Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 1 of 27 PageID #: 1
`
`,/ 4+) 5/,4)( 34&4)3 (,342,’4 ’0524
`*02 4+) 3054+)2/ (,342,’4 0* ,/(,&/&
`,/(,&/&10-,3 (,6,3,0/
`
`’,6,- &’4,0/ /0%
`
`# # # # # # # # # #
`
`&/4+).$ ,/’%$
`
`@%
`
`’+&( 1,1)2$
`
`1<7;=?;::$
`
`(9:9=87=?%
`
`6)2,*,)( ’0.1-&,/4
`
`4B7?DI?<< /DI>;C% 2D9’ #O/DI>;CP$ 8G?D=H I>?H HJ?I 7=7?DHI 0>7: 4?F;G #O4?F;GP$% 7 <EGC;G
`
`>?=>BM 9ECF;DH7I;: 4G;H?:;DI <EG 7D /DI>;C FB7D L>E >7H <B7=G7DIBM K?EB7I;: >?H G;HIG?9I?K;
`
`9EK;D7DI E8B?=7I?EDH IE E8I7?D 7D JD<7?G 7:K7DI7=; EK;G /DI>;C ?D 7 8?: <EG 7 HI7I; 9EDIG79I LEGI>
`
`8?BB?EDH E< :EBB7GH’ /8H;DI ?CC;:?7I; ?D@JD9I?K; G;B?;<% /DI>;C <79;H I>; FGEHF;9I E< 7 9ECF;I?IEG
`
`7GC;: L?I> ?IH 9ED<?:;DI?7B 8?: HIG7I;=M% L;7AD;HH;H% 7D: EF;G7I?ED7B F;G<EGC7D9; C;IG?9H’
`
`/DI>;C I>;G;<EG; <?B;H I>?H 6;G?<?;: 0ECFB7?DI IE E8I7?D ?D@JD9I?K; G;B?;<’
`
`1&24,)3
`
`)’
`
`4B7?DI?<< /DI>;C% 2D9’ ?H 7D 2D:?7D7FEB?H&87H;: 8JH?D;HH’ /DI>;C ?H 7D 2D:?7D7
`
`9EGFEG7I?ED L?I> ?IH FG?D9?F7B FB79; E< 8JH?D;HH ?D 2D:?7D7FEB?H% 2D:?7D7’ /DI>;C ?H G;=?HI;G;: IE
`
`:E 8JH?D;HH ?D I>; 5I7I; E< 2D:?7D7’
`
`*’
`
`1;<;D:7DI 0>7: 4?F;G ?H 7D ?D:?K?:J7B 7D: 7 9?I?N;D E< 2EL7’ 4?F;G ?H :EC?9?B;: ?D
`
`2EL7 7D: G;H?:;H 7I -+(. ),(I> /K;DJ;% 2D:?7DEB7% 2EL7 ,()*,’
`
`1:22-CV-450
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 2 of 27 PageID #: 2
`
`*30)1’)&2).-
`
`,(
`
`=FGP 4MROQ K?V CUCOAGPC HROGPBGAQGML MSCO 4MRLQ 777 MD QFGP 4MKNJ?GLQ @CA?RPC GQ
`
`?OGPCP RLBCO QFC J?TP MD QFC >LGQCB <Q?QCP& L?KCJV QFC 5CDCLB =O?BC <CAOCQP 3AQ& *1 >(<(4( X *1,/(
`
`3AAMOBGLEJV& QFGP 4MROQ F?P MOGEGL?J HROGPBGAQGML MSCO QF?Q AJ?GK RLBCO +1 >(<(4( X *,,*(
`
`-(
`
`=FC 4MROQ ?JPM F?P PR@HCAQ K?QQCO HROGPBGAQGML GL QFGP K?QQCO NROPR?LQ QM +1 >(<(4(
`
`X *,,+ @CA?RPC AMKNJCQC BGSCOPGQV CUGPQP ?LB QFC ?KMRLQ GL AMLQOMSCOPV GP GL CUACPP MD #0.&)))(
`
`.(
`
`3LQFCK GP ? AGQGWCL MD 7LBG?L?& ?LB :GNCO GP ? AGQGWCL MD 7MT?( =FRP& AMKNJCQC
`
`BGSCOPGQV GP NOCPCLQ(
`
`/(
`
`=FC ?KMRLQ GL AMLQOMSCOPV GP GL CUACPP MD #0.&)))( 3P BGPARPPCB GL BCQ?GJ @CJMT&
`
`3LQFCK PCCIP QM OCAMSCO AMKNCLP?QMOV B?K?ECP& GLHRLAQGSC OCJGCD& ?LB GQP ?QQMOLCVP[ DCCP ?LB
`
`AMPQP( 3LQFCK[P AJ?GK DMO AMKNCLP?QMOV B?K?ECP ?JMLC GP D?O GL CUACPP MD #0.&)))( =FC GLHRLAQGSC
`
`OCJGCD PMREFQ GP ?JPM D?O GL CUACPP MD #0.&)))& @CA?RPC& ?@PCLQ QFC CLQOV MD GLHRLAQGSC OCJGCD& :GNCO
`
`TGJJ @C DOCC QM AMKNCQC ?E?GLPQ 3LQFCK RPGLE 3LQFCK[P QO?BC PCAOCQP ?LB MQFCO AMLDGBCLQG?J
`
`GLDMOK?QGML ?LB QM PMJGAGQ ? ARPQMKCO ?LB ?AAMRLQ $QFC 7MT? 6C?JQF 8GLI ?AAMRLQ% ?@MRQ TFGAF FC
`
`M@Q?GLCB QO?BC PCAOCQP ?LB MQFCO AMLDGBCLQG?J GLDMOK?QGML& OCPRJQGLE GL B?K?ECP QM 3LQFCK TCJJ GL
`
`CUACPP MD QFC HROGPBGAQGML?J KGLGKRK(
`
`/(01.-%+ *30)1’)&2).- %-’ 4(-3(
`
`0(
`
`:COPML?J HROGPBGAQGML ?LB SCLRC GP NOMNCO GL QFGP 5GPQOGAQ ?LB 5GSGPGML @CA?RPC
`
`:GNCO[P ;<> 3EOCCKCLQP GLAMONMO?QC @V OCDCOCLAC QFC QCOKP MD 3LQFCK[P +)*0 3LQFCK 7LACLQGSC
`
`4MKNCLP?QGML :J?L $QFC Y7LACLQGSC 4MKNCLP?QGML :J?LZ%( 3 AMNV MD QFC 7LACLQGSC 4MKNCLP?QGML
`
`:J?L GP ?QQ?AFCB ?P (;7858: $# =FC 7LACLQGSC 4MKNCLP?QGML :J?L GLAJRBCP ? K?LB?QMOV DMORK’
`
`PCJCAQGML AJ?RPC PCQQGLE SCLRC CUAJRPGSCJV GL DCBCO?J ?LB PQ?QC AMROQP MD 7LBG?L? DMO ?LV BGPNRQCP
`
`*1-2//-0S(+
`
`+
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 3 of 27 PageID #: 3
`
`eE[FOH[ TH‘ HYPZL V\[ VM VY YLSH[L [V [OL @SHU VY HU‘ YLSH[LK HNYLLTLU[Z’f #:UJLU[P]L 5VTWLUZH[PVU
`
`@SHU b *)’))’$
`
`+.20/’3&2+/.
`
`0’
`
`3U[OLT PZ HU :UKPHUHWVSPZ&IHZLK JVTWHU‘ [OH[ WYV]PKLZ OLHS[O JHYL ZLY]PJLZ [V
`
`TPSSPVUZ VM 3TLYPJHUZ HJYVZZ [OL DUP[LK B[H[LZ’ CV IL[[LY ZLY]L P[Z TLTILYZ% 3U[OLT VWLYH[LZ H
`
`U\TILY VM UL[^VYR&IHZLK THUHNLK JHYL WSHUZ [V NYV\WZ VM HSS ZPaLZ% HZ ^LSS HZ [V PUKP]PK\HSZ HUK
`
`[OL =LKPJHYL HUK =LKPJHPK THYRL[Z’
`
`1’
`
`3U[OLT VWLYH[LZ ZVTL VM [OLZL WSHUZ [OYV\NO Z\IZPKPHYPLZ’ ?UL VM P[Z Z\IZPKPHYPLZ
`
`PZ 5VTT\UP[‘ 5HYL 9LHS[O @SHU VM >LIYHZRH% :UJ’% H =LKPJHPK HUK 5OPSKYLUgZ 9LHS[O :UZ\YHUJL
`
`@YVNYHT #e59:@f$ WSHU [OH[ VWLYH[LZ PU >LIYHZRH’ 5VTT\UP[‘ 5HYL 9LHS[O @SHU VM >LIYHZRH% :UJ’
`
`KVLZ I\ZPULZZ \UKLY [OL [YHKL UHTL e9LHS[O‘ 4S\L >LIYHZRH’f 3UV[OLY VUL VM P[Z Z\IZPKPHYPLZ PZ
`
`3TLYPNYV\W :V^H% :UJ’ #e3TLYPNYV\W :V^Hf$% H =LKPJHPK HUK 59:@ WSHU [OH[ VWLYH[LZ PU :V^H’
`
`)(’
`
`6LMLUKHU[ 5OHK @PWLY ^VYRLK MVY 3U[OLT HZ [OL @YLZPKLU[ VM 9LHS[O‘ 4S\L
`
`>LIYHZRH’ :U [OPZ YVSL OL OHK YLZWVUZPIPSP[‘ MVY KPYLJ[PUN [OL WSHUgZ Z[YH[LNPJ% MPZJHS% YLN\SH[VY‘% HUK
`
`VWLYH[PVUHS HJ[P]P[PLZ’ 4LMP[[PUN OPZ [P[SL HUK ZLUPVYP[‘ H[ 9LHS[O‘ 4S\L >LIYHZRH% @PWLY ^HZ OPNOS‘
`
`JVTWLUZH[LK HUK YLJLP]LK T\S[PWSL Z[VJR NYHU[Z HZ WHY[ [OL :UJLU[P]L 5VTWLUZH[PVU @SHU’
`
`))’
`
`7HJO Z[VJR NYHU[ @PWLY YLJLP]LK \UKLY [OL :UJLU[P]L 5VTWLUZH[PVU @SHU PZ NV]LYULK
`
`I‘ H ALZ[YPJ[LK B[VJR DUP[ 3^HYK 3NYLLTLU[ #eABD 3NYLLTLU[f$’ ?U =HYJO )% *(*)% 3U[OLT
`
`PZZ\LK @PWLY [OYLL Z[VJR NYHU[Z% LHJO JV]LYLK I‘ H ZLWHYH[L ABD 3NYLLTLU[’ COL =HYJO )% *(*)
`
`ABD 3NYLLTLU[Z HYL H[[HJOLK JVSSLJ[P]LS‘ HZ (:67479 #’
`
`)*’
`
`:U L_JOHUNL MVY YLJLP]PUN [OL YLZ[YPJ[LK Z[VJR NYHU[Z% @PWLY HNYLLK [V YLZ[YPJ[PVUZ VU
`
`OPZ HIPSP[‘ [V \ZL 3U[OLTgZ JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU% [V JVTWL[L ^P[O 3U[OLT% [V ZVSPJP[ 3U[OLTgZ
`
`J\Z[VTLYZ HUK HJJV\U[Z% HUK [V ZVSPJP[ 3U[OLTgZ LTWSV‘LLZ’
`
`)0,1..,/]’*
`
`+
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 4 of 27 PageID #: 4
`
`)+’
`
`?U >V]LTILY *+% *(*)% @PWLY WYV]PKLK 3U[OLT ^P[O UV[PJL [OH[ OL ^HZ YLZPNUPUN’
`
`3 JVW‘ VM [OPZ UV[PJL PZ H[[HJOLK HZ (:67479 $’ @PWLYgZ LTWSV‘TLU[ ^P[O 3U[OLT LUKLK H ^LLR
`
`SH[LY VU >V]LTILY +(% *(*)’
`
`),’
`
`:U OPZ YLZPNUH[PVU UV[PJL% @PWLY KPZJSVZLK [OH[ OPZ UL^ LTWSV‘TLU[ ePZ ^P[O H
`
`JVTWL[P[VY HUK PZ H SPRL WVZP[PVU I\[ PZ UV[ ^P[OPU [OL NLVNYHWOPJ HYLH PU ^OPJO EOLF J\YYLU[S‘
`
`ZLY]LEZF’f #ALZPNUH[PVU >V[PJL% 7_’ +’$ 9PZ W\YWVY[LK YLHZVU MVY YLZPNUPUN ^HZ [OH[ [OL B[H[L VM
`
`>LIYHZRH TH‘ ILNPU [OL WYVJLZZ PU [OL UL_[ ZL]LYHS TVU[OZ [V YLIPK P[Z =LKPJHPK THUHNLK JHYL
`
`VYNHUPaH[PVU #e=5?f$ JVU[YHJ[Z c H ZPNUPMPJHU[ L]LU[ [OH[ YLX\PYLZ LUVYTV\Z WSHUUPUN HUK
`
`Z[YH[LNPJ KL]LSVWTLU[’ 9L JSHPTLK [OH[ [OL UL^ YVSL% ^OPJO OL KPK UV[ PKLU[PM‘% ePZ SVJH[LK PU H
`
`ZLWHYH[L Z[H[L MVY ^OPJO EOL OHKF UV JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU% UV KPYLJ[ 3U[OLT VWLYH[PVUHS
`
`RUV^SLKNL VY V]LYZPNO[% UVY HU‘ RUV^U [YHKL ZLJYL[Z’f #Id.$
`
`)-’
`
`COL SPRLS‘ YLHZVU ^O‘ @PWLY KPK UV[ PKLU[PM‘ OPZ YVSL PZ ILJH\ZL KVPUN ZV ^V\SK
`
`\UKLYTPUL ^OH[ OL ZHPK PU OPZ YLZPNUH[PVU UV[PJL’ DWVU PUMVYTH[PVU HUK ILSPLM% @PWLY HJJLW[LK H
`
`YVSL HZ [OL 57? VM 5HYLBV\YJLgZ HZWPYHU[ :V^H =LKPJHPK WSHUdH Z\IZ[HU[PHSS‘ ZPTPSHY WVZP[PVU
`
`^P[O H KPYLJ[ JVTWL[P[VY’ 5HYLBV\YJL J\YYLU[S‘ KVLZ UV[ OH]L H =LKPJHPK =5? JVU[YHJ[ PU :V^H’
`
`9V^L]LY% WYPVY [V @PWLYgZ YLZPNUH[PVU MYVT 3U[OLT% [OL :V^H 6LWHY[TLU[ VM 9\THU BLY]PJLZ
`
`#e:V^H 69Bf$ HUUV\UJLK P[Z PU[LU[PVU [V YLIPK P[Z =5? JVU[YHJ[Z MVY [OL Z[H[LgZ =LKPJHPK
`
`THUHNLK JHYL WYVNYHT% 9LHS[O <PUR’ 3TLYPNYV\W :V^H PZ J\YYLU[S‘ VUL VM VUS‘ [^V =LKPJHPK
`
`WSHUZ [OH[ WHY[PJPWH[LZ PU [OL :V^H 9LHS[O <PUR WYVNYHT’ DWVU PUMVYTH[PVU HUK ILSPLM% PU OPZ UL^
`
`YVSL HZ [OL 57? VM 5HYLBV\YJLgZ :V^H HZWPYHU[ =LKPJHPK WSHU% @PWLY PZ J\YYLU[S‘ SLHKPUN
`
`5HYLBV\YJLgZ LMMVY[Z PU WYLWHYPUN HUK Z\ITP[[PUN P[Z IPK [V :V^H 69B PU KPYLJ[ JVTWL[P[PVU ^P[O
`
`3U[OLTgZ IPK’ 5HYLBV\YJL KVLZ UV[ J\YYLU[S‘ VWLYH[L H =LKPJHPK WSHU PU :V^H% ZV @PWLY OHZ UV
`
`JVUJLP]HISL HJ[P]P[PLZ V[OLY [OHU WYLWHYPUN MVY [OL MVY[OJVTPUN YLIPK’
`
`)0,1..,/]’*
`
`,
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 5 of 27 PageID #: 5
`
`).’
