Filed
`13 September 5 P4:09
`John Warren
`County Clerk
`Dallas County
`
` IN THE COUNTY COURT
`
`Cause No. CC-12-01595-A
`
`
`BIANCA ELLIOTT COLGIN,
`INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF
`ARDEN LOUISE COLGIN, A MINOR,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`
`
`
`vs.
`
`ROBERT M. FARRELL, and NORTH RIO
`VISTA, LTD,
`
`Defendants.
`
`
`
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`
`
`PLAINTIFF’S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO QUASH AND MOTION
`FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING PLAINTIFF NOTICE OF ORAL
`DEPOSITION OF ROBERT M. FARRELL
`
`TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
`
`
`
`
`
`AT LAW NO. 1
`
`DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
`
`
`
`
`Bianca Elliott Colgin, in both her individual and representative capacities, Plaintiff,
`
`moves the Court for an Order denying Defendants’ Motion to Quash and for Protective Order,
`
`and for an Order compelling the second deposition of Robert M. Farrell.
`
`A.
`
`Procedural History
`
`
`March 2012
`September 2012
`September 2012
`July 25, 2013
`August 2, 2013
`August 5, 2013
`August 6, 2013
`August 9, 2013
`
`Suit Filed
`Deposition of William Hullum
`Deposition of Robert Farrell
`Production of Phone Records by AT&T
`Notice of Deposition of North Rio Vista, Ltd.
`Motion to Quash the Deposition of North Rio Vista, Ltd.
`Notice of Deposition of Robert Farrell
`Motion to Quash the Deposition of Robert Farrell
`
`Course and Scope of Employment is the Central Liability Issue
`
`This wrongful death suit includes allegations that Ranch Hand William Hullum was in
`
`
`B.
`
`
`
`the course and scope of his employment with North Rio Vista, Ltd. (“NRV”) and/or Robert M.
`
`
`
`Page 1
`
`

`
`Farrell at the time of the shooting death of Clinton Colgin. NRV and Farrell should be aware of
`
`the danger of hinging success on this all or nothing issue. For now, however, millions of
`
`insurance dollars ride on the jury’s answer(s) to the course and scope question(s).
`
`
`
`Here, Plaintiff presents her course and scope evidence in summary fashion:
`
`� Hullum completed ranch work for NRV in five separate years (2007-2010, 2012).
`� Hullum worked more than 2,000 hours and more than 250 days.
`� Hullum was paid more than $21,000.
`� Hullum, along with Ranch Manager Overton and Ranch Hand McClendon, is listed as a
`driver on NRV’s Commercial Auto Policy, amendment effective September 28, 2010.1
`� Hullum’s last day of paid work for 2010 appears to be September 23rd from records
`produced in discovery,2 but the amendment effective date for the policy listing Hullum as
`an insured ranch driver is September 28, 2010.3 Further, Hullum had extensive
`communication with ranch personnel after September 23, 2010 and through the accident
`date of November 7, 2010. See, generally, AT&T mobility usage records, attached.
`� The last check to Hullum in 2010 dated October 10, 2010 (work from 9/14/10 to 9/23/10)
`makes no indication that it was a final check.4
`
`
`1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 2
`
`
`
`
`
` 3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`If Hullum was not working for the ranch after September 23, 2010, he would not likely be listed on a ranch
`insurance policy with an “amendment effective date” of September 28, 2010.
`
`
`4
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 2
`
`

`
`� Hullum was never terminated from employment.5
`� Farrell testified that the weekend was a “working weekend”.
`� Hullum was not deer hunting the day of the accident.6
`� Hullum owns a deer rifle but not bring it to the ranch that weekend.7
`� Hullum worked after the death of Colgin (“Arena Work” in February 2012).
`� “Help me out that weekend if things need to be done.” Farrell deposition.
`� Hullum was “supposed to go get a sick cow” that morning.
`� Hullum was on his way to repair a deer blind. Hullum deposition.
`� Hullum was attempting to clear a feral hog. Hullum deposition.
`� Hullum was using a ranch tool to clear the feral hog (Hullum did not own the rifle).
`� Hullum was in the process of clearing a feral hog for the benefit of ranch operations at
`the time of the accident. “You don’t want [feral hogs] eating your babies.”
`
`
`
`On July 25, 2013, long after the September 2012 deposition of Mr. Farrell and Mr.
