The U.S. Supreme Court has wiped away a Fifth Circuit ruling that upheld a copyright verdict against Grande Communications Networks, sending the case back for reconsideration in light of the Court’s recent decision narrowing when internet service providers can be held liable for subscribers’ piracy. The move does not end the dispute, but it is an important reset in one of the closely watched lines of cases testing secondary copyright liability against broadband providers.

In practical terms, the justices granted, vacated, and remanded the case, directing the Fifth Circuit to take another look under a new liability framework.