.
`
`" ‘ff. REFl;EREAN C.E (EOEYING
`S PE__ClAALlNST_RUCTIQ.NS
`
`%
`
`k '1
`
`‘
`
` LiXPPLiC_3A.‘fI()_.'f\3.f«§ERi‘Al7'NUMBER
`
`9"?4/7"‘-7£.‘?C$0 ‘
`.‘\'
`
`- J?
`
`, %.
`
`’ :izum3‘_z~:R-dF_‘¢oPLEs-:
`1
`-
`J
`'-
`‘
`'
`.
`
`.,.
`
`rsténdérd copy‘ proaqctgbfi-rorxéguxér appafcazibns is '
`_2oopies;—.for‘ APQ‘l7_‘applica(ions.i(‘is« 4 copies; jif-
`I gddiliodal Cdpi_e'S' are (equired. please note 6e!dw_ '
`
`. _.
`
`'
`
`'—
`
`‘b:}zLw_' «_:_>r~'re- cic5'Pi'_ éiEQu1Réo-
`_-
`" .;m:DiT1*d5zAL C0'P I'EVS_l§EQ_UI.REQ
`I
`.
`
`” RefUr§NV6’Rt¢%tNga.L(s;Lwm{.cAsg_ .
`
`_
`
`
`
`101
`
`

`
`ARPLK5AT|ON"ru|0..'
`
`FILING one
`
`v
`
`—‘ FIRSTNAMEDINVENTORV
`
`‘
`
`J “
`
`.;
`
`'
`
`.
`
`‘
`
`'
`I‘.
`
`UNITED’ STATE —_faEPARTME_NT-OF COMMERCE
`Patehtqnd Trademarli 0fli<_:_eI
`A
`"
`V
`‘
`,A'udriass:' COMMISSIONER OF P}\TENTS'ANDTRADEMARKS_ '
`"
`Wgshlngtdn. D.__C.20231
`-
`_
`_
`j ’
`:
`ATTORNEY »noc_KEfN’o.«.-\.
`128.uflt:'7is
`'-
`
`I-.'nj*s«/£11-:5._,c1a__ ‘VI _‘_'1 2'/'2'1../jag:
`
`.'_s1Nn':aH _'
`
`'-
`
`'
`
`;
`
`-
`
`_-
`
`_'
`
`-;
`
`' W_l'1!'J'I.{§f22E=
`_
`-
`_
`'
`_
`-'
`_ L
`'F"HILLIF_'Ei VAN’ SANTEN ::I~_nR+<-'
`wan:-D.
`'se_MtJR"r-zMt~:R"'.' '.
`- Erin 1.vJEST.MAD1.$CIN S‘ITREET"$E_.|ITE asap.
`' c:H'1c_m2o- 1-1.‘ 50551.
`'
`.‘
`'
`-
`.
`2
`"_
`=—.
`..
`
`2
`
`-.-
`
`-
`
`.‘
`
`--w..
`
`«A
`
`--
`
`'
`
`~
`T-2._=_-:<:;‘::-:=
`-_DA_T‘EMAlLED:_'
`
`.
`
`.
`
`_
`
`.PI:edsé:tind‘ bel c'mi and/tor a‘ttapMhed»ah"Ofli¢_e‘ cqmfijfinlcation cbhcernir;:ug' this‘appIiéa!ion or
`Droc6f°dlng.“jf
`'
`»
`»
`‘-
`~
`-"
`.
`H
`.-
`
`_
`
`_
`
`_ Commisslqner oi Pptents hind fiadémarks ‘
`
`.
`
`,
`
`F'1"O-I00-'(fii:I.2.m-if
`'."-q.§.eno:'zum-gIra-aoomeog-
`
`.
`
`,
`
`102
`
`

`
`_
`
`t3fl'r'ce Action Summary" “M
`
`I
`
`‘
`
`-
`
`_
`
`‘
`
`,
`
`j
`
`‘
`
`-'
`
`"l
`y
`
`.
`
`i
`
`i
`
`Appl,icant[s)
`Application No.‘
`SINGH Ei‘_Ai_.'
`'o9}21‘7,4oo
`_ Artunlt
`'-
`Examiner
`_ VincentErKcvalick
`'
`‘gets
`'
`TE of th_is'comrriunicatiar_i appears on the cover sheet with the correspondence address --
`V -- The MA_!LING
`i
`.
`"
`“
`'
`-
`-
`-
`Period for Reply y
`'3 ’
`i
`‘A SHORTENED S"rATUTORY=Pl':;RlOD’FOR REPLY IS SET TO EXPIRE § MONTH(S) FROM
`THE MAJLING DATE OF TH|SvCOMMliJN|CATl'ON'..
`-‘
`.
`_
`-' Extensions of time maybe available under the provisions of 37 Cl5R 1.136 (a).
`In no event, however, may a reply betimely fled
`,
`,‘ alter_SlX (6) MONTHS from the mailing date of this communication.
`-.
`»
`'
`.
`‘
`_
`_
`A -...It the period for reply specified above is less than thirty (30) days, a reply within the statutory minimum of thirty (80) days will
`_
`_
`be considered timely. ;
`'
`_
`_
`.
`7
`'
`.
`‘
`.
`.
`' -
`If No period for reply is specified above, the-maximum statutory period will apply and~will expire SIX (6)_ MONTHS from the rnaiing date of this .
`~
`~
`.commu'nication_.
`‘
`..
`,
`'
`_
`j
`'
`,.
`'-
`-
`_
`- Failure to reply within the set or extended period for reply will, by statute, cause the application to_ become ABANDONED (35 U.S.C. 5 133}.
`Status
`_‘
`»
`v
`‘
`‘l
`5
`"
`‘
`'.
`-_
`_
`V
`'
`-1')|:"‘*Re,.sponsivveto communicationis)fiiedion.
`'"2a)E This action is FINAL.
`*
`f V
`.
`2t_i)l:l This‘ action is non-final.
`3)]: vSin'c‘e this application is incondition forallowance except forformal matters, prosecution as to the rnelils is .
`a
`closed in accordance with the practifie. under Ex parte Quayle, 1935_C.D’. 11, 453 Q.G..213.
`'
`-
`VDisposition_of_claims
`,
`,
`In
`t
`l.
`_
`I
`'
`~
`&
`I
`.
`' 4)|X C|aim(s) ‘.1-'4 a_rid_6-1V6Vis/are pending inthe application,
`' H 4
`. 4a)‘Ofih'e‘ Vabove"c|aim(s)"__~is‘/are wi'th'dravvri from consideration.»-
`5)|: Claim‘(s)lgis/areyallowedi;V‘:
`H
`‘
`J
`'
`"
`6)|: ,Clairn(s)
`is/are rejected."
`i
`_
`V
`V 7)[:_‘C:‘llain1(s).’j is/are objectedto.
`i
`Claims
`aresubject to restriction and/or election requirement.
`_
`I
`Application Papers
`_
`,_
`9)l:_l The specification is objected tobyvxthfie Examiner.
`.
`1
`»
`.10)|j. Ihe'drawing(s) filed on ‘
`is/are objected to by the Examiner.
`_‘ i1)lj: The proposed drawing correction filed on '
`»
`is; -'a)l:I approved b)l:] disapproved.
`' V_ 12)l:l' The oath orudeclaration is objected to by-_'theExaminer.'
`
`'
`
`.
`
`. Priority under-.35 lJ.S.C.§11.9
`_
`13)I] ‘Acknowledgment ismade ofa claim forforeignpiiority under 35 U.S.C. § 119’(a_)-id); I
`V ‘ajlj-All -. b’)l:l‘ some * c)EI_V None of the‘Cl§RTlFlEl5 copies of the priority documents "have. been:
`‘iflj received.
`‘
`.’
`'
`" "
`t
`.“
`'
`"‘
`2._|:l , received in Application No. (Series Code I Serial Number)
`received in this National Stage application from the International Bureau (PCT Rule 1T.2(a)).
`See the attached detailed Qffice actionfor a iist of the certified copies not received. _
`I
`'
`'14)D Acknowledgement is made o'f,a claim for d'omestic‘priority under 35 U.S.C. & 119(3).
`'
`Attachme'nt(s).
`
`I
`
`I
`
`l
`
`y
`
`I
`
`.
`
`.
`
`I
`
`'
`,
`*
`v
`14) D notice of References Cited (PTO-892).
`.15) El tiotice of Qraflsperson's Patent Drawing Review (PTO-948)
`16) D lnformationVDisclosure Statement(s) (PTO-1449) Paper_No(s)
`us. Peténtend Trademark Ema
`,
`_
`PTO-326 (Rev. 398)
`2
`
`-'
`
`‘
`
`'
`
`‘
`..
`
`Interview Summary (PTO-413) Pap-at Nora).
`17) El
`18) D Notice of Informal Patent Application (PTO-152) '
`19) El Other:
`'
`V
`r
`
`.
`
`_
`
`.‘
`
`,
`V
`.__
`y Office Action Summary
`
`'
`
`y
`
`.
`
`_
`' Part of Paper No. 4
`
`-V
`
`103
`
`

