FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 P l
`
`
`NYSCEF 30c. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`
`
`
`154599/20;
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`\D‘X NO-
`11/07/20:.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`R«c« V«3 VYSCEF:
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT FF
`EXHIBIT FF
`
`

`

`
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/15/2015 12:56 PMFILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12-2015 (02:53 P l
`NYSC 3F DOC. NO. 269
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 149NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`IND
`EX NO.
`154599/2013
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`
` VYSC
`
` *uIV‘ .D
` 3F:
`
`12/m5/2015
`
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/15/2015RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`

`Mtpt'rrisor:
`
`
`
`I tnplo) cc:
`
`
`
`’2'
`
`r
`
`f
`
`I'
`
`I
`'
`f/
`{"1 7);"
`
`,
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK
`INDEX N0. 154599/2013
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 9M
`
`
`
`
`
`nIVnD nYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`zva‘itcsf
`ON TE’IE JOB “VJ U [{Y F RM Report Bate:
`:
`.1"
`‘ cu York Cit) Transit ‘
`‘
`'xi!
`fl l H ‘l‘l:
`Department must call in employee injury within 24 hours ol'injury. (1-888-682—4301)
`z mplm t'e & Supervisor:
`Complete this form upon occurrence of injury or recurrence of injury on duty
`and make three {3) photocopies.
`Complete the Department Section on front side of form, Employee‘s Section if applicable, and
`Investigation Form on reverse side. FAX BOTH SIDES OF FORM TO Workers‘
`Compensation l?nit 718-694-3281/‘3807 and to System Safety (646) 252-5793. Send Original
`within two business days to Workers’ Comp. l30 Livingston Street, 10'“ floor. Send copy to the Dept.
`Injury Reporting Unit; and keep 1 copy.
`Complete Employee Section and Differential Application on front side of this report and keep 1 copy.
`
`
`S’I‘IONS AND BOTH SIDE}? H: FERN]
`I’LEAS F. i’illi‘i’l' — FULLY ANSWER A LL Q1}
`UNION AFI‘TLIA'TIQN:
`1
`“3" ’l
`M'I‘A-NYCTfl
`MABSTOA U
`_
`.-
`_
`.
`_i \_i_i_'_! 0“" l‘: ['73 SEVTIQN til'cutploi'ee is; not available,Super-riaur mm! till out and sign form]
`.
`'
`.
`.
`.
`r ’
`.- ._:
`J
`_
`-
`_
`.-
`.'
`.
`*_
`..
`Jr..._!_
`.
`:
`qt;
`.-.__
`,4.
`
`Incl e-v -
`.
`’
`.
`"'
`l'n'tal
`'
`'
`3i.l.____l‘ar-iil'ayrolltl:
`-
`«our;
`“___‘.soc.hec.#:
`,
`_
`I
`.
`
`lion-r \tllill'xfih'Q Apt. it}:
`.35"
`(_‘J 1
`.t' t'A_--‘:_ -'._5__-_r_ N
`llootc Phonc:1_'_‘:=_‘1'vl
`:-
`’
`'v
`I"
`-,'
`'» 1‘
`”“1““. |iirt|l__-“-___ ._"' __I
`_
`'“V:":JéJ&gE%
`mmm
`fit?
`'-%
`T : LLL14i'
`Miowh__m;-
`
`
`I“! 'f -
`l.
`'1" 'lr'P
`L" 1-1 “‘0
`Title rutlt‘
`
`HI:
`1 lilt'
`_:‘.-_,". _,_____.-D““-' ‘3‘ WWW—L3‘r F .r
`
`i!—
`,
`,_
`Date Supcrt-iaor
`_
`I-h's “aria-1L
`Ilrs Worked
`,
`
`I1. Iil.'l“\ nittuzlfifl-
`_
`Resp. (.‘tr. 8:
`Neath-m; ."
`""-
`t
`J
`_- -Un_\
`iii In}: 5' 5— Prior 1' Bays:_l_7’éf___
`ll!
`
`'_'. r-lllilp} “'ut'li Stains:
`‘
`Recurrence ol‘l’t err injury?
`.
`_
`.‘
`
`No Work:
`.; .-—
`‘r':
`N: v Unknown:
`.
`I"'__LRL‘T€L
`Date of Prior lninry:
`i: (If
`|tDUs__l-__:__.__
`
`'r
`ttr t. HI Horns ftp olr’xp )Vagostllr: :3 f- H r r.
`Work I-lrsruat:
`Sehetluletl Lunch:
`___-____
`Work i-lr5t\\"eck;
`65.9
`l}
`,
`.
`‘
`_
`_
`_
`—
`IJHSCRiBE INJURY
`” /r
`
`
`~
`“it “-Ii‘i'i
`u-
`1",
`I‘J"
`‘i'illlc:_‘1:'__fi'_:-_;_ @t,-_t‘.\-l [L‘r'rct'e om!)
`Dale of Ulnlllt (ifflllfflit‘hhickfl’ffi
`«'-
`Il
`;
`r'
`
`
`
`i nraiiltll- an iti-thtutintir'Buiiilitfiaj—DcpnI: 1%?
`a;
`l”? 1'
`."__'-_': no}
`.-\rcai'liootlo‘VeI-iclem‘l‘mck
`sci/:1
`Count)
`1- ‘._.
`
`-
`||'-'-= n i re _ion doing uiiEiTinjtt'i'fil or when injury recurred?
`-\
`
`_D-‘w;_l;__-.\}1hll-.
`|_-'LL;_i~:i
`’
`
`{ton on! iniurymposurc irccui".'_ is. ado;-
`.
`': LIP-5 L
`.‘
`—JL__I.
`
`.-'- »'- I~ ':__-,_‘ .- _J ‘ .' " - -' {i ' L r a" it". .- -' . -44 J _g'- : .-'.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`w. [i -‘- c 3'—
`
`\\ La; riiiet‘L‘i or substance direct]; harmed the ctuploycc'.’
`
`
`
`‘-'\ h. «lid injur} occur? I“; II
`r -.:.'
`I. ‘1'.
`rh—E
`-i'
`I ---."\i
`t.
`-L..
`'
`
`1
`.
`e,
`I—..
`..~.-—
`.
`_1.
`
`*\.:u|a-|.linitn'}:[l)'1lt‘ ofinjnt'y .-\:'\'1) part lll_l'lllll}'1
`I 1"“! U ’(Cé
`bid“ Ll
`I'M-L14l \
`”11L-
`t—J-‘I' i‘ '4 L5
`-
`U}: -'-‘
`C—
`
`/
`Received Workers’ Comp. Statement of Rights? \':_
`V:
`ninth-11 i'reatnn-nt Requested“!
`‘1: V V:
`Hut-uni Iniury on Duty. InstructionSheet?
`‘1":
`'35”
`N:
`i'lrcm- be ad\ ised that in the event ol'a last time injur) greater than 30 daist (greater tltnn l5(13)5 l'or DOB employees). lost time relating to the onwthc-
`int: iniur) n ill he designated as leave usage under the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) ifyou are otherwise eligible. This notice does not constitute
`a .\ aix l‘l' of any riuhlflljiat the Transit [\llillllril} has to conjrurcrt the claimed on-thc-job injury.
`
`,.
`It
`3-"
`”-\
`‘1
`"
`9‘
`"‘
`‘
`t.
`l mploycr Signaltit'e:__ :yj’f—v{IE--- _ —rJ___II_I‘.I__:--'ii'£‘_lr:/MA/_lf]
`Date:
`“
`J
`"
`I
`'
`‘ SHIN. Signaturc:__ , __.
`__
`,
`.
`
`(if employee fails to sign)
`
`-
`
`1
`
`[)1 l;~l".li-.lll'-_i‘f‘l l.-\ l, Al’l’l .l('.')\Tl()\‘
`s mptou u: must sign Differential Application to begin processing. Signature dot-s not denote agreement with Supervisor‘s Report nor “orkers'
`( ontpenmliuu determinations ofcligihiiit}.
`t omit-Htand that. ill making this application for Differential [lenciiL l have agreed that the Authority may seek to recoup the Value ol
`lltllt‘l‘clliitll Benefits paid from any indgntcnt or settlement ol'an action algttinSI third particsl lll:|}‘ institute as a result of this injury.
`I in = cl») apply for payment tii‘tlilTi-Et'itlittl _-
`.
`.
`‘
`.
`“t
`L‘l
`~3-
`{all
`I
`til]1ltl_\t‘t"§ Name (please priory: 1L3;
`-
`-
`if Ht‘ilplnyee‘s Signature:
`I _': L- (- '___h!"“'1i"":‘l.’_.'_.nme_ ;
`
`-. .
`__ ___
`
`
`I
`
`I
`
`;
`_ i
`
`' 1.5" I
`'I‘ELEPHONIC CONTROL #4“; '
`DATEREPORFN)MACFORDRUGMLCOHOLTESHNGL___‘L_#__J_F_”_
`RULE COMPLIANCE: At time of injury was employee:
`:
`Y: N"
`W as ioinr) olnertctl'J:
`
`Performing assigned duties?
`link:
`Y: \/ 1V:
`ll .‘"‘- um it i0!) relatetl'I:
`
`‘
`I r t
`i L
`Dalc httlppt'tl uork:
`Upwfitwe}
`I
`I
`Return to work date:
`Hm.- iniured returned to “orig? YW W :N:_\*_
`N: )5 ll'yes. employee must complete Waiver S: Election Form.
`\\ \I\'l-‘.R & ELEPI‘iOHN RIEQl'le‘.S’J‘1-§l): Y:
`'
`A
`-
`9‘. ft:
`.
`1‘95 ""L“?
`'
`.
`-
`,.
`..
`'
`1' “-..
`Edu'h'fi‘
`Supt-Himt‘ lewELf—LI
`r‘: agt%5;__:f:_5lmh Wilillilil’vxfi-
`.4.
`-'
`-.
`'-
`"
`”a"?
`“I
`1"
`"
`if
`-"
`4'”
`
`Pl"'""..__._...’f 1
`
`
`l_‘IlCl’ \R'I‘MEN'l‘ Si‘X'TlUN
`
`i
`
`'il't'tlvt‘ 3".3E'lil‘i'
`
`r-
`
`'
`
`“LN:—
`
`.
`.,
`...__.. _-
`
`'
`
`--V-
`_“1 ’
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 P l
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`.
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`154599/2013
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX N0-
`
`
`
`
`
`RNCNIVND \IYSCEF:
`11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`I. ;\' THE JOB INJURY [NV ESTIGATION FORMI
`PASS max-1111112: ‘5
`111151'0N515
`INJURED EMi‘LOYEE NAME:
`.
`—
`_I_I J9
`.
`1\.11RN INFORMA'I'ION
`I
`
`11511111: _Z: 1111) “1'- "‘
`111m ..-\1111<1-'.N-1)1',11111) _mw'L .1
`1-‘1115'111'1'1j111';1N.11.'1w31‘1'\11-::M»
`1.111
`\ .N‘1i('1,$REDHMMEDIATE HAZARD LL]\II\I\11D El)cs'1‘imc.
`0‘5" Whv.”.12..
`'
`‘ZNTG "N AWAY11111N11111111~N111 \‘v’I-{EREWAS 1'1‘131er" mm 111':
`.11-».
`.
`.
`_
`._
`11
`1111
`\'I‘1\
`
`
`‘(
`2*
`"21.1"
`...1_i
`’-< ~
`C11_N"’_I'
`511111: Ny_.i{1|i(.odc
`1’ (“3; ‘1 r
`\l)1)Ri;SS;
`
`$176115
`11133111111111.1121) ovmmam?
`Dyes
`1:11111
`11:1
`\11 DIN 11.11121:
`‘. \,\II{1)|-‘ PHYSICIAN OR OTHER IIEAI TH C'ARE PROFESSIONAL:_
`
`__
`
`_ _
`
`_ _
`
`\1 'l‘-I’l1\‘Dl1\'G
`1
`-.
`11 1 151135 l1\’l"0R:\-1ATION
`11m.- ?.I;'I1}___D1111 W11).
`1\11 111 1>1-:\,11'11m11:1N'1‘1-:1<\-'11-:w1:1):j€f11:
`
`11:1 |’\$S N12N1I111211. 1013 1111.1:01- .~\1.1.\N'1'1'N1:ssr-;s;
`
`_
`
`_
`
`_ DA'IEINTERVIEWED:_ if:
`' _
`1
`~'
`'
`DATE IN"I'ER\"IIZ\V’ED:__ ‘7
`"cf '
`'
`
`IN.“ I“ S—(FTNI'I l.‘«IOR\1-\IIO1\
`I
`I
`)1
`\ I ION [3131.] AIL: Twin
`\\(nk/pzisscngcr/olhcr
`Hm gumscngcrimhcr
`r_II|!115.‘-=_
`""~'._ .—"-'t_-:-.JT" _
`IT?"- —-L—‘_"—.
`,-1II1 1‘1
`( I1 iI\.\I’II IAKIEN. I311»..- Dnn 1.1"IiI\.‘ _
`'1 [\IE ()I' INIL2RY 5" I.;\'E-'
`
`
`P.___w___Y11r11_____'l'¢>\i-'c1
`Truck .‘s'
`SLZIIIOII____5IIOPI__V_ __
`SIquII
`Vehicic .=-‘
`__
`IDCp01_____"_____‘iluicmnm =__
`
`
`-_ J: '3"
`_
`-—
`.3
`__
`__ .. __3KI€’I(‘II!\'IA1')I'~'.:Dyes Wm)
`\\-'|1_\".’_ I
`.. t:—
`
`.'".-‘.‘_"'-"€.'">
`
`_
`
`"TA- .
`
`I
`
`
`WIIA'I'III'R: Clclmu Helmldy 1211-11111 Dsmm Bother
`l IUIII'IN’I' (WMIJIIIUNB: Elwin! Elpnm [31.11th
`
`_
`5111‘: 1 II RAI.
`|.'| IlMl.N'I‘i (lnilc'111 Iiiiur. chippcdslnir. unissing hundiuii clc )flgmd Upoor Detail:
`I 13th _.J'J _IIgfi-g- f _Ol111:mg;.1_a_ 5m; :~9__}t.._r. 5:.»- :._.--,_
`11111 1.11.11151-L1'1N111 1211511011 :Isflmm- 1J.1..11-§11_Lr‘15_€:_
`\AMI'. Iincludc Idcnliliculimi number ii".1pplicnblc1_
`.. :11 dd €'
`1 ‘
`__
`(ONDI'lIONtmuntl Upoor ()'I'lI|-CR:__
`I (Ill til’X-IILNT'MACI'[IN t“ IOOL INVOLVED
`
`\\.N1.N SIS
`1' I-’ ()I'I.l'Z/PROC‘I'CDURI'ZS
`
`[31111
`
`IA
`
`[1110
`FUI I.()\’I"l'.[,'): 3ch5
`($912;
`I'UI II Yz‘I’RUL'I'fINéilli Al’l’l |(_'1\I‘II.I‘.
`(_‘UMI’LI'I'I'IEDZ Dyes W11
`III “NI-VINO INI10UIRI'D: Dyes film I
`1’1 RSUNAI
`I’RIJ'II'LCIIV’F ICI'.)UII’I\'II'1N'I REQUIRI'II): Eyes U110
`IN USE: Elves D110
`’
`l
`MINI )I HUN ()1: I’I’Ii: [figmd Clpuur
`I)ul:IIII_3LL‘L1_)_ “Imf'; 1
`4.Ti31'l:.13_‘1_§
`()'|'III".R:
`1111 Il’.\ll".1'\"l
`l
`\‘ I l RI'I: DNus
`£51110 (Aleli HI' IA“ URI-'.:
`IMI’ROI‘IZR OVER/NINJN:
`LACK OFMAIN'I'IENANCIE:
`\l \( MINI-111001 15 SIC D'LORRI.(['I. Y: DINcN Bin)
`INSPIEC'IION REQUIRILI): Elves Din)
`LAS'I'INSI’i'CC'I'ION:
`\ \I 1 lil .\l<l).\' IxI-'()1? IRII): Dycs
`E1110
`IN PLACE: Uycs
`Elm)
`IN USE: DINcs Dim
`\I \I‘IIRIAI.
`I ___ (‘1)NI‘ACI'VL'I'I'II_:I “5'1
`.__
`1\I‘11\‘I-'1)'1'11:_‘._"II/31
`\' \I- 1 (il ARIIS RI 1_11.’-'II<I.11) [has D110
`IN PLACE: U51» Elna
`I'I\\ IROiViVII'ZN'I‘
`
`USED C'(')RRI'{("I'I.Y: D51». Elna
`IN 15317.: Dyes
`D1111
`
`
`
`,/
`OTHER: V
`
`_
`
`131111
`('01.!) RIiL/N'I‘I'Il): Dyes
`{81111
`II] .\ |' l{l"1..t\'i'lil): I:I_\C>;
`\ \I-’l GUARDS RI-QUIRI'II): DIN'L'N EInn
`IN Pl..ACl€1D}-cs
`\ I IS( '1’.” .ANECIL‘S CONTRIBUTING I‘AFI'ORS
`()1 IEI'R [jNII’LL'JYI-CIiSLHfl;
`-‘ __ INJURED EMPLOYEE DISTRACTED:
`
`ROOI (\USF. OI‘ INJUR)'(WI1\ did iniuIIN'Janwsnic occur2’)
`73$? .C'i_I.:‘r“~Eé'~__.__ l.r,-_=;f_:______Jy<-f_'1-I__
`RI ( ()MMIC NDATIONS
`
`_
`01111111: Chcs D110
`Elm)
`IN |."i'I'.' DIN-:5 Chm
`
`__ __m_~_
`
`.
`
`y, : _A_____DRUOIAL.('OIIOL ”.5 ’ I, __()T.H[R'.__
`
`./:-'
`f -.
`_-
`
`‘I‘{'-'I"_"
`[5"ch ‘_('f’.:f"‘b'.‘.
`1,161,
`
`
`\( I'l(>5\ l’l.AN TO PREV‘FN'I RICCURRE\(l‘. (\V11.11 can he done to prevent another similar“_'1Imim'1''1
`
`
`CH“. .-'...:_..
`;_'}1';\I.1.
`(W LIL»: '7 ";__ 2.1.1.1.
`_1_1_1‘.5.1»...
`..
`_1-1'1v-
`‘
`
`\( III)\ [’I..\;\' IMPI. 1'1Ml'...\"'li'.' I): Chas
`D1111
`I,)/\I|"'
`_______
`( \II’I I”IIH): Uxus
`(1)\li\ll ;\'l('2,'\I‘Iil) I'll-"bll'ISANDREC()1ViMI.NI)A'I‘IONS
`l \II’I ()‘1’l:li5:U_\cs U110
`l'JA'J Ii:___I
`
`O'IIIIiR DIVISIONS: Dyes
`
`[Inn
`
`DA'I'IL:
`
`[3111i
`
`IM'I Ii:
`
`(.‘licck (his Imx —v D‘— iIIlic employee independently and voluntarily rcqiicsls that his 111' her mum: no! he entered
`ll LXI-SS (RSI-ls ONLY:
`111 1111-1112,. ”checked. from as n priN':'n_\' 1011113111 case.
`('
`7 '
`5
`11"
`_
`;
`.-'
`_
`J"
`II
`.
`_’
`m 151111—1101: N1\1\Ili:_/I_\?)CUH- 1;..11'1...
`S_IGN.\TLRI/z/(3-1»?0‘: 9*...1’ASSvaJ. ?
`{I’ILL'IIN‘L‘ [111111)
`’.:.
`1m 1111»: ;\.I\N,\(
`1 NAME:
`_.-'-_1—_ ""1.:‘ugx 1;» L
`.
`" SIGNATURE: 1.5.3".
`" 1': .__.r'
`IIPlcuscpzinn
`}
`fl
`_
`,
`_
`.~-
`, 5
`I .1
`/“L
`,1}
`..,
`,'
`1
`'
`~———
`REV: 5125.107 -_____ PIIONM 4": -3 id ' : 1 ”f 7 ,f
`
`
`
`1 110.111 c 3.52009
`
`
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 PM
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX NO- 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`
`RfiCfiIVfiD VYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`.
`NEW YORK ClTY TRANSIT
`ON THE JOB INJURY MANAGEMENT FOLLOW-UP FORM
`n'
`'
`.‘.
`-
`‘
`
`
`Manager Name: E~J'_-._.dr":ft..
`.-'. ‘
`It-i
`I-
`“
`Employee Name:
`LLLLt
`1&617:;_;Hv_iLli,
`
`t—1 {—7
`this»
`Title:
`in»;
`*
`-
`I -
`Titie._
`
`Dass Number:
`if Ptffijfir
`Pass Number:
`r‘rL? to ‘3
`
`Department/Division: .R rig-Hf;
`fir—LL
`rim.“
`Department/Division: twin-Sufi; .92..
`-_-
`‘v"
`
`' "i r! ‘r'
`Division RC:
`-
`Work Location:
`:7,
`ru-J
`__
`
`_‘zfii‘Z 1‘ng: - FF"? 6‘“
`Teiephone.
`
`Date of injury:
`__Trl “
`l7-
`,-
`Descnption of injury
`C LL14“ _Lh
`r- __. gnu ,
`t_,LL__
`_ L
`L
`~ r';_
`
`
`___ A-.._:'~.’!J_'_II_:_-'
`xiv/Ha" -111.-'+__::‘_ru_+‘«__
`‘
`_LL‘.
`*
`J‘ v7;
`x..._’ L_‘-’ '._’
`-
`.J'
`1'
`r
` .- "'4.
`
`
`V
`
`Action Taken.
`_‘Li Emergency Room 1:] Personal Physician
`
`Hospital: 11,-ei-lev’txfi-
`ri.::iI-.?:T£{
`Name:
`__
`
`511;; _}L§'—_tj€.i's
`_
`Address:
`Address:
`
`ré'j"
`: A4
`\1'
`
`"
`'
`‘
`Telephone:
`Telephone:
`
`Physician:
`:3 Medical Assessment Center (MAC), or
`Other, explain:
`
`'2? independent Medical Examiner (IME)
`
`Location:
`
`
`
`
`
`Physician:
`Telephone:
`
`Employee condition:
`
`6‘ 1.3 P-I'G
`
`
`
`
`=2] Non- work related condition identified. explain:
`
`
`Can employee work the following day?
`- 3/0 L. -_L,
`If No. when can employee return to work?
`It return date is unknown. when is employee's next evaluation?
`
`:1
`
`El Yes
`
`E No
`
`do L» :Lua
`
`Cl Contact day of employee:
`Ell Full duty: perform routine tasks
`{3 Restricted. explain: ___.__._____——————————————--m——"—‘——“—“
`
`
`
`
`El Restricted work available
`Cl Restricted work unavailable
`CJ Return to full work
`Date:
`
`Cl Employee failed to report to full work
`Date:
`
`.
`ClEmployee‘ failed to keep MAC/lME visit
`Date:
`,- .
`-
`.'-l'
`I
`'
`I
`1|;- (.
`
`Manager's Signature #5}; (“ii-"effigy ‘22..
`r
`.
`
`__
`
`w NewYork CityTransit
`
`Date
`
`— 2 — 22L
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 P l
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX NO- 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`
`R«C
`«IV«D VYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`Memorandum
`
`MTA
`New York City Transit
`
`Date M
`
`Manhattan and Bronx
`Surface Transit
`Operating Authority
`
`To
`
`74MNIB/i;(9.23 bait/YLIEA-Jm. 14'
`
`__
`
`From
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`SiGNATURE
`se-smms ovoe
`
`APPROVED
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 PM
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX NO- 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`RnCnIVnD VYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`® New York City Transit
`
`
`
`Memorandum
`
`Date: 3/2/12
`
`To: B. Venture, G. Supt.
`
`From: A. Danylchuk, Supt.
`
`Re: P. Woitovich Accident
`
`On 3/‘2/ 12 @ approximately 10:50am. I received a call from M18 1, M. Donofrio and he told
`me that P. Woitovich had an accident while inspecting a vent bay at 14th St. He informed me that
`Mr. Woitovich had fallen into the vent bay when the ladder he was descending gave way. He also
`informed me that he had called for emergency services.
`I immediately notified G. Supt. E. Ventura and responded to the scene. Upon arrival at the
`scene, '1 was informed by W. Pisciotta, Supt. ICC, that EMS had just taken Mr. Woitovich to
`Bellevue hosPital, and that W3 1, M. Donofrio had accompanied him.
`1 took photos of the area and interviewed M/S 1, Pollidoro (ICC) who was at the scene when
`the accident occurred. He informed me that a ladder had been placed into the vent bay and when
`Mr. Woitovich began to descend, the ladder slipped away causing Mr. Woitovich to fall. During my
`investigation I noticed that there was oil and grease present ontop of the vent grating as well as in
`the bottom of the vent where the ladder was. (photos attached).
`I then proceeded to Bellevue hospital to meet with Mr. Woitovich and Donofrio. Upon
`arrival, I was informed that Mr. Woitovich had suffered 2 broken heels. I interviewed Mr.
`Woitovich, and filled out the accident forms (attached).
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 PM
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX NO- 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`
`RnCfiIVnD VYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`® New York City Transit
`
`Date: 3/2/12
`
`To: E. Ventura, G. Supt.
`
`From: A. Danylchuk, Supt.
`
`Re: P. 'Woitovich Accident
`
`Who
`
`What
`
`When
`
`Where
`Why
`
`Paul Woitovich, an NUS 1
`DOB ~1 1/11/53
`Weight ~ Approx. 220ibs.
`Good health
`Sick time avaii- Unknown at this time
`Prior accidents- Unknown at this time
`
`Injured both feet when he fell whiie descending a ladder
`
`3/2/12 Approx. 10:30am
`
`Vent bay in front of 235 E. 14th St.
`Ladder slipped from beneath him while descending into bay for an inspection.
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 P l
`
`
`NYSCEF 30c. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`
`
`
`154599/20;
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`
`\D‘X NO-
`11/07/20:.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`R«c« V«3 VYSCEF:
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT GG
`EXHIBIT GG
`
`

`

`
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/13/2016 03:41 PMFILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`
`
`
`
`
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269
`R«.C«.IV«.D NYSCEF: 04/03/2016
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 179NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/13/2016RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK -
`NEW YORK COUNTY
`
`
`
`KATHRYN E. FREED
`PRESENT:
`HON. KATHRYN FREED
`w n,
`L
`.
`,
`PAUL worrovrw,
`
`Justice
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`_ V ‘
`
`PART _2_
`
`INDEX NO.
`
`154599/2013
`
`MOTION DATE
`
`03/11/2016
`
`CITY OF NEW YORK, et al,
`'
`
`Defendants
`
`MOTION SEQ. NO.
`
`004
`
`The following papers, numbered 1 to
`
`,were read on this motion to/for
`
`default
`
`Notice of Motion/Order to Show Cause - Affidavits - Exhibits
`
`_________________________________________ No(s)
`
`1, 2 (A-L)
`
`Answering Affidavits ' Exhib“
`
`............................................................................................. ”0(5)
`
`ReP'Ying ”idem
`Cross Motion
`
`......................................................................................................................... “0(5)
`
`No
`
`Upon the foregoing papers, it is ordered that this motion is
`
`Granted without opposition.
