Plaintiffs

Aura Capital Ltd.Dimensional Emerging Markets Value FundDFA Investment Dimensions Group Inc., on behalf of its series Emerging Markets Core Equity PortfolioEmerging Markets Social Core Equity Portfolio and T.A. World ex U.S. Core Equity PortfolioDFA Investment Trust Company, on behalf of its series The Emerging Markets SeriesDFA Austria Limited, solely in its capacity as responsible entity for the Dimensional Emerging Markets TrustDFA International Core Equity Fund, and DFA International Vector Equity Fund by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC solely in its capacity as TrusteeDimensional Funds plc, on behalf of its sub-fund Emerging Markets Value FundDimensional Funds ICVC, on behalf of its sub-fund Emerging Markets Core Equity FundSKAGEN ASDanske Invest Management A/SDanske Invest Management CompanyNew York City Employees' Retirement SystemNew York City Police Pension FundBoard of Education Retirement System of the City of New YorkTeachers' Retirement System of the City of New YorkNew York City Fire Department Pension FundNew York City Deferred Compensation PlanForsta AP-fondenTransamerica Income Shares, Inc.Transamerica FundsTransamerica Series TrustTransamerica Partners PortfoliosJohn Hancock Variable Insurance TrustJohn Hancock Funds IIJohn Hancock Sovereign Bond FundJohn Hancock Bond TrustJohn Hancock Strategic SeriesJohn Hancock Investment TrustJHF Income Securities TrustJHF Investors TrustJHF Hedged Equity & Income FundAberdeen Emerging Markets Equity Fund, Aberdeen Global Equity & Income FundAberdeen Global Natural Resources FundAberdeen International Equity Fund, each a series of Aberdeen Funds; Aberdeen Canada Emerging Markets FundAberdeen Canada Socially Responsible Global FundAberdeen Canada Socially Responsible International FundAberdeen Canada Funds EAFE Plus Equity Fund and Aberdeen Canada Funds Global Equity Fund, each a series of Aberdeen Canada FundsAberdeen EAFE Plus Ethical Fund, Aberdeen EAFE Plus Fund, Aberdeeen EAFF Plus SRI Fund, Aberdeeen Emerging Markets Equity Fund, and Aberdeen Global Equity Fund, each a series of Aberdeen Intitutional CAberdeen Fully Hedged International Equities FundAberdeen International Equity FundAberdeen Global Ethical World Equity Fund, Aberdeen Global Responsible World Equity FundAberdeen Global World Equity Dividend Fund, Aberdeen Global World Equity FundAberdeen Global World Resources Equity Fund, Aberdeen Emerging Markets Equity Fund, Aberdeen Ethical World Equity Fund, Aberdeen Multi-Asset Fund, Aberdeen World Equity Fund, Aberdeen World Equity InAberdeen Latin America Equity Fund, Inc.Aberdeen Latin America Equity Fund, Inc.AAAID Equity PortfolioAlberta Teachers Retirement FundAon Hewitt Investment Consulting, Inc.Aurion International Daily Equity FundBell Aliant Regional Communications Inc.BMO Global Equity ClassCity of Albany Pension PlanDesjardins Dividend Income FundDesjardins Emerging Markets FundDesjardins Emerging Markets FundDesjardins Global All Capital Equity FundDesjardins Overseas Equity Value FundDevon County Council Global Emerging Market FundDevon County Council Global Equity FundDGIA Emerging Markets Equity Fund L.P.Erie Insurance ExchangeFirst Trust / Aberdeen Emerging Opportunity FundGE UK Pension Common Investment FundHampshire County Council Global Equity PortfolioLondon Borough of Hounslow Supperannuation FundMacKenzie Universal Sustainable Opportunities ClassMarshfield Clinic, Mother Theresa Care and Mission TrustMTR Corporation Limited Retirement SchemeMyria Asset Managment Emergence, MNational Pension Service, and NPS Trust Active 14Ohio Public Employees Retirement SystemWashington State Investment BoardAberdeen Latin American Income Fund LimitedAberdeen Global ex Japan Pension Fund ppitFS International Equity Mother FundNN Investment Partners B.V., acting in the capacity of managementNN Investment Partners B.V., acting in the capacity of management company of the mutual fund NN Global Equity FundNN Investment Partners B.V., acting in the capacity of management company of the muitual fund NN Hoog Dividend Aandelen FondsNN Investment Partners B.V., acting in the capacity of management copmany of the mutual fund NN Institutioneel Dividend AandelenNN Investment Partners Luxembourg S.A., acting in the capacity of management company SICAV and its Sub-Funds, and NN (L) SICA, for and on behalf of NN (L) Emerging Markets High Dividend, NN (L) FirstAura Capital Ltd.WGI Emerging Markets Fund, LLCBill and Melinda Gates Foundation TrustBoard of Regents of the University of Texas SystemTrustees of the Estate of Bernice Pauahi Bishop, DBA Kamehameha SchoolsLouis Kennedy, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situatedKen Ngo, individually and on behalf of all other similarly situatedCity of Providence, individually and on behalf of all other similarly situatedHandelsbanken Fonder ABPublic Employee Retirement System of IdahoPeter Kaltman, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situatedUnion Asset Management Holding AGJonathan Messing, individually and on behalf of all other similarly situated + see more - see less

Plaintiff - Appellees

Universities Superannuation Scheme LimitedEmployees Retirement System of the State of HawaiiNorth Carolina Department of State Treasurer

Appellants

Mathis B. BishopCatherine O. BishopJoseph GielataRichard GielataEmelina Gielata

Defendant - Appellees

Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. PetrobrasPricewaterhouseCoopers Auditores IndependentesBB Securities Ltd.Theodore Marshall HelmsPetrobras Global Finance B.V.Petrobras America Inc.Mitsubishi UFJ Securities (USA), Inc.HSBC Securities (USA) Inc.Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith IncorporatedStandard Chartered BankBank of China (Hong Kong) LimitedBanco Bradesco BBI S.A.Banca IMI, S.p.A.Scotia Capital (USA) Inc.William Thomas Haynes, as trustee for the benefit of W. Thomas and Katherine Haynes Irrevocable Trust for the benefit of Sara L. HaynesBernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossman LLPCitigroup Global Markets Inc.Itau BBA USA Securities, Inc.JP Morgan Securities LLCMorgan Stanley & Co. LLC + see more - see less

Defendants

Mariangela Mointeiro TizattoJosue Christiano Gome Da SilvaDaniel Lima De OliveiraSantander Investment Securities Inc.Banco Votorantin Nassau BranchJose Sergio GabrielliSilvio Sinedino PinheiroPaulo Roberto CostaJose Carlos CosenzaRenato de Souza DuqueGuillherme de Oliveira EstrellaJose Miranda Formigl FilhoMaria Das Gracas Silva FosterAlmir Guilherme BarbassaJose Raimundo Branda PereiraServio Tulio Da Rosa TinocoPaulo Jose AlvesGustavo Tardin BarbosaAlexandre Quintao FernandesMarcos Antonio ZacariasCornelis Franciscus Joze Looman + see more - see less

Other Parties

Spencer Bueno, Objector - Appellant