`Plaintiffhas no adequate remedy at law for the inilingemcnt of it: marks as
`allegedheroin. Unit-.-asDofcitdantis ptvliniittariiy andvetmmntly enioincd by this com
`Plaintiff will suffer ltrcparablc harm.
`25.
`In acting as itllegt-.d herein, Dcicndant has. acted with
`towardPlaintiff. Ptatmmis therefore
`emtitlcd to an award of punitive dnmagas for tho 3
`_ eltaznplo and by way of punishing the Defendant.
`
`akaof
`
`oppression. fraud and malice
`
`mum Q nuu 1@mm
`ts and r:al1:gosthe.nl1cgmIons of paragraphs 1 through 25 as if
`
`slve exp:-.t-‘tancc. cure. and skill in
`
`Plaintiff mpea
`25.
`'
`fully set fotth herein.
`27.
`All it direct rcsull of Pluintifl"s lung iutdvexten
`"W9 B5“-°“
`marketing and selling its i
`nsumuce products and services under the. nnmcs of
`"The Beacon," and under the lighthouse
`
`l
`
`-
`
`" “Beacon Ittstmmca“ and
`Mutual Insurance Company,
`service: mark, Plaintiff has acquired a reputation for excellane: in the insttrancc field. and
`
`commands extensive sales.
`28.
`Dcieridant. by using names and logos vlccuptivcly similttr to the Plaintiffs. is
`tnislcading lh: public into belicvingthat its services are somehow sponsoredby or connacted
`with Plaintiff's business when, in fact. theta is no such connection.
`thl: good
`29.
`Such
`acts by Defendant are. likely to tleptivo Plaintiff of the benefit of
`and dilute the distinctive
`will associated with its marks, injun: Plaintifi"s butiinoss reputation.
`do Island General Laws § 6-2-12.
`
`quality of Piaiuti ft‘ s marks. in violation of Kilo
`
`6
`
`PAGE7112* RCVDAT 3l11l2nll44'26'22 PM [Eastern StandardTime
`-
`-
`
`V
`]*SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-2l0*DNIS'?467068*cSlD'*DURATION
`-
`-
`
`(mm-ss):0348
`
`

`
`
`
`MRR.-1 1-2884
`
`16 3 43
`
`RUPES & GRFIY
`
`‘
`
`I can 51v.
`
`M-""“5"'-mi
`
`1-5'21
`
`ROPES s. GREY
`
`1''.
`
`P . 88
`1U
`
`mag
`
`30.
`
`As the‘.direct and proximate tosult of the acts of Defendant as alleged lleroiu.
`
`Plaintiff has suffercd and will continue to suffer
`
`reputation. and profits.
`31.
`Plaintiffhe no adequate remedy at law against this dilution of its marks andlor
`Unloss Defendant is prellminarfly and pennanently enjoined by
`
`injury lo its business reputation.
`
`this court, Plaintiff will suffer ix-reparablo harm.
`WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays for zelicf as f011OW8=
`1.
`That Defondam, its officers. agents. scrvants, employees and
`ropmsaumivos and all ollhcrporscms. firms orcorpomlions in active concert orpanicipation
`therewillmube preliminarily ancfihoroafter oermafitfil '
`Using in any manner in cotxnoctlon with any of no insurance p
`ta)
`services or in connection with any advertising. marketing 0!‘ PI°m°¢i°nS "5 SW“
`insurance products and srviccs, any name or logo deceptivoly similar to
`as and trade names, including tho use of Onoacacnn
`
`Plaintiff‘ 5 service ma
`lxusunmcg-. and the lightholwe logo, or any colorable lmilazion thoroof, in a manner
`which is likely to confuse. the public into believing that Defendant's inéumnce
`products and services an: mnrkuled. sold. sponsored or authorized by Plaintiff:
`
`and
`
`(b)
`
`Doitlfi ally not or thing calculated or likely to cause cm:
`s of the public or tho lmde. or prospective purchasers of
`
`fusion or mistake
`
`in the minds ofmembar
`Defendant's insurance products and sowicca. as to the source of insurance:
`products and services markmd. sold. offered for sa1e,~or likely to douoive
`members of the public or the trade or prospective purchasm. into bolioving that
`
`-
`PAGE 8I12 * RCVD AT 3l11!2004 4'26'22 PM [Eastern Standard Time *
`-
`~
`] SVR.USPTO-EFXRF-210*DNlS'?467068*CSlD'*DURAT|0N
`-
`-
`
`-
`(mm-ss).03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`.f}‘.qR_".11.—.2?E‘.‘. _.1.§_:_4“
`
`RUPES a GRRY
`
`mm M
`
`I J'lJL-B6-2681
`
`15l21
`
`R01-'-Es 9, mm
`
`r P.B9
`.
`11
`
`P 18
`
`than-. is some. connection hctwaen Tlcfcndimt and Plaintiff or thatDefendant's
`sad, offered for sale or
`insurance products and services are marketed. sold. advmi
`
`2.
`That Defendant. pursuant tn
`dtstmction all advertisements, letterlmds. labzla: Bis!!!» Dfifitfiv PWd“°l1iWflW'=- P3¢k58'-'-°-
`
`wrappers, l'SCBpI.El.C1e3 and mini
`names. or name» or logos dcceptivcly sln1ilnrtoPiainr5f1”$ Safvice mfirki 3“ "350 WW5» W 3“?
`‘Jziion thereof, and all plates. molds. matrices. find
`repmduczlnn. counterfeit. copy of colorable iml
`
`V other maans ofmaking the same;
`3. mr;l.iIE_ii5"Cé}"Q§§{2i“£§§i‘i*aEE”E{{I:iirisfiud15:iy'o'v¢:r'ld'Plntndff::1liaHhu=pmfi1s....
`realized by Defendant, or others acting in conccrt nr panicipntion thurawith. from the sale of
`insurance products a
`= mm‘? “id ‘Tam
`r §.crvic:as uncle: its unauthorized use ofPlnintifl"s aawic
`g and unfair rncthods of cQmp¢:_h'tiO‘i_'i as gliggcd ixerein:
`mines and Dul'cnd:mi's false advenisin
`Thai Plaintiffrecover its damages sustained as a result ofDefendznivs
`4.
`a service marks and trade
`false advcrtising and unfair cuxnpetikion nndinf1'1ng!-mentl)fP1£l§Miff’
`
`.
`
`..
`
`..
`
`..
`
`names:
`
`Thai. plaimm‘ be award:-.6 three time Defendant's profits or three time
`5,
`Plaintiffs damages. whicheveris greater. mgetllar with Plaintiff's rcasonable af1°1'MY5' {B95
`
`pursuant to is U.S.C. §§ 11i'I(a) and (b);
`6.
`' That Plaintiff bu awarded punitive damagcs pursulmt to Rhode: Island
`
`common law;
`
`‘I.
`
`That Plaintiff recover the. costs ofthis suit‘. anti
`
`-
`-
`
`PAGE 9l12*RcvD AT 3!11I20044'26'22 PM [Eastern Standard Time *
`-
`
`] SVR.UsPTO-EFXRF-210*DNIs'7467068*CSlD'*DURAT|0N- -
`
`
`
`
`
`-(mm-ss).0348
`
`