`
`and AAC Management Corp., (“AAC") (collectively
`Defendants 235 East 14m Street Realty LLC (“14In Street"),
`“movants") move, pursuant to CPLR 3212, for an Order granting them summaryjudgment dismissing the Complaint
`and any and all cross-claims asserted against them and for summary judgment on 14‘h Street’s cross claim against
`defendant Trihop 14‘h Street, LLC ("Trihop") for contractual indemnification.
`
`Factual and Procedural Background
`
`The underlying action was brought by Plaintiff, Paul Woitovich, for alleged personal injuries which he sustained while
`performing work below the sidewalk in front of 235 East 14‘" Street, New York, New York while on a ladder inside a
`subway airway shaft on behalf of third-party defendant, New York City Transit Authority (“NYCTA”). Plaintiff served the
`original Summons and Complaint on the City of New York on or about May 16, 2013.
`
`On or about June 10, 2013, Plaintiff served a Supplemental Summons and Amended Complaint naming, inter alia,
`movants herein and defendant Trihop. Plaintiff claimed that he was injured, inter alia, as a result of violations of Labor
`Law sections 240(1) and 241(6) and due to common law negligence.
`Issue wasjoined by movants herein on or about
`July 24, 2013.
`In addition to their answer, movants asserted cross-claims inter alia, against Trihop for contribution,
`common—law indemnification, contractual indemnification and breach of contract forfailure to procure insurance. By
`verified answer dated January 4, 2014, Trihop joined issue and asserted cross—clams inter alia, against movants for
`contribution, common-law indemnification and contractual indemnification.
`
`The instant motion for summary judgment, pursuant to CPLR 3212, dismissing the Complaint and any and all cross-
`claims asserted against movants and forsummaryjudgment on 14m Street's cross-claim against defendant Trihop 14m
`Street, LLC, (“Trihop"), for contractual indemnification was filed on or about November 23, 2015.
`
`Movants note that it is uncontroverted that the sole purpose of the airway shaft is to provide fresh air into NYCTA’s
`154599/20l3 Mot’on No, 004
`‘
`WOlTOVICH, PAUL VS. CITY OF NEW YORK
`
`Page 1 of 3
`
`1 of 3
`1 of 3
`
`

`

`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`F I LED : NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK —1’ ‘
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`NY S gubngv‘ay nggni. Plngtn‘f wgs6rn2jLured when the ladder he was standiliigaogiglig ytflfgmlflnfdgrchfitgnd hJe llefiigi¥ithg 0 l 7
`bottom of the airway shaft, He further testified that, as he was lying on the ground after his fall, he observed grease
`and particles of pancakes on the bottom of the airway shaft. See Exhibit A, plaintiff‘s EBT, at pages 86-87.
`
`Movant 14m Street is the owner of the mixed—use building located at 235 East 14m Street. Movant AAC was mistakenly
`named in the action, and has no relationship to the building. The actual management company forthe subject building,
`is non-party Marin Management Company. See Exhibit D, Hodzic EBT, at p. 14.
`
`Defendant Trihop leased the ground floor of the subject building, where it operated an IHOP restaurant. See Exhibit
`F, Scannapieco EBT, at pp 10, 127-128; and Exhibit G, lease agreement. Scannapieco, the Director of Operations
`for Trihop, testified that, on the day in question, Trihop had placed its garbage over the subway grates that covered
`the airway shaft, See Exhibit F, Scannapieco EBT, at pp. 39, 55-56, 59, 61, 68-69, 94. He further testified that the
`placement of the garbage bags was done under the direction and supervision of Trihop. Id, at pp. 39, 55-56, 59, 61,
`68-69, 94.
`
`Movant, 14‘" Street, also notes that the testimony of its superintendent, Osman Hodzic, is uncontroverted and that
`that he testified that he placed the movant’s residential garbage in front of the adjacent building at 231 East 14m Street
`and that there is no subway grate in front of 231 East ‘I4m Street. Hodzic further testified that he placed the garbage
`there because he was responsible for the residential garbage at that building. See Exhibit D, Hodzic EBT, at pp. 25-26,
`30, 63-64.
`
`Finally, with respect to indemnification, 14'“ Street cites section 11.03 of the lease agreement, between itself and
`Trihop, which requires Trihop, as tenant, to indemnify 14‘" Street, as landlord, for“all claims, actions, damages, liability,
`cost and expenses, including attorney’s fees, in connection with all losses, including loss of life, personal injury and/or
`damage to property...occasioned wholly or in part by any act or omission of Tenant..." See Exhibit F.
`
`Plaintiff and co-defendants, including named co-defendant herein, Trihop, do not oppose the motion despite being
`served with the same. After a review of the papers presented, all relevant statutes and case law, this Court grants
`the motion.
`
`Movants’ Position
`
`Movants assert that they are entitled to summary judg ment dismissing the complaint and all cross claims against them.
`First, they argue that they are not subject to liability pursuant to Labor Law sections 240(1) or 241 (6) because they are
`not owners or contractors, They further assert that they owed no common law duty of care to plaintiff because the City
`of New York owned the airway shaft where plaintiff was injured. Upon dismissal of all direct claims against them, argue
`movants, they are entitled to the dismissal of all cross claims against them, Finally, 14‘" Street urges that it is entitled
`to summaryjudgment on its claim for contractual indemnification against Trihop.
`
`Conclusions of Law:
`
`Labor Law section 240(1) imposes liability on premises owners and contractors for certain elevation-related risks and
`the failure to provide adequate safety devices to protect against the same. See Keenan v Simon Properties Group, Inc,
`106 AD3d 586 (15‘ Dept 2013). Labor Law section 241(6) imposes a nondelegable duty on owners and contractors
`to provide reasonable and adequate safety to workers. See Ross v Curtis-Palmer Hydro-Elect Co., 81 NY2d 494
`(1993). Here, movants established prima facie that they were not owners pursuant to Labor Law sections 240(1) and
`241(6), See Matter of91Si St. Crane Collapse Litig., 112 AD3d 477 (1S1 Dept 201 3); Grilikhes v International Tile & Stone
`Show Expos, 90 AD3d 480 (1 5‘ Dept 201 1 ). Further, they established that they did not contract for the work performed
`by plaintiff, as the NYCTA was undertaking the project. See Ex. A, Plaintiffs EBT, at 28, 35; Ex. L, Wisell Aff., at par.
`6, See Chang Zhang Zou v 122 Dev., LLC, 103 AD3d 519 (15‘ Dept 2013).
`
`Movants established their prima facie entitlement to the dismissal of plaintiffs claim pursuant to Labor Law section 200,
`which sets forth a landowner’s common law duty to provide a safe place to work, since they showed that they '
`“exercisejdj no supervisory control over the operation" in which plaintiff was allegedly injured. Yong Ju Kim v Herbert
`Constr. Co., 275 AD2d 709, 712 (2d Dept 2000). Specifically, Hodzic testified that he placed the garbage for 235 East
`14th Street in front of 231 East 14'“ Street in an area where there was no subway grate. See Ex. D, Hodzic EBT, at 25-
`26, 30, 6354. Further, the City was the “undisputed owner" of the airway shaft where the alleged incident occurred.
`See Ex, K, Wisell Aff., at par. 2; Ex. B, Rodriguez EBT, at 19-21, 24; Ex. C, lease.
`
`Given their freedom from any negligence in this matter, movants are entitled to summary judgment dismissing the
`cross claims against them for contribution and common-law indemnification. See McLaughlin vAnn-GurRea/ty Corp,
`107 AD3d 469 (1‘I Dept 2013); Stallone v Plaza Constr. Corp, 95 AD3d 633 (1“ Dept. 2012),
`Page 2 of 3
`2
`1545990013 Motion No. 004
`2 of 3
`
`O f 3
`WOITOVICH, PAUL vs. CITY OF NEW YORK
`
`
`
`

`

` F ILED : NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 1 ‘ W“
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`"
`'3‘
`'9 '
`
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`NYSQOE erngeszlaimlqugainsg r§IoLvants for contractual indemnificatiolfizgngg Eyotsgusgg §I9c§§1ére 9511:? (QJZtl/agt 0 l 7
`pursuant to which they agreed to indemnify any other party-to this action. See Hughey v RHM-88, LLC, 77 ADsd 520
`(1“ Dept 2010),
`
`Finally,14m Street has established its prima facie entitlement to summary judgment on its claim seeking contractual
`indemnification from Trihop. As noted above, the lease between Trihop, as tenant, required it to indemnify 14"‘ Street,
`as landlord, for any damages, including costs, expenses, and attorneys‘ fees, arising from any act or omission by
`Trihop. See Exhibit F. Thus, the intention of the parties is clearly implied from the agreement. See Torres v LPE Land
`Dev. & Constr., Inc., 54 AD3d 668, 670 (2d Dept 2008). Scannapieco, the Director of Operations for Trihop, testified
`that, on the day in question, Trihop had placed its garbage over the subway grates that covered the ain/vay shaft. See
`Exhibit F, Scannapieco EBT, at pp. 39, 5556, 59, 61 , 68-69, 94. He further testified that the placement of the garbage
`bags was done under the direction and supervision of Trihop. Id., at pp. 39, 55-56, 59, 61, 68—69, 94. Since 14m Street
`proved itself free from any wrongdoing, it is entitled to summary judgment awarding it costs and attorneys‘ fees on its
`claim for contractual indemnification against Trihop. Cf., Cave Constr. CO, Inc. v Gealtec Remodeling Corp, 58 ADad
`660 (2d Dept 2009).
`
`Therefore, in accordance with the foregoing, it is hereby:
`
`ORDERED that the branch of the motion for summaryjudgment by defendants 235 East 14m Street Realty LLC and
`AAC Management Corp. seeking dismissal of the complaint and all cross claims asserted against them is granted,
`without opposition, and the complaint and all cross claims are dismissed against those defendants, with costs and
`disbursements to the movants as taxed by the Clerk upon the submission of an appropriate bill of costs; and it is
`further;
`
`ORDERED that the branch Of the motion which seeks an order granting defendant 235 East 14‘h Street Realty LLC
`summary judgment on its claim for contractual indemnification against defendant Trihop 14m Street LLC is granted,
`without opposition; and it is further,
`
`ORDERED that the issue of the amount of 235 East 14‘h Street Realty LLC’s costs, disbursements and attorneys' fees
`it is owed by Trihop 14m Street LLC is referred to a Special Referee to hear and report with recommendations, except
`that, in the event of and upon the filing of a stipulation of the parties, as permitted by CPLR 4317, the Special Referee,
`or another person designated by the parties to serve as referee, shall determine the aforesaid issue; and it is further,
`
`ORDERED that counsel for movants shall, within 30 days of the date of this order, serve a copy of this order with notice
`of entry, together with a completed information sheet, upon the Special Referee Clerk in the Motion Support Office,
`Room 119, 60 Centre Street, who is directed to place this matter on the calendar of the Special Referee‘s Part (Part
`50R) for the earliest convenient date; and it is further,
`
`ORDERED that this constitutes the decision and order of this Court.