`
`Hullum, Plaintiff received phone records for relevant dates. Tellingly, Ranch Hand Hullum
`
`made only one call on the morning of November 7, 2010 before he called 911 about an hour later
`
`at 8:24 a.m.—at 7:13 a.m., Ranch Hand Hullum called the ranch manager Neal Overton. The
`
`call lasted one minute and 31 seconds, which is enough time for Ranch Hand Hullum to receive
`
`his work instructions for the day. And before the call to Overton, Ranch Hand Hullum texted
`
`ranch hand McClendon. Ranch hand McClendon replied to Hullum’s text just 11 minutes before
`
`Hullum’s call to 911.8
`
`
`5
`
`It was a .222, but I wasn’t going out to shoot deer. I was going to watch deer. And where I was hunting,
`there’s a flat and then there's a creek, and we’ve got a government trapper that traps out there, and that’s
`one of his main spots that he was catching coyotes, and so I was really, you know, watching deer and see
`what's coming in there, and if a coyote comes, you know, shoot a coyote.
`
`
`
`
`
` 6
`
`
`
`Q. The .270 rifle that you own -- … what do you use that rifle for?
`A. Deer hunting.
`
`See Phone Records, attached (Bates 155, 190, and 191).
`
`Page 3
`
` 7
`
`
`
` 8
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`
`
`Ranch Hand Hullum has admitted to law enforcement that he “was supposed to go get a
`
`sick cow” that morning.9 He has admitted he was going to attend to a disengaged deer blind with
`
`a rotted out floor.10 He has admitted that he used Rob Farrell’s Ranch Rifle earlier that morning
`
`in an attempt to clear coyotes.11 He has admitted that ranch owner Farrell wanted Ranch Hand
`
`Hullum to shoot coyotes and feral hogs to keep them from “eating babies” and to keep them
`
`from tearing up the land.12 Finally, there is no dispute that Ranch Hand Hullum was attempting
`
`to shoot a feral hog—again with Ranch Owner Farrell’s Ranch Rifle—when he shot ranch guest
`
`Clinton Colgin.13 For all of NRV’s claims that Hullum was there to deer hunt, he never hunted
`
`deer that weekend and did not even bring his deer rifle.
`
`Ranch owner Farrell and ranch hand Hullum even exchanged four text messages on
`
`November 6, 2010, just one day before the accident. Ranch hand McClendon and ranch hand
`
`Hullum exchanged two texts immediately prior to the shooting. Despite the mountain of “course
`
`and scope” evidence, NRV “steadfastly” denies that Ranch Hand Hullum was in the course and
`
`scope of employment on the morning of Clinton’s death. Plaintiff is entitled to discovery on
`
`matters relevant to the denial, including a second deposition of Mr. Farrell regarding texts and
`
`phone calls between him and ranch personal at or near the time of this accident.
`
`Page 4
`
`
`
`
`9 See interview of William Hullum.
`10 See Id.
`11 See Deposition of William Hullum.
`12 See Id.
`13 See Id.
`
`
`

`
`C.
`
`Conclusion
`
`
`
`Though Plaintiff believes that the course and scope issue should be a matter of stipulation
`
`between the parties, the remaining defendants continue to defend the case claiming that Hullum
`
`was not working that day. Deposition testimony regarding text messages and phone calls is
`
`needed to clarify this central issue. The request for a second deposition is not in any way an
`
`attempt to harass Mr. Farrell. Rather, this is an important issue in an important case. The
`
`deposition is sought so that justice may be done.
`
`Plaintiff prays for the above-requested relief and for any additional relief to which she
`
`may show herself justly entitled.
`
`Respectfully Submitted,
`
`
`
`/s/ Jeffrey W. Hightower, Jr.
`Jeffrey W. Hightower, Jr.
`Texas SBN: 00793951
`William O. Angelley
`Texas SBN: 24001658
`
`HIGHTOWER ANGELLEY, LLP
`4144 North Central Expressway
`Suite 1230
`Dallas, Texas 75204
`Phone: 214.580.9800
`Fax: 214.580.9804
`E-mail: jeff@hightangel.com
`
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I hereby certify that on the 5th day of September, 2013, a true and correct copy of the
`foregoing document was served upon all counsel of record according to the Texas Rules of Civil
`Procedure.
`
`
`/s/ Jeffrey W. Hightower, Jr.
`Jeffrey W. Hightower, Jr.
`
`
`
`Page 5
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/15/10
`10/16/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`
`1
`2
`3
`4
`5
`6
`7
`8
`9
`10
`11
`12
`13
`14
`15
`16
`17
`18
`19
`20
`21
`22
`23
`24
`25
`26
`27
`28
`29
`30
`31
`32
`33
`34
`35
`36
`37
`38
`
`tr
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`08:30A
`08:34A
`08:34A
`08:38A
`09:07A
`09:07A
`09:19A
`09:21A
`09:26A
`09:38A
`09:48A
`09:50A
`09:56A
`09:57A
`10:04A
`10:17A
`11:15A
`11:21A
`11:22A
`11:22A
`11:32A
`05:07P
`07:14P
`07:16P
`07:17P
`07:17P
`07:24P
`07:28P
`07:32P
`07:33P
`07:35P
`08:54A
`10:09A
`11:08A
`02:38P
`02:39P
`02:39P
`02:42P
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:32
`0:12
`0:22
`0:10
`0:00
`0:17
`0:31
`0:25
`0:08
`0:37
`0:00
`0:10
`0:03
`0:04
`0:07
`0:08
`0:22
`0:21
`0:01
`0:26
`0:14
`0:09
`0:24
`0:31
`0:10
`0:23
`0:02
`0:02
`0:00
`0:07
`0:03
`0:09
`0:15
`0:08
`0:15
`0:00
`0:02
`0:00
`
`Originating
`Number
`12149145487
`14056647853
`13256651990
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143458250
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12143520090
`18176887478
`19724194000
`12149145487
`19724194000
`19403283229
`19403688752
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12148083625
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12146169277
`
`Terminating
`Number
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13256651990
`19724194032
`19724194032
`12142441472
`15012762137
`12145208874
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143458250
`12143458250
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19406540708
`19729227151
`15012762137
`15012762137
`12145551212
`18006058610
`12143520090
`12143520090
`18003473288
`12149145487
`12146169277
`15012762137
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12149145487
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`0:25
`4:10
`0:29
`5:32
`0:00
`1:39
`0:32
`0:26
`0:40
`9:14
`0:17
`5:52
`0:22
`1:31
`0:26
`3:33
`0:34
`0:00
`1:32
`1:32
`1:00
`1:38
`0:00
`0:04
`0:00
`0:45
`2:21
`3:03
`0:00
`0:04
`31:33
`0:36
`1:52
`0:22
`0:19
`0:00
`0:20
`0:00
`
`Number
`Dialed
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13256651990
`19724194032
`19724194032
`12142441472
`15012762137
`12145208874
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143458250
`12143458250
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19406540708
`19729227151
`15012762137
`15012762137
`411
`18006058610
`12143520090
`12143520090
`180034732888
`12149145487
`12146169277
`15012762137
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12149145487
`
`AT&T Proprietary
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`
`The information contained here is for use by authorized person only and is
`not for general distribution.
`
`Page 1
`
` Colgin 00001
`
`
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/17/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/18/10
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`
`39
`40
`41
`42
`43
`44
`45
`46
`47
`48
`49
`50
`51
`52
`53
`54
`55
`56
`57
`58
`59
`60
`61
`62
`63
`64
`65
`66
`67
`68
`69
`70
`71
`72
`73
`74
`75
`76
`
`tr
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`02:44P
`07:21P
`07:22P
`08:42A
`08:48A
`08:57A
`09:58A
`09:58A
`10:06A
`10:36A
`10:38A
`10:39A
`10:49A
`11:40A
`12:08P
`12:08P
`12:09P
`01:28P
`02:21P
`03:24P
`03:54P
`03:57P
`04:19P
`06:43P
`06:45P
`06:45P
`06:47P
`06:47P
`06:47P
`06:52P
`06:53P
`06:55P
`07:03P
`10:44P
`11:39A
`11:41A
`01:38P
`05:24P
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:08
`0:18
`0:22
`0:19
`0:16
`0:15
`0:20
`0:01
`0:12
`0:22
`0:08
`0:00
`0:13
`0:13
`0:20
`0:05
`0:02
`0:11
`0:08
`0:11
`0:25
`0:08
`0:22
`0:07
`0:01
`0:02
`0:00
`0:01
`0:21
`0:21
`0:01
`0:23
`0:20
`0:09
`0:06
`0:17
`0:09
`0:25
`
`Originating
`Number
`12146169277
`12144158171
`12144158171
`12146757531
`12149145487
`12149145487
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12144158171
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12144158171
`12149145487
`14694506444
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143458250
`19403283229
`12149145487
`12148027328
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12146757531
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12146757531
`12145022846
`12145022846
`12149145487
`19038160169
`12149145487
`
`Terminating
`Number
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12144158171
`19406598479
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12145145069
`18176887478
`12149145487
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12146750737
`12144456025
`12144456025
`12146930717
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12146757531
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19724194032
`12149145487
`12142441472
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`0:50
`0:00
`0:44
`0:00
`5:09
`1:53
`0:00
`0:04
`0:30
`0:29
`0:46
`0:25
`31:30
`0:17
`0:07
`0:38
`0:43
`0:02
`1:03
`2:26
`0:34
`5:51
`0:32
`1:43
`0:05
`0:23
`0:00
`5:11
`5:11
`0:00
`0:19
`1:06
`0:00
`2:45
`0:48
`1:20
`4:53
`0:16
`
`Number
`Dialed
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12144158171
`19406598479
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`18176887478
`12149145487
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12146750737
`12144456025
`12144456025
`12146930717
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12146757531
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19724194032
`12149145487
`12142441472
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMB
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`m2M_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2m
`m2M
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMB
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`
`The information contained here is for use by authorized person only and is
`not for general distribution.
`
`Page 2
`
`AT&T Proprietary
`
` Colgin 00002
`
`
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`10/19/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/20/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`
`77
`78
`79
`80
`81
`82
`83
`84
`85
`86
`87
`88
`89
`90
`91
`92
`93
`94
`95
`96
`97
`98
`99
`100
`101
`102
`103
`104
`105
`106
`107
`108
`109
`110
`111
`112
`113
`114
`
`tr
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`06:32P
`06:33P
`06:33P
`07:53P
`08:34A
`09:01A
`09:07A
`09:07A
`09:07A
`09:08A
`09:12A
`09:15A
`09:25A
`10:19A
`10:33A
`10:33A
`10:33A
`11:13A
`12:15P
`01:11P
`01:12P
`01:12P
`01:20P
`03:47P
`03:48P
`04:07P
`04:16P
`04:28P
`05:22P
`06:03P
`06:03P
`06:04P
`06:07P
`10:22P
`10:23P
`08:27A
`08:28A
`08:28A
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:21
`0:01
`0:02
`0:10
`0:29
`0:08
`0:00
`0:01
`0:23
`0:09
`0:09
`0:01
`0:09
`0:14
`0:21
`0:01
`0:26
`0:09
`0:21
`0:21
`0:02
`0:02
`0:17
`0:31
`0:24
`0:11
`0:29
`0:15
`0:07
`0:10
`0:04
`0:00
`0:05
`0:26
`0:00
`0:21
`0:01
`0:02
`
`Originating
`Number
`12142441472
`12149145487
`12142441472
`12147395144
`12149145487
`12142441472
`19723923366
`12149145487
`19723923366
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19723923366
`12149145487
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12143343884
`18174440442
`12149145487
`12144358797
`12149145487
`12144358797
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145077919
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12146759111
`12146759111
`12149145487
`12148027328
`12148027328
`12149145487
`12148027328
`
`Terminating
`Number
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12548653377
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12143520090
`19723923366
`12145551212
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145208874
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12144358797
`12143520090
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12145264300
`12149145487
`12146759111
`12146759111
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12148027328
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`0:00
`1:17
`1:17
`5:25
`5:09
`6:25
`0:00
`0:31
`0:31
`3:14
`0:39
`1:30
`2:55
`1:56
`0:00
`0:58
`0:58
`9:58
`2:56
`0:00
`0:26
`0:26
`4:37
`0:00
`0:26
`3:46
`0:00
`1:03
`0:29
`0:04
`0:09
`2:50
`0:19
`0:57
`2:33
`0:00
`0:41
`0:41
`
`Number
`Dialed
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12548653377
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12143520090
`19723923366
`411
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145208874
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12144358797
`12143520090
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12145264300
`12149145487
`12146759111
`12146759111
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12148027328
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`
`M2M_VMC
`M2m
`m2M
`O2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`O2M
`M2m
`O2M
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`m2M_VMC
`M2m
`m2M
`O2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2m
`m2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2m
`m2M
`
`The information contained here is for use by authorized person only and is
`not for general distribution.
`
`Page 3
`
`AT&T Proprietary
`
` Colgin 00003
`
`
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/21/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`
`115
`116
`117
`118
`119
`120
`121
`122
`123
`124
`125
`126
`127
`128
`129
`130
`131
`132
`133
`134
`135
`136
`137
`138
`139
`140
`141
`142
`143
`144
`145
`146
`147
`148
`149
`150
`151
`152
`
`tr
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`09:07A
`09:14A
`09:22A
`09:23A
`09:23A
`09:23A
`09:29A
`11:19A
`11:24A
`11:24A
`11:25A
`12:05P
`12:05P
`12:05P
`01:07P
`01:43P
`01:45P
`02:04P
`02:05P
`02:05P
`02:36P
`02:36P
`02:39P
`02:46P
`02:55P
`02:55P
`02:55P
`02:55P
`02:56P
`03:12P
`03:40P
`03:40P
`03:40P
`04:06P
`06:19P
`06:19P
`06:51A
`08:35A
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:09
`0:04
`0:28
`0:00
`0:02
`0:23
`0:11
`0:06
`0:04
`0:13
`0:30
`0:20
`0:25
`0:02
`0:09
`0:46
`0:02
`0:21
`0:01
`0:25
`0:21
`0:01
`0:11
`0:23
`0:02
`0:00
`0:01
`0:21
`0:22
`0:22
`0:21
`0:01
`0:26
`0:16
`0:20
`0:01
`0:08
`0:18
`
`Originating
`Number
`12146757531
`19728694243
`12149145487
`19729227151
`12149145487
`19729227151
`12149145487
`12142405003
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143343884
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12146328876
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12145145069
`12149145487
`19724503322
`12149145487
`19724503322
`12146328876
`12146328876
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`
`Terminating
`Number
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12548653377
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`19729227151
`12149145487
`12143343884
`19723129925
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12143343884
`12146328876
`19724503322
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12143520090
`12145145069
`13173419000
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`150508724425
`12145464000
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`3:19
`0:00
`5:47
`0:00
`0:54
`0:54
`7:14
`0:12
`0:00
`0:00
`0:27
`0:00
`0:29
`0:29
`0:59
`0:38
`0:44
`0:00
`0:22
`0:22
`0:00
`1:14
`3:46
`0:29
`0:06
`0:00
`0:33
`0:33
`0:37
`0:06
`0:00
`0:25
`0:25
`2:09
`0:00
`0:04
`0:00
`6:26
`
`Number
`Dialed
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12548653377
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`19729227151
`12149145487
`12143343884
`19723129925
`12143343884
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12143343884
`12146328876
`19724503322
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12145145069
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12145145069
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`150508724425
`12145464000
`
`AT&T Proprietary
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`
`M2M_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`m2M
`M2m
`m2M
`M2m_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`m2M_VMC
`m2M
`M2m
`M2m_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMB
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2m_VMB
`O2M
`M2m
`O2M
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_DIR
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMB
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`
`The information contained here is for use by authorized person only and is
`not for general distribution.
`
`Page 4
`
` Colgin 00004
`
`
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`
`153
`154
`155
`156
`157
`158
`159
`160
`161
`162
`163
`164
`165
`166
`167
`168
`169
`170
`171
`172
`173
`174
`175
`176
`177
`178
`179
`180
`181
`182
`183
`184
`185
`186
`187
`188
`189
`190
`
`tr
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`09:07A
`09:19A
`09:27A
`09:29A
`09:29A
`09:31A
`09:52A
`10:29A
`10:34A
`10:38A
`11:06A
`11:07A
`11:07A
`11:07A
`12:55P
`12:55P
`12:55P
`01:48P
`01:49P
`01:49P
`02:23P
`02:35P
`02:36P
`02:36P
`03:02P
`03:02P
`03:36P
`03:36P
`03:36P
`04:18P
`04:20P
`04:21P
`04:24P
`04:28P
`04:36P
`04:39P
`05:09P
`05:59P
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:09
`0:12
`0:10
`0:00
`0:01
`0:15
`0:14
`0:14
`0:02
`0:22
`0:10
`0:00
`0:01
`0:01
`0:20
`0:01
`0:26
`0:20
`0:01
`0:26
`0:22
`0:20
`0:01
`0:26
`0:21
`0:01
`0:20
`0:01
`0:27
`0:06
`0:35
`0:09
`0:14
`0:09
`0:13
`0:09
`0:10
`0:13
`
`Originating
`Number
`12149145487
`12149145487
`15019202305
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19724503322
`12142441472
`12149145487
`12142441472
`15012273200
`12149145487
`15012273200
`12145266262
`12149145487
`12145266262
`18178214508
`14049159707
`12149145487
`14049159707
`12145333329
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`
`Terminating
`Number
`12148027328
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`18176887478
`12144158171
`19723871000
`18178078386
`19724503322
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12145266262
`12145243683
`12145343683
`18178214508
`12143520090
`12145022846
`12145145069
`18179892277
`12143520090
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`1:57
`1:22
`3:18
`0:00
`0:29
`7:59
`3:40
`1:57
`0:33
`0:39
`12:10
`0:00
`0:38
`0:38
`0:00
`0:02
`0:02
`0:00
`0:26
`0:26
`0:24
`0:00
`0:49
`0:48
`0:00
`0:03
`0:00
`0:52
`0:52
`0:50
`0:21
`2:34
`1:55
`0:57
`1:21
`1:42
`0:26
`0:40
`
`Number
`Dialed
`12148027328
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`18176887478
`12144158171
`19723871000
`18178078386
`19724503322
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12145266262
`12145243683
`12145343683
`18178214508
`12143520090
`12145022846
`12145145069
`18179892277
`12143520090
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`310410262514769
`
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2M_VMB
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`O2M_DIR
`M2M
`M2m
`m2M
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMC
`M2m
`m2M
`M2M_VMC
`M2M_VMB
`O2M_VMC
`M2m
`O2M
`M2O_DIR
`M2m_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2M_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`M2O_DIR
`
`The information contained here is for use by authorized person only and is
`not for general distribution.
`
`Page 5
`
`AT&T Proprietary
`
` Colgin 00005
`
`
`
`

`
`1321247.006
`07/25/2013
`SCAMP
`
`Run Date:
`Run Time:
`Voice Usage For:
`Account Number:
`Item
`Conn.
`Date
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/22/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/23/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/24/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`10/25/10
`
`191
`192
`193
`194
`195
`196
`197
`198
`199
`200
`201
`202
`203
`204
`205
`206
`207
`208
`209
`210
`211
`212
`213
`214
`215
`216
`217
`218
`219
`220
`221
`222
`223
`224
`225
`226
`227
`228
`
`tr
`
`MOBILITY USAGE
`
`07/25/2013
`12:36:15
`(214)914-5487
`315632170
`Conn.
`Time
`06:06P
`06:08P
`06:09P
`06:15P
`09:36A
`11:14A
`11:18A
`11:28A
`12:47P
`04:33P
`04:34P
`04:34P
`04:34P
`04:34P
`04:42P
`04:44P
`05:09P
`06:49P
`03:14P
`03:14P
`03:14P
`04:24P
`04:27P
`05:44P
`05:48P
`06:09P
`06:09P
`06:34P
`06:55P
`08:28A
`08:36A
`08:47A
`08:48A
`08:50A
`08:52A
`09:27A
`09:27A
`09:27A
`
`Seizure
`Time
`0:26
`0:08
`0:06
`0:13
`0:12
`0:08
`0:16
`0:10
`0:07
`0:13
`0:00
`0:01
`0:01
`0:07
`0:03
`0:05
`0:03
`0:08
`0:20
`0:01
`0:24
`0:20
`0:21
`0:15
`0:37
`0:02
`0:14
`0:18
`0:16
`0:09
`0:07
`0:04
`0:30
`0:25
`0:28
`0:21
`0:01
`0:24
`
`Originating
`Number
`12149145487
`12146169277
`15012762137
`12149145487
`12145333329
`12146169277
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12144158171
`12149145487
`12144158171
`19406598479
`12146169277
`12146169277
`12146169277
`12145464000
`19728960900
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12143458250
`12143458250
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143463690
`12149145487
`12143463690
`
`Terminating
`Number
`15012762137
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19406598479
`12143634911
`12143520090
`19406598479
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12143520090
`12145027946
`12147395144
`12145027964
`12145027964
`19728960900
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12143601714
`12147345724
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`
`Elapsed
`Time
`0:33
`0:45
`1:32
`0:27
`2:21
`0:36
`1:00
`5:01
`0:35
`1:03
`0:00
`1:03
`1:03
`1:06
`1:43
`0:24
`1:03
`1:37
`0:00
`0:52
`0:52
`1:52
`2:18
`0:18
`1:12
`0:00
`6:21
`2:07
`7:04
`0:17
`2:59
`0:27
`0:52
`0:27
`0:52
`0:00
`0:38
`0:38
`
`Number
`Dialed
`15012762137
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12143520090
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19406598479
`12143634911
`12143520090
`19406598479
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12143520090
`12145027946
`12147395144
`12145027964
`12145027964
`19728960900
`18176887478
`12149145487
`12149145487
`12149145487
`19728960900
`12143601714
`12147345724
`12149145487
`13173419000
`12149145487
`
`IMEI
`
`IMSI
`
`Description
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`01193200556676
`011932