`
`5VU[YHY‘ [V @PWLYgZ YLWYLZLU[H[PVU [OH[ OL OHK eUV JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVUf HIV\[
`
`3U[OLTgZ VWLYH[PVUZ PU :V^H% @PWLY QVPULK 5HYLBV\YJL VUS‘ HM[LY VI[HPUPUN OPNOS‘ JVUMPKLU[PHS
`
`PUZPKLY PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ 3U[OLTgZ YLIPK Z[YH[LN‘ HUK L_[LUZP]L JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[
`
`3U[OLTgZ HWWYVHJO MVY [OL :V^H 9LHS[O <PUR YLIPK’ :UKLLK% VU ?J[VILY )0% *(*)% @PWLY H[[LUKLK H
`
`JYP[PJHS Z[YH[LNPJ WSHUUPUN YL]PL^ JHSSLK H e4\ZPULZZ ?WLYH[PUN AL]PL^f WYLZLU[LK I‘ ;LMM ;VULZ%
`
`[OL @SHU @YLZPKLU[ MVY 3TLYPNYV\W :V^H% ^OLYL ;VULZ WYV]PKLK KL[HPSLK PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[
`
`3TLYPNYV\W :V^HgZ VWLYH[PVUHS TL[YPJZ HUK P[Z Z[YH[LN‘ MVY [OL :V^H 9LHS[O <PUR YLIPK’
`
`)/’
`
`3M[LY [OH[ WYLZLU[H[PVU% HUK HYTLK ^P[O OPZ PUZPKLY RUV^SLKNL HIV\[ 3U[OLTgZ :V^H
`
`Z[YH[LN‘% @PWLY ZH^ HU VWWVY[\UP[‘ [V JHWP[HSPaL VU [OL JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU OL OHK ILLU
`
`WYV]PKLK [V VI[HPU H eZPaHISL PUJYLHZL PU ILULMP[Z HUK ZHSHY‘f I‘ QVPUPUN HU 3U[OLT JVTWL[P[VY PU
`
`:V^H’ ?U ?J[VILY *)% *(*) c H TLYL [OYLL KH‘Z HM[LY H[[LUKPUN [OL 4\ZPULZZ ?WLYH[PUN AL]PL^
`
`HIV\[ :V^H c @PWLY LTHPSLK OPTZLSM H JVW‘ VM OPZ YLZ\TL [OH[ OL [P[SLK e5OHK @PWLY
`
`G:V^HGALZ\TL’KVJ_’%f HUK PU SH[L ?J[VILY VY LHYS‘ >V]LTILY% OL ILNHU PU[LY]PL^PUN MVY OPZ UL^
`
`YVSL ^P[O 5HYLBV\YJL HZ P[Z =LKPJHPK WSHU WYLZPKLU[’
`
`)0’ =VYLV]LY% IL[^LLU ?J[VILY *)% *(*) HUK >V]LTILY )0% *(*)% @PWLY MVY^HYKLK
`
`ZL]LYHS KVJ\TLU[Z MYVT OPZ ^VYR LTHPS [V OPZ WLYZVUHS LTHPS% PUJS\KPUN KVJ\TLU[Z L_WYLZZS‘
`
`KLZPNUH[LK I‘ 3U[OLT HZ JVUMPKLU[PHS% [OH[ HYL YLSH[LK [V 3U[OLTgZ Z[YH[LN‘ PU [OL :V^H 9LHS[O
`
`<PUR YLIPK’ 3Z VUL L_HTWSL% HUK HZ KPZJ\ZZLK M\Y[OLY ILSV^% VU >V]LTILY )(% *(*)% HM[LY
`
`YLJLP]PUN OPNOS‘ JVUMPKLU[PHS
`
`PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ 3U[OLTgZ =LKPJHPK Z[YH[LN‘ H[ 3U[OLTgZ
`
`=LKPJHPK <LHKLYZOPW B[YH[LN‘ =LL[PUN% @PWLY MVY^HYKLK OPTZLSM H KVJ\TLU[ WYLWHYLK I‘
`
`3U[OLTgZ =HYRL[ 5VTWL[P[P]L :U[LSSPNLUJL #e=5:f$
`
`[LHT SHILSLK e:V^H 9LHS[O >LLKZ
`
`3ZZLZZTLU[’f COH[ KVJ\TLU[ JVU[HPUZ H SPUR [V H OPNOS‘ JVUMPKLU[PHS /,&WHNL HZZLZZTLU[ WYLWHYLK
`
`I‘ [OL =5: [LHT MVY [OL :V^H 9LHS[O <PUR YLIPK’
`
`)0,1..,/]’*
`
`-
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 6 of 27 PageID #: 6
`
`)1’
`
`BVTL VM [OLZL MVY^HYKLK LTHPSZ% SPRL OPZ YLZPNUH[PVU UV[PJL% PUJS\KL VI]PV\ZS‘ ZLSM&
`
`ZLY]PUN Z[H[LTLU[Z’ 8VY L_HTWSL% PU H >V]LTILY )0% *(*) LTHPS [OH[ @PWLY MVY^HYKLK [V OPTZLSM%
`
`OL ^YV[L% eCOPZ ULLKZ WYPU[LK MVY >7 DZLE’Ff COPZ Z[H[LTLU[ PZ SPRLS‘ UV[OPUN TVYL [OHU HU H[[LTW[
`
`[V WYV]PKL H ZOLLU VM WSH\ZPISL KLUPHIPSP[‘% ILJH\ZL OL WYV]PKLK 3U[OLT ^P[O OPZ YLZPNUH[PVU UV[PJL
`
`Q\Z[ [^V I\ZPULZZ KH‘Z SH[LY’
`
`*(’
`
`:UZ[LHK VM JVTWS‘PUN ^P[O OPZ VISPNH[PVUZ [V 3U[OLT% ^OPJO OL HJRUV^SLKNLK PU
`
`OPZ YLZPNUH[PVU UV[PJL% @PWLY OHZ PU[LU[PVUHSS‘ TPZSLK 3U[OLT YLNHYKPUN [OL JPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ VM OPZ
`
`ZLWHYH[PVU% OPZ YL[LU[PVU VM [YHKL ZLJYL[Z HUK V[OLY JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU% HUK OPZ JVTWSPHUJL
`
`^P[O OPZ UVU&JVTWL[P[PVU HUK UVU&ZVSPJP[H[PVU VISPNH[PVUZ’ :UKLLK% 3U[OLT VUS‘ JVUJS\ZP]LS‘
`
`KL[LYTPULK [OH[ @PWLY QVPULK 5HYLBV\YJL ^OLU 3TLYPNYV\W :V^H WLYZVUULS ZH^ OPT ZVSPJP[PUN
`
`Z\WWVY[ MVY 5HYLBV\YJL H[ [OL :V^H 5HWP[VS I\PSKPUN2
`
`)0,1..,/]’*
`
`.
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 7 of 27 PageID #: 7
`
`*)’
`
`@PWLYgZ ]PVSH[PVUZ VM [OL ABD 3NYLLTLU[Z% JV\WSLK ^P[O OPZ TPZHWWYVWYPH[PVU VM
`
`3U[OLTgZ [YHKL ZLJYL[Z HUK V[OLY JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU% THRLZ JSLHY [OH[ PTTLKPH[L PUQ\UJ[P]L
`
`YLSPLM PZ ULJLZZHY‘ [V WYV[LJ[ 3U[OLTgZ SLNP[PTH[L WYV[LJ[HISL PU[LYLZ[Z’
`
`**’
`
`3Z KPZJ\ZZLK PU TVYL KL[HPS ILSV^ HUK PU 3U[OLTgZ =V[PVU MVY CLTWVYHY‘
`
`ALZ[YHPUPUN ?YKLY HUK =LTVYHUK\T PU B\WWVY[ [OLYLVM% 3U[OLT YLZWLJ[M\SS‘ YLX\LZ[Z [OH[ [OL
`
`5V\Y[ LU[LY PTTLKPH[L PUQ\UJ[P]L YLSPLM IHYYPUN @PWLY MYVT HU‘ PU]VS]LTLU[ PU [OL :V^H YLIPK HUK
`
`VYKLYPUN OPT [V YL[\YU HU‘ 3U[OLT [YHKL ZLJYL[Z VY V[OLY JVUMPKLU[PHS PUMVYTH[PVU PU OPZ WVZZLZZPVU%
`
`J\Z[VK‘% VY JVU[YVS HUK [V JH\ZL [OL YLTLKPH[PVU VM HU‘ PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ 3U[OLTgZ IPK Z[YH[LN‘
`
`[OH[ OL KPZJSVZLK [V 5HYLBV\YJL’
`
`)%&23%, %,,(*%2+/.1
`
`$#
`
`$03-+/52 ’+,.3./)3+ %42.0+22 &03+1+232
`
`*+’
`
`3U[OLT PZ HU :UKPHUHWVSPZ&IHZLK JVTWHU‘ [OH[ WYV]PKLZ OLHS[O JHYL ZLY]PJLZ [V
`
`TPSSPVUZ VM 3TLYPJHUZ HJYVZZ [OL DUP[LK B[H[LZ’ 3U[OLT OHZ HWWYV_PTH[LS‘ .,%((( LTWSV‘LLZ%
`
`^P[O TVYL [OHU -%((( LTWSV‘LLZ SVJH[LK PU :UKPHUH’ CV IL[[LY ZLY]L 3TLYPJHUZ% 3U[OLT VWLYH[LZ
`
`H U\TILY VM UL[^VYR&IHZLK THUHNLK JHYL WSHUZ [V NYV\WZ VM HSS ZPaLZ% HZ ^LSS HZ [V PUKP]PK\HSZ HUK
`
`[OL =LKPJHYL HUK =LKPJHPK THYRL[Z’
`
`*,’
`
`3U[OLT% [OYV\NO P[Z Z\IZPKPHYPLZ 9LHS[O‘ 4S\L >LIYHZRH HUK 3TLYPNYV\W :V^H%
`
`WYV]PKLZ =LKPJHPK WSHUZ [OYV\NOV\[ [OLPY YLZWLJ[P]L Z[H[LZ’ COLZL =LKPJHPK WSHUZ VWLYH[L I‘
`
`WYV]PKPUN OLHS[OJHYL JV]LYHNL [OYV\NO WYP]H[PaLK =LKPJHPK WYVNYHTZ M\UKLK I‘ H TP_ VM MLKLYHS
`
`HUK Z[H[L M\UKZ’
`
`*-’
`
`3U[OLTgZ Z\JJLZZ PU [OL OLHS[OJHYL PUK\Z[Y‘ PZ H YLZ\S[ VM ‘LHYZ VM OHYK ^VYR HUK
`
`PUNLU\P[‘’ 3U[OLTgZ JVUMPKLU[PHS% WYVWYPL[HY‘% HUK [YHKL ZLJYL[ PUMVYTH[PVU HUK HKTPUPZ[YH[P]L HUK
`
`VWLYH[PVUHS HJ\TLU HSSV^ P[ [V THPU[HPU THYRL[ ZOHYL HUK [OYP]L PU HU L_[YLTLS‘ JVTWL[P[P]L
`
`PUK\Z[Y‘’ 3U[OLTgZ I\ZPULZZ PZ WYVMP[HISL I‘ ]PY[\L VM P[Z Z[YH[LNPJ Z[Y\J[\YPUN HUK PTWSLTLU[H[PVU
`
`)0,1..,/]’*
`
`/
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 8 of 27 PageID #: 8
`
`XO R]\ Y[X_RMN[ WN]‘X[T\’ YX[]OXURX XO VNVKN[ KNWNOR] YUJW\’ JWM \^K\]JW]RJU RW_N\]VNW]\ RW
`
`XYN[J]RXWJU RVY[X_NVNW]’ JUU XO ‘QRLQ R\ M[R_NW Kb RWOX[VJ]RXW ]QJ] R\ [NPJ[MNM J\ QRPQUb
`
`LXWORMNW]RJU Kb 7W]QNV JWM R]\ LXVYN]R]X[\) 7W]QNV QJ\ MN_NUXYNM JWM VJRW]JRWNM R]\ LXVYN]R]R_N
`
`YX\R]RXW RW ]QN VJ[TN] RW UJ[PN YJ[] KNLJ^\N ]QR\ LXWORMNW]RJU JWM Y[XY[RN]J[b RWOX[VJ]RXW’ ‘QRLQ
`
`7W]QNV ]JTN\ \RPWRORLJW] VNJ\^[N\ ]X \JONP^J[M O[XV Y^KURL MR\\NVRWJ]RXW)
`
`-1)
`
`FX VJRW]JRW 7W]QNVg\ LXVYN]R]R_N JM_JW]JPN JWM YX\R]RXW RW ]QN VJ[TN]YUJLN’
`
`7W]QNV NaYNWM\ \^K\]JW]RJU
`
`]RVN’ NOOX[]’ JWM NaYNW\N MN_NUXYRWP ][JMN \NL[N]\ JWM X]QN[
`
`LXWORMNW]RJU K^\RWN\\ RWOX[VJ]RXW’ ‘QRLQ RWLU^MN’ K^] J[N WX] URVR]NM ]X5 @NMRLJRM YUJW XYN[J]RXWJU
`
`YJ[JVN]N[\6 @NMRLJRM @9B LXW][JL] Y[XL^[NVNW] \][J]NPb6 LXVYN]R]R_N RW]NUURPNWLN JKX^]
`
`@NMRLJRM KRMMRWP XYYX[]^WR]RN\6 LXVV^WR]b QNJU]Q MNVXP[JYQRL RWOX[VJ]RXW6 YUJW JMVRWR\][J]RXW
`
`RWOX[VJ]RXW JWM ORWJWLRJU VN][RL\6 JWM X]QN[ K^\RWN\\ VN]QXM\’ \][J]NPRN\’ JWM YUJW\’ RWLU^MRWP
`
`\JUN\ \][J]NPRN\ JWM VN]QXM\)
`
`-2)
`
`FX Y[X]NL]
`
`R]\ ][JMN \NL[N]\ JWM X]QN[ LXWORMNW]RJU JWM Y[XY[RN]J[b K^\RWN\\
`
`RWOX[VJ]RXW’ 7W]QNV \]X[N\ R]\ ][JMN \NL[N]\ JWM LXWORMNW]RJU RWOX[VJ]RXW XW \NL^[N LXVY^]N[
`
`\b\]NV\)
`
`>W JMMR]RXW’ ]QN RWOX[VJ]RXW R\ LXVYRUNM JWM \]X[NM RW YJ\\‘X[M(Y[X]NL]NM NUNL][XWRL
`
`MJ]JKJ\N\’
`
`RWLU^MRWP Y[XY[RN]J[b RW]N[WJU Y[XP[JV\ ]Q[X^PQ ‘QRLQ 7W]QNV JPP[NPJ]N\ JWM
`
`VXWR]X[\ RWOX[VJ]RXW [NUJ]RWP ]X R]\ XYN[J]RXW\) 7LLN\\ ]X LXWORMNW]RJU RWOX[VJ]RXW R\ O^[]QN[
`
`[N\][RL]NM ]X \YNLRORL ^\N[ Y[XORUN\ \X ]QJ] ^\N[\ XW ]QN WN]‘X[T QJ_N JLLN\\ XWUb ]X \YNLRORL OXUMN[\
`
`[J]QN[ ]QJW ]QN NW]R[N ^WR_N[\N XO 7W]QNVg\ ][JMN \NL[N]\ JWM LXWORMNW]RJU RWOX[VJ]RXW)
`
`-3)
`
`7W]QNV QJ\ \YNW] J \RPWRORLJW] JVX^W] XO ]RVN JWM VXWNb JWJUbcRWP JWM [NORWRWP
`
`R]\ XYN[J]RXWJU YN[OX[VJWLN JL[X\\ _J[RX^\ \]J]N YUJW\) FQN @NMRLJRM VJ[TN] RW ‘QRLQ =NJU]Qb
`
`8U^N ANK[J\TJ JWM 7VN[RP[X^Y >X‘J XYN[J]N R\ YJ[]RL^UJ[Ub LQJUUNWPRWP’ J\ @NMRLJRMg\ LX_N[NM
`
`YXY^UJ]RXW R\ LXVY[R\NM XO YXX[ JWM MR\JKUNM RWMR_RM^JU\ ‘QX XO]NW QJ_N VX[N LXVYUNa VNMRLJU
`
`,3/411/2_)-
`
`3
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 9 of 27 PageID #: 9
`
`WNNM\ JWM QRPQN[ LJ[[bRWP LX\]\’ ]Q^\ [NZ^R[RWP \YNLRORL NaYN[]R\N ]X MN_NUXY Y[XP[JV\ ]X \N[_N ]QN
`
`QNJU]QLJ[N WNNM\ XO ]QN\N VNVKN[\)
`
`-4)
`
`7W]QNVg\ ][JMN \NL[N]\ JWM X]QN[ LXWORMNW]RJU RWOX[VJ]RXW’ JWM R]\ NaYN[RNWLN
`
`XYN[J]RWP LXVYUNa QNJU]Q YUJW\’ Y[X_RMN R] ‘R]Q J LXVYN]R]R_N JM_JW]JPN RW ]QN VJ[TN]YUJLN) >W
`
`>X‘J’ OX[ NaJVYUN’ 7VN[RP[X^Y >X‘J R\ XWN XO XWUb ]‘X @NMRLJRM Y[X_RMN[\ ‘QX R\ L^[[NW]Ub
`
`Y[X_RMRWP \N[_RLN\ RW ]QN E]J]N) B]QN[ @NMRLJRM Y[X_RMN[\ ‘R]QX^] ]QN KNWNOR] JWM LXVYN]R]R_N
`
`JM_JW]JPN Y[X_RMNM Kb 7W]QNVg\ WXW(Y^KURL’ LXWORMNW]RJU RWOX[VJ]RXW QJ_N KNNW ^WJKUN ]X
`
`\^LLN\\O^UUb XYN[J]N’ JLL[^RWP \^K\]JW]RJU UX\\N\ Y[X_RMRWP LJ[N X[ Na]NW\R_N R\\^N\ Y[X_RMRWP
`
`]RVNUb YJbVNW] ]X Y[X_RMN[\)
`
`$#
`
`%0,. *17/8=9 &4736<4/5: +1:0 ’/,3:0< $3;/ )/-8,92,
`
`.+)
`
`CRYN[ SXRWNM 7W]QNV ]Q[X^PQ J LX[YX[J]N ][JW\JL]RXW RW -+-+) >W -+,4’ CRYN[ SXRWNM
`
`INUU9J[N XO ANK[J\TJ’ >WL)’ J\ R]\ @J[TN] HRLN C[N\RMNW]) >W -+-+’ 7W]QNV JLZ^R[NM INUU9J[N XO
`
`ANK[J\TJ’ >WL) O[XV R]\ YJ[NW] LXVYJWb’ INUU9J[N =NJU]Q CUJW\’ >WL)’ JWM [NWJVNM INUU9J[N XO
`
`ANK[J\TJ’ >WL) ]X 9XVV^WR]b 9J[N =NJU]Q CUJW XO ANK[J\TJ’ >WL) M*K*J =NJU]Qb 8U^N ANK[J\TJ)
`
`.,)
`
`;OONL]R_N ?JW^J[b -+-,’ 7W]QNV Y[XVX]NM CRYN[ ]X DNPRXWJU HRLN C[N\RMNW] XO
`
`BYN[J]RXW\ OX[ =NJU]Qb 8U^N ANK[J\TJ’ JWM 7W]QNV JPJRW Y[XVX]NM QRV ]X C[N\RMNW] RW @Jb -+-,)
`
`.-)
`
`>W ]QR\ [XUN’ CRYN[ QJM \^K\]JW]RJU [N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[ =NJU]Qb 8U^N ANK[J\TJg\
`
`XYN[J]RXWJU JWM ORWJWLRJU YN[OX[VJWLN) =R\ M^]RN\ RWLU^MNM VJWJPRWP \]J]N JWM UXLJU [NUJ]RXW\QRY\’
`
`LJY]JRWRWP ]QN YUJWg\ \][J]NPRL PXJU\’ MR[NL]RWP XYN[J]RXW\’ JWM VJRW]JRWRWP ]QN YUJWg\ \]J]^\ J\ JW
`
`JYY[X_NM @NMRLJRM YUJW Y[X_RMN[) >W JMMR]RXW’ CRYN[ ‘J\ [N\YXW\RKUN OX[ Y[NYJ[RWP JWM NaNL^]RWP
`
`]QN YUJW OX[ JW NaYNL]NM [N(Y[XL^[NVNW] OX[ ]QN ANK[J\TJ VJ[TN])
`
`..)
`
`:^[RWP QR\ NVYUXbVNW] ‘R]Q 7W]QNV J\ J QRPQUb LXVYNW\J]NM \NWRX[ NaNL^]R_N’
`
`CRYN[ [NLNR_NM ]QN XYYX[]^WR]b ]X YJ[]RLRYJ]N RW 7W]QNVg\ >WLNW]R_N 9XVYNW\J]RXW CUJW JWM [NLNR_N
`
`[N\][RL]NM \]XLT P[JW]\) BW X[ JKX^] @J[LQ ,’ -+,4’ CRYN[ [NLNR_NM ]Q[NN \NYJ[J]N [N\][RL]NM \]XLT
`
`,3/411/2_)-
`
`4
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 10 of 27 PageID #: 10
`
`P[JW]\ LXUUNL]R_NUb J‘J[MNM \N_N[JU Q^WM[NM ]QX^\JWM MXUUJ[\ RW 7W]QNV \]XLT’ \^KSNL] ]X
`
`LXWMR]RXW\ NW^VN[J]NM RW ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]\)
`
`./)
`
`FQN DEG 7P[NNVNW]\ LXW]JRW [N\][RL]RXW\ XW CRYN[g\ JKRUR]b ]X ^\N 7W]QNVg\
`
`LXWORMNW]RJU
`
`RWOX[VJ]RXW’
`
`]X LXVYN]N JPJRW\] 7W]QNV’ JWM ]X \XURLR] 7W]QNVg\ L^\]XVN[\’
`
`Y[X_RMN[\’ JWM NVYUXbNN\)
`
`.0)
`
`>W ENL]RXW 2%J& XO ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]’ CRYN[ [NLXPWRcNM ]QJ] 7W]QNV MN[R_N\
`
`\^K\]JW]RJU NLXWXVRL _JU^N O[XV R]\ e9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW’f ‘QRLQ R\ MNORWNM ]X RWLU^MN5
`
`YUJW\’ MN\RPW\’ LXWLNY]\’ LXVY^]N[ Y[XP[JV\’ OX[V^UJN’ JWM NZ^J]RXW\6 Y[XM^L]
`O^UORUUVNW] JWM \^YYURN[ RWOX[VJ]RXW6 L^\]XVN[ JWM \^YYURN[ UR\]\’ JWM LXWORMNW]RJU
`K^\RWN\\ Y[JL]RLN\ XO ]QN 9XVYJWb’ R]\ JOORURJ]N\ JWM JWb XO R]\ L^\]XVN[\’ _NWMX[\’
`K^\RWN\\ YJ[]WN[\ X[ \^YYURN[\6 Y[XOR] VJ[PRW\ JWM ]QN Y[RLN\ JWM MR\LX^W]\ ]QN
`9XVYJWb XK]JRW\ X[ QJ\ XK]JRWNM X[ J] ‘QRLQ R] \NUU\ X[ QJ\ \XUM X[ YUJW\ ]X \NUU R]\
`Y[XM^L]\ X[ \N[_RLN\ %NaLNY] OX[ Y^KURL Y[RLRWP UR\]\&6 VJW^OJL]^[RWP’ J\\NVKURWP’
`UJKX[ JWM \JUN\ YUJW\ JWM LX\]\6 K^\RWN\\ JWM VJ[TN]RWP YUJW\’ RMNJ\’ X[ \][J]NPRN\6
`LXWORMNW]RJU ORWJWLRJU YN[OX[VJWLN JWM Y[XSNL]RXW\6 NVYUXbNN LXVYNW\J]RXW6
`NVYUXbNN \]JOORWP JWM [NL[^R]RWP YUJW\ JWM NVYUXbNN YN[\XWJU RWOX[VJ]RXW6 JWM
`X]QN[ LXWORMNW]RJU LXWLNY]\ JWM RMNJ\ [NUJ]NM ]X ]QN 9XVYJWb$\ K^\RWN\\)
`
`%Id. d 2%J&)& e9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXWf R\ JU\X MNORWNM ]X RWLU^MN RWOX[VJ]RXW Y[X]NL]NM Kb ]QN
`
`>WMRJWJ GWROX[V F[JMN ENL[N]\ 7L]’ ^WUN\\ \^LQ RWOX[VJ]RXW R\ TWX‘W ]X CRYN[ X[ ]QN PNWN[JU Y^KURL
`
`]Q[X^PQ VNJW\ X]QN[ ]QJW J K[NJLQ XO J M^]b ]X VJRW]JRW ]QN LXWORMNW]RJUR]b XO \^LQ RWOX[VJ]RXW)
`
`.1)
`
`CRYN[ JP[NNM ]QJ]’ OX[ \X UXWP J\ 7W]QNVg\ 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW [NVJRWNM
`
`LXWORMNW]RJU’ QN ‘X^UM WX]5
`
`%7& ^\N 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW OX[ ]QN KNWNOR] XO JWb YN[\XW X[ NW]R]b X]QN[ ]QJW
`]QN 9XVYJWb X[ R]\ JOORURJ]N\6 %8& [NVX_N’ LXYb’ M^YURLJ]N X[ X]QN[‘R\N [NY[XM^LN
`JWb MXL^VNW] X[ ]JWPRKUN R]NV NVKXMbRWP X[ YN[]JRWRWP ]X JWb XO ]QN 9XWORMNW]RJU
`>WOX[VJ]RXW’ NaLNY] J\ [NZ^R[NM ]X YN[OX[V ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ M^]RN\ OX[ ]QN 9XVYJWb
`X[ R]\ JOORURJ]N\6 X[ %9& ‘QRUN NVYUXbNM JWM ]QN[NJO]N[’ Y^KUR\Q’ [NUNJ\N’ MR\LUX\N X[
`MNUR_N[ X[ X]QN[‘R\N VJTN J_JRUJKUN ]X JWb ]QR[M YJ[]b JWb 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW
`Kb JWb LXVV^WRLJ]RXW’
`RWLU^MRWP X[JU’ MXL^VNW]J[b’ NUNL][XWRL X[ VJPWN]RL
`RWOX[VJ]RXW ][JW\VR]]JU MN_RLN X[ VNMRJ)
`
`%Id.&
`
`,3/411/2_)-
`
`,+
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 11 of 27 PageID #: 11
`
`.2)
`
`>W ENL]RXW 2%K& XO ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]’ CRYN[ JP[NNM ]X ]QN OXUUX‘RWP [N\][RL]RXW XW
`
`QR\ JKRUR]b ]X LXVYN]N JPJRW\] 7W]QNV5
`
`:^[RWP JWb YN[RXM RW ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] R\ NVYUXbNM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb’ JWM
`M^[RWP J YN[RXM XO ]RVN JO]N[ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ ]N[VRWJ]RXW XO NVYUXbVNW] %]QN
`eDN\][RL]RXW CN[RXMf& ‘QRLQ’ ^WUN\\ X]QN[‘R\N URVR]NM Kb JYYURLJKUN \]J]N UJ‘’ R\ %R&
`]‘NW]b(OX^[ %-/& VXW]Q\ OX[ ;aNL^]R_N HRLN C[N\RMNW]\ JWM ]QN C[N\RMNW] # 9QRNO
`;aNL^]R_N BOORLN[’ JWM %RR& ]QN P[NJ]N[ XO ]QN YN[RXM XO \N_N[JWLN X[ ]‘NU_N %,-&
`VXW]Q\ OX[ JUU X]QN[ CJ[]RLRYJW]\’ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] ‘RUU WX]’ ‘R]QX^] Y[RX[ ‘[R]]NW
`LXW\NW] XO ]QN 9XVYJWb’ MR[NL]Ub X[ RWMR[NL]Ub \NNT X[ XK]JRW J 9XVYN]R]R_N CX\R]RXW
`RW J DN\][RL]NM FN[[R]X[b JWM YN[OX[V J DN\][RL]NM 7L]R_R]b ‘R]Q J 9XVYN]R]X[’ J\
`]QX\N ]N[V\ J[N MNORWNM QN[NRW)
`
`%R& 9XVYN]R]R_N CX\R]RXW VNJW\ JWb NVYUXbVNW] X[ YN[OX[VJWLN XO \N[_RLN\
`‘R]Q J 9XVYN]R]X[ %7& ]QN \JVN J\ X[ \RVRUJ[ ]X ]QN \N[_RLN\ RW ‘QRLQ
`CJ[]RLRYJW] YN[OX[VNM OX[ ]QN 9XVYJWb RW ]QN UJ\] ]‘NW]b(OX^[ %-/& VXW]Q\
`XO CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ NVYUXbVNW] ‘R]Q 9XVYJWb’ X[ %8& RW ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]
`‘RUU ^\N JWb 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW XO ]QN 9XVYJWb)
`
`%RR& DN\][RL]NM FN[[R]X[b VNJW\ JWb PNXP[JYQRL J[NJ RW ‘QRLQ ]QN 9XVYJWb
`MXN\ K^\RWN\\ JWM RW ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] Y[X_RMNM \N[_RLN\ RW’ QJM
`[N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[’ QJM J VJ]N[RJU Y[N\NWLN X[ RWOU^NWLN RW’ X[ QJM JLLN\\ ]X
`9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW JKX^]’ \^LQ K^\RWN\\’ ‘R]QRW ]QN ]QR[]b(\Ra %.1&
`VXW]Q\ Y[RX[ ]X ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ ]N[VRWJ]RXW XO NVYUXbVNW] O[XV ]QN
`9XVYJWb)
`
`%RRR& DN\][RL]NM 7L]R_R]b VNJW\ JWb JL]R_R]b OX[ ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM
`[N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[ ]QN 9XVYJWb ‘R]QRW ]QN ]QR[]b(\Ra %.1& VXW]Q\ Y[RX[ ]X ]QN
`]N[VRWJ]RXW XO ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ NVYUXbVNW] O[XV ]QN 9XVYJWb X[ JKX^]
`‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW)
`
`%R_& 9XVYN]R]X[ VNJW\ JWb NW]R]b X[ RWMR_RM^JU %X]QN[ ]QJW ]QN 9XVYJWb X[
`R]\ JOORURJ]N\& NWPJPNM RW VJWJPNVNW] XO WN]‘X[T(KJ\NM VJWJPNM LJ[N YUJW\
`JWM Y[XP[JV\’ X[ ]QN YN[OX[VJWLN XO VJWJPNM LJ[N \N[_RLN\’ QNJU]Q
`RW\^[JWLN’ UXWP ]N[V LJ[N RW\^[JWLN’ MNW]JU’ URON X[ MR\JKRUR]b RW\^[JWLN’
`KNQJ_RX[JU QNJU]Q’ _R\RXW’
`OUNaRKUN \YNWMRWP JLLX^W]\ JWM 9B8D7
`JMVRWR\][J]RXW X[ X]QN[ Y[XM^L]\ X[ \N[_RLN\ \^K\]JW]RJUUb ]QN \JVN X[ \RVRUJ[
`]X ]QX\N XOON[NM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb ‘QRUN ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] ‘J\ NVYUXbNM’ X[
`X]QN[ Y[XM^L]\ X[ \N[_RLN\ XOON[NM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb ‘R]QRW ]‘NU_N %,-&
`VXW]Q\ JO]N[ ]QN ]N[VRWJ]RXW XO CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ NVYUXbVNW] RO ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]
`QJM [N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[’ X[ 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW JKX^]’ \^LQ X]QN[
`Y[XM^L]\ X[ \N[_RLN\ ‘QRUN ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] ‘J\ NVYUXbNM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb)
`
`%DEG 7P[NNVNW] d 2%K&)&
`
`,3/411/2_)-
`
`,,
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 12 of 27 PageID #: 12
`
`.3)
`
`>W ENL]RXW 2%L& XO ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]’ CRYN[ JP[NNM ]X ]QN OXUUX‘RWP [N\][RL]RXW XW
`
`QR\ JKRUR]b ]X \XURLR] 7W]QNVg\ L^\]XVN[\ JWM JLLX^W]\5
`
`:^[RWP JWb YN[RXM RW ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] R\ NVYUXbNM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb’
`JWM M^[RWP ]QN DN\][RL]RXW CN[RXM JO]N[ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ ]N[VRWJ]RXW XO
`NVYUXbVNW]’ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] ‘RUU WX]’ NR]QN[ RWMR_RM^JUUb X[ J\ JW NVYUXbNN’
`YJ[]WN[’ LXW\^U]JW]’ RWMNYNWMNW] LXW][JL]X[’ X‘WN[’ JPNW]’ X[ RW JWb X]QN[
`LJYJLR]b’ MR[NL]Ub X[ RWMR[NL]Ub’ OX[ J 9XVYN]R]X[ XO ]QN 9XVYJWb J\ MNORWNM
`RW \^K\NL]RXW %K& JKX_N5 %R& \XURLR] K^\RWN\\ O[XV JWb LURNW] X[ JLLX^W] XO ]QN
`9XVYJWb X[ JWb XO R]\ JOORURJ]N\ ‘R]Q ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM LXW]JL]’
`YJ[]RLRYJ]NM RW ]QN LXW]JL]’ X[ [N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[’ X[ JKX^] ‘QRLQ ]QN
`CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM TWX‘UNMPN XO 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW Kb [NJ\XW XO ]QN
`CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ NVYUXbVNW] ‘R]Q ]QN 9XVYJWb’ %RR& \XURLR] K^\RWN\\ O[XV JWb
`LURNW] X[ JLLX^W] ‘QRLQ ‘J\ Y^[\^NM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb X[ JWb XO R]\ JOORURJ]N\
`JWM ‘R]Q ‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM LXW]JL]’ X[ [N\YXW\RKRUR]b OX[’ X[ JKX^]
`‘QRLQ ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW] QJM TWX‘UNMPN XO 9XWORMNW]RJU >WOX[VJ]RXW Kb [NJ\XW
`XO ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ NVYUXbVNW] ‘R]Q ]QN 9XVYJWb’ ‘R]QRW ]QN ]‘NU_N %,-&
`VXW]Q YN[RXM Y[RX[ ]X ]N[VRWJ]RXW XO NVYUXbVNW]) <X[ Y^[YX\N\ XO ]QR\
`Y[X_R\RXW’ JW RWMR_RM^JU YXURLbQXUMN[ RW J YUJW VJRW]JRWNM Kb ]QN 9XVYJWb
`X[ Kb J LURNW] X[ JLLX^W] XO ]QN 9XVYJWb ^WMN[ ‘QRLQ RWMR_RM^JU YXURLRN\
`J[N R\\^NM’ X[ J LN[]RORLJ]N QXUMN[ RW \^LQ YUJW ^WMN[ ‘QRLQ P[X^Y YXURLRN\
`J[N R\\^NM’ \QJUU WX] KN LXW\RMN[NM J LURNW] X[ JLLX^W] \^KSNL] ]X ]QR\
`[N\][RL]RXW \XUNUb Kb [NJ\XW XO KNRWP \^LQ J YXURLbQXUMN[ X[ LN[]RORLJ]N
`QXUMN[)
`
`%Id. d 2%L&)&
`
`.4)
`
`>W ENL]RXW 4%J& XO ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]’ CRYN[ JLTWX‘UNMPNM ]QJ] ]QN [N\][RL]R_N
`
`LX_NWJW]\ RW ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW] eJ[N [NJ\XWJKUN JWM WNLN\\J[b ]X Y[N\N[_N ]QN UNPR]RVJ]N K^\RWN\\
`
`RW]N[N\]\ XO ]QN 9XVYJWb’ R]\ Y[N\NW] JWM YX]NW]RJU K^\RWN\\ JL]R_R]RN\ JWM ]QN NLXWXVRL KNWNOR]\
`
`MN[R_NM ]QN[NO[XV6 ]QJ] ]QNb ‘RUU WX] Y[N_NW] QRV X[ QR\ O[XV NJ[WRWP J UR_NURQXXM RW ]QN
`
`CJ[]RLRYJW]$\ LQX\NW K^\RWN\\ JWM J[N WX] JW ^WM^N [N\][JRW] XW ]QN ][JMN XO ]QN CJ[]RLRYJW]’ X[ JWb
`
`XO ]QN Y^KURL RW]N[N\]\ ‘QRLQ VJb KN RW_XU_NM)f
`
`/+)
`
`>W ENL]RXW 4%K& XO ]QN DEG 7P[NNVNW]’ CRYN[ JP[NNM ]QJ] ]QN ]N[V XO ]QN [N\][RL]R_N
`
`LX_NWJW]\ ‘X^UM KN Na]NWMNM Kb ]QN YN[RXM ]QJ] CRYN[ ‘J\ WX] RW LXVYURJWLN ‘R]Q ]QN DEG
`
`7P[NNVNW])
`
`,3/411/2_)-
`
`,-
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 13 of 27 PageID #: 13
`
`’$
`
`,6;2< .>>291= >52 &?=692== +;2<.>694 -2@62A 3:< >52 ):A. <2/61
`.91 :/>.69= 0<6>60.7 69=645>= 69>: %9>528C= ):A. 369.906.7=# /61
`=><.>24B# .91 0:8;2>6>6@2 0:9=612<.>6:9=$
`
`.+(
`
`CXO YP ^RO UOc \O]ZYX]SLSVS^SO] YP K ZVKX D\O]SNOX^ S] ^Y OX]_\O ^RK^ RS] Y\ RO\ ZVKX
`
`\OWKSX] K ]^K^O’KZZ\Y‘ON AONSMKSN ZVKX(
`
`.,( AKXc ]^K^O]& SXMV_NSXQ BOL\K]UK KXN =YaK& RK‘O MYX^\KM^] aS^R AONSMKSN WKXKQON
`
`MK\O Y\QKXSdK^SYX] $gA7C]h% ^Y Z\Y‘SNO ROKV^RMK\O ^Y ^RK^ ]^K^Oi] AONSMKSN’OVSQSLVO ZYZ_VK^SYX(
`
`HXNO\ WKXKQON MK\O& AONSMKSN \OMSZSOX^] K\O OX\YVVON SX K Z\S‘K^O ROKV^R ZVKX& aRSMR \OMOS‘O] K
`
`PSbON WYX^RVc Z\OWS_W P\YW ^RO ]^K^O( GRO ROKV^R ZVKX S] ^ROX \O]ZYX]SLVO PY\ Z\Y‘SNSXQ PY\ KVV Y\
`
`WY]^ YP ^RO \OMSZSOX^i] ROKV^RMK\O XOON](
`
`.-(
`
`GY NO^O\WSXO aRSMR Z\S‘K^O ROKV^RMK\O MYWZKXSO] K\O K_^RY\SdON ^Y Z\Y‘SNO MK\O
`
`_XNO\ K ]^K^Oi] AONSMKSN Z\YQ\KW& K ]^K^O KQOXMc& _]_KVVc ^RO \OVO‘KX^ NOZK\^WOX^ YP ROKV^R KXN
`
`R_WKX ]O\‘SMO]& S]]_O] K MYWZO^S^S‘O LSNNSXQ Z\YMO]] ^R\Y_QR K \O[_O]^ PY\ Z\YZY]KV] $gE:D]h Y\
`
`g\OLSN]h% ^Y \OLSN ^RO ]^K^Oi] AONSMKSN A7C MYX^\KM^]( 5X^ROW AONSMKSN ZVKX] K\O \O[_S\ON ^Y
`
`MYWZO^O SX ^RO]O Z\YM_\OWOX^] aS^R ^RO ]^K^O KQOXMc ^RK^ KNWSXS]^O\] ^RO AONSMKSN Z\YQ\KW SX
`
`^ROS\ ]^K^O K^ ^RO OXN YP ^ROS\ \O]ZOM^S‘O MYX^\KM^ ^O\W] SX Y\NO\ ^Y \O^KSX ^ROS\ L_]SXO]]( 5] K \O]_V^&
`
`O‘OX SX cOK\] aROX ]^K^O AONSMKSN WKXKQON MK\O Z\YQ\KW] K\O XY^ SX ^RO Z\YM_\OWOX^ Z\YMO]]&
`
`MYWZO^S^S‘O LSNNSXQ S] KVaKc] K XOK\’^O\W Z\Y]ZOM^ LOMK_]O WKXc ]^K^O AONSMKSN A7C MYX^\KM^]
`
`RK‘O ^O\W] ^RK^ VK]^& YX K‘O\KQO& ^R\OO $-% ^Y PS‘O $/% cOK\](
`
`..(
`
`GRO E:D)\OLSN Z\YMO]] S] K ‘O\c NO^KSVON& \YL_]^& KXN \O]Y_\MO’SX^OX]S‘O Z\YMO]](
`
`GY LO aOVV’ZY]S^SYXON PY\ K AONSMKSN WKXKQON MK\O E:D ^KUO] WYX^R] YP ZVKXXSXQ& KXKVc]S]& KXN
`
`ObOM_^SYX( =X KNNS^SYX ^Y PSXKXMSKV PY\OMK]^SXQ& 5X^ROW OWLK\U] YX K MYWZ\OROX]S‘O \O‘SOa YX ^RO
`
`\O[_O]^SXQ ]^K^Oi] XOON]& Z\SY\S^SO]& KXN _XS[_O MRKVVOXQO] YP ^RK^ WK\UO^ ^Y NOVS‘O\ K Z\YZY]KV ^RK^
`
`WOO^] ^RO \OLSN [_KVSPSMK^SYX] aRSVO KV]Y MYWWS^^SXQ ^Y _XS[_O KXN YP^OX Z\YZ\SO^K\c ]YV_^SYX] KXN
`
`SXXY‘K^SYX] ^RK^ aSVV KN‘KXMO ]^K^O Z\SY\S^SO](
`
`+2.300.1‘(,
`
`+-
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 14 of 27 PageID #: 14
`
`./(
`
`5X^ROW ]ZOX^ ]SQXSPSMKX^ ^SWO ON_MK^SXQ DSZO\ KLY_^ 5X^ROWi] LSNNSXQ Z\YMO]]O]
`
`KXN WO^RYNYVYQc( 5X^ROW KX^SMSZK^ON ^RK^ BOL\K]UK aY_VN LO S]]_SXQ KX E:D SX ^RO ]YWOaRK^’
`
`XOK\ P_^_\O KXN SX‘O]^ON ]_L]^KX^SKV ^SWO Z\OZK\SXQ DSZO\ PY\ ^RO Z\YM_\OWOX^ Z\YMO]](
`
`.0(
`
`5] ZK\^ YP ^RK^ Z\OZK\K^SYX& DSZO\ \OMOS‘ON ]SQXSPSMKX^ KXN NO^KSVON MYXPSNOX^SKV
`
`SXPY\WK^SYX KLY_^ 5X^ROWi] Z\YM_\OWOX^ ]^\K^OQc SX =YaK& K XOSQRLY\SXQ ]^K^O aS^R ]SWSVK\
`
`ROKV^RMK\O XOON]& ]SWSVK\ NOWYQ\KZRSM]& KXN ]SWSVK\ S]]_O] \OVO‘KX^ ^Y S^] \OLSN Z\YMO]](
`
`.1(
`
`5X^ROW KV]Y SX‘S^ON DSZO\ ^Y K^^OXN ^RO 6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV EO‘SOa PY\ =YaK YX
`
`CM^YLO\ +2& ,*,+( BY\WKVVc& ZVKX Z\O]SNOX^] P\YW Y^RO\ ]^K^O] NY XY^ K^^OXN 6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV
`
`EO‘SOa] PY\ Y^RO\ ]^K^O]& L_^ DSZO\ \OMOS‘ON KX YPPO\ ^Y K^^OXN ^Y PKWSVSK\SdO RSW]OVP aS^R 5X^ROWi]
`
`LSN Z\YMO]]& YL]O\‘O RYa KX ObZO\SOXMON ZVKX D\O]SNOX^ KZZ\YKMRO] ^RO LSN Z\YMO]]& KXN ]OO RYa
`
`^RK^ ]^\K^OQc MY_VN LO KZZVSON SX =YaK& K WK\UO^ aS^R ]SWSVK\ MRK\KM^O\S]^SM] ^Y BOL\K]UK(
`
`.2(
`
`5^ ^RO CM^YLO\ +2 6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV EO‘SOa& >OPP >YXO]& ^RO ZVKX D\O]SNOX^ KXN
`
`79C PY\ 5WO\SQ\Y_Z =YaK& Z\Y‘SNON NO^KSVON SXPY\WK^SYX KLY_^ 5WO\SQ\Y_Z =YaKi] YZO\K^SYXKV
`
`WO^\SM] KXN S^] ]^\K^OQc PY\ ^RO =YaK <OKV^R @SXU \OLSN( GRO Z\O]OX^K^SYX SXMV_NON ]ZOMSPSM
`
`PSXKXMSKV KXN YZO\K^SYXKV WO^\SM] KLY_^ ^RO ZO\PY\WKXMO YP 5WO\SQ\Y_Z =YaKi] AONSMKSN ZVKX&
`
`SNOX^SPSMK^SYX YP ^RO ZVKXi] gGYZ - D\SY\S^SO] PY\ ,*,,&h KM^SYX S^OW] ^Y WKSX^KSX KXN SWZ\Y‘O ^RO
`
`ZVKXi] PSXKXMSKV ]^KLSVS^c KXN [_KVS^c ]^\K^OQc& KXN K ]_WWK\c YP ^RO ZVKXi] MYWW_XS^c’LK]ON
`
`ZYZ_VK^SYX ROKV^R ]^\K^OQc& aRSMR SXMV_NON M\S^SMKV ZK\^XO\]RSZ]( =^ KV]Y SXMV_NON ^RO SNOX^S^c YP
`
`ZY^OX^SKV MYWZO^S^Y\] ^RK^ >YXO] ObZOM^ON ^Y ]_LWS^ LSN] SX MYXXOM^SYX aS^R ^RS] \OLSN( 7K\OFY_\MO
`
`S] YXO YP ^RO MYWZO^S^Y\] >YXO] SNOX^SPSON N_\SXQ RS] Z\O]OX^K^SYX(
`
`.3(
`
`DO\RKZ] WY]^ M\_MSKVVc& SX ^RO 6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV EO‘SOa& >YXO] ]RK\ON ]O‘O\KV
`
`\S]U] ^RK^ ^RO ZVKX PKMO]& ^RO PSXKXMSKV SWZKM^ YP ]_MR \S]U]& KXN 5X^ROWi] ZVKX ^Y \O]YV‘O OKMR YP
`
`^RY]O \S]U]( GRS] SX]SNO\ SXPY\WK^SYXfSXMV_NSXQ 5X^ROWi] SX^O\XKV K]]O]]WOX^ YP ^RO ZVKXi]
`
`+2.300.1‘(,
`
`+.
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 15 of 27 PageID #: 15
`
`‘_VXO\KLSVS^SO] QYSXQ SX^Y ^RO \OLSN Z\YMO]]fS] Z\OMS]OVc ^RO SXPY\WK^SYX ^RK^ K MYWZO^S^Y\ VSUO
`
`7K\OFY_\MO MKX _]O ^Y ^K\QO^ KXN ObZVYS^ 5X^ROWi] ‘_VXO\KLSVS^SO] KXN ]^\K^OQc aROX Z\OZK\SXQ S^]
`
`YaX LSN(
`
`/*(
`
`DSZO\ KV]Y ZK\^SMSZK^ON KXN \OMOS‘ON Z\O’6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV EO‘SOa WK^O\SKV]
`
`KLY_^ Y_^]^KXNSXQ S]]_O] \OVK^ON ^Y ^RO PY\^RMYWSXQ =YaK \OLSN& SXMV_NSXQ MYWWYX MRKVVOXQO]&
`
`ZY^OX^SKV YZ^SYX] ^Y \O]YV‘O ^RY]O MRKVVOXQO]& KXN ZY^OX^SKV LK\\SO\] ^Y \O]YV‘SXQ ^RY]O Z\YLVOW](
`
`($
`
`,6;2< 72@2<.42= %9>528C= 0:936129>6.7 693:<8.>6:9 >: :/>.69 .
`0:8;2>6>6@2 ;:=6>6:9$
`
`/+(
`
`DSZO\ KZZK\OX^Vc ]Ka ^RK^ 5X^ROWi] QOXO\Y]S^c SX Z\OZK\SXQ RSW PY\ ^RO _ZMYWSXQ
`
`BOL\K]UK \OLSN Z\Y‘SNON RSW aS^R K _XS[_O YZZY\^_XS^c ^Y ^KUO ^RO ZVKcLYYU 5X^ROW ]RK\ON aS^R
`
`RSW KXN _]O S^ ^Y ]OM_\O K ZY]S^SYX aS^R K MYWZO^SXQ =YaK ZVKX(
`
`/,(
`
`GR\OO NKc] KP^O\ ^RO =YaK 6_]SXO]] CZO\K^SYXKV EO‘SOa& DSZO\ OWKSVON RSW]OVP K
`
`MYZc YP RS] \O]_WO ^RK^ RO ^S^VON g7RKN DSZO\ J=YaKJEO]_WO(NYMb(h
`
`/-(
`
`CX CM^YLO\ ,/& ,*,+& DSZO\ RKN KX SX^O\‘SOa Y\ Y^RO\ WOO^SXQ aS^R 7K\OFY_\MO(
`
`/.(
`
`DSZO\ ^ROX RKN K ]O\SO] YP SX^O\‘SOa] aS^R 7K\OFY_\MO ObOM_^S‘O]& SXMV_NSXQ >OXXSPO\
`
`8Y_QRO\^c& FID& <_WKX EO]Y_\MO]& 9\RK\N^ D\OS^K_O\& 7RSOP 9bOM_^S‘O CPPSMO\& >KS DSVVKS& 7RSOP
`
`CZO\K^SXQ CPPSMO\& KXN FMY^^ AK\UY‘SMR& 9bOM_^S‘O ISMO D\O]SNOX^& AK\UO^] # D\YN_M^](
`
`//(
`
`CX BY‘OWLO\ ,& ,*,+& DSZO\ PY\aK\NON RSW]OVP K ‘SNOYMYXPO\OXMO VSXU PY\ KX
`
`SX^O\‘SOa aS^R ?S\]^OX @K@_XK& ID 7Y\ZY\K^O FYMSKV EO]ZYX]SLSVS^c PY\ 7K\OFY_\MO& ]MRON_VON PY\
`
`^RO ]KWO NKc K^ KX _XUXYaX ^SWO( 5ZZ\YbSWK^OVc YXO WSX_^O LOPY\O PY\aK\NSXQ ^RS]
`
`‘SNOYMYXPO\OXMO VSXU& DSZO\ PY\aK\NON K MYZc YP YXO YP RS] EFH 5Q\OOWOX^] ^Y RS] aY\U OWKSV(
`
`/0(
`
`HXKaK\O ^RK^ DSZO\ aK] KM^S‘OVc ZVKXXSXQ ^Y MYWZO^O KQKSX]^ 5X^ROW SX =YaK&
`
`5X^ROW MYX^SX_ON ^Y Z\Y‘SNO DSZO\ aS^R RSQRVc MYXPSNOX^SKV SXPY\WK^SYX KXN ON_MK^O RSW KLY_^
`
`5X^ROWi] \OLSN ]^\K^OQc(:Y\ ObKWZVO& P\YW BY‘OWLO\ 3’+*& ,*,+& DSZO\ K^^OXNON KX SX’ZO\]YX
`
`+2.300.1‘(,
`
`+/
`
`

`

`Case 1:22-cv-00450-JRS-MG Document 1 Filed 03/07/22 Page 16 of 27 PageID #: 16
`
`AONSMKSN @OKNO\]RSZ F^\K^OQc AOO^SXQ SX =XNSKXKZYVS]& =XNSKXK aS^R 5X^ROWi] XK^SYXKV AONSMKSN
`
`D\O]SNOX^& SXNS‘SN_KV AONSMKSN ZVKX Z\O]SNOX^]& KXN Y^RO\ ]OXSY\ VOKNO\]( 5^ ^RO YX]S^O AONSMKSN
`
`@OKNO\]RSZ F^\K^OQc AOO^SXQ& 5X^ROWi] ObOM_^S‘O] Z\Y‘SNON DSZO\ KXN Y^RO\ ZVKX Z\O]SNOX^] aS^R
`
`RSQRVc MYXPSNOX^SKV SXPY\WK^SYX \OQK\NSXQ 5X^ROWi] Y‘O\KVV AONSMKSN ]^\K^OQc& SXMV_NSXQ S^] \OLSN
`
`]^\K^OQc SX ]^K^O] VSUO BOL\K]UK KXN =YaK(
`
`/1(
`
`BY^KLVc& K] ZK\^ YP ^RO AONSMKSN @OKNO\]RSZ F^\K^OQc AOO^SXQ ^RK^ DSZO\ K^^OXNON&
`
`5X^ROWi] 7RSOP ;\Ya^R CPPSMO\ PY\ ^RO AONSMKSN L_]SXO]]& 5K\YX @KWLO\^& Z\Y‘SNON K ]^\K^OQSM
`
`Y‘O\‘SOa YP VO]]YX] ^RK^ 5X^ROW RKN VOK\XON ^R\Y_QR ^RO \OLSN Z\YMO]] SX ‘K\SY_] ]^K^O] KXN
`
`5X^ROWi] Y‘O\KVV ]^\K^OQc ^Y \O^KSX KXN Q\Ya S^] AONSMKSN L_]SXO]]( 5WYXQ Y^RO\ SXPY\WK^SYX&
`
`@KWLO\^ Z\O]OX^ON RS] ^OKWi] KXKVc]S] YP aRK^ RKN aY\UON aOVV KXN RKN XY^ aY\UON aOVV SX Y^RO\
`
`LSN]& Y_^VSXON 5X^ROWi] ]^\K^OQc PY\ ]_LWS^^SXQ ]_MMO]]P_V LSN]& SNOX^SPSON QKZ] Y\ ‘_VXO\KLSVS^SO]
`
`^RK^ 5X^ROW PKMO] SX LSN] KXN 5X^ROWi] ]^\K^OQc PY\ MVY]SXQ ^RO QKZ]& KXN& YP ZK\^SM_VK\ \OVO‘KXMO
`
`^Y ^RO Z\YM_\OWOX^ Z\YMO]] SX =YaK KXN BOL\K]UK& Z\Y‘SNON KX Y‘O\‘SOa YP 5X^ROWi] KZZ\YKMR ^Y
`
`ROKV^R O[_S^c S]]_O] SX \_\KV ZYZ_VK^SYX]( GRO SXPY\WK^SYX ^RK^ @KWLO\^ Z\Y‘SNON SX ^RS]
`
`Z\O]OX^K^SYX aK] XY^RSXQ ]RY\^ YP 5X^ROWi] ZVKcLYYU PY\ =YaK KXN Y^RO\ AONSMKSN A7C MYX^\KM^
`
`LSN] KXN S] Z\OMS]OVc ^RO SXPY\WK^SYX ^RK^ K MYWZO^S^Y\ VSUO 7K\OFY_\MO MY_VN _]O ^Y QKSX K
`
`MYWZO^S^S‘O KN‘KX^KQO Y‘O\ 5X^ROW SX ^RO Z\YM_\OWOX^ Z\YMO]] KXN ^Y Z\OZK\O K WY\O OPPOM^S‘O
`
`KXN MYWZOVVSXQ \O]ZYX]O ^Y ^RO =YaK \OLSN(
`
`/2( AY\OY‘O\& Y‘O\ ^RO XOb^ ]O‘O\KV aOOU]& DSZO\ PY\aK\NON K X_WLO\ YP 5X^ROW
`
`NYM_WOX^] ^Y RSW]OVP& SXMV_NSXQ MYXPSNOX^SKV KXN Z\YZ\SO^K\c SXPY\WK^SYX ^RK^ aY_VN LO Ob^\OWOVc
`
`ROVZP_V SX Z\OZK\SXQ K \O]ZYX]O ^Y ^RO =YaK \OLSN