`
`i-K'Applic_a-tionJControl Number: 09/211,400 i
`
`An tlnit: éevs
`
`V DETAILED ACTION ~ '
`
`Response to Amendment
`
`I
`
`i
`
`In This Office Aetioh is in response to Applicantifs Amendment dated Decemlaer 22, 2000 in'*"_
`1.
`“response. to PTO Office Action dated September 1', 2000‘ The amendment to c1a.i_in§1_.;;
`I the "H
`
`I
`
`_rei>§/riting of claim‘4 in independent forth;
`
`the cancellatiori ofclaim 5 and.Ap'plica;nt_’s
`
`,,-
`
`__
`
`.
`
`I have beeninotedi and reflected in_ the action set forth hereinbelowt
`
`-
`
`1
`
`'-"App1icant’s"remarks have been fully co_nsidered'but are not oersuaeive.
`
`'1?._ela'tive td I‘
`
`I
`
`App1icant’s remarl<s teaching "‘touch-responsive areas located in a section ofthe screen p3nion- _
`
`1
`-
`Patent No. 5,_4S_5,.l7‘il)
`_ displaying has portion of said orie discrete sub-page”; Henshaw
`te_Zl.Cl16§__‘.‘_‘th.e'fo:11I_‘ corners and-theifour sides ofthe visual representation ofthe controliatea offer
`
`i
`
`icontrolelement areas in the form ofg “buttons” implemented as anycther fimctionial controllareal
`
`I
`
`i
`
`a cursor, touch on a touch screen or the like..”"(c:ol.“ 2, lines 57-61 ;'é.ncl'_Figs.'
`to be Selected
`i"_ EC); ._ Henshaiiv fi.1r_El'ier_ teaches “Butt‘ons‘on‘ the four sides ofthe visuial_represent-aiib_n map
`
`.
`
`‘
`
`I
`
`'
`
`.
`
`'
`
`‘
`
`i
`
`ofthe_lVwri:ii’k_ol5-iect
`. control the horizontal '{Iertical'iniplernental scrolling. ofthe
`displayed Within the worh area window" (col. '2, lines 64-67). I In thattboth the-imageilaeiriig --
`dispilayed and the'buttons controlling the movement ofthe irnage’-(e,g. scrolling) a13e_'hoth'
`I’.
`disolayed. on the same screen (item 2 in Figs. 2A-"2C) it would. ha've'heen lobvioinus toe person of‘ I
`
`:_
`
`V.
`
`_
`
`i
`
`, ordinary skill in the art atvtheltime of
`
`invention that the image representing the buttons‘could '‘
`
`g
`
`_
`
`104
`
`

`
`-.
`
`.5r
`x ’.
`
`"7
`
`iApplicetion/ControlNurnberzoé/217,400“ A
`
`-
`
`Unit": 2573
`
`1
`
`1
`
`i
`
`f"
`
`.:
`
`‘i have been-displayed within the houndaty that definesthe aiea on the 'sci'ee'n ofthe di5'pl§.yed '
`"mega". :-
`t-he dispilay in-
`, _e_gai‘t‘ii11g.A'p'p|ic'am"s‘remi:t_tks relativetoi l_Ienshgiu_not teaehing the tneans
`tnode’5'_‘-/1'-'1_enshew cleaily teitehes the cioiitrot. btittons to initiate scrolling (col. 2, lines v
`iwl-1iC__h initi_at_es_eontrelLmoti_e_and the s.ci“ol7liné moveriient.v_'It‘}ivOu1d"haireibieenylpbvious to
`. __iI1I-petstin.ini"_ordir=tanfy.'s1ii11
`theianiatthe tirne oftheliiiventti-o_‘ri that ifthere ihiiigvinefii inihaving .
`-separrlate a.ction,'one to set the mode: and the's'econ‘d‘t"o :'stairti'the‘movement., it xi/_ovuld hzive i.
`
`V‘
`
`I
`
`I
`
`'* ,
`
`'- ibeeniofiw-ious to do 96.
`
`.
`
`h
`
`t
`
`'
`
`.Clain.1 Rtajeétions '-~35
`
`§ 103
`
`.
`
`_‘
`
`I
`
`I
`
`The3fo]Iovi'iiig isa quotation of35 U.S.C. 1'03i(ii) ‘whieh forms the basis for all obviousness
`I
`_'
`'ri3J'$:ctions.set_f.<_:_rth
`thisibiffice notion: i
`V
`i
`i
`I
`I
`I
`
`‘
`
`(a) A patent _niay not beobtained though the invention is not identically disclosed or described asiset forth in
`‘section 102 of this title, if the differences between the subject inatter sought to be patented gnd the prior a_It:are .
`such that the subject matter us a whole would have been obvious at"the time the invention was'tt'tude to a persoizr '
`-having ordinary skill in the art to which said subject matter pertains. Patentability shall npt be negatived by the _
`manner in whieh the invention was made. _ W
`being unpa.té'1't.t-al]:|)'li°',:'-diver
`l03
`.(-Ilauiiis 6'an.c19-11_are rejecitediundeiii55
`K
`i
`V
`W
`'Hensh§._v;¢:ai.:.'_
`'
`V
`i :1‘.l,e]altiwfe.to c.I‘a.ir_n 6,_ I-ljenshaiiiti et al.>'t.eache_s, a data: storage d'e_v_ice including a‘ 'soreen’p‘o1'tion for
`displajiing la
`a virtual page lgrger then’ saidsei'ee_n portioii vihe_tehy'only_"a‘portion h
`ofthe xfirtufll piigeis-tiisplayeid in said scieen po1jtion;_‘anc:i'virtual‘ tiagelconiplrisinfiia‘}itliLit’a|ity
`--‘dislcretlei Sula-pages (cul_ 3_,‘1ines V15'-:19)", a displayeontrol ‘structure comv'p1is_ing>~:7 at plurality of‘
`
`I
`
`I
`
`.
`
`l__
`
`__
`
`105
`
`

`
`7-
`
`.
`
`I
`
`-_"'AppIication!(i3ont'rol Nnrnber: (59/2i1i7,40(iJ'
`
`'
`
`V
`
`*
`
`p
`
`_
`
`_
`
`'
`
`‘15age_ii'
`
`‘. ‘Art Unit:_ 2673
`
`'
`
`J
`
`-I ‘discrete touch-responsive areas in different sections of said screen portion, each of said touch-
`" respoiisitfe areaslbeing adapted to generatea page signal responsive to being touched—b_y‘a_user
`_'(col.-2, lines 57-6-1 and col. 3, lines 1-6); _a sensor adapted to generate a panning signal '
`responsive to Selective input by a user‘(col. 6, lines 61-65); afirst screen portion displayeontrol
`A.
`' adapted;to' panover the virtual page_responsiVe to a panning signal (col. .2, lines 57-67),
`'
`display a selected part of one discrete ’stib'-palge responsive to a page signal generated in response ‘
`
`i
`
`.
`
`to a user touching one of the discrete touch-‘responsive areas located in a section ofthe screen
`
`portion _displaying a portion of said one discrete subapage (col. 3,; liens 15-19).
`
`The difference between the ‘teaching ofHenshaw et all
`
`thatofthe instant "invention ll. that
`
`__
`
`Henshaw et al. teaches the panningnisignal being initiated by pressing a touch panel arenas
`
`I
`
`opposedto the panningsignal being initiated by a signal generated by a sensor.
`'
`‘ It wonld have been obvious to a‘ person ofordinary skill in the
`at the time ofthe innention __
`-that the signalgenerated by pressing aniarea ofthe touchpanel (a virtiial.button) to generate
`
`I
`
`the signal to" initiate the ‘panning action could be generated several ways including the said signal-
`
`being generated front the output ofvarious types of sensors —
`
`I
`
`1
`
`-Regarding claims -9-1 1, Henshaw et al. teaches the display control structure wher_ein'.- said virtual
`
`_'
`
`' page comprises a plurality
`
`sub-pages with each sub-pagelorientecl side-by-isideltvithiltrleast one
`
`ofthe other ol"the sub-‘pages;
`said screen portion is ‘substantially as large as each"sub'-p_age;_ 'an_d
`eaehisnb-page isalogiqal unit otsaid virtnal page (col. 3,1ir1es 15-19)-.1
`-
`i
`
`'
`
`106
`
`

`
`V‘
`
`.’
`
`. Appticatia'ii/caniro: Nfimber:_o9/g17,4_o'o j
`"Kg:-iJ;:it_:'.'26'J3_
`—‘
`f
`'
`'
`l_
`
`._
`
`A
`'
`
`'
`
`‘
`
`"
`I
`10§(a)>é1s1;<‘:§ng t;n}.3a1“te::'r.;1;2ib1.v,e’_‘:(>\/,c.3rét a1: '
`35
`“ Qlain;
`‘.64.
`_§s_iitapi::}'liés:ff3c1§.jin6ihjtefx;3Ahereinabo§/e,;and ii__»1rt1_1er fl'1’r"1 Vs:»/i’Ac=.i2s/‘ qf_Rei§hrfefi"(iJ .§‘é.._f;§_;§:£it -_ I _
`
`I
`
`L"
`
`'
`
`'7
`
`,
`
`I
`
`‘ "
`
`_.
`
`-
`
`In _‘ _1{‘e]‘:_i.'ti'vt':-tilt‘) claim.7‘, I-I‘énv’s‘h2v1w"et‘a_l.’does noét te‘a._¢l:1 the diéplay éontrol st,r‘11V'c:nturei»2s/.h¢_1jei1'1"the' " '
`':..-gg-,i1.-501: cQrI'1‘§.)l:iS€SI.at
`]'e2:1stvone’orief1tatiofi sqnscsr x11‘c::unted,o'r1tb‘11é:_d§\/icé and-.‘configL.1fédt<b) ‘§‘;en‘s'eK ‘
`7‘ c:}han'ges.iI_i-‘po§i£i_c:r'1 ofthe d¢\i‘i:<:e
`.z’1;1l'efere1}c;e"cobfaingte,'§3;$térfi_'é}nd‘tfansfi1it mottiton/__signa‘l
`‘ 5
`‘V
`,
`:
`L
`I’
`’
`},* "
`‘V~>‘..V
`ilgichlep t§78£‘:|ll'll¢S _'§_a.id 'co;}trVcl>l‘stfu'c:’tL.1.re wh¢reiIv1’.Sé‘1id: s'ex‘1'so.,r'cvcfiylllprisész at'i'E:ast:cifie <$rient'at_id1.1_ ._ , . :
`moufitéd or1'th_é'_device' and conflg_u‘red'to'sense_c1'1angés iii ;§'oSifi'on'6fthé devic¢“ir|Ha —-".
`. ;
`an-:s=:fereriv-_;2LKé_c;1'c>':r<'1in'stt:':_Eygfqm agdvtrfigsfxfif habfifzn ;§ignél.sVind‘icé;tivé'of
`change_s_‘ ((301.
`]_in:=.l's'
`
`'_._
`
`M '
`
`V
`
`I‘
`A"
`
`‘
`
`"
`
`time of;t\he‘.7inv;ent'ioI1.: to E"
`lskilijinithé
`_’ VI.t would h2‘1‘\"/e l_:J.ee,n‘- obvuiciusi a persbn
`‘:in'co'rp_‘ora'te_ inuthlé devi<‘ife-a-as:'t’z{uéh1V: b3-r_II-I‘§r‘1_shav§»§*.‘t‘val. the f‘e,a:tuArAe a$._Vt£'_1ug}1"i‘by Reichlgh
`_
`.
`‘1;a\}i1-ig
`irlnoitionl_se:r1sor‘ip:<>orfi_o.raté<i the device. as’ t§ILight“1).3_.{I{I;¢nshaw ef 51. xéroizldlfi
`‘
`" ‘<'i':e:\fice ‘1'r1:ore.us’e1j’f‘ri_e':1i‘é11§‘/by(e'd1#:ing»the number ofActions ‘z11:1As‘er Wc:>uldK‘:}1:313:/glto
`ill‘! '<")rd<=;1-'
`.
`tlo Vi1iit‘iat<‘3:a»‘p£1m1i.11“g‘s>igr‘;a1 to f!1é"imagé dfsplaj mve:A1‘ns.
`It:};vou1_tj"1;ave be‘e1‘1“fii’r7tI;etj.Qb;;Ii¥‘)1;1_s
`a.‘
`, éersofi of ordinaiyskill
`aft é1§‘the"fime oftlie“in\’renti;m ‘;ccb)':inc11K.1de_i:1.thq.cAi_evice‘ asg taught:
`Hénshawet al ‘r:1‘cpnf§6i ‘<;i?(:uit';a;japted .to‘gefi_i:.’1!'e1‘t‘e
`r_¢e_sv;$().r_1§i.-\‘:/'eb_Vto_a;11M§;iqn= sivgqal
`ithafif WC$Li1fi fedufx
`numb:erAV<r>factipnk-tpheiisélr W>()l1'l\'.V1‘h_%l\_/et(.) maél$e'i_r1_ ordéfitorihifiate the ‘
`‘pahning feéfure.' '
`
`[I
`
`Z
`
`i
`
`I
`
`.
`
`_
`
`,
`
`.
`
`'
`
`"-
`
`'
`
`-
`
`~
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`107
`
`

`
`2::-~_
`M:
`
`' Appii_ci1tioniControl Number: -99/2,1-.7,4'oo
`
`Unit‘: :57‘; 7 '
`
`_‘
`
`.
`
`7 _.With respectutd elaiin”8,’Henshavv_et al. teaches asecond screen portion display‘ control“ including
`
`at least orie_touch-responsive first area on said screen portion adapted to selectively place said
`
`second screen pdrtion display control in a panning mode vvhereby said screen portion pans over
`
`I tl1e'*virt'u'al'pagie responsiveto said panning. signal" when touched by a user, and a touch-‘responsive _
`
`second area ‘on said screen portion adapted to selectively take said second screen portion display
`
`I
`
`-. control out ofsaid-scanning mode when to_uched by ?l_u_ser; and a switch a'dapt'ed to selectively
`
`. connected t'>n'e.of said first and second screenvportion display controlsto said screen portion (col; '
`
`2, lines S7-67). "
`
`-
`
`'7-'Cla'ir'ns' '12-16 are~rej‘eeted under 35 U'.S.(,i.‘1Q3_(a3 as being unpatentahle over Reichlen
`'
`I
`_ taken iavith lieoshavv et al.
`
`4'
`
`-
`
`‘Relative to claim -12, Reichlen teaches. a ‘data storage device including a screen portion for
`
`v_isu"ally-_disp1aying.apointer and a_vi1g1ua1 page includingicomniand areas, said page _.
`
`i
`
`i
`
`"I providing a user interface "for generating a comrnand: signalito control aprogram in said device,_-
`.n- ‘.
`
`' afid interface control structure co:1'nprising:' a least one sensor rnount”ed'on'the'devioe and _
`
`' configured to sense" changes in position ofthe deviceiin a reference coo_rdi_nate-
`
`and '
`
`t
`
`H
`
`.
`
`transmit signals'indicat'ive of said changes;-a’c'ontrol circuit adapted to move ‘said pointier in said.
`
`'screen'port_ion responsive to signals from said sensor indicative of said positionichaiigesivvhen-sajd
`
`V
`
`'
`
`- coyntrolcircuit is in‘ a'move n__1ode__.
`
`"Reichlen does not teach a touch responsive first area adapted to maintain said-control circuit in
`
`' said‘ move rnode during touching ofthe firstiarea by a user. '
`
`‘-
`
`'v
`
`108
`
`

`
`--'_npp1ication1contioINumber:09/217,400
`. A_I_1'Unit:'2-6.73 I
`
`" -
`
`‘
`
`»
`
`C
`
`'
`
`'
`
`"
`
`-Pa_ge7'..__
`
`K Henshavtget ail. "teach es ,a touch-responsive first area adaptedto maintain said control circuit in
`
`said move mode during
`.. ..
`
`ofthe first-area by a user (col. _2, lines 5‘7-6.1 and col! 3, lines 1-‘I
`
`_
`
`n
`
`'
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`wouldihave been obvi'ou's to a nerson of ordinary_ skill in the
`
`at the time ofthe invention to f
`
`l
`
`incorporate inthe 'de\,‘/ice_ofReichle:n the feature as taught by IV-Ienshaw et al. ‘in that it would
`
`'
`
`. afford- the use; hands on control ofthe ‘duration bfthe ‘move mode. _
`
`'_Rega1jdin"g claim '13, Henshaw_et al. teaches the intetfacecontrol structure coinpri__sing_ acommand‘
`
`' control adapted to generate a-program cornrnancl signal re_spcnsive_ to the bointer being locate in —
`
`'
`
`’
`
`‘H
`
`V one of the- command area ofthe virtuafiltpage when touching ofthe first area by a user
`(col. _
`H‘ 6,_ .1ii1¢s‘l 61-65)‘
`It would have been obrzious to a person ofordinary slldlllin the art__at the time of _
`
`I
`
`:the'inyentionlthatv'vhen touching ofthe first area ceasestthis release ofthe depressed area would
`
`._ generate a"sign'al t_o,stop the action associated With‘the area when the area is‘depr'essed.
`
`'
`
`__
`
`I Wit-h.resi:e:ctof.c1aims 14-l6, Henshaw teaches said interface control structure 'fi.1rther'coInlprising‘.‘-I .
`
`I
`
`a tiouchuresponsive second area adapted to generate a programcornmand signal responsive to the _
`
`I
`
`I
`
`pointer lbei_ng_ located
`
`one ofthe command.areas vivhenithe second area is touched by aluser -
`
`.
`
`(col,?_'_6,.‘1ines "T61-‘6;5‘biand sheet 2 of9‘ Figs. 2A_-2C)';‘_'_Wherein said first and second areas ‘_corr|pri_se'
`
`.
`
`V
`
`‘
`
`Hand sai_d_screen portion is’ disposed on one side'ot7 said _device_ *
`buttons (col. 1, lines 57-67);
`and ‘said nush.butto'ns are located on .a side of side ‘device different .than,t_he one‘ side. (Sheet '2 of '
`-_-l9,figs-ax-2.6)i_-'-—
`-
`.' Q
`""
`
`109
`
`

`
`Application/‘ControlNliumberz 09'/2i7,4oov '
`
`'
`
`'
`
`’_ '
`
`Unit: 267-3 _
`
`.
`
`_
`
`Matter
`
`lAl.l‘awa_lb‘le
`l
`*
`V‘
`H
`I
`Claims", 1.4- areallowed‘,
`V’
`l
`V
`' The "following is an‘exar‘ninerls staternentlof-reasons‘ for allowance": V
`_
`-7‘.
`f Relative to claim 1,
`prior
`ofrecorddoes not teach aldata storage devicepincludingascreen
`portion for.visually displpaslingl a
`ofa
`page larger thansaidjscreen portiortlu/hereby_‘or_1.ly. _
`a portionol‘the virtual page is displayedin ‘saidllscreenipolrtiponz _a displaylcontrol sltructure/_ _ '.
`comprising"a touch-responsive second area on said“ screen p.or§ion,- said second area llrhen‘touched '
`.. by aiuser placing a control'circuit-outofa panning mode and said second area bleling the part ofa ‘
`V‘.
`page dlsplayedjon said screen portion when
`ideviceis in said
`mode. V
`V ‘H
`Regarding clairn 4, theprior art ofrecord .vdoes»hot
`a"data storage’ def‘/iceincluding:a screen‘
`portion for visually displafringa part ora'virti1alpagelarger
`said screenp'o1fion'_i§llierel)yron1yN ‘
`a portion ofthefvirtual pagelisl clisplayedlin thescreen_plo>rti_on,t aldisplaylcontroli
`ll
`l
`comprises a.touch{respo’nsive second area on said screen portion which
`the '
`, entirety"ofthe screen portion when said device is
`said panning rnode,.'said second area-lwhen_
`‘touched by a user placing saidcontrol circuit out:said
`rnode.'_‘
`-
`V Anylcornrnents considered necessary by applicant
`be submitted no later tharltlhe
`payment of:the issue fee a,nd','.to avoid processing delagrs‘, should‘preferably:accompany_the'issI.ie
`./fee. Such submissions should be clearly labeled "éornrnents or_1.§ta'te_rn_ent
`.
`Allowance"
`
`.'
`‘K
`
`‘
`
`._
`
`I
`.
`
`I’
`
`I‘
`
`A
`
`'
`
`l
`
`2
`
`-
`
`110
`
`

`
`;.:.
`
`_
`"_
`‘-‘
`’
`_IV
`Application/Co_ntr.0lNumber: O9/2_17,40‘0’
`
`-,
`
`'
`
`.
`
`E
`
`-An{_injt:25'7_3 .
`
`.
`f f
`'Cagiclusié}t
`‘.
`p.
`I Therprioraftnizttieincifrecerciiatid netreliediiiponhiis goiieidered pertinent_to eppfieant-'s
`
`.7; _
`
`K‘
`
`I
`
`.
`
`I
`‘1\/iIi11e§'e't',al.
`5A,_s_41,(57sp_
`.‘.i_’ U.S.‘Pé'1t‘e_r.1't1\iI<‘).J',
`in
`»—5i,7o3,,623'3"V_-V “:H‘all -
`i’atei1t
`i5§‘6.4w8,}é42iv VMil1erié‘t A"
`‘
`_{S-'lI-'‘aten-t'No.'‘
`' HU.:S.Pater_1t’_.N6_._ 4» _5,615,132‘ “T i
`7fJ.__s. Patej1tNb.
`5,523,285 _ Moiikaitia ':e_tfal';"l
`‘ THIS ACTION IS
`FINAL; _i4ppiicant is reniineled ofithe eiitensionjlofltimie
`ii
`8%.
`pldliey as set foftli in 37.
`136Ce).
`I
`J A shettened statutory ‘period fof replyjito thi; final actibii is iset to" .> ‘
`'1V\/[0N”i['I;iJS‘from_the mailing date ofthi_s'z.1<’:ti(‘)n.‘ In the eyent}. firétfigaly med vmfin TWQ
`_
`'1 '
`!
`‘V MONTHS: ofthe. meiling date of‘this
`ai1d.the.’adi/isp1:y‘_action.is i1cit’mai:.1e‘<1‘_i1nti1 after" :
`V
`I the
`efthe iishofteriled stuatutety periei1,vtheIithe sH<>rte11ed'statutoiy petied I
`wilifexpire oni.t1_1e date the adyisory aetion is.i11§iiled,: ianly eigterisionfeeu
`to 37".. '
`:_
`ICFR I3t5(a) Wili 'Be’ca]cuiete¢i frcilti the
`dete of.‘>th_-.=,'t1diIi"s<iry aeti9ii._
`no event,
`l'
`lit:-ulrlever, will the statutéty4p'ei'ioAdi fer repiyi expire later then’
`the rtiailirig date ‘
`7
`' ofthis_finaJac'1ion.-
`-
`t
`«
`
`-_
`
`pp
`
`_
`
`.
`
`V
`
`.
`
`V
`
`ii '
`
`111
`
`

`
`'
`
`Z
`
`A[.iplicati'onlContriil.Number:',09/217,400
`-_ Arit,'Unit 2673..
`
`_ A
`
`V
`
`’
`
`'
`
`'
`
`,1’-_age .10:
`
`_
`
`‘
`
`._
`
`'-
`.
`.
`_
`"Responses
`‘
`'
`V
`' ~.
`_-
`Responses tothis action should be mailed to: Commissioner of Patents and " -_ _ }
`9.
`Trademarks Washington, DC. 20231._ Ifapplicant desires to fax a response, (703) 308-9051' may
`‘be used for fomial communications or (703) 308-6606 for informal or draft communications.
`_
`i
`I NOTE: 3. Request for Continuation (Rule 609 or 62) cannot be faxed.
`»
`'
`‘
`‘
`.
`.
`'
`- Please label" "PROPOSED” or “DRAFT” for informal facsimile communications." For afier
`final responses, please label “AFTER FINAL” or “EXPEDITED PROCEDURE” on the
`-
`document."
`.
`-
`'
`.
`_
`.
`"
`'
`_‘
`‘
`-
`I
`__
`'_'
`—
`l-_Iand-deliveredresponses should be brought to Crystal Part II, 2121 Crystal Drive,
`' -' Arlington, VA, Sixth Floor (Receptionist).
`‘
`'i
`'
`’
`'
`0
`‘
`l
`'
`'.
`
`_
`
`'
`
`__.
`___
`‘
`Inquires
`.
`_
`.
`-
`..
`_
`-
`K Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications fi'otn the
`10.
`, examiner should be directedto Vincent E. Kovalick whose telephone number is-(703) 306-3020.
`The examiner can nonnally be reached on Monday-Thursday from 9:0O.a.m-. to 4-:00‘p.m".
`.
`'
`If attempts to reach the examiner.-by telephone are unsuccessfirl, the examiner’s
`' " supervisor, _Bipir_1 Shalwala, can be reached on (703) 305.4933.
`
`'
`
`2
`
`‘Any inquiry of a general nature’ or relating to the status ofthis application or proceeding .
`'
`1 1.
`"should be directed to the G-roupreceptionist whose telephone number is‘
`'
`'
`.
`'
`(7p3)3os_—3'9oo.
`'
`-
`’
`-
`*
`'
`.
`.
`
`"
`
`6'
`
`'
`
`.
`
`'.VincentE.Ko_valick'
`
`112
`
`

`
`Q
`
`.
`
`r
`
`' ".\V§5ob. PHvz'LLI!éS; VANSANTEN. cLARK’la;MoRrmE}z 2
`rounnsumme
`g I A'rro_a.NaYs A'r.L.«w
`-__
`-
`sun: aaoio
`;
`500 WEST MADISON STREET
`Cr-yrrc/mo. ILLINOIS 60661-2511 .
`
`'
`
`V SENT".
`
`'
`
`l
`
`NOTSEI:\lT'~:
`
`._
`
`in
`
`1"-ELEICIO‘-Pi§,v_fl_
`
`_
`
`_
`"May 14;,.2_od1 —'
`'- ‘Examiner Vinca'r'n'fg‘E.'l‘<ovai'icl'<‘-
`.'_LJeffrey‘L.
`l
`‘
`singlh at ¢.-'sea'a. N5." 09/2'17',4oo _
`FOu.=Raf: E10051-US-1280.00076
`
`’
`
`’
`:_
`DATE:
`'ATTENT_l0N':
`~
`v- FROM:
`gag:
`w
`
`I
`
`I
`
`I
`
`‘ V’"PAGESETlRA'NSM|T'l'ED:’
`
`-6,. “+ This ‘lrens‘mitta[l?ege_
`
`-V‘ADDlrIoNAL.MEssAGs:
`\
`
`N
`
`r
`
`i This facsimile may contain PHIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION intended anly for
`‘ s the use by the perennial named above.
`If-you are not a person to whom jhle feceimllals eds
`_. _dree'eed, you are hereby notified that any dletribution, copying, or dler.-ieeure of the contents
`of thin feeeirniie Is 51:13]}; gghil.-med. However. any review of this Ieoelmlle by other than the
`perennial i‘cIe‘ntlfled,abeve ehell not constitute eweiver ofprlvilege or confidentiality.
`if you
`have received this facsimile in error, please notify the sender immediately by telephone. collect,
`and return the original to the above address.
`.
`‘
`.
`
`rrivou HV.l\VE‘ANV brr=ncuL1'v REc_ElVINi3 ‘nus TRANSMISSION, PLEASE CONTACT KAREN I
`V SANDERSON AT (312) 375-1900}.
`‘
`‘A
`-
`v-
`’
`.
`V
`'
`_
`‘
`='
`
`' Bl O_FlIGl|\lAL wru. NOT FOLLOW
`
`'-
`I :1 ORIGINAL‘ WILL FOLLOW VIA:
`I
`'
`‘ 12 5. ‘(EA Rifioyernlqht Mail‘
`‘
`El Regular Mall
`. ‘°’“°°'
`El Hand Delivery
`.
`Eliother
`«
`‘
`
`113
`
`

`
`1" agnr BY¢X§foxATeIepopier‘7U2D
`._
`_cEnv1=_:
`
`1'
`
`3125752958»-»
`_
`.3
`
`n oEFa%c1AL
`
`’ V:EX‘P'EDlTEE‘J PROCEDURE.
`12so.ooo7e
`' P10051-US-RMOT
`'
`P/5iTEN_T '
`
`'
`
`V
`
`"-
`
`-IN -THE UAN|TE!51.STATE‘S'PATENT And TRADEMARK QFHFICEH '
`
`In". re A'ppiica_fion oi‘:
`
`»
`
`'
`
`V
`
`‘
`
`n Md.NAiéINGH at al
`
`_‘
`
`' Serial No. 09n'217;4V00
`
`>
`
`v
`
`-
`
`. _ -H|euibec§napa;'21,199s ‘A
`
`-
`
`) DISPLAY CONTROL FOR HAND-
`; ~HELD DATA pnocessme -nevncs
`
`..)‘Group Art Unit 2673
`)'
`
`'Exa_n1ina'rVincént.'E. Kovaliclé
`
`I
`
`" .-
`
`3'
`
`.IiEdqé$‘?-Ear} RECONSIDERATION AFTER i‘=lNA'L-OF‘FlcE’ ACTION V
`
`1
`
`_ Box AF
`Commigsionér'for“Patants,_
`W_§shingto.n, D.C.v 20_231 ,_
`
`‘
`
`.
`
`-‘
`
`'
`
`"
`
`__:'._S|r:
`
`_
`
`1
`.
`In: résponse to_ the‘ "FINAL Oflfice Action dated ‘February 23, 2001_.
`' Appjlcantsnnfinh tq raspnnd as follows:
`
`‘REMARKS ~
`
`'
`. "App:|ic:ant regpeéffulhly requests that the Final Flejeofion of pending
`'c|"a'll'l'Ia I1-4 and 6-16 bnréconéidaied forv_the beldw réasons.
`'
`1
`
`.OERT|F|OA;I'l0N OF FAéS|.Mil.E TRANSMISSIO-N
`i nniieby: £:art‘rfy'-that lint: dnfrnspnnnlnaa |: halng unnimmnd to Be): AF. Commmlonar for Htlntl. Altn: Eltlflllfllf KWWGIIO1 '
`7D3I30B-9051_un Mny 14. 2001.
`.
`'
`'
`’
`.
`"
`-
`‘
`--
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`smnuzurei
`
`'
`
`"”Nn-no:
`
`"V Kiaren Sandman
`
`114
`
`

`
`..
`
`—
`
`f"T"-""§iiNT'"aYi)<éFb’:k"té'i'éE6b‘i'é 4
`
`,4-
`
`exivsbnan Paocsounja h
`-.
`12‘so.oc§>o76
`P10_05'1.-US~RMOT
`= PATENT.
`
`KL ‘
`
`I
`
`_
`
`.
`
`' ,
`
`Applyiwqant reepectfully submits that theettegested madifinua;-tiona qf‘
`
`Henehawl lsitggestedy inthe Final‘.Office ‘Actiolnare (1) inepptap‘fiia1e|y'Vbas'ad "en
`V hihldeilghttathetitheh‘-Vahy‘proper suegeation ‘in the art,'. and (2) even ifvntarda
`. weutd her resbutlt
`the strueture recited in therlejeoted elaims.
`I
`‘epectficalty, it Iefirst submitted that the ‘,rnodifi.cati‘on bf Henshavy ‘
`which fetms the basis of the rejet;t_Ion'.ef clairunsl 6 er eeq.
`(1'.e., tomove the
`’ buttoneilspblay ateas Vinto data dieplay :areas'eince th_ey efettisplayed-bVon‘th_e’.
`samescreen) is'.n‘p't’ibn any way‘su‘gg'esteu.by _Henshayv. V Certaihiy there‘ iiis no’
`'exh|icit teachirytg.
`it..'In fact, all of the illuletrated structutee ‘in’!-ylehelhevy show’
`’ the buttonvdisptay afeas duteitlefef thacentral
`dieelay» area. »_PV\/l‘o"1_'ee‘_\ie'n[',
`Icorltsistentwith the second pelnt discussed below, Henehaw easentially teachee '
`
`away freq‘) moyibnng the button diaplay areas as ‘suggested the Off.ice‘Acti6n,
`
`since to move those areas in such a manner wottld significantly detract from the I
`
`main“ displeyerea} jvvuith the button display areas":c:overing~_‘(an‘ci Interrupting) the
`
`display of the .pe‘ge. Mor_ris teaches ‘placing the buttbn dieplayioutside the
`
`7 eutermgst Boundary ef the main display, even if on the same s5:reer_t.: clearly
`
`' becatise this will avoid the undesirable-interrupted displeyfi
`
`Mere:over,.e\/‘en if_H_ensh'aw were modtffed as. proposed, it vsieuld
`
`5
`
`, not result ihthe claimed linvjention. That is, not enly do both of the _referenced
`
`hsections (col; 2; ‘lines 57-61 ‘and cuh 2,
`
`lines e4;e7—) ‘teach pbsltleningj the
`
`115
`
`

`
`.l'
`
`» §‘l28'1§_,2‘__fJ\A5-P‘
`_ ,
`:
`
`_EXB_EDlTED PROCEDURE
`.,
`'- 1280-00076‘
`' PJOO51-US-fiM_OT ’
`.
`_
`-- PATENT;
`
`I‘
`
`control buttons.-outside,:of'.
`/
`'
`‘ "e
`ortion», but,‘a_s_iI|ustratad in l
`' ‘referenced Figsf 2A-2C, these "buttons" all htlavyevthheir own visual representation
`I
`(i.e;; they can '_be.seen).'HTherefore,‘even’ though the "image being? displayedji
`and thel'i_U'l3Q§.l8Présentin9y;th§_button" are included in thetsame.-screen (meané ‘
`ing only that they areori acontinuous screen; as opposed to se'p‘ara‘te screens); '
`
`"
`
`.
`
`iris a non sequitur to than "conclude that modifying them as suggested (vyh;ether_
`
`obvious. or not)j would result in the claimed. i_nvantion‘heoau_se __
`
`‘Qt ‘image representingth/e button is displayed. is‘, ipso factd. not ‘
`.
`.. gags image is ‘heir-ig’disg|aygg.; iPerl'-lapls i‘nore;simp‘_ly stated,.e\_/en if th’ev'b'ut'tonV '
`
`'
`
`.
`
`‘Ti_ma‘g‘e.ir_i Hen"ah,av\r_'Awe’re'to:.be imovyed inside of an onutelr boundaryofrax display
`of epaga. thentthe area _dis_p'|aying. the button image would cease to be an area
`‘wherethe pae image is being ‘displayed: Thus, even the‘rnodification' to l-_1‘an-.
`
`‘shew suggested lay the bffice Action Wouldiriottnneet the claim recitation that
`the display ‘control be adapted toerelspohd f'to auser touching o_n‘e~'of the dis- _.
`
`crete touch-responsive areas located'ln ;a section of the-screen portion display-9 _'
`ing a portion of said one discrete sub‘-page", because t_ha~t_ouch_responsive area
`'ot the Henshew.button'coulg not gay§.§ih_]1 be located in Va sectionof the screen
`. Vnortion displaying abortion ofllthevpaligeif‘.
`
`,
`
`_
`
`.
`
`«
`
`The Office Act_io'n‘atates that it would be obvious to movethe
`"image representing‘-rthe buttons‘"j\Jvi{hin‘iha boundary that definasthe area on‘ 4
`"ah
`
`,
`
`V‘
`
`116
`
`

`
`- I
`
`\-
`
`x'e‘i-’6£‘réi’é'é'6b'i'éF"7'r)éhA
`
`99:36.
`
`-
`
`’
`
`_ -.
`
`."" "1“v'u‘ajéoa'e'2‘§s:‘a:“sf""""" "
`
`1.
`
`EXPEDITED PROCEDURE
`-
`,.12ao'.ooo76
`P100951-US-FIMOT’
`‘
`PATENT
`
`2
`
`I-loweverl, the clalrh
`the screeri of the displayed image" (Qfriee Action, p. 2-3).
`does hot refer to an outer boundary — lt refers to ‘the screen portlbnsbéntairiihg‘
`ldisplevl. which’ is semethlng vary difrarent-V.’ ‘By mevlng the-Merrie‘ bultens info
`ar1_outVer ;'l$§un&a}y"; the result Is to eliminate portions of thescreen on ‘which
`the pege can bjeldisplaxl/old es_ illuetreted,below.' It is élear thareuclw zi result is
`. particxularlx/uvdleadyantaéeeus gilvanithe llmited "area; usually availeble‘ for dlsplaxl
`lngthe first place...
`
`4 v 1
`999999-9999-99
`..
`v
`9
`.0 9-:5;99¢99;gg9949,99;99gq993%99
`6999999999999
`O 9 O
`. .*2‘I°2*2*3°2°1°1°2°3°I*2°'
`3'?39
`>.9.9.9.9.9.9.9.9 9 9
`a
`99009
`-,9,9.9;o.9,9,9
`91919293999gfififig§V§?V§$‘fi?399;¢¢;¢I9393g%
`99
`9¢ 0 O
`.9? f
`9
`g v
`*2O O
`%%%%&&&fiflfiflfifl&
`9
`9¢¢
`C%&%&%&flhfl-%~
`%9
`9999999999999
`00O4p¢'.
`..C..C‘.§...‘
`QWOQCOCCQOQOO
`J 999993’'93?9;;99¢9O O
`
`9
`39
`9
`9¢;;v;gyg§ggg
`§ 9 9 59
`Q 9O
`999999999999
`9
`99
`
`5 99
`;
`9% 9 9 a
`9Q
`«z 90«Q; 9
`Vflflflflfiflfififlfl.
`§999%&&&h~
`
`9
`
`.5. 9V_
`9
`9'9'9
`Q935Q9
`~:’
`94;;
`9
`0
`9
`9 9
`O
`0
`O09;;
`
`.9 v3 99
`,9
`gfi
`.9
`.0
`00
`O O
`9
`.99
`’
`6%
`9o:’gy993999
`Q}‘99
`oz.6 Q0.0
`Q?fi§9999999;.99553599
`99
`9
`;
`99§W5PQ.8?99§39
`9°:
`O-:9
`Q
`9
`990%:
`’9
`9.9A9.9f¢..-..-_
`
`.95
`’
`
`‘C
`';?.')°
`u
`'
`
`C~:
`9 9
`95
`9
`9
`9
`O
`95
`Q999
`~:9
`99
`6.9
`9
`9
`‘Q
`’0
`oz,9
`9999¢9
`
`CD509610'«:«:»:«:~:999<99JU%&9§99gpgp
`
`9 0
`3f0OOO
`9
`9
`%-
`O
`5.Q9
`O
`9
`fifi
`Q;.9
`OO
`0
`C.
`O O
`90Q:
`§U5§V%999
`I9; 9
`¢¢¢¢9?§VU¥59
`999999999999,
`999999999999
`99999999999
`"999999§g59
`9
`9999999999
`99999999999
`9%
`».avvvvvvvvvs
`.v.v.V.V.‘.0.9.9.V...‘.9."...«9A'-
`
`9 O
`
`C 9
`9
`g:
`
`9'
`
`9'
`
`33‘:$3*:’*¢§¥§5$599499"JU%fl9§39gfi99999
`
`9'
`
`117
`
`

`
`- -' V" »-.l:ET)(:I?E|5'|TED'PROCEDURE
`. 12ao'.ooo7e‘ ‘
`- P10’O51-US-RMOT
`’_PATENT _
`
`—
`
`'
`
`'5 In the, above rfapresénlféeitien-To.f’the modification bf Hgn-gnaw‘ vyhich forrhethe‘
`
`"b_aeis'cf the rejection at isstie;-‘the’ cro's's-'hatch_edv"pcrtions“representexecs dis- :
`lullayhini 5 page ~iifiat;e "and" the solid pbrtionerepjrésent ar,eas.. displaying the
`
`’ "button iméges. ,‘l'h_e solid_ a‘r'ees'-'er_e ‘hate "secticr'i‘of‘th’e‘ s3::_reen:'p-ortion display-
`hiingla portien cf [a pa§e]“' —,they are sectianeef the screen difspla'yin‘jg‘the‘t$ut-
`
`-*
`
`tcne, :The_ screen pcrtion displaying a ppitioii bf the page is not a ‘simple reo_tan-
`glej’but eteetangle with hg_|g§'in’ it.
`
`..
`
`in shottfeince the modifieationjo Henshaw is not mighgested, and
`
`since haven the modification tb.Henshaw would‘ n<_>t,'resu|t_irj_i theinventionl re.
`1 cited in-span; 6 ani:l'it;‘clepe:r'-id'ant claims 6-V1.1, clelrny-6"is_belie\./ed to be a||o'w-’
`,abl'e.m¥ V
`
`" ._
`
`-With .ree‘pect:‘to the rejectiori:-ot.¢‘;laIm ‘12'.'at ee¢7_fi, it is respectfully
`
`‘submitted: that the suggested modiflcations"er'e beeed on hirtdeiéht as elready‘
`
`argued in /Amendment "A"'_. 4Mo‘raver, centrery, to the assertion.”iitthehdffictai
`
`.‘Actio.h,v_the buttone in Hensh’aw~ do Inct relate‘ toia "i1nov'e..mpcle'l' xtulring tocch-i.
`in_9‘} butvineteed simply ‘cauusei rnqvéntent.
`‘The"clear‘_|angue:g:e_ c_‘fVAp'plicant’s
`
`‘
`
`.
`
`‘
`
`'
`
`dIé“?§0s_ure is thet a Ymove mode"is a cendition in which itvtqi/.e_m¢'._=,hn‘t may, by;
`does ngj _ngg'g_§§gL_‘;'iIy", occur‘, tiependihug upone eecpnd input... lfithe ‘Examiner .
`
`7
`
`' va"'g>rae’s_ that this eifinificent distinction iwithitwe differentelerhents la ’sen's_.oaf‘_
`
`and_a touc’h=§rjespov-rtsivci area] eeparetely establishing the move rrviod'e;a,nV<:lA‘_I'h'ove-.
`
`,‘
`
`118
`
`

`
`-
`4'
`
`. E§(PEDlTED PROCEDURE ‘
`’
`123000076 .
`"P1005‘1-‘US.-RMOT '
`V
`T
`.PATENT
`
`'
`
`2
`
`_- Ar'ne_I-at) is péfehéahig‘ but dc$gs‘n<:Avt_ ag"ree that the preséfft Iangufigé is $u_fVfician>tV tfi 1
`pstabiish that c'onfigur§t;c>'n‘éé a part of clairfi; 1:2, he is ésked to 'call the L‘m‘d_ar..
`‘
`séignedpso tfiét suitaHia_Iangfiagé can A_|yoVeMabgraedMupo.r1.7
`I
`'
`‘ "
`A
`.
`1
`..i:l1‘i‘s reébecfifully requgstéfl that, thé fej§ctions.of the claims. he.‘
`.,
`‘Z: recc_mside_red anci, in:v‘viav~v »'¢£§'f'tl_1é,_al;»c_>;r{a., p>énding‘.t_:laims 1‘-4;and §-1.6 t_>é_.'a:1.
` r:‘:weg.fl
`I
`L
`I
`H I
`' Resp9hctfU|Iy.submitted.
`A‘ WOOD‘-PHILLIPS, VAN SAMEN. M
`CLARK & MORTIMER ,
`‘
`
`'
`
`’
`
`.
`
`f ay L. Clark '
`No. 29,141
`
`% May 14} 209:1.
`
`'
`
`T
`
`A’ 500 West Madison Street
`suite 3800 1
`;
`" Chicao, IL 60661-251.1
`(312)_876r-1.800’
`.
`'
`
`_‘
`
`'
`
`119
`
`

`
`l .vv~,D.;.v..vN.,.p:%9l9r%§$<E2
`at "-62 5‘ 0 f l
`1
`"lN'_I_'l-I-']i‘.I‘._T_NIVTED' Sf1‘..A'li‘ES.P.1_i\T_ENT‘Al‘1D TRADEMARi<.‘oi?FlCE
`'
`'1
`I
`:I’54onaSin.gl1and1lobertl\(Iil..andsA _
`L Exarn.iner:_‘AllysonP‘ume1li
`7
`i
`iacgng:
`._
`Date:____12r2j1