`
`DATED:
`
`4I7l2016
`APR - 7 2015
`
`:
`1. CHECK ONE
`2. CHECK As APPROPRIATE:
`3. CHECK IF APPROPRIATE:
`
`MOTION Is:
`
`154599/2013 Motion No. 004
`WOITOVICH. PAUL VS. CITY OF NEW YORK
`
`HON.
`_
`_
`_~5fi;
`
`JUSTICE 0F SUPREI» COUIQFHRYN E. FREED, J.S.C.
`
`NON-FINAL DISPOSITION
`E] CASE DISPOSED
`GRANTED DDENIED [:I GRANTED IN PART
`|:|OTHER
`[:| SETTLE ORDER
`E] SUBMIT ORDER
`|:| Do NOT POST
`[:| FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT |:| REFERENCE
`Page 3 of 3
`3
`f 3
`O
`3 of 3
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 P l
`
`
`NYSCEF 30c. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`
`
`
`154599/20;
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`
`\D‘X NO-
`11/07/20:.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`R«c« V«3 VYSCEF:
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT HH
`EXHIBIT HH
`
`

`

`
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/28/2016 06:33 PMFILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK lib-2018 05:83 P l
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 288
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 188NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`
`INDEX NO- 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`R«.C«.IV«.D \IYSCEF: 101/88/2016
`
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/28/2016RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`
`
`SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF N W YORK
`
`NEW YORK COUNTY
`
`PRESENT:
`
`HON. KATHRYNFREED
`mSIICEOF SUPREMECOURT
`
`r______________
`
`'
`
`Index Number : 154599/2013
`WOITOVICH, PAUL
`VS
`
`
`
`
`
`
`CITY OF NEW YORK
`
`Sequence Number: 001
`DEFAULT JUDGMENT
`
`PARTA
`
`INDEX No_
`
`MOTION DATE
`MOTION SEQ. NO. QQL
`
`The following papers, numbered 1 to __ , were read on this motion tolfor
`
`Notice of Motion/Order to Show Cause — Affidavits — Exhibits
`
`Answering Affidavits — Exhibits
`
`Replying Affidavits
`
`Upon the foregoing papers, it is ordered that this motion is
`
`I No(s).
`
`I No(s).
`
`I No(s).
`
`DECIS‘ED I?! ACQQTDTQE WITH
`ACCOZ‘TIPANYENG DECISION I ORDER
`
`
`
`MOTION/CASEISRESPECTFULLYREFERREDTOJUSTICE
`
`
`
`FORTHEFOLLOWINGREASONS):
`
`Dated:
`
`IO - ail“ [Q
`OCT 2 o 2015
`
`1. CHECK ONE: .....................................................................
`
`
`
`:1 CASE DISPOSED
`
`,J.S.C.
`A
`'
`msnce 0F SUPREME COURT
`
`E NON-FINAL DISPOSITION
`
`2. CHECK As APPROPRIATE: ...........................MOTION IS: 3 GRANTED
`
`[B DENIED
`
`C] GRANTED IN PART
`
`[:1 OTHER
`
`3. CHECK IF APPROPRIATE: ................................................ D SETTLE ORDER
`
`E] SUBMIT ORDER
`
`[:1 DO NOT POST
`
`D FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT D REFERENCE
`
`lof 12
`1 of 12
`
`
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 PM
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`INDEX NO~ 154599/2013
`
`
`
`
`
`R«.C«.IV«.D \IYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/07/2017
`
`
`
`SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
`
`COUNTY OF NEW YORK: PART 2
`_______________________________________________________________________X
`
`PAUL WOITOVICH,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`-against-
`
`ORDER AND DECISION
`Index No. 154599/13
`
`Seq. Nos. 001 and 005
`
`THE CITY OF NEW YORK, INTERNATIONAL
`HOUSE OF PANCAKES, LLC, TRIHOP 14‘h
`STREET LLC, 235 EAST 14‘h STREET REALTY
`SERVICES INC. and RESTAURANT
`
`TECHNOLOGIES, INC,
`
`Defendant.
`______________________________________________________________________ x
`
`HON. KATHRYN E. FREED:
`
`RECITATION, AS REQUIRED BY CPLR 2219 (a), OF THE PAPERS CONSIDERED IN THE REVIEW OF
`THIS MOTION.
`
`MOT. SEQ. NO. 001
`
`PAPERS
`
`NOTICE OF MOTION AND AFFIDAVIT ANNEXED
`AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION
`REPLY AFFIRMATION
`
`MOT. SEQ. NO. 005
`
`NUMBERED
`
`1-2 (Exs. A-P)
`3 (Ex. A)
`4
`
`NOTICE OF MOTION AND AFFIDAVIT ANNEXED
`AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION
`
`1-2 (Exs. A-J)
`3 (Ex. A)
`
`UPON THE FOREGOING CITED PAPERS, THIS DECISION/ORDER ON THE MOTION IS AS FOLLOWS:
`
`This order resolves motion sequence numbers 001 and 005.
`
`In this personal
`
`injury action, plaintiff Paul Woitovich moves (motion sequence 001),
`
`pursuant to CPLR 3212, for partial summaryjudgment as to liability on his claims against defendant
`
`the City ofNew York (“the City”) pursuant to Labor Law §§ 240(1) and 241(6). The City moves
`
`20f 12
`2 of 12
`
`
`
`

`

`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/07/2017 01:03 PM
`FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11m2017 01:03 PM
`
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`NYSCEF DOC. NO. 261
`
`INDEX NO. 154599/2013
`IN