`
`16: 44
`MRR-11-2884
`. -- ..-.
`.
`
`REIPES 8. GRFIY
`
`nun nu.
`
`J'|.fl.*-Q6-2531.
`
`15:21‘
`
`RDPES s. cm;
`
`F’. 18
`(5
`
`g,
`
`5"“
`
`\
`\
`
`3.
`
`'
`-
`mm 1- relxef as xt deems
`That the Coast gm‘ 5“°“ °“‘°’ “mu
`3
`
`meet and
`
`just.
`
`11:2 BEACON NAUTUAL INSURANCE
`
`COMPANY '
`
`ay its Attomevsv
`PARTRIDGE SNOW & HAHN L1»?
`
`n E. Snow (#1774)
`5;;
`so 5:
`oz main street
`:3,
`'
`(4o:)‘a6‘1‘-3200'
`(401) 861-8210 FAX
`
`'
`
`59¢-131.1/1 3114“
`
`PAGE 10I12* RCVD AT 311112004 4:26:22 PM [Eastern standard Time] * SVRIUSPTO-EFXRF-210 * DN|S:7467068 * CSID: * DURATION (mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`MRR-11-2884
`
`16:44
`
`RDPES 8. GRRY
`
`JLL-B6-2681
`
`15:21.
`
`RDPES s. GRAY
`
`I
`
`P.11
`
`1’ '12
`
`.-—‘:
`- .'‘:—.‘-j
`On Beacon Gem
`_,..... ....-—-—---»--— "" "" ' ‘
`wafimm *1!“ 028% ms
`401425-1667
`
`
`
`V
`
`’
`. 5.
`
` .
`
`f T":"
`=.1z;m Mutual lnsumnca Cu.
`
`
`
`Fax: cmnu4m.s2s-2930 1 Ur-drnv"1f1'*S“°“9”’z°’5 A W’ ‘Wm’ huwwlwmlc
`
`gum-.msal.cam
`
`Anaaiwo
`
`PAGE 11112 * RCVD AT 311112004 4:26:22 PM [Eastem Standard Time)’ SVRIUSPTO-EFXRF-210 * DN|S:746?D58* CSIDI * DURATION (mm-ss):03-48
`
`

`
`
`
`‘Q-
`
`MF1l.?-11-2.B._@_4.1 I
`
`-44
`. ..
`
`RUPES 8. GRRY
`
`.
`
`_
`
`F’. 12
`
`JUt.~i36-29131
`
`15:22
`
`Rupee a may
`
` And proudly announces a new owner: White Mountains
`Insurance Group. What's not changing is 0neBeacon's
`
`commitment to provide insurance solutions and Superior
`
`
`claims service. which has began shinlng brightly for
`
`
`170 years. We remain cl ediczite-d to the independent
`
`
`agent and the ccnmsel and human touch
`
`
`you provide. The -peaplc-based relation-
`
`
`ships we create together will be at
`
`
`the very heart of our mutua!
`
`
`success. woigkinxag by your
`
`
`side. CH\eBc:acurL can help
`you provide customized
`
`coverages and the
`
`local knowledge ’
`
`
`
`
`Ilmt In your
`
`C I 1 e }‘l 1 5'
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`'PAGE 12f12* RCVD AT 31111200441922 PM [Eastern Standard Time ‘' ' ] SVR.USPTO-EFXRF-ZN’DN|S'7457U53* CS|D' * DURAT|0N
`'
`'
`
`
`
`TDTQL F’.1'S
`
`'
`(mm'55)-0348
`
`TUTRL P. 12

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket