`ESTTA362657
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`08/11/2010
`
`Filing date:
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`Notice of Opposition
`
`Notice is hereby given that the following party opposes registration of the indicated application.
`Opposer Information
`
`Pet Holdings Inc.
`08/11/2010
`
`190 Queen Anne Ave N Suite 250
`Seattle, WA 98109-4968
`UNITED STATES
`Pet Holdings, Inc.
`Pet Holdings, Inc.
`
`Original inclusion of comma was incorrect
`
`Name
`Granted to Date
`of previous
`extension
`Address
`
`Party who filed
`Extension of time
`to oppose
`Relationship to
`party who filed
`Extension of time
`to oppose
`
`Attorney
`information
`
`VENKAT BALASUBRAMANI
`FOCAL PLLC
`800 FIFTH AVENUE, SUITE 4100
`SEATTLE, WA 98104
`UNITED STATES
`venkat@focallaw.com Phone:2065294827
`Applicant Information
`
`Application No
`Opposition Filing
`Date
`Applicant
`
`77868181
`08/11/2010
`
`Publication date
`Opposition
`Period Ends
`
`04/13/2010
`08/11/2010
`
`Combo Ventures
`10A 1401 Ocean Avenue
`Brooklyn, NY 11230
`UNITED STATES
`Goods/Services Affected by Opposition
`
`Class 041. First Use: 2009/04/22 First Use In Commerce: 2009/04/22
`All goods and services in the class are opposed, namely: Providing an Internet website portal in the
`field of entertainment, pertaining to the realm of human and animal error, updated daily in the form of
`pictures, video and text
`
`Grounds for Opposition
`
`Priority and likelihood of confusion
`
`Trademark Act section 2(d)
`
`Mark Cited by Opposer as Basis for Opposition
`
`
`
`U.S. Registration
`No.
`Registration Date
`
`Word Mark
`Design Mark
`
`3748736
`
`02/16/2010
`
`FAIL BLOG
`
`Application Date
`
`04/08/2009
`
`Foreign Priority
`Date
`
`NONE
`
`Description of
`Mark
`Goods/Services
`
`NONE
`
`Class 038. First use: First Use: 2008/01/03 First Use In Commerce: 2008/01/03
`Communications services, namely, providing facilities for users of computers,
`mobile and handheld computing devices, and wired and wireless communication
`devices to post, transmit, receive, retrieve, organize, search and review text,
`voice, audio and visual content and data via optical and electronic
`communication networks; telecommunication services, namely, transmission of
`text, voice, audio and visual content and data via optical and electronic
`communication networks; mobile media services in the nature of electronic
`transmission of online entertainment media content in a wide variety of subject
`matter for others
`Class 041. First use: First Use: 2008/01/03 First Use In Commerce: 2008/01/03
`Electronic publishing services, namely, publishing of online works of others
`featuring text, voice, audio and visual content; entertainment services in the
`nature of non-downloadable music, voice, audio and visual content and data
`Class 042. First use: First Use: 2008/01/03 First Use In Commerce: 2008/01/03
`Providing temporary use of non-downloadable computer software for use in
`posting, transmitting, receiving, retrieving, organizing, searching and reviewing
`text, voice, audio and visual content and data via computers, mobile and
`handheld computing devices, and wired and wireless communication devices;
`application service provider (ASP) services featuring software used for the
`dissemination, distribution and review of text, voice, audio and visual content
`and data via optical and electronic communication networks; providing
`temporary use of non-downloadable computer software for social networking;
`hosting an online website featuring web portals, web logs, blogs, electronic
`bulletin boards, collaboration and wiki sites related to the dissemination,
`distribution and review of online content in a wide variety of subject matter
`
`Attachments
`
`77709571#TMSN.jpeg ( 1 page )( bytes )
`NOTICE OF OPPOSITION - FILED VERSION.pdf ( 9 pages )(437041 bytes )
`
`The undersigned hereby certifies that a copy of this paper has been served upon all parties, at their address
`record by First Class Mail on this date.
`
`Certificate of Service
`
`
`
`Signature
`Name
`Date
`
`/vb/
`VENKAT BALASUBRAMANI
`08/11/2010
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` ! "#$% &''()*) +)( , - .../01
`
` 23" 4567,8+ ,9-:
`5'' ;)) , -
` %A 329 B&6
`
`5'' ;:
` B)()C 7A , <$D E: 100E
`<-
` 2FD()*) 7A &')( G: 100
` 95=5 >3,"?@3+ 669:
`
`
`&''()*-
`
`
`
` $ ! ''()*) +)( , - .../01 !)(# , <$D E: 100E DH 9 $D
`>F; 669 IJ&''()*JK: ,L M % ()$)# ()D)()H * $'H: C); 329 B&6 ;
`#$% ! F; ) * *) L) JNOPQORSTOSRPUSVWQRSPXYTRNZPQOPR[SP\QSZ]PY\PSORSTRNQO^SOR_P
`XSTRNQOQO`PRYPR[SPTSNZ^PY\P[a^NOPNO]PNOQ^NZPSTTYTPaX]NRS]P]NQZbPQOPR[SP\YT^PY\PXQcRaTSW_PdQ]SYP
`NO]PRSeR:J L)* L; 'FD();# ) 5!!)*)( 8f &')( G: 100: ! (( L)C 'H
`D()<; ) L)(( D #$C# DH C);) ! 329 B&6 $%A 2 4 (#)C; *-
`IJ5'' ;JK: g;)C * ' ) : <)C ); ')*)'( '(* ! DF;);; E0 hF
`& &<F , : +F) 1i0: +(: g;)C E/0E- &** #)C(H: 5'' ; !)(; );
`, )* ! 5'' ;)) C);) ! 329 B&6 $%-
`
`" C F#; ! ); '' ;)) ; ! (( L;A
`-j5'' ; ; D)# *;;H k;) ! )$ L)) L)* !)( );
`, )* ! 5'' ;)) -
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`!
`
`
`46781,649502.6:;95<7-81=10>5?2,1:131645?-75/46745-?5,-.</367495.-@1:6520=5A20=A6:=5,-.</310>5
`=681,649520=5B176=520=5B176:6445,-../01,231-05=681,6453-5<-439537204.139576,6186957637168695
`-7>201C6954627,A520=576816B536D3958-1,6952/=1-520=5814/2:5,-03603520=5=23258125-<31,2:520=5
`6:6,37-01,5,-../01,231-05063B-7E4F536:6,-../01,231-0546781,649502.6:;9537204.1441-05-?536D395
`8-1,6952/=1-520=5814/2:5,-03603520=5=23258125-<31,2:520=56:6,37-01,5,-../01,231-05063B-7E4F5
`.-@1:65.6=12546781,6451053A65023/765-?56:6,37-01,537204.1441-05-?5-0:1065603673210.6035.6=125
`,-03603510525B1=65827163;5-?54/@G6,35.233675?-75-3A674+
`
` #&J +6:6,37-01,5
`</@:14A10>546781,649502.6:;95</@:14A10>5-?5-0:1065B-7E45-?5-3A6745?623/710>536D3958-1,6952/=1-520=5
`814/2:5,-03603F5603673210.603546781,6451053A65023/765-?50-0K=-B0:-2=2@:65./41,958-1,6952/=1-5
`20=5814/2:5,-03603520=5=232+
`
` %LJ +<7-81=10>536.<-727;5/465-?50-0K
`=-B0:-2=2@:65,-.</36754-?3B2765?-75/465105<-4310>9537204.13310>9576,61810>95763716810>95
`-7>201C10>954627,A10>520=576816B10>536D3958-1,6952/=1-520=5814/2:5,-03603520=5=23258125
`,-.</367495.-@1:6520=5A20=A6:=5,-.</310>5=681,649520=5B176=520=5B176:6445,-../01,231-05
`=681,64F52<<:1,231-0546781,65<7-81=675MNOPQ546781,645?623/710>54-?3B2765/46=5?-753A65
`=1446.10231-095=14371@/31-0520=576816B5-?536D3958-1,6952/=1-520=5814/2:5,-03603520=5=23258125
`-<31,2:520=56:6,37-01,5,-../01,231-05063B-7E4F5<7-81=10>536.<-727;5/465-?50-0K=-B0:-2=2@:65
`,-.</36754-?3B2765?-754-,12:5063B-7E10>F5A-4310>5205-0:1065B6@41365?623/710>5B6@5<-732:495B6@5
`:->495@:->4956:6,37-01,5@/::63105@-27=495,-::2@-7231-0520=5B1E1541364576:236=53-53A65=1446.10231-095
`=14371@/31-0520=576816B5-?5-0:1065,-03603510525B1=65827163;5-?54/@G6,35.23367+
`IH
`
` %
`
` R
`
`
`
`
`
`* H
` UR
`
` H*
`
`
`
`
`since at least January 3, 2008. Opposer filed its application to register the FAIL BLOG mark on
`
`2.
`
`Opposer owns the registered trademark FAIL BLOG (U.S. Trademark
`
`Registration No. 374873 6), a standard character mark, in connection with "communications
`
`services, namely, providingfacilitiesfor users ofcomputers, mobile and handheld computing
`
`devices, and wired and wireless communication devices to post, transmit, receive, retrieve,
`
`organize, search and review text, voice, audio and visual content and data via optical and
`
`electronic communication networks; telecommunication services, namely, transmission of text,
`
`voice, audio and visual content and data via optical and electronic communication networks;
`
`mobile media services in the nature ofelectronic transmission of online entertainment media
`
`content in a wide variety ofsubject matterfor others" in International Class 38; "electronic
`
`publishing services, namely, publishing ofonline works of others featuring text, voice, audio and
`
`visual content; entertainment services in the nature ofnon-downloadable music, voice, audio
`
`and visual content and data" in International Class 41; and "providing temporary use ofnon-
`
`downloadable computer softwarefor use in posting, transmitting, receiving, retrieving,
`
`organizing, searching and reviewing text, voice, audio and visual content and data via
`
`computers, mobile and handheld computing devices, and wired and wireless communication
`
`devices; application service provider (ASP) servicesfeaturing software usedfor the
`
`dissemination, distribution and review of text, voice, audio and visual content and data via
`
`optical and electronic communication networks; providing temporary use ofnon-downloadable
`
`computer softwarefor social networking; hosting an online websitefeaturing web portals, web
`
`logs, blogs, electronic bulletin boards, collaboration and wiki sites related to the dissemination,
`
`distribution and review of online content in a wide variety ofsubject matter" in International
`
`Class 42. Opposer has used the FAIL BLOG mark in connection with the above-stated services
`
`
`
`
`
`
` &%# ' ( ( %$ % )*+,-,./0
`1& 2 ( 3 444
`5
` $ 2 '67 # % %
` $ 2 ! " #
`81 ! " $%% # 92
`
` :$ : : 2 :$ 2 % % ;% %%
` % ;% % $ ;2 : %
`$##
`<1 % $ '67 $%% #
`
`
` ! " # 72 # $ 2% $ 2
`'67 # ; % % $
`=1 ; % ; % 2 %
` % >; 2 $ ; ? 2 #
`;: % 22 % ;% ? % % 2 2
`;$ 41 22 2% % %;% ! " # 22
` @% (
`
`1! 22 # %; % ;
` : ! " # % A2 ; ! " #
` B ; 2$ %: 2 $ & %: $
`
`
`
`connection with the FAIL BLOG mark, and the quality of those services, the FAIL BLOG mark
`
`April 8, 2009. A copy of the registration information for Opposer's FAIL BLOG mark, obtained
`
`from the Trademark Electronic Search System database, is attached hereto as Exhibit A.
`
`3.
`
`There is no issue of priority concerning application Serial No. 77781021.
`
`Applicant began first use of the EPIC FAIL mark and filed its application for registration long
`
`after Opposer began first use of its FAIL BLOG mark.
`
`4.
`
`FAIL BLOG, as embodied in the market since at least January 3, 2008, is an
`
`online website which allows users of the website to upload photos and videos to the site, add
`
`captions to the photos and videos, and share the postings by means of various social news and
`
`bookmarking applications.
`
`5.
`
`On information and belief, EPIC FAIL, as embodied in the market since at least
`
`April 22, 2009, is an online website providing almost identical services as those provided under
`
`Opposer's FAIL BLOG mark. Consumers are likely to be confi1sed by Applicant's use of the
`
`EPIC FAIL mark for services that are nearly identical to those offered by Opposer.
`
`6.
`
`Opposer's services and Applicant's services are offered through identical channels
`
`of trade. Moreover, the target consumers for both parties‘ services — consumers seeking to post,
`
`view and share humorous photos and videos — are identical. Accordingly, consumer confi1sion is
`
`inevitable.
`
`7.
`
`Opposer has continuously used and advertised the FAIL BLOG mark throughout
`
`the United States for a significant time.
`
`8.
`
`By reason of continuous marketing, advertising and promotion of services in
`
`has extremely valuable goodwill that inures to the benefit of Opposer. This goodwill has been
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` !
`"!#
` $
`
` '
`
`
`!( )
`(
`'
` +
`
`
`
`,-!#
` $
` %
`
`
`'
`
` $ / '
`
` $
` $
`
` '
`
`
`,,!#)
`
`
`
` /
`
`
`,4!#%
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`789%9' %
`
` :
`
` $
`
`
`
`
` '
` ' <--
`
`/' 2 ,--' 2
`' 7
`%
`!
`
`
`
`and will continue to be harmed by the use and registration of the confusingly similar mark EPIC
`
`WHEREFORE, Opposer asks that its opposition to Application Serial No. 77781021 be
`
`sustained and that Applicant's proposed registration of the mark EPIC FAIL be refi1sed. Please
`
`direct all correspondence to the attention of Venkat Balasubramani, Focal PLLC, 800 Fifih
`
`Avenue, Suite 4100, Seattle, Washington 98104. The undersigned is authorized to act on
`
`Opposer's behalf.
`
`FAIL sought to be registered by Applicant.
`
`9.
`
`Applicant's mark is similar in appearance and sound to Opposer's mark. Both are
`
`standard character marks, comprised of two four-letter words, with each mark containing the
`
`word "fail." The word "fail" is the dominant component of each mark. Consequently, the marks
`
`create an extremely similar commercial impression.
`
`10.
`
`Applicant's EPIC FAIL mark so resembles Opposer's FAIL BLOG mark as to be
`
`likely, when applied to the Applicant's services, to cause confi1sion, mistake or deception as to
`
`the source or origin of Applicant's goods by creating the erroneous impression that Applicant's
`
`goods originate with, are sponsored, approved, endorsed or licensed by, are affiliated or
`
`associated with, or are in some other way connected to Opposer.
`
`11.
`
`The granting of a trademark registration for the EPIC FAIL mark to Applicant
`
`would be contrary to 15 U.S.C. § l052(d) and would violate or diminish the prior and superior
`
`rights of Opposer in its FAIL BLOG trademark.
`
`12.
`
`Opposer will be damaged if Applicant obtains registration of its mark because
`
`Applicant will obtain statutory rights in the mark in violation and derogation of the established
`
`prior rights of Opposer in its FAIL BLOG mark.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` ) *
`!"#$!% " &&' (&
`+,"- .--,
`
`/*% 0 1 2 /
`
`1 2 /
`
`3 + "4 ' 5 6&
`5 ' 7" 83&6
`. % (9 (863(:
`+;% (9 (9899
`$ % 4 2<
` "
` *
`
`
`. = >
`
`
`
`Seattle, WA 98104
`Phone: (206) 529-4827
`Fax:
`(206) 260-3966
`Email: venkat@focallaw.com
`
`Opposer submits the required filing fee of three hundred dollars ($300.00)
`
`contemporaneous with this Notice of Opposition.
`
`DATED: August 11, 2010
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`FOCAL PLLC
`
`By: /s Venkat Balasubramani
`Venkat Balasubramani
`
`800 Fifih Avenue, Suite 4100
`
`Attorneys for Opposer
`Pet Holdings Inc.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`
`
`
`
`i+35(*0j05k405l0j
`&&'()*+,)(-.&/&'()*+,)(-012+34(567308+)(3908:.4+,0;'188<
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&VWXYZX&W[\[]^&_`Xa&b[]&YcX&d[aX&^[&cXWXYZX&ZbZ^Xe&cXZ[]cfXZ&YWW[fY^Xd&g[c&b[]h
`&
`mnmopqmrsqmtuvwxtmyzrr{|m{}mrsqm~|rq|qr
`u{pqmr{mqrz|mr{m
`
`
`
`&&=>??@ABC@DBCE@FGHBEIH@JK@LIH@MFN@OO@PQRSTRTO@>U=@SPOP
` 5(*0)(-0
`55*.0)6*
`&h&&&&h&&&&[ee]afY^[aZ&ZXcfXZ&aYeXWb&c[da\&gYfW^XZ&g[c&]ZXcZ&[g&f[e]^XcZ
`e[WX&Yad&`Yad`XWd&f[e]^a\&dXfXZ&Yad&_cXd&Yad&_cXWXZZ&f[ee]afY^[a&dXfXZ&^[&[Z^&^cYaZe^
`8+(73+.
`cXfXX&cX^cXX&[c\Ya X&ZXYcf`&Yad&cXX_&^X¡^&[fX&Y]d[&Yad&Z]YW&f[a^Xa^&Yad&dY^Y&Y&[^fYW&Yad
`XWXf^c[af&f[ee]afY^[a&aX^_[c¢Z£&^XWXf[ee]afY^[a&ZXcfXZ&aYeXWb&^cYaZeZZ[a&[g&^X¡^&[fX&Y]d[&Yad
`Z]YW&f[a^Xa^&Yad&dY^Y&Y&[^fYW&Yad&XWXf^c[af&f[ee]afY^[a&aX^_[c¢Z£&e[WX&eXdY&ZXcfXZ&a&^`X&aY^]cX
`[g&XWXf^c[af&^cYaZeZZ[a&[g&[aWaX&Xa^Xc^YaeXa^&eXdY&f[a^Xa^&a&Y&_dX&YcX^b&[g&Z]¤Xf^&eY^^Xc&g[c&[^`XcZh
`¥¦§&¨&©h&¥¦§&¨&ª&«¬¬¨¦¨&©
`&h&&&&h&&&&¨WXf^c[af&]WZ`a\&ZXcfXZ&aYeXWb&]WZ`a\&[g&[aWaX&_[c¢Z&[g&[^`XcZ
`gXY^]ca\&^X¡^&[fX&Y]d[&Yad&Z]YW&f[a^Xa^£&Xa^Xc^YaeXa^&ZXcfXZ&a&^`X&aY^]cX&[g&a[a®d[_aW[YdYWX&e]Zf
`[fX&Y]d[&Yad&Z]YW&f[a^Xa^&Yad&dY^Yh&¥¦§&¨&©h&¥¦§&¨&ª&«¬¬¨¦¨&©
`&©h&&&h&&&&Vc[da\&^Xe[cYcb&]ZX&[g&a[a®d[_aW[YdYWX&f[e]^Xc&Z[g^_YcX&g[c&]ZX&a
`[Z^a\&^cYaZe^^a\&cXfXa\&cX^cXa\&[c\Ya a\&ZXYcf`a\&Yad&cXX_a\&^X¡^&[fX&Y]d[&Yad&Z]YW
`f[a^Xa^&Yad&dY^Y&Y&f[e]^XcZ&e[WX&Yad&`Yad`XWd&f[e]^a\&dXfXZ&Yad&_cXd&Yad&_cXWXZZ
`f[ee]afY^[a&dXfXZ£&YWfY^[a&ZXcfX&c[dXc&¯°V±&ZXcfXZ&gXY^]ca\&Z[g^_YcX&]ZXd&g[c&^`X
`dZZXeaY^[a&dZ^c]^[a&Yad&cXX_&[g&^X¡^&[fX&Y]d[&Yad&Z]YW&f[a^Xa^&Yad&dY^Y&Y&[^fYW&Yad&XWXf^c[af
`f[ee]afY^[a&aX^_[c¢Z£&c[da\&^Xe[cYcb&]ZX&[g&a[a®d[_aW[YdYWX&f[e]^Xc&Z[g^_YcX&g[c&Z[fYW
`aX^_[c¢a\£&`[Z^a\&Ya&[aWaX&_XZ^X&gXY^]ca\&_X&[c^YWZ&_X&W[\Z&W[\Z&XWXf^c[af&]WWX^a&[YcdZ
`f[WWY[cY^[a&Yad&_¢&Z^XZ&cXWY^Xd&^[&^`X&dZZXeaY^[a&dZ^c]^[a&Yad&cXX_&[g&[aWaX&f[a^Xa^&a&Y&_dX&YcX^b
`[g&Z]¤Xf^&eY^^Xch&¥¦§&¨&©h&¥¦§&¨&ª&«¬¬¨¦¨&©
`84)6*)(*
`²9)()34+(.
`²2)7,+*
`)(-³()´76µ
`¯±&§°ª¶°¦¶&·°¦°§¨¦&¬°¦¸
`²5*+
`8+(7)2¹k,º+(
`»¼
`7276µ0³)4+°cW&&©»
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` !!"
`#
`
`&'()'&*
`$ %
`#
`
`,-./* !!
`+
`0
`12345672879:;<=>?@ABC5ADEF2:F275F83GH23"!I-AAAJ8D6-@; K!6.;;>
`H6<5847F8")!"
`L M
`6.AODE=.A
`# N
`+ N
`VM W
`#
`
`:258E5:G
`YZ [+
`G5R3
`\N
`]^_W`a]ab\V`\$+`c]ab`L# _a]adeb\$`bba]a_`Ya]a#\fL gY\ ga
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` !"#$$% &''()*
`+++,"% --(('../01.1/ *)2 +*-+3*
`4*%'$* *)25
`6*7-(('../01.1
`8'923+'()
`923+'()
`
`
`
`
` !"#$$% &'',*
`*';+'')+/';*/-(('../01.1/(-+++&
`**''7!)9('
`.<1.-,(/-.1-
`32+/&=2..0>1
`6*7-(('../01.1
`
`8'923+'()
`923+'()
`
`
`
`electronically via ESTTA on August 11, 2010, to the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board of the
`
`address:
`
`Combo Ventures
`
`1401 Ocean Avenue, Apt 10A
`Brooklyn, New York 11230
`
`Dated: August 11, 2010
`
`/s Venkat Balasubramani
`
`Venkat Balasubramani
`
`CERTIFICATE OF TRANSMISSION
`
`I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing NOTICE OF OPPOSITION was submitted
`
`United States Patent and Trademark Office.
`
`Dated: August 11, 2010
`
`/s Venkat Balasubramani
`
`Venkat Balasubramani
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing NOTICE OF OPPOSITION was served by
`
`certified first-class mail, postage-prepaid, on August 11, 2010, upon Applicant